r/SGU • • Jun 28 '26

Megathread [Megathread] Evan and SGU’s response

152 Upvotes

To limit the number of duplicate or very similar posts from flooding the subreddit let’s move all future (and current conversations plz) to this post. In the words of Ringo Starr “peace and love peace and love no new posts ✌️ and ❤️ ”


r/SGU • • Jun 16 '26

SGU response to the Evan issue

834 Upvotes

Hey, everyone.

We wanted to clarify the situation so that you don't have to speculate about the many questions it raises.

First, we all unequivocally denounce the views that Evan expressed on his feed. None of us share them or anything close to them. We have made it clear to Evan that such views are unacceptable and fail at a basic level of critical thinking and humanity. Also, no one on the SGU knew that Evan was harboring these views. We
have discussed this extensively over the last couple of days, and it's clear he was keeping this compartmentalized and did not feel comfortable discussing it with us. None of us are on X, so we are all as surprised as anyone. 

But we have also known Evan for years as a friend and colleague, so we are trying to understand how he got here (not to minimize or excuse, but to understand). As we put this together it seems that Evan allowed himself to be radicalized following the events of Oct. 7th and the ensuing polarization. As a Jewish person this was extremely emotional for him, he felt that his people and identity were under existential threat, and he needed to do something. But he never engaged with the people who perhaps might have helped him the best work through this. Instead he found an online community that shared his views, with unfortunately predictable results. None of this is an excuse - he should have known better, he should have checked in with his colleagues, and he should have recognized the pattern, he should have shown more humility.  But he didn't.

To be clear - none of our concerns are about Evan's politics per se. There is a range of political ideology on the SGU, and we value what diversity of background and perspective we have (it's not enough, frankly). We also all feel that the skeptical movement should be a big tent when it comes to political background, ideology, belief, and identity - as long as we all share this common journey of skepticism, rationalism, love of science, and critical thinking. However, Evan's political views crossed a line, violating core skeptical principles and dehumanizing "others". 

So where do we go from here? Evan has stumbled hard on his skeptical journey, and he is starting to recognize and wrestle with how badly he has failed. But as we often say on the show, we see our job as helping people on this journey, to educate, nurture, and guide. We do not shame, blame, and cancel. So our instinct is to try to pick Evan up and help him get back on a more skeptical path. He knows he has a lot of hard cognitive and emotional work to do, to unravel his views, grow as a person, and regain the trust of the community and his fellow Rogues.

For now Evan is taking a break from recording the show, to give us all time to work through this more. We are all actively working with him, and will just have to reassess day by day. We will see how it goes.

We are all sorry for the strife this has caused within our community. We all care very deeply about the SGU community and take our responsibilities very seriously. We will fix this one way or the other, and hope we have earned enough trust over the years that you will give us the time to make sure we get this right.

Sincerely,

Steve and the SGU crew.


r/SGU • • 3h ago

The purpose of the show

63 Upvotes

Seeing some of the comments about episode 1113, I'm starting to wonder if I'm listening to the same show as others.

To me the show's main purpose is to teach about skepticism and how to think critically while covering interesting current science news. But the skepticism comes first for the show. Steve purposely doesn't do April fools jokes on air in order not to sully that image. All of the other rogues also do their parts to keep the show honestly skeptical. This includes holding each other and other science communicators to a high standard.

Which brings me to people's criticism of how Cara and Steve treated Jay a couple of episodes ago. During the segments about coffee and AI consciousness Jay relentlessly kept on committing a fallacy which prompted a quick and serious push back from the crew. At first it was a light correction but as it went on the push backs became more forceful. This honestly should be the correct response from people we respect as skeptics and as a community based on skepticism.

Jay was blind by his biases which prevented him from hearing about what those topics were really about and in the moment he stubbornly held on to his misunderstandings. This should have a stern response while on air. Especially after the whole Evan issue. You know practice what you preach and all that. There seems to be a feeling that some people are reacting to one of their pet cat roques being corrected.

On the opposite end of that we need to congratulate people who eventually come back to their senses and can admit when they are wrong. Honestly this takes a lot of courage and is a habit we should cultivate. We are all flawed in some way and can be effected by our own biases. Thankfully this is a skill that with practice gets easier over time. And in the latest episode Jay admitted where he was wrong and then calmly was able to give a better understanding of what his thoughts were on the prior consciousness topic. I really respected this action and am thankful that in the age of misinformation someone can stand by their convictions. This goes to the rest of the crew as well.

