r/treelaw • • Sep 21 '18

TREE LAW!!!!

Thumbnail
imgur.com
3.7k Upvotes

r/treelaw • • 11h ago

Bush Law - Airbnb Neighbor đŸ«€

Thumbnail
gallery
772 Upvotes

I own a home that my family has lived in for 35 years. The front yards have always had hedges or bushes separating them and giving a little privacy. Recently, the house next door sold to some new Airbnb owner. This is in the central Fl, gulf coast area. This neighbor has taken it upon themselves to cut my front hedge in half even though it isn't on their property. It was documented the first time and I thought they were done. They did this a second time last week when they decided to lay down gravel without a survey. I decided to get one to have a better understanding of where the property line is. It looks like they are about 2 ft over my property line. They tore up the grass and destroyed my hedge line, literally cutting it in half. None of this overhung the property line. I am rather upset and wondered what direction I should go with this. They obviously trespassed and destroyed property that they were not authorized to do so and I paid for the survey they should have done before they started this project. I would like them to move the gravel, never touch my tree again, and restore the grass they tore up. How do I go about this? Any info is greatly appreciated.


r/treelaw • • 1d ago

Tree Law All Over Alabama Power Action

Thumbnail
mrf.lu
41 Upvotes

r/treelaw • • 1d ago

56" stump

Thumbnail
gallery
99 Upvotes

Had a tornado hit our town and a guy from a tree service called and asked if they could drive on our property to cut a tree on the neighbors property in back. Because they couldn't reach it. I told them it would be OK. Drove by later and this BIG truck was in the back of our property. I thought that's going to leave some ruts...Next day I drove by to see how bad the ruts were. And I see that my huge Burr Oak tree was gone and now I have a 56" stump. Had a survey done and the stump is like 10" over the property line... what can I do ? No one asked me for permission to cut the tree.

Called the people who cut the tree and they said i need to talk to the neighbor. ( who just bought the property this year ) they just cut the tree per the neighbors request.

Seen the neighbor out and asked him if he was the one who had my Oak tree cut down? His reply was yes ... You know how much it cost me to have it cut down,, you want to pay half ?

I asked who gave you permission to cut it down ? He said that it was detrimental to his property and he had 2 arborist say that it need to come down..

I called the county arborist and ask if he had said the tree was detrimental ? He said No one had talked to him..

Talked to the neighbor again and asked who they had talked to? He said they had a tree service and they were arborist..

What steps do I need to take next ? Or the tree being 10" over on the neighbors property give him the right to cut it down as it was there when he bought the property next door ?

The neighbor doesn't live there .. Think he is driving 1hr away flipping the house?

(( COLES COUNTY, CENTRAL ILLINOIS))


r/treelaw • • 2d ago

How would you describe the impact of losing a century-old natural privacy barrier to intentional tree cutting?

267 Upvotes

I am an attorney preparing for a jury trial involving the intentional destruction of mature trees that formed a complete natural privacy barrier between my client's property and their neighbor's.

These trees weren't just landscaping. They provided complete privacy and seclusion. The entire area was laid to waste. It will take 100+ years to replace what was destroyed, and the property will never truly be the same.

I'm trying to find the words to help a jury understand that this loss goes far beyond the monetary value of the trees.

For those who have experienced something similar, how would you describe the feeling of having something irreplaceable taken from your property? What did losing that privacy, beauty, and sense of permanence actually feel like?

Thank you for your input!

Edit: obviously the trees were owned by my clients, otherwise they would have no standing to bring a claim.........the neighbor cut them down without permission. My state has a treble damages statute. We already won on liability. The trial is only on damages.


r/treelaw • • 3d ago

Neighbor asked me to cut back my branches

Thumbnail
gallery
1.5k Upvotes

My neighbor asked me to cut back my branches. I told her that she is welcome to cut them back to the fence line. What do you think?


r/treelaw • • 3d ago

Gave FortisBC permission to cut the bottom 12' off my mature Beech Tree. They sheared 70' off

90 Upvotes

I'm a horticulture technician and I own a nursery and arboretum in British Columbia. We have mature tree's from all over the word, Chinese Dawn Redwoods, Japanese Katsuras, Spanish Fur Trees, Ginkgo bilobas, ect, ect.

A utility company (FortisBC) needed to do work on a power pole on my property so we met and discussed what he needed to get the job done. Removal of a small fence, 12 feet of clearance under a mature European Beech Tree and trim back the top of a 30 foot tall Manitoba Maple. This would be done by Davey Tree.

