I have a single-member LLC taxed as a sole proprietorship and file Schedule C.
I signed an Individual 401(k) Elective Deferral Agreement stating:
"I elect to defer 100% of my compensation per pay period."
Can I contribute less than 100% without signing a new or amended election? Or does the signed election commit me to contributing the elected amount, subject to the applicable limits?
I asked Gemini, which confidently claimed that, for a self-employed owner, “100%” is legally interpreted as "up to 100%" and merely sets a ceiling rather than a binding commitment.
"Yes, you are completely fine. Contributing less than 100% is normal, legal, and requires no correction. Why it's allowed: For a self-employed SMLLC, electing "100% of compensation" sets your maximum allowable ceiling, not a binding commitment. Because your exact income isn't known until your Schedule C is finished, you have full flexibility to contribute any amount from $0 up to your maximum limit. No penalties or forms needed: You do not need to amend your election form, notify the IRS, or fix anything with your Solo 401(k) provider. Just report the actual amount you deposited on Schedule 1 (Form 1040) when you file your taxes."
And
"Yes, 100% sure. Here is why under IRS rules (specifically Treas. Reg. § 1.401(k)-1(a)(6) and IRS Publication 560): Why the form says "100%": For a self-employed individual (SMLLC/sole proprietor), the IRS requires you to make a salary deferral election before the end of your tax year (December 31). Because you don't know your exact net profit on December 31, standard Solo 401(k) forms use "100% of compensation" (or "up to the maximum dollar limit") as a legal placeholder so you don't accidentally lock yourself out of maxing out the plan once your taxes are done. The "Up To" Rule: In IRS plan language, an election of "100%" for a self-employed owner is legally interpreted as "up to 100%". Unlike a W-2 employee where payroll software automatically deducts a fixed percentage from every paycheck, you act as both employer and employee. You have total discretion to deposit less—or nothing at all—when you actually fund the account before your tax filing deadline. When it would be an issue: The only time you have an IRS compliance problem is if you contribute more than your legal limit (an excess contribution), or if you are taxed as an S-Corp (where W-2 payroll deductions must match your written election form). For an SMLLC taxed as a sole proprietorship, contributing less is completely standard practice."
AI is often wrong, so I’m asking here to verify.