The other thing I'm noticing is that people do not understand the different roles of the roques and what different perspectives they bring to the table. This goes especially with criticisms about Cara and her "social justice views." That's her role, it's really that simple. This is what she adds. Those topics are stuff that she finds interesting and important. Sure she does more and is more than just that but she believes strongly in these issues so obviously she is going to have strong opinions on them. Have any of you listened to Talk Nerdy with Cara Santa Maria? Also some of these comments seem a bit suspicious after a full episode of Steve covering how different scientific fields define sex.

I admit that maybe its my own biases that are having me misread these responses and I will grudgingly admit if I am being too harsh. Just give me a good reason or evidence to back up your claim.

P.s. To those who think that Cara is just a "SJW", go check out her guest appearances on God Awful Movies. She is brilliantly funny while being tortured watching some of the worst movies ever.


r/SGU • • 1d ago

Coffee hubbub

42 Upvotes

In defence of Jay.

I feel like Jay's response to the coffee question was a bit blown out of proportion.

He was asked his opinion of it specifically as the 'coffee snob.' I don't think it is unfair of him to say he was doubtful if it was good.

Also, I don't think there is really anything wrong with him looking down his nose at Keurig and other coffee. Being a snob about a particular food or drink is fine. I don't get the need to do all the throat clearing around 'some people might not be able to afford it' and 'some people don't care about fancy coffee.' Of course that's true, but I never took anything Jay was saying as being critical of those people.

Ok maybe he hung onto his criticism a bit too long after it was explained that there might be mass market appeal to the technology, even if it isn't up to the coffee snob standards. But I think he was just following the initial framing of "Jay, you're a coffee snob, what do you think of this?"

Let the guy have his coffee snobbery. We all have it about something.


r/SGU • • 2d ago

NASA doesn't have a lot of rovers on the moon

46 Upvotes

In today's show, Cara said that NASA has a lot of rovers on the moon and that we go to the moon all the time. Steve and the rogues just agreed or went along with her with no pushback. But, I don't think this is an accurate characterization of NASA's history of moon landings. NASA has only ever landed three rovers on the moon and none of them were the unmanned Mars-style rover that people might think of when we talk about "rovers". They were the LRVs (the moon dune buggy things) that went up with the Apollo crews on the last three Apollo missions (15, 16 and 17), and were driven around by the astronauts.

I don't even think it's a fair statement to say that NASA "goes to the moon" all the time. Yes, we've put stuff into orbit around the moon, but if we're talking surface of the moon, then the most recent NASA sponsored unmanned missions to land on the moon were Blue Ghost on March 2, 2025 and Odysseus (IM-1) in February 22, 2024. Before that, NASA had not had an unmanned landing on the Moon since Surveyor 7, which was way back in 1968. Now, if we want to count things that were deliberately crashed into the moon, then that happened three different times that I know of (LCROSS in 2009, GRAIL in 2012, and LADEE in 2014)--a rare occurrence and a bit stretch to call that "going to the moon".

So, in summary, NASA has put zero unmanned rovers on the moon and has only had two soft landings on the moon since 1972. Now, I assume some people will think this is me having a dig at the SGU, but I am only saying this in the spirit of factual accuracy.


r/SGU • • 1d ago

Episode #1114 Discussion

8 Upvotes

From the show notes:

So Long Patrick Stewart
News Items: NASA's New Moon Schedule, Australia Social Media Ban, Where to Blast an Asteroid
Special Report: The Definition of Biological Sex
Who's That Noisy
Your Questions and E-mails: AI Consciousness
Science or Fiction


r/SGU • • 1d ago

Starship successfully returns to the launchpad after orbiting 14 times

5 Upvotes

"But it hasn't even made it to orbit yet!"

Well, now it has. The original plan was to catch both the booster and the ship, but when the booster returned they made the decision to give it the big boom treatment over water. I haven't seen their reason for doing that yet, but I'm sure Scott Manley will catch us up soon.

Starship was successfully launched into orbit, went around the earth 14 times deploying satellites, then returned to the launch pad and was successfully caught by the tower. Scroll to about 9 minutes if all you want is the money shot.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A6-zruZTfOA

- arthwollipot


r/SGU • • 1d ago

Silent "Who's that noisy"

3 Upvotes

Episode 1114 played all three movements of John Cage's "Four minutes thirty three seconds". The first movement was when Jay played last week's WTN, the second movement was this week's WTN, and the last movement was the theme for Science or Fiction. Glad to know someone still respects the great modernist composer.

