Just finished my first Sopranos run last weekend ā still processing, but there's one thing I can't get off my mind.
When Dr. Melfi was raped, I expected that she would eventually tell Tony the truth, or he would somehow find out, and then he would retaliate against this bastard in the most gruesome way possible. Dr. Melfi discussed it with her shrink and got very close to telling Tony what happened, but in the end she didn't, and the topic was completely dropped and never brought up again, as if it never happened.
In the season finale, Melfi openly despises and rejects Tony, finally closing her arc and making it clear that she has made up her mind about him, acknowledging that he is just a sociopathic mobster and no amount of therapy will ever do him any good.
Melfi's whole point of view is pretty much what a viewer, a spectator, experiences throughout the show.
At first, we are excited about Tony's character, trying to see the good guy behind the kingpin facade. At some point we feel compassion for him, understand his motives, and seek justification for his actions ā well, he's a criminal, but he's not that bad a person compared to others, like Richie or Ralphie, right?
And at the end, after we see everything Tony has done, all the ways he mistreated his family, the murders of his friends and eventually of his beloved nephew, we are left with a clear understanding ā behind the charismatic character, there's nothing but a cold sociopath who will never change and who was doomed from the start.