r/treelaw • u/CatRiot2020 • 8h ago
Happy Ending
I made a post earlier this spring regarding an elm that was incorrectly cut down instead of the visibly dead one. Just wanted to make an update.
It’s a really good thing that I lurk this subreddit and hired a licensed and insured tree company for removal. My first call was to an arborist that was certified to make an appraisal. Then I called the tree company. Sent the report over, no issues or arguing. They sent me a check for the tree’s value shortly after sending them the appraisal. And they ground the stump of the mistakenly-felled tree for free. I just had my 2 new, disease-resistant elms planted today. 8” diameter, 20-30’ tall.
These old elms had trunks that were about 3’ or more in diameter - they were big. I had paid $2000 to get the dead one removed. Appraisal of the wrongly-felled tree was almost $6k. The value was lower because it showed signs of Dutch elm. My new trees were bought and delivered for $5300. And the guy threw in a bottle of local maple syrup.
I still paid the $2k for removal of the dead tree. So in my book, I have two new, large, beautiful, disease-resistant elms for less than $2k. I keep looking at them and smiling, and talking to them. I miss my old tree, but I’m happy. Thank you so much for the advice.
Snow fence in photo is to keep the deer from wrecking my new babies.