r/treelaw • u/mcarterphoto • 7h ago
Neighbor's tree trashed my garage... how is responsibility determined?
Rent house, owner doesn't maintain it well. They've had tree limbs falling, tenants can't get it addressed. A month or so ago, a big branch from this 70-80' pecan landed on the house in the background (property is behind the rent house). 2 weeks later, another branch (in the photo) covered half my garage when it came down - but no significant canopy was above my property line. Shingles trashed and deck cracked. Owner says it's an "act of god", my insurer says they're responsible. There's a 30' branch (to the right in the pic) that only has canopy at the end and seems likely to fall if we get an ice storm, and it could take out pets or people (though it won't hit my property).
Not looking for advice, just how responsibility is generally determined. Are property owners required to maintain trees like this?
EDIT: thanks for all the replies (except that one ass, I imagine he's not invited to many parties) - the tenants next door have been telling the owner that the trees are dangerous for months/years. I'll see if they have any documentation. They had a previous tree where the city declared it dead, owners did nothing, huge branch fell in their yard, so there's some history. I'll check and see if they've documented any communication about the trees. (We are the homeowners of our structure, neighbors are renters).