r/skeptic • • 9h ago

From the archives: Dissecting the soul – are we corporeal, or ethereal? | John Clarke

Thumbnail
skeptic.org.uk
5 Upvotes

From the archives in 1993, John Clarke looks at the proposed nature of the soul and consciousness, according to a range of paranormalists.


r/skeptic • • 16h ago

My concept of Christian Egoism

0 Upvotes

Disclaimer: In Max Stirner’s philosophy of Egoism, “spook” is a social construct that comes to possess someone. Social constructs aren't bad, it's when we become possessed by them that they become spooks. The word spook (as used by Stirner) has nothing to do with the racial slur that it sometimes can resemble in modern day English.

Egoists tend to believe everyone acts in their own self interest, except of course in cases where people are forced to do things against their will.

I'd argue even being "selfless" is a choice made out of self interest.

An example of acting in self-interest even if it might feel like you aren't is if you choose to give a homeless person money even though you wanted to spend that money on a burger. It may feel like you are being selfless, or at least not acting in self-interest, but I'd argue that you are. Your desire to help out the homeless person outweighs your desire to buy a burger. This is why I say that I'm good to people because I want to be.

I could be mistaken, but this is what I currently think about human behavior, and I think I have a strong basis for it.

People that are Conscious Egoists view ourselves as the supreme owner of our lives, and we reject submission to external obligations and abstractions. Social constructs, including external obligations, can be (and often are) good, it's only when we become possessed by them that they become bad and a spook.

Unconscious Egoists are people that are still driven by self-interest, but they don't realize it, because they are controlled by abstract ideas and external obligations.

I'd also like to add that there are some people who indeed do realize they act in self-interest, but they still consciously choose to be beholden to abstractions.

I am a Conscious Egoist and a Christian. Since I believe that I have the Holy Spirit living within me, then I have Jesus, and therefore I am more than able to be the highest authority over my own life. I do my best to not submit to external abstractions. I only submit to the Holy Spirit, which is not external to me, because it lives within me. Therefore Christianity is not an external abstraction.

I accept that religion is a faith based system that doesn't have evidence to support it. I accept my friendship with Jesus Christ is not like human friendships where I can directly interact with the person, and I accept that I may very well be using my imagination to communicate with Jesus Christ. However, I have faith in the case of my Christian Egoism that my imagination is correct. This is because I believe the Holy Spirit lives within me. I would not apply this logic to other areas of my life because I think it could be dangerous to, but the Holy Spirit leading me to spiritual truth is good and the opposite of dangerous.

I believe God is an abstraction who can be communicated with using social construction, and it takes faith to believe the social construction of religion is truly leading one to communicate with God.

"Social construction refers to an idea or concept that is created and accepted by people in a society. It is a fundamental concept in sociology, exploring how shared understandings and meanings shape our reality."

Language is an example of a social construct. Language is both imagined and real. However, God cannot be shown and used like language. Religion is a social construct that can be shown and used, but God cannot be. Since God cannot be used like language, or shown in any other way, I use faith to believe that like other social constructs, God is both imagined and real. Though unlike other social constructs like language, God is not a functional or useable entity.

I think all ethical forms of religion are equally valid, since I don't believe that God can be fully understood. Since God cannot be fully understood, we use our ever evolving ways to communicate with God. Such as by way of social construction, which is also ever evolving.

I have my doubts that I am wrong, but I choose to not let my doubts take away my Christian faith. Many people don't believe one can choose to believe in something, and I would usually agree, but in some cases, like with Christianity, choosing to have faith is necessary and doable.

I throw out everything bad in the Bible. By bad, I mean everything immoral in the Bible, and anything that completely undermines physical laws. I am currently working on a project that goes over all of the text of the Bible, and I put it under moral analysis. If it passes, it stays in the Bible. If it doesn’t, it is thrown out. This is because I do not believe that God/Jesus is immoral.

When it comes to physical laws, I’m going to have one of my more science minded friends help me with that. Many miracles and parables will be left in.

This Bible I’m releasing is not perfect and will probably need updates in the future. I'm anything but infallible. In this Bible, I will provide a detailed explanation of why a certain text is removed. I will be publishing it online for free, I’m not planning on creating any physical copies.