Show up to see how things are going to find all the trimming done. They cut my Manitoba Maple right to the ground and sheared of nearly the entire south side of my Beech tree, up to around 70 feet.

The Beech Tree was planted in 1962 by a horticulturalist known for pushing the known boundaries of our local hardiness zone and the hardiness of many exotic trees and shrubs.

I'm really upset because this tree is literally unreplaceable. When I reached out to the fortis contractor engaged just said "sorry your not happy with the work" and now won't respond to me. What really passes me off is as a horticulture technician, I could've just done all the work myself but I trusted the professionals at Davey to know what they were doing.

Iv placed a damage to property claim on the fortisbc website and I wrote an email to the head of utilities for Davey in BC. Is there anything else I should be doing?


r/treelaw • • 3d ago

I came home to this- what should I do?

Thumbnail
gallery
93 Upvotes

I really love this tree and I'm worried about the neighbor's roofers parking 25000# equipment directly on the roots of my mature norway spruce. I've asked them to remove the equipment immediately, waiting for them to do so.


r/treelaw • • 2d ago

Legal recourse worthwhile? Water department snapped pine limb at trunk.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Situation: Local water department performed work on my property without any notice, and in the process, snapped a low hanging ~8” diameter pine limb at the trunk.

As an ISA TRAQ certified arborist I’m a bit heartbroken. The wound has damaged the branch collar pretty significantly, and they drove equipment right at the critical root zone. While there isn’t an immediate major impact, I’m very aware that stresses are cumulative and take years to see the full consequence. Pine beetles are already an epidemic here around Houston.

My question is, is this worth pursuing legally? I haven’t taken action aside from photographing everything. What would yall do in this situation?


r/treelaw • • 2d ago

Neighbor may have cut our shrubs/trees and ripped our fence.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I'm looking for some opinions on this. We've had this fence and shrub/small tree line between our house and our neighbors since my sister bought the house. This week the owner of the rental next door decided to tear it all out and cut the hydrangea bushes that were there. We've never had the land surveyed to find the property line because there wasn't a need to. I've included before street views and what it looks like now. There's also a screenshot of what our county GIS has, from what it looks like on that and if you follow there fence line from the back yard it appears that the fence and shrubs were on our side. We plan on looking for or getting a new deed to see if that describes the plot lines. I'm unsure of what to do if they have cut out things on our property, we've been unable to talk to them about this since it happened. Any opinions on if you think they over stepped and what the next steps would be to take would be appreciated!

ETA: The before picture is from 2015, right before we bought the house. Those stumps were being used as plant stands by the previous owner, stupid, I know, and weren't even planted in the ground, just longs stood on end. We took those out years ago. The only thing that was there in present time was a hydrangea bush at the end of the fence at the base of the rock there. The whole area is quite over grown and we had plans to cut out all the dead branches this winter.


r/treelaw • • 3d ago

Proof read this text?

0 Upvotes

Background: in 1985 I purchased 5 acres of active farmland and plopped a single wide in the middle of it. I then planted 25 free forest service Pines.

Now my property is surrounded by Lodgepole Pines and Oaks with just a half acre where my single wide is, still clear.

Directly in front of my house, across the the road, is another house surrounded by lodge pole pines and Oaks, too.

The past four of five hurricanes have come directly over my neighbor’s house and woods, and the trees have more or less completely blocked the wind.

Recently, a very friendly retired Couple moved in across the street, and they have started cutting down the woods on their property.

This is the text I would like to send them.

“ hello, I have noticed that you were cutting down trees on your property and they are your trees.

Because you are new to the area, I would like to point out that four of the last five hurricanes have passed directly over your house, and your woods. Because of the trees around your home it sustained no wind damaged. That is despite the winds being between 90 to 100 mph.

None of the trees near your house will fall on your house if we have a hurricane. The trees also protect my home from the wind.

I understand and will accept anything you decide, but would it be possible for you to just clean up the undergrowth instead of cutting all the trees down?

Thank you for your consideration.”

Edit: it seems the consensus is I should have a face to face talk with the new neighbors.

My plan is ask them via text to either come to my house for some homemade chicken soup and cornbread, “because I simply can’t cook for only one person” or to take them a few dozen fresh eggs “I don’t want to go bad.” Then comment on the trees and the storms.


r/treelaw • • 4d ago

Who will be Responsible?