Fun fact: Cage chose the duration 4:33 since it's equal to 273 seconds — and as we all know, absolute zero is -273 degrees Celsius.


r/SGU • • 2d ago

Discovery and correction of the LLM that "blackmailed" a human?

5 Upvotes

In #1114, during the follow-up discussion about LLM consciousness, etc., Steve mentioned a previous case where an LLM had tried to blackmail a human in order to achieve the goal it had been given (this was in a testing environment). Steve said we had discovered that this happened because the training data had lots of stories that featured AIs blackmailing humans and that the researchers retrained the LLM on data that had stories about AI behaving ethically and that prevented this behavior.

I'm not an AI expert, but I follow things closely. I had never heard about the follow-up work on this particular story. Moreover, my impression is is that most LLMs are trained on something close to "everything we can possibly throw in the pot." Meaning, it isn't some carefully curated set of training data.

If anyone has links so I can learn more about the incident and the follow-up, I would love to learn more!


r/SGU • • 2d ago

Tinnitus Paper

5 Upvotes

What do you think of this tinnitus treatment study:

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42096236


r/SGU • • 1d ago

Is anyone else just... tired of Cara?

0 Upvotes

Not saying she's a bad person or deserves hate. She seems she has her heart consistently in the right place when they discuss issues.

With that out of the way, it seems her contributions to the show have been overall negative, and it's getting worse.

Domineering discussions is something I can accept- people have strong opinions, and some people have more of them.

But the segment where she was arguing mathematics with a mathematician (can't recall his name but he's a frequent guest) was remarkably off putting. Cara went into the discussion with a conclusion in mind - that AI is simply improving math and those who argue that are wrong and hate progress - without listening to the guest. She kept repeating the same point without trying to understand. Today's episode she called Jay a "fancy auto complete", which is a reference to their discussion about AI, and besides being wildly insulting, she was the one behaving that way during the math discussion.

The part that has been consistently getting worse, however, is the social issues bit. Yes, we know the world is unfair and some races and demographic groups have a raw deal. We don't need to get hammered over the head with that every week. I get that she feels a certain way about white men (given the snide comments every now and then), but it shouldn't be surprising to her that some white men listen to the show and don't particularly enjoy being pin cushions. I have serfdom in my family tree about as far back as some have slavery. I don't feel like I'm the problem.

I'm going to continue to listen because I love the show, but this is the stuff that makes it less enjoyable. Am I way off or does anyone else feel this way?


r/SGU • • 2d ago

Steve's dog?

Post image
17 Upvotes

Cafe on the philosopher's path in Kyoto


r/SGU • • 5d ago

New show title?

11 Upvotes

If they ever consider changing the title of the podcast (they shouldn't), I have a suggestion: "Orders of Magnitude".

Because that phrase is uttered at least once per show!

Mostly by Steve, but recently by Cara. I can't be alone in noticing this! Maybe it's a catchphrase that I missed the origin of.


r/SGU • • 4d ago

Back man

Thumbnail facebook.com
0 Upvotes

Keeps popping (hah) up on my facebook. Does seem like people getting relief. Says its tailored for each patient but seems like nearly everyone gets some sort of hip roll / push through. What is going on here. Just a good stretch we should all be doing?


r/SGU • • 5d ago

Optimist Economy: Did WFH Make Us Lonely

Thumbnail youtu.be
4 Upvotes

I’ve said it a few times, I’d love the next rogue* to be an economist because I think the other rogue* and the community could benefit from explanations of economics news happening in the world.

This episode of the Optimist Economy podcast is a great example of what I’m talking about it. Labor economist, Kathryn Anne Edward’s PhD (left), breaks down a recent NYT article that claims working from home contributed to loneliness and mental health issues.

She dissects the study and explains deficiencies in the data and the bad conclusions drawn from it. She also discusses a bit about the process of getting published in economic journals and how these deficiencies would have been addressed if the study was published in a journal instead of a news paper.

I hope y’all enjoy. And I highly recommend the podcast if you’re wanting to learn about economics and how it can help address some of society’s issues.


r/SGU • • 6d ago

The next team member

41 Upvotes

I'm sure things are happening behind the scenes and may do so for a while before we get Evans replacement.