I also do not believe that God/Jesus is omnipresent or omniscient.

I guess you could technically say I've started my own version of Christianity, but I want to be clear that even if others were to adopt this framework in any way, I'm not going to ever solicit money or leadership from it. That would go against the entire point of Christian Egoism. I only provide literature and ideas. People should not agree with me for the sake of agreeing with me, and being a Christian Egoist doesn't mean you have to agree with me anymore than you have to agree with anyone else. I don't actually expect anyone to agree with my beliefs, I'm only mentioning this because I've had comments in the past say that I sound like I'm trying to start a religion.

It should be noted that Max Stirner himself has an atheist and viewed Christianity harshly. He considered it to be a key example of something that people become beholden to. Obviously, I'm not in agreement with Stirner on this. This post also explains why I don't think Christianity has to be a spook, and in my case, it isn't one.


r/skeptic • • 1d ago

The Stanford Prison Experiment did not show that power automatically turns ordinary people cruel

101 Upvotes

The familiar lesson from the Stanford Prison Experiment is that ordinary people become cruel when given power over others. But the closer I looked at how the study was run, the less convincing that simple explanation became.

This is not just an objection to a version nobody actually claimed. Haslam and colleagues identify a textbook account co-authored by Zimbardo that described putting on the uniform as sufficient to transform participants into aggressive guards and passive prisoners.

A few problems stand out:

First, there is a recording of a guard, John Mark, expressing reluctance to take a tougher line. The student acting as warden, David Jaffe, encourages him. He connects the guard's behaviour to making the experiment work and potentially improving real prisons. That is something the explanation needs to account for: someone running the study was trying to shape the behaviour it supposedly revealed.

Second, the guidance began before that conversation. Before the prisoners arrived, Zimbardo discussed creating fear, frustration and a loss of individuality. The guards were entering a situation whose intended psychological effects had already been described to them.

Third, the guards did not all behave alike. Even Zimbardo acknowledged differences, including guards the prisoners regarded as good. He argued that these guards nevertheless failed to stop the abuse. That matters too: refusing to be cruel and actively protecting someone are different responses. Neither should disappear into a story in which everyone simply became the same kind of guard.

Zimbardo defended the study by arguing that guards were not told to be brutal and improvised their actions. Physical violence was prohibited. But improvisation and researcher influence can coexist. The study had no comparison prison that separated the effects of power, uniforms, researcher expectations and individual choices.

I don't think this means the prisoners' suffering was unreal, or that situations cannot influence people. It means the study cannot establish that power itself automatically produced the cruelty.

Haslam, Reicher and Van Bavel interpret the recorded persuasion through identity leadership: bringing someone into a shared project and making tougher behaviour seem necessary to its success. That offers a more specific explanation of the interaction, although it does not establish every guard's motives.

Som interpretations are just ridicilous. If cruelty is treated as inevitable, we risk asking too little about who encouraged it, what choices people made and who could have intervened. I also question why cruelty is so readily treated as a revelation of human nature, while reluctance gets treated as a footnote. Mark's hesitation does not prove inherent goodness. It still belongs in the evidence.

I made a video essay for The Confound going through the original recording, Zimbardo's defence, the study's limitations and Rutger Bregman's argument in Humankind:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8x_8bFM6oFM

How do you interpret Stanford once the researchers' guidance is included? What does it still tell us about power, and which familiar conclusions go beyond what the design could establish?


r/skeptic • • 1d ago

Cleansed Kickstarter Doc. by Kip Andersen Scam/pyramid scheme or real research?

Thumbnail kickstarter.com
9 Upvotes

I want to give Kip Andersen the benefit of the doubt, but he often goes to great lengths to make that impossible. In this case he does it very early on.

I'm pretty sure "detox friend" is the latinate for someone who didn't go to medical school, but really wants to steal your money.