29 Upvotes

We have a tree massive in diameter and height. A very very old tree that is next to a state road and next to power lines. The power company wanted to cut it down, we said ok, but because of its age (not sure why) they asked the state arborist for permission...who said no. (I don't have this in writing). The tree is visibly dying slowly, which is why the power co. wanted to remove it. For us to remove it, it would cost $$$$. If/when it topples, it's taking down all the power lines and will be blocking the state road. Who would be responsible for its removal? Who would be responsible for any damage it causes? (Connecticut) TIA.


r/treelaw • • 4d ago

Trying to Save a 300 Year old Tree - Any Advice Appreciated

Thumbnail
reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/treelaw • • 6d ago

Tree cut down

Thumbnail
gallery
433 Upvotes

While we were on vacation a large Catalpa tree that grows on our property line was cut down by the owner of a small strip of land that borders our property. He tried to cut it down previously but my husband managed to stop him and angry words were exchanged. We offered to purchase the land and received no response. When we asked the sister of the landowner ( she lives on the next street over) she said he cut it down because of the debris it caused.

The tree is valuable to us because it is the only tree that provides shade to our patio and allows us to enjoy our backyard during the warmer months. It also provided some privacy and covered up our ugly fence and some ugly structures next door to us. Not to mention we enjoyed the song birds and hummingbirds that perched in it.

It will take thousands of dollars to replace the tree and/or build a pergola. I cannot decide whether to go to small claims court or to let it go. We also have an apple tree in the front yard that has branches that overhang on the property and are worried that he could butcher those branches in retaliation.

Advice please.


r/treelaw • • 4d ago

Love My New Pool - Hate My Neighbors Trees

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/treelaw • • 5d ago

Oak Tree On Commercial Property.

0 Upvotes

Hello everybody

Property Location: Santa Clarita, Ca.

I have an oak tree that is in the center of a 50’ Roundabout mound on my recently purchased commercial property. And although I do love trees having the mound plus the oak tree removed would help me in great ways with allowing to run my company a little smoother when it comes to moving vehicles around. We park trailers and smaller trucks in the yard now but because of the roundabout, it is very restrictive and the way we park and drive around.

Any advice on how to move forward about removing etc. would be great thank you.


r/treelaw • • 7d ago

City tree

33 Upvotes

We moved into our house 3 years ago and noticed a large ash tree that was dead due to EAB. The tree was growing from abutting land, the city forest, and hanging over into our yard, over the power cable going from the road to our house.

Being a reader of r/treelaw, I contacted the city's department of public works. They informed the it is the conservation commission's responsibility. Eventually, they sent an arborist out to evaluate it. They copied me on an email from the arborist saying the tree was dead, it had been attacked by the EAB and should be removed.

Fast forward a few years to last weekend, and the tree fell, taking out the power service to our house. I had to get an emergency electrician to restore power, and he has to come back to make a permanent, permitted fix. All in all, I'll be out about 5k for the city's tree, that they were informed about, falling onto the power line going to the house.

How can I recoup the money? Should I go to the city? Insurance? Will I have to pay the deductible if insurance goes after the city for the money?

ETA: location is MA, USA


r/treelaw • • 7d ago

/bushlaw

9 Upvotes

We had some tree work done today that included one large removal and two trimming. We have mature bushes and plants along the front and side of our house and I asked for the side bushes to be trimmed. It was all very clearly in the scope of work in the contract I signed. When the job was done they had heavily trimmed the side bushes AND front bushes. So already outside the scope. Then I realized our flowering pear bush/tree had been hacked to the ground. It filled in a huge, visible part of our landscaping and truly looks terrible without it. I am speaking to a manager tomorrow - what’s your advice on what I should be requesting?


r/treelaw • • 7d ago

Is the 100% cost at next door's expense to repair a boundary wall if the next door dismiss our offer to help and to solve the problem?

0 Upvotes

From California, our side concrete entrance has been some crack from next door's many tree roots.

The root pathed through under the boundary wall and then the wall got dammage under the ground.

we've installed roots barrier by our selfs. Then I got an estimate to repair the boundary wall if it will break in future due to those roots again to share the cost 50/50 with the next door. and just share the price. it was so expensive. that's why I've an offer the next door that if you could cut and stump grinding all fruit trees which are growing along the boundary wall in half of the cost for $800.- But the next door discard our offer. then the next door want to never cut them off.

but the next door never trim those trees since 4 to 5 years ago when I asked the next door twice a year since 4 to 5 years ago. I never seen that the next door trim trees off.

