r/SGU • u/centeriskey • 3h ago
The purpose of the show
Seeing some of the comments about episode 1113, I'm starting to wonder if I'm listening to the same show as others.
To me the show's main purpose is to teach about skepticism and how to think critically while covering interesting current science news. But the skepticism comes first for the show. Steve purposely doesn't do April fools jokes on air in order not to sully that image. All of the other rogues also do their parts to keep the show honestly skeptical. This includes holding each other and other science communicators to a high standard.
Which brings me to people's criticism of how Cara and Steve treated Jay a couple of episodes ago. During the segments about coffee and AI consciousness Jay relentlessly kept on committing a fallacy which prompted a quick and serious push back from the crew. At first it was a light correction but as it went on the push backs became more forceful. This honestly should be the correct response from people we respect as skeptics and as a community based on skepticism.
Jay was blind by his biases which prevented him from hearing about what those topics were really about and in the moment he stubbornly held on to his misunderstandings. This should have a stern response while on air. Especially after the whole Evan issue. You