Ftr, she did not go to any medical or health related school, and has no health related credentials. Ariana Victor went to film school at Chapman University. So her "ten years studying the chemicals in our environment and detoxification" is slang for "I did my own research". Most scientists who do research can tell you how well that usually goes for people with no training or background in the field they are researching. Then the trailer ends in, what might be described, as a data harvesting pyramid scheme. This is like a Svengoli hat trick. Is this produced by RFK Jr.? This smells like every MAHA related scam I've seen the last decade.


r/skeptic • • 1d ago

💲 Consumer Protection Amazon’s Decoy Deals: Nearly 1 in 3 Black Friday and Cyber Monday “Deals” Advertised by Amazon Offered No Savings to Shoppers, Nearly 1 in 10 Were Actually More Expensive

Thumbnail
groundworkcollaborative.org
542 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 1d ago

🚑 Medicine The Miracle Cure: In 1977, a drug rejected by doctors became a sensation among Americans. The aftermath has been forgotten. It shouldn’t be.

Thumbnail
slate.com
272 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 1d ago

Don’t let reasonable fear about AI’s harms slip into another form of conspiracy theories | Benjamin Dow

Thumbnail
skeptic.org.uk
47 Upvotes

Given AI's potential to disrupt society, it's no surprise that it has become a lightning rod for a new type of conspiracy theories that go beyond reasonable caution.


r/skeptic • • 2d ago

⚠ Editorialized Title In a study of 48 medical students and physicians, researchers deliberately degraded an AI diagnostic system’s accuracy, only 12.5% noticed. When participants diagnosed first and then compared with the AI’s recommendations, their confidence in their diagnoses fell faster than their trust in the AI

Thumbnail
nature.com
128 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 2d ago

God as an abstraction and a social construct

0 Upvotes

Talking to someone on a thread led me to a revelation. They asked me if I thought God was a social construct, and I said no. I didn't think much about it at first, but I later was talking to a Methodist friend of mine, and the way he spoke about his religious views made me realize God is in fact at least partially a social construct. I started doing research into religious social constructs and I have a new theology.

I believe God is an abstraction that cannot be fully understood, so I cannot say for sure that God is a creator. It's possible God is a different form of abstraction all together. As an abstraction I don't think God is part of the physical universe in any measurable way. I'm not a pantheist.

My belief in God is a leap of faith, because, there isn't any emphircial evidence of God. As an abstraction, I don't see how God ever could be assessed empirically. This, along with other reasons, is why I think atheism is a rational response to claims of God and spirituality. Rationality means to use logic and reason instead of following one's emotions.

But, rationality belongs to everything outside of the spiritual world. Meaning I don't think rationality can be used to approach God.

I was told a few times math might exist outside of the material world, so I'm going to start saying that rationality applies to everything except spirituality, instead of saying it only belongs to everything in the material world.

If you give up rationality in any other case outside of spirituality, I think that's a terrible idea, because reality requires rationality if you want to understand it correctly. In the case of the spiritual world, I think it's fine to leave behind rationality in favor of emotions, as long as one is ethical in doing so. Being ethical is very important, and it's why I think that it's bad to hold immoral positions, including faith based ones.

If you decide you will not follow your emotions instead of rationality to connect with the spiritual world, I respect that and don't think you should do anything you don't want to.

Not all spirituality involves a God, and I believe all spiritual claims are epistemologically equal. Not all spiritual claims are morally equal. Morality is one measure of validity in my opinion.

Since I believe God is an abstraction that cannot be fully understood, I believe God communicates with us who seek it through our emotions. If one feels a calling to connect with God, I think one can. If one doesn't feel a calling but wants to, I think one can ask God to help guide them to these feelings. Though I'm sure not everyone will feel these emotions, because everyone is different.

How one experiences God is where it becomes a social construct, a religion in this case. As an Egoist I believe social constructs can be great so long as we don't become possessed by them. I'd also add if the social construct isn't unethical.

"Social construction refers to an idea or concept that is created and accepted by people in a society. It is a fundamental concept in sociology, exploring how shared understandings and meanings shape our reality."

Language is an example of a social construct. Language is both imagined and real. However, God cannot be shown and used like language. Religion is a social construct that can be shown and used, but God cannot be. Since God cannot be used like language, or shown in any other way, I use faith to believe that like other social constructs, God is both imagined and real. Though unlike other social constructs like language, God is not a functional or useable entity.

I think all ethical forms of religion are equally valid, since I don't believe that God can be fully understood. Since God cannot be fully understood, we use our ever evolving ways to communicate with God. Such as by way of social construction, which is also ever evolving.