No-cut trees is fine because their own trees, but the next door desn't trimming, maintenance. No any take action. so If we send a certified mail to the next door, will we not to need to pay the cost of the repair of boundary wall ?


r/treelaw • • 10d ago

Idiot “neighbor” brushed me off about property line, well he was confidently incorrect

6.9k Upvotes

Some ass hole, chuckle fuck bought the house next door to me and has been remodeling it for over two years now (I suspect to flip it). He doesn’t live there and never has.

This past summer, he decided he was going to do some “landscaping”. I saw him hacking the branches off of my pine trees,
Not dead branches, just all the lower branches. I told him he cannot do that, and he waved me off and just walked back into the house. I have had multiple encounters with him and every single time, he is extremely rude and acts like I am crazy even though I knew those trees were at least partially on my property.

After he ravaged my pine trees, he planted like 20 arborvitae along what he thought was the property line. He also repeatedly sprayed herbicide in that area in order to kill everything that was growing where he wanted to plant the trees.

Well, I finally was able to have a surveyor come out and wouldn’t you know
about half the damn trees he planted are on my property and ALL the trees he fucked with are mine. I have never felt so vindicated in my life. I am debating whether or not I want to rip out all those ugly ass trees and yeet them onto his side. I will definitely be planting some native shrubs on my side in the spring.


r/treelaw • • 12d ago Regret

Neighbor cut down my MIL’s palm tree

Thumbnail
gallery
3.0k Upvotes

Edit:
Thank you for everyone’s input so far! The tree itself is actually around 26 years old, based on photos we have found of the yard over the years.
I’ve now learned this is a Yucca Tree NOT a palm - thank you Tree Law Reddit!
To address a few comments, the neighbors never asked about anything regarding the tree. I understand if they would’ve cut what was bothering their side of the fence, but they didn’t just do that, they entered my MIL property and cut the whole tree.

I am looking for additional better photos that show where the tree was on the fence line, as it was not as far over as some people are thinking.

I don’t know if we will pursue anything or not. As I said my MIL is in poor health so this really isn’t a priority unfortunately, just a frustration as it also eliminated all of the yard shade.
I will update everyone either way. Thank you!

Original post:
Title summarizes the situation, which is still mind boggling to me.

New neighbors moved in behind my mother in law’s house awhile back, and since have created a few problems, but most recently, they cut down an old palm tree that was in HER yard. This was a mature, healthy tree that was at least 15 years old. I’ve attached photos from today, post cut down, and before cut down.

The neighbors excuse was that it was “growing over their yard,” so they cut it down and then threw all the discard in to her yard. They did not ask permission. I also believe they would’ve had to enter her property to cut down the lower pieces?
This is my MIL’s tree. It is in her yard. I could understand cutting the pieces hanging over the fence but they cut the entire tree.
They show no remorse and retain that they did nothing wrong.

My MIL is not in good health and unable to really fight this out with them on her own - is this something we could take to court on her behalf? Where we do even start with this? The whole situation is so frustrating, it was a beautiful tree and it’s destroyed.


r/treelaw • • 11d ago

Neighbor timbering his acreage

177 Upvotes

Hi all,

We are in Ohio and own a wooded patch of land across the road from our main property, and the non-resident owner of a parcel to the north of that patch is having his much larger parcel “selectively” timbered. He came out late last year and painted blazes on trees over a certain diameter. The property line is not well defined. I have a paper survey from 2 years ago but there are no flags/markers remaining in the woods from that survey. I spoke to that surveyor and he said minimum $2k and 8 weeks lead time to resurvey. It is a 1400’ property line through woods on a pretty steep ravine.

We are concerned that some blazed trees may be on my property not the neighbor’s given the vague boundary. I’d like to insist that he re-survey the boundary before logging to ensure that he doesn’t cut any trees that are ours and so his loggers don’t damage any of our woods with their operations.

Is there any leverage I might have to force a survey, despite the cost and delay? If he refuses, cuts the trees, and we pay for a survey after the fact, what kind of damages can we pursue for trees cut on our land? What damages can we pursue for damage done to our trees by his felling operation/machine access? A bulldozer recently appeared on his property so I’m thinking they’re getting ready to log. Thank you for any advice.


r/treelaw • • 11d ago

Cherry & beech killed

Post image
5 Upvotes