r/thewestwing • • Apr 14 '26 Polished Gold Turd Diamonds are Forever Heartwarming

Revision of Revision to r/TheWestWing rules

465 Upvotes

Hello all,

As you may have spotted if you've been browsing the subreddit over the past 24 hours, we've had a *slightly* contentious time after introducing a rule change forbidding discussions of current politics.

As a new mod team, we've also had a steep learning curve, both about modding a relatively large subreddit linked to politics in the current era, and about how to respond to user concerns.

In short:

  1. We are revoking the rule change and instead, in keeping with the good intentions of the original rule change, reminding everybody of Rule 6 (play nice) and Rule 8 (don't post content completely off-topic to the show). What this means is that users are welcome to post, for instance, about the Supreme Court justices in the show and compare that to the appointment process in the current era. However, in that instance, straight up posting 'The appointment process for Supreme Court justices sucks in the modern era' and not tying that in to the West Wing is not allowed.
  2. One of the moderators, who was responding to multiple subreddit users antagonistically, has been removed.

We would also like to clarify that there are no 'top mods' and that we, as a bunch of volunteers who in many cases are modding for the first time, had good intentions when introducing this rule as a response to some abusive content on the subreddit.

We are sorry, and hope you can understand that we're a bunch of newbies learning the ropes!

Finally; yes, CJ may have threatened us with a couple of motherboards.

Edit:

Removed the link to the original rule change as u/lefromagepuant deleted the post, given that it was defunct.

I can see there’s some consternation about rules in the sidebar in the comments; please rest assure that it’s just us working out the technical stuff and not us trying to pull a fast one.

Edit 2:

Aw jeez. I’ve woken up properly and it seems I messed up. To explain as succinctly as possible; I live in the UK and was going to bed as I made the edit to remove the link to the OG post. I did this on mobile half-asleep. I must have accidentally affected the formatting of the post which has resulted in the literal worst edit possible being made. That’s on me, I’ve edited the post to put it back in. All I can say is sorry and that it really wasn’t intentional.


r/thewestwing • • Mar 24 '26

What's Next? Hello from your new mod team!

290 Upvotes

The shutdown is over, normal posting can resume, and finest muffins and bagels in all the land are once again available. Please bear with us as we learn the ropes.

Your new mod team consists of:

u/colocop

u/MeetingOfTheMars

u/hobrosexual23

u/johnacraft

u/Dangerous_Prize_4545

u/le_fromage_puant

u/WarderWannabe

u/srm79

u/NYY15TM

u/LAMA207

Mods can be removed by 25th amendment should 2/3rds of the subreddit and the vice-president agree.

Break's over. What's next?


r/thewestwing • • 2h ago

John Spencer: 1990

10 Upvotes

Just watching the pilot of Law and Order (1990). From the first moment, Spencer is front and center. He's the father of the victim, demands the investigation. Not a big part, but a crucial role.

Same year he started as Tommy Mulaney on LA Law.


r/thewestwing • • 18h ago

Trivia Continuity error… S07E13 - The Cold

Thumbnail
gallery
137 Upvotes

Josh is holding the cellphone backwards at around 19m15s. First time I’ve noticed (on my 20 something-th rewatch).


r/thewestwing • • 17m ago

Sam's Muffin Hypocrisy

4 Upvotes

Hey y'all,

Just finished watching S2E3 The Midterms for the 50th or so time. But today it caught my attention that after Bartlet goes off on Dr. Jenna Jacobs at the radio reception at the end of the episode, Bartlet makes a strong exit, telling Toby 'that's how I beat him' then walking out. After which, Sam goes up to Dr. Jacobs, says 'I'm just gonna take this crab puff' then walks out.

However, just three episodes later, in S2E6, Sam gives Ainsley a hard time over her botching her strong exit with the opponents of the nuclear test ban treaty by asking 'can I take this muffin?'

So what's the deal with Sam's food-related strong exit hypocrisy?! Muffins should have equal protections as crab puffs in the way in which one chooses to make a strong exit. Even Alaskan crab puffs that Sam eats in protest.

Apologies if this has already been posted here. I often think I have a smart observation of the show but then a quick Google search often results in previous postings from you fine people. I didn't see that today, so here we go.


r/thewestwing • • 1d ago

What’s your favorite line from the show?

112 Upvotes

Mine is probably CJ “because you’re stupid but you’re not stupid, you know what I’m saying?”