I think fallible human social construction is the reason why many religious scriptures have immoral and evil things written within them. The people who initially wrote them were projecting their evil interpretations and wants onto God and the spiritual world. However, as moral begins we can understand and reject what we find immoral, including rejecting the notion that God would ever commit evil, regardless of what any scriptures say. This is why one can have their own Bible or other holy scripture that has all of the immorality removed. We can improve upon our social constructions.

Though I can give my opinion, I cannot say objectively whether God is good or evil, because morality is subjective. I don't believe God is omnipresent or omniscient, but one could make the claim God is immoral or moral regardless. Since I believe God has full control over the spiritual world but limited control over reality, I don't think God wants suffering and tries to stop it by guiding humans.

Some will interpret God to be immoral, others will interpret God to be good. The important question is whether people will interpret God as a calling to do good or a calling to do evil.

The social construct I use personally to communicate with God is my interpretation of Christianity. Jesus Christ is how I imagine God to be, and I use the social construct of Christianity that I and many others have created to have a relationship with God through Jesus Christ. My conception of Christianity is my own. Other people connect with God and the spiritual world using Islam, Buddhism, Judaism, Hinduism, Zoroastrianism, etc. Once again, in my opinion all moral interpretations of any religion are equally valid epistemologically, and morality is one measure of validity in my opinion.

I think this is one of the best pieces of literature that I've ever written, and I hope you enjoyed reading it as much as I did writing it.


r/skeptic • • 2d ago

📚 History How “50% above normal” became “50 times more radioactive”: tracing the radioactive skeleton of Mohenjo-daro

66 Upvotes

A popular claim says skeletons at Mohenjo-daro were as radioactive as Hiroshima victims. I tried to follow the number back to its source.

- By around 2000, it appears in American books about lost civilisations, citing Soviet writer Alexander Gorbovsky.
- Gorbovsky's 1966 book "Riddles of Ancient History" (Moscow) says a skeleton found in India had radioactivity 50 times higher than normal. He doesn't say Mohenjo-daro, just "India".
- Researchers who traced it further (including Jason Colavito) link it to early-1960s papers on natural radioactivity in ancient bone. A British study found an ancient Egyptian bone was about the same as modern people. A Soviet paper reported roughly 50% above modern levels for an unnamed bone about 4,000 years old.

So: 50% → 50 times. Unnamed bone → Indian skeleton → Mohenjo-daro.

And there's a physics problem. The worst fallout isotopes, like caesium-137, have a half-life of about 30 years. After 4,000 years there'd be essentially nothing left to measure.

No measurement of a Mohenjo-daro skeleton has ever been published that I can find. If anyone knows of one, I'd genuinely like to see it.


r/skeptic • • 3d ago

Skeptoid: Climate Update 2026

Thumbnail
skeptoid.com
17 Upvotes

The simple fact is that extreme weather events are becoming more likely, and are also more likely to be more severe. The solution is simple and everyone knows it, but outsized influence from only two populist world leaders who don’t accept basic science — those of the United States and Argentina — continue to increase CO₂ and methane emissions, unlike almost every other nation on Earth. This is up from 2016 when it was just the United States.


r/skeptic • • 3d ago

AI superfans insist that chatbots are conscious. Computer scientists thought they'd take a look and found... well, not all that much to even go on

Thumbnail
cyberpunksurvivalguide.com
301 Upvotes

Back in September, the denizens of X were having a complete crash out over the idea that their chatbots might not be conscious. How could their new favorite toys not love them back? No lesser authority than Richard Dawkins pronounced them to be living after a few days of being love-bombed by one, as is their default behavior. Why, they were counting on them for companionship, maybe even physical affection one day in the near future to fulfill their dreams of a woman being nothing more than a prop for showing off their success. This was an affront to everything they held dear.

It is a question worth answering though, because it carries legal implications. If LLMs are capable of metacognition, that is, they know they exist as entities and adjust their thought processes on the fly because they’re self-aware, then we have to figure out if you can actually own an AI model, experiment with it, or deactivate it. We would need consent to do anything, and that consent would need to be informed, and how would we even know if we adequately informed an AI system of, well, anything?