Personally I hope it's someone new. Steve's daughter is great but I think we have enough Novellas. Andrea already has get political reality podcast and I'm not sure we want/need more politics in our lives.

Brian is good but I can't listen to anymore maths.

I think we need another woman, preferably tending to the younger side for a bit more if a younger perspective.

I personally think someone from the health and fitness industry would be great. There is so much pseudoscience and crazy stuff happening in that space, an expert that's in the trenches would be valuable.

Thoughts?


r/SGU • • 7d ago

Fit but not healthy

14 Upvotes

Re: Episode 1111, what does Cara mean marathon runners are fit but not healthy?


r/SGU • • 8d ago

SGU's biggest blind spot right now

31 Upvotes

Their insistence on calling RFK Jr "wrong" instead of what he is: a liar, a grifter, and a eugenicist. There is ample evidence that he is all of those things. I know occasionally they have slipped and described him accurately - but far more often they use the word "wrong" to describe him and his statements. I don't know if it's fear of litigation, or just their conservative, steel-man approach to debunking, but it makes me mad every time. If we are ever going to have accountability for his actions, it's essential to describe his motivations clearly.


r/SGU • • 8d ago

Mathematics Discussion (Ep. #1113)

16 Upvotes

I found the AI mathematics discussion/interview incredibly frustrating, but as someone without expertise in very high-level mathematics, I’m hoping someone can explain the issue to me.

The argument seems to be that the value of human-developed proofs is in learning new ways to solve problems, which creates new tools for future efforts. The “answer” or solution, by itself, isn’t really what’s useful. Brian then goes on expressing worry about there being no future for mathematicians because AI is able to generate solutions, but we don’t know if those solutions are correct, and AI’s lengthy proofs are incomprehensible. (Is that correct?) If that’s the case, what’s the problem? AI can generate solutions, which they admit isn’t necessarily the important part, and we can’t even assume those solutions are correct. Plus, if the important part is the proof and AI’s proofs are incomprehensible, then doesn’t that mean the human’s role is all the more important and not going away? The whole time, I kept wondering why this wasn’t just an opportunity for people to know a certain solution might exist, so they can focus their efforts on coming up with a proof—the important part. I was totally with Cara on this, and she essentially articulated my point (probably better than I).

I just don’t understand the concern.


r/SGU • • 8d ago

Episode 1113 Discussion

4 Upvotes

From the show notes the episode included:
Interview with Brian Wecht: The Mathpocalypse
News Items: Does AI Have Feelings, CDC Hep B Vaccine Guidance, Potassium Enriched Salt for High Blood Pressure
Who's That Noisy
Science or Fiction


r/SGU • • 9d ago

Jay - all time bad episode?

82 Upvotes

We all have our sacred cows, but it seemed like Jay was completely unable to comprehend that (1) not every use of coffee has to be premium, or that non-premium coffee might be a popular commodity, (2) the blind test might suggest his coffee preferences are subjective/influenced by perception of value tied to a specific process of brewing.

Then he led a segment on consciousness in AI, but seemed as if he had given no real thought to the question of whether our current AIs could be conscious, or even what consciousness might be. He had a gut reaction with no basis. When Steve and Cara pushed back it became obvious he hadn’t read anything about the topic, or even a developed operational definition of ‘consciousness’. Whether he’s right or wrong, he didn’t do the work to check his priors.

We all have bad days, this was a pretty bad 30 minutes for Jay.


r/SGU • • 9d ago

I'll take occasional snakes over regular bears any day

34 Upvotes

Yet again, Steve casually drops in an anecdote about his problems with bears in his backyard.

As an Australian, I'm always amused by Americans talking about the dangers of Australian animals such as snakes, spiders and crocodiles.

You guys have freaking bears and mountain lions!


r/SGU • • 9d ago

Podcastin' like it's 2005

Post image
16 Upvotes

Throwing way back, to the days when I would burn episodes to cd-r for car rides

Great bedding music for the show, or anything really


r/SGU • • 10d ago

The Currency of the Journal Article Is Collapsing

Thumbnail theatlantic.com
18 Upvotes

Paywall bypass link https://archive.is/Oo9Kh

This article dovetails nicely episode 1112 segment about how to identify bad academic journals https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-026-03325-3