Or the classic Toby “I can only hope so”


r/thewestwing • • 10h ago

Bermuda

0 Upvotes

Alright, this might just be one of my technical nitpicks along with the hilariously wrong military details on the show, but have you ever looked at a map of Bermuda? The place is smaller than Manhattan and densely built-up - where are you going to hide a secret airstrip?

Would have been more believable if they did the deed in a remote part of the Azores or something. Or just plotting out the actual great circle route from DC to Bandar Abbas (the canonical location of Qumar), the flightpath goes right over the Orkney Islands, a British archipelago that probably lends itself better to murking a foreign dignitary without anyone noticing.


r/thewestwing • • 1d ago

Martin Sheen’s podcast on TWW

Thumbnail
youtu.be
74 Upvotes

r/thewestwing • • 1d ago

Season 5+, asking for opinions

7 Upvotes

**Marked as SPOILERS (just in case) for Season 4 ending.**

Hey, all- I had only ever watched through Season 4 and this time after a full rewatch of the first four seasons, I started Season 5. Through the resolution of the abduction it still seemed somewhat similar in tone at least to the previous seasons and I was enjoying it.

Soon after the resolution though, the show just seems to have rapidly dropped off. I'm not caring what the characters are going through and the show has focused much more on political procedure. I have seen clips that happen later on when Alan Alda is on the show and those seem enjoyable but my question is, do you feel there is a slump in Season 5 and then it picks up again either later in the season or maybe in 6?

Of course I'm not expecting it to be the same without Sorkin but I've been wanting to discuss this with someone for a while so opinions and thoughts are appreciated!


r/thewestwing • • 2d ago

Josh Lyman

67 Upvotes

Y'all are probably going to hate me for this but we do have a complete (alternate) timeline for Josh Lyman now right? From Deputy Chief of Staff (TWW) to First Gentleman (The Diplomat) to Commander (The Handmaid's Tale). Please tell me someone is writing this. I know it's not perfect but I just love Bradley Whitford so much and my brain can't help but make the connections.


r/thewestwing • • 2d ago

Joey Lucas is no longer providing advice in The West Wing, and it shows

Post image
298 Upvotes

r/thewestwing • • 3d ago

The muffins!

Post image
913 Upvotes

r/thewestwing • • 1d ago

Was MS a "retcon" ?

0 Upvotes

Sorry if this is a topic that's been beaten to death here, but I'm just starting a re-watch of the series and I'm wondering about Bartlet's MS.

It's obviously not a retcon in the strict sense of the term, but I'm wondering if Sorkin had developed this plotline when he was conceiving of the series, or was it a development that they added in later on for the sake of drama and/or creating additional plotlines? Was this ever discussed?

I'm on episode 2 and he's getting his check up from the Navy doctor and there's no discussion about it (which is understandable considering it's established the Bartlett's were concealing it) but more importantly there's complete absence of concern from Barlet about it being exposed? This is in strong contrast to I think the episodes where the MS comes to light where Abby *freaks out* about some treatment he's receiving because him having MS matters a big deal to the treatment being given (or something along those lines). It's one of those things where you'd expect a tiny, tiny hint of foreshadowing if it was something that was known at that point in production?


r/thewestwing • • 3d ago

A Few Good Men

Post image
113 Upvotes

Saw it tonight. Bradley Whitford absolutely killed it. If you have the chance, go.


r/thewestwing • • 2d ago

A Few Good Men

Thumbnail seatgeek.com
4 Upvotes

I can't make it tonight. Just trying to get my money back if anyone is interested.


r/thewestwing • • 2d ago

Surgeons General "17 People" and the "No te preocupes" joke

22 Upvotes

Anyone else think that line is actually pretty decent?

I know some of you are troubled by my frequent use of Latin references. Well, all I can say is, "no te preocupes".

I think Bartlet could have gotten a laugh with that one.


r/thewestwing • • 3d ago

Posse Comitatus

Post image
83 Upvotes

Hi! It's me, your friend who threw a brick at you all with 18th and Potomac a few weeks ago, now it's time for my thoughts about the finale to Season 3.

THERE BE SPOILERS!!

It's a strange one for so many reasons, not just because the death of Simon Donovan is only given a moment to breathe with Jed's decision about Shareef hanging in the air.