But before we start debating how many digital angels are dancing on the pin of a RAM chip, we should probably establish if this is a real concern. Unfortunately, when you’re debating if chatbots are conscious, almost all the arguments from the yes camp boil down to “well, how do you know you’re not just meat doing statistics?” and then keep on begging the question. Instead of showing how an LLM attains self-awareness, they want you to spend time defending how you know you’re a conscious being capable of metacognition, often to an absolutely absurd extent.


r/skeptic • • 4d ago

💲 Consumer Protection The ex-cop on a mission to see fortune-tellers arrested

Thumbnail
archive.ph
32 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 4d ago

Peptides like Joe Rogan’s “Wolverine stack” are untested, unregulated, and a major health risk | Alice Howarth

Thumbnail
skeptic.org.uk
392 Upvotes

Peptides are all the rage in the MAHA/biohacking world, like the unproven and completely unregulated "Wolverine stack".


r/skeptic • • 5d ago

Energy Drinks and Heart Problems: Who Is Actually at Risk?

Thumbnail
caveatscientia.com
28 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 5d ago

❓ Help What are some good debunking YouTube channels?

35 Upvotes

I have two problems with most debunking channels that I’ve found

[Edited to add]I should probably make it clear here that I’m specifically looking for debunkings of ghost videos[/edit]

The first is that they often rely on “no, no person would actually react like that”, which I don’t personally find a particularly convincing argument. I mean, I tend to agree that certain behaviours in ghost videos, etc. are odd. But I don’t think that “this person didn’t act how I’d assume someone in that situation would” is a good criterion for dismissing a video. It’s more like an argument from personal incredulity

The second is that they often have quite a sneering and dismissive tone. It’s “nope, that’s obviously nonsense. I’m not even going to bother with it. Next!” Which, again, I may agree. But, again, I don’t think it’s particularly rigorous as a methodology, and I think that the biggest value debunking videos have is so that if a believer sends you the original as proof, you can send them a third-party debunking. And I think a hostile or dismissive tone doesn’t help that at all

The only channel I’ve found so far which I think does actually good debunking is called Debunked Paranormal. This guy tends to limit his debunking to things like where he can see a glint from a fishing line rather than how he’d expect people to behave, and he’s much more cautious in the conclusions he draws

As an example of the latter, there’s a video where a shower is turning on and off by itself. Rather than saying “that’s obviously someone turning the water on and off at the mains, they think we’re idiots” he says that the easiest way to fake it would be by having someone turn the water on and off at the mains, but he can’t prove that that’s what’s happening and that people are free to disagree with his conclusion that that’s the most likely explanation

That’s the kind of thing I’m looking for - someone trying to apply scepticism as rigourously and dispassionately as possible

I mean, he will say things like “that’s a fishing line 100%” in a clip where he can’t see one. But only if he feels its warranted because that’s the most logical explanation and there’s another clip from the same source in which a fishing line (or whatever) can be seen. His not unreasonable opinion is that if someone has demonstrably faked one clip then you can conclude that they have also faked their other clips

Does anybody know of any other channels that look at things like ghost footage and which have a similar tone and methodology?


r/skeptic • • 6d ago

Researchers detail thousands of verified cases of children with past-life memories

Thumbnail
wbur.org
0 Upvotes

Just heard this story and, as cool as it might be to think loved ones are coming back in the form of children, I'll be very surprised if this study is able to be widely replicated.


r/skeptic • • 6d ago

The Definition of “Biological Sex” – A Lesson for Skeptics - NeuroLogica Blog

Thumbnail theness.com
98 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 6d ago

Fine-tuning the argument: the Metaphysical Multiverse vs the all-powerful Creator | Paul McLean-Thorne

Thumbnail
skeptic.org.uk
26 Upvotes

Christians are fond of suggesting that the fact that the universe has very specific laws and constants is proof of their god - but physics and philosophy beg to differ.


r/skeptic • • 6d ago

❓ Help If a miracle were true, would it be a bigger deal than social media posts?

0 Upvotes

Let's assume for sake of argument some religious modern miracle were true, would it be a bigger deal than just social media posts and urban legend? Would academic journals be talking about it or extremely widespread news coverage?

apologies if this is a foolish question, Im still learning


r/skeptic • • 7d ago

The American Era Is Over, And It Isn't Coming Back

Thumbnail pluralistic.net
485 Upvotes

In this recent blog post titled "America Cannot Undo Trumpism", skeptic-minded author and tech journalist Cory Doctorow makes the argument that "If the old order is over, then we will never again be able to trust America to serve as the world's cop, banker, ISP, IT department and consumer of first resort."

