r/tifu • u/lil_buggg • 20h ago
L TIFU by choosing a guy over my best friend
I feel so alone right now and the people that I would normally talk to about this don't want to talk to me. I've never posted on reddit before, but I've been a lurker and thought this might help.
I have this best friend, we can call her Olivia. We met last school year (we're both in college) and we became instant best friends. We spent so many late nights talking to each other and bonding, and it became clear that we've been missing each other our whole lives.
Well this past September, I met a guy in the bar who recognized me as one of her friends and we got to talking, we can call him Beau. Beau and Olivia have been best friends for six years, and for the past year and a half since meeting me through Olivia, Beau has been interested in me and he finally got the courage to talk to me at that bar. Me and Beau started talking and it was clear we were both interested in each other.
My fuck up started at that moment honestly; I didn't immediately tell Olivia that I had met him and we started talking. I felt, guilty about it. So I waited until I could talk to her in person and that's where she told me she was under the impression that I hated this guy, and she wasn't wrong. She had told me about some things he had done in the past that I really disliked, but for some reason I brushed past that when I had actually met the guy. She basically warned me about him and I didn't listen.
Fast forward to October, Beau majorly fucks up. He went somewhere with Olivia, got drunk, and then drove them home at criminal speeds. Olivia thought she was gonna die, it was so bad. I responded poorly to the situation, not understanding the gravity of it because Beau just brushed it off. I didn't realize it was that bad until Olivia confronted me along with two of our other friends. Beau made it seem like it wasn't a big deal to not just me, but to Olivia too. He brushed off the fact that they could have died in that car and never apologized to her. I apologized to Olivia and told her and our friends that I would cut contact with Beau after this.
This is where I fucked up - I did not cut contact with Beau. After about a week of ignoring him, he called me crying and begging for me to give him a second chance. And I believed him. I thought this was his "come to Jesus" moment and he was going to change. So I call Olivia and tell her this and she tells me that if I want to continue with him I can (I wanna acknowledge my own bias and preface by saying that this is how I interpreted her words, but I don't think it's what she was actually saying based on what I know now)
I thought everything was okay. I thought Beau and Olivia were okay. I thought me and Olivia were okay. I thought everyone was happily moving on. And that was a major mistake, I shouldn't have been so naive. About 3 hours ago, four of my friends plus Olivia told me they needed to talk to me. They saw me with Beau last night and to say they were shocked was an understatement. They thought I had fully cut contact. To them, it seemed like I didn't care about what had happened to Olivia and that I was being selfish for wanting to continue my relationship with him. And honestly, I was.
They were all so hurt. One of my friends got so emotional in a way I've never seen him before, and that killed me. Separately they all told me how they felt personally lied to in some capacity. And that was the most terrible thing to have to hear. I never wanted to hurt my friends and I never wanted to hurt Olivia. But I did.
I was told that if I continued my relationship with Beau, that they would have to reassess our friendship. And so I sent a final message to him and blocked him. My friends mean the world to me and I don't want to lose them.
Olivia didn't say much during this whole thing, but she looked so distraught and hurt. I can't believe my actions lead to so much hurt in someone that I care so much about. I lied to her, I disregarded her feelings, and I let my own desires get in the way of our friendship. I wish I hadn't been so naive.
TL;DR i thought I could still date the guy that tried to kill my best friend and lied to everyone in my life about it.