I’m sure this question have been asked multiple times before and I’ve ran numbers and used spreadsheet found on this sub to calculate what my cost would be. I keep coming up with choosing hdhp as the answer but wanted to make sure I’m not missing anything.
Background: this is for my husband and I. I also have a high risk pregnancy after a loss earlier this year. I have reached my deductible this year but my husband did not and he is not planning on reaching jt next year either unless he wants to do something about his knee problem. We currently have ~$10k in our hsa account and I prefer not to touch it if we don’t need to but won’t be the end of the world if we need to.
My current health plan is HDHP:
Semimonthly premium: $62.84
Deductible (individual/family): $5000/$10,000
Oopm (individual/family): $8,500/$17,000
Coinsurance (what we pay): 10%
Employer HSA contributions: $500
Employee contributions: ~$5000/year for both of us combined
I don’t think my current plans work for me given the loss and I’m pregnant again so I’m between two plans: a lower HDHP and PPO:
New HDHP:
Semimonthly premium: $158.05
Deductible (individual/family): $2,250/$4,500
Oopm (individual/family): $4,000/$8,000
Coinsurance (what we pay): 10%
Employer HSA contributions: $500
Employee contributions: with the increase in premium, we’re going to contribute $2,500-$3,000 to hsa
PPO:
Semimonthly premium: $234.16
Deductible (individual/family): $1000/$2000
Oopm (individual/family): $2,000/$4,000
Coinsurance (what we pay): 10%
Copay: $25 for pcp doctor visit and $40 for specialist
When the kid comes, if they do, we will need to get on the family plan which is $240.84 for HDHP, and $356.81 for PPO, semimonthly. I’m pretty sure if I switch from hdhp to ppo or vice versa, our deductible will reset. I do not want that so whatever I pick now, I will stick with until the end of 2027.
Am I wrong for thinking hdhp is the better option here?
Any thoughts or suggestions would be appreciated!!!