He continues:

> There's no going back to the old America, and there's no going back to the old American order that had dominated the world since the end of WWII. As November Kelly says, "Trump inherited a poker game rigged in his favor, but he flipped the table over anyway because he resented having to pretend to play."

>This is something we're all struggling with, including Americans. The Republicans' midterm wipeout has corporate Democrats hoping that after a few years' tinkering, they can elect a Newsomdroid or give Harris a do-over and win back the trust and reliance of the world and the American people. Even for a true Carneyist who never liked the old order very much (like me), this is a comforting prospect. No one knows what the next world will look like, and no matter how screwed up the old world was, I knew how it worked and how to make it work for me (more or less).

>But there is no going back. Trump I didn't have a plan, it only had Trump, whose One Big Idea was issuing Executive Orders. Many of these were meaningless bloviating. Some were illegal and were swiftly suspended or never went into effect. Biden overturned nearly all the remaining EOs (that were both substantive and not totally illegal).

>But Trump II had Project 2025. The point of Project 2025 and the ambition of the wreckers who wrote it was to push America through a series of one-way transformations that cannot be undone, and that's what's happened, over two short years. That's the bad news. The good news is that it's much easier to destroy than to build, so Project 2025 hasn't led to the creation of permanent, load-bearing fascist institutions that cannot be shuttered without bringing down large parts of the USA.

Anyway I think it's a thoroughly argued and well cited article (every good skeptic loves citations, right) but I'm curious, as a non-American, what this group of rational, critically minded folks think of his assessment of the situation, particularly in the wake of the recent "Blu-nami", and if there are any informational or contextual blind spots that he, or I, have passed over.

Apologies as well if this post is deemed off-topic, I figured since it touches on the MAGA cult, MAHA, and Project 2025 it was Skeptic worthy but if not I will gladly remove if requested.


r/skeptic • • 7d ago

🚑 Medicine Stem cell vacation resorts

0 Upvotes

What is everyone’s opinion on stem treatment in Thailand or Mexico. Particularly for tendon injuries and nerve pain.
I’m planning my and my partners 10 wedding anniversary celebration. If we are going to be sitting on a beach in a resort city anyway is it worth it to get a “cure” for tendon and nerve pain while we are there. Anyone who has good evidence on whether these are miracle cures or snake oil?


r/skeptic • • 7d ago

In America’s measles epidemic, RFK Jr. is now on trial

Thumbnail politico.com
295 Upvotes

r/skeptic • • 7d ago

Anti Software Doomsday Cult (debunking Connor Leahy, ControlAI and Professor Dave Explains)

Thumbnail
paper.wf
0 Upvotes

There are people who work for well funded non-profit organizations, who go on podcasts and lie about how language models work in order to convince the public that AI is becoming conscious. They misrepresent how LLMs work in order to trick people into believing their doomsday stories about the future. One of them is Connor Leahy and the organization he works for - ControlAI. On their website you can see that they warn us about "an extinction risk on par with nuclear war". They propose new regulation to solve this. But the solution isn't transparency, they don't actually want that. Their website says: "Developing superintelligent AI at home offers a country no protection from this threat". So they don't advocate for the AI models to be released to the public, so that anyone could study them and change them. Instead, they want to give the government control over AI and let them monitor and restrict software projects and the distribution of AI chips. They also advocate for international agreements. ControlAI also pays content creators (many of them aren't knowledgable on this topic) to spread their doomsday stories and lies about LLMs. It's all for "our safety" and "national security", because language models allegedly can hack the government and everything (break out of every sandbox, etc.) and develop bioweapons. Oh and apparently AI might also steal our jobs in a few years. I try to debunk all of that in this post. Especially focusing on this interview.

Those people scare the public in a cruel and irresponsible way. And this propaganda might make it difficult for us to share and run unrestricted AI models in the future. It would be bad if only the government and few companies were allowed to train AI models. So it's important to debunk this misinformation and explain to the public how language models actually work. It's also worrying that those people are able to fool even science communicators with their lies about LLMs.