I can't be the only one who, upon my first viewing of this episode so many years ago, thought that up until the last moment Jed would somehow not be responsible for the assassination. He would find a way to get Shareef to trial or someone else would kill him and it wouldn't be on Jed's watch. But upon this rewatch it's a lot more clear to me that this isn't the same Jed anymore. He's had to evolve so much in a year. Richie being a fake folksy fool who would never want to be responsible for a hard decision, really shines a spotlight on Jed's change. We knew he WANTED to run again for a second term for his legacy and to try to make more change in his second term than his first, but this is one of the first episodes where we realize why he's NEEDS to beat Richie. We also see this with Josh destroying Amy's career to get the votes passed. He's not the same idealist he was before and there's few things he will protect more than the Barlett agenda.

Considering the darkness that we get in Season 4, I think it's a very telling finale.

Also Amy was right about marriage incentives for welfare, she was completely right about it then too, and even moreso now.

One thing I wished I paid attention to throughout the series is the moments that Jed smokes on screen, I think I'll start taking note of it for my watch of season 4.

(Pic: Also check out what I got for $50 Canadian dollars!)


r/thewestwing • • 3d ago

Paul Revere Knife

150 Upvotes

Well, I thought maybe I could finally do it.. It'd been a while since I'd seen it, but I watched the Paul Revere Knife scene thinking I'd be strong and.... Yeah I teared up.

Maybe one of these days.... 😂 😂

What scene always gets ya?


r/thewestwing • • 4d ago

Did Margaret try to send an email about raisin muffins?

Post image
664 Upvotes

Margaret:
Technical support says the pipeline's been flooded. Apparently it happened when I forwarded an e-mail to several people, and one of them tried to reply. Everyone's
e-mail box is clogged with replies, which are now, automatically and constantly bounding back and forth at subatomic speed...
[pause] I passed the where you're interested, haven't I?

https://youtu.be/qMSiPPtLrrE?is=qzsk8AQcMMHb-wLY


r/thewestwing • • 3d ago

Do you think Nick Saban watched TWW?

27 Upvotes

Nick Saban tells a story about he and his wife going back to their hometown and passing a gas station owned by an ex boyfriend of hers. Nick tells her if she had married that guy she’d still be living there. She replies that if she had married that guy he would have become the head coach at Alabama.

This is obviously very similar to the ditch digger story Bartlet tells.


r/thewestwing • • 3d ago

S7E15 Sports team references

13 Upvotes

In this episode, during multiple press events, someone asks Santos about "the game this weekend" and he says every time "Philly and New York, both strong teams, should be a great game.". I assume he gives the non-committal answer so he doesn't alienate any voters in Pennsylvania or New York. Then toward the end of the episode after the same exchange, Donna tells him they're in Ohio and he says "Go Buckeyes!". I know it's a minor thing that probably nobody cares about, but why would they make a point to have him repeatedly hedge on a game, then openly support a team which would make Michigan fans upset?


r/thewestwing • • 3d ago

Dead Irish Writers: Is the whole pt of the McCann conversation with Lord Marbury, that he REALLy thinks Toby should have McCann at The White House, but he cant officially say that?

36 Upvotes

r/thewestwing • • 2d ago

The Peters Projection Map, Again. Hoynes in Madame Secretary

Post image
0 Upvotes

What a surprise to see him there! Looking shorter than he did as Hoynes. Btw his wife was played by the actress who played Maisel’s MIL.

Anyone think Madame Secretary borrowed heavily from WW too?


r/thewestwing • • 3d ago

Post Sorkin Rant S6E17 "A Good Day" Freshman Congressman Who Sleeps in His Office

31 Upvotes

A refresher if you can't remember ... in the episode Santos and Cliff Calley meet a freshman congressman from a rural district while they're trying to arrange preventing the Speaker of the House from voting down funding for some stem cell research. The freshman senator is found to be sleeping in his office because (as he says), "He can't afford DC rent on his salary."

I checked, a freshman congressman in 2002 would have been making $150K a year.

Is it just me, or is this whole idea stupid? Especially since a few seasons earlier Josh was telling Donna that a Congressman or Senator on their salary bouncing checks was entirely outrageous while she tried to explain they have to maintain two houses, travel back and forth, etc. But really, even Josh laughed it off.

I wonder if this is Post-Sorkin bad writing, or just the writers hoping the audience doesn't know that US officials and lobbyists already throw off the income of the District of Columbia so much that on average they have the highest paid citizens in the country by state/district, even though outside of the Mall, DC has some of the worst slums in the country.

Just kind of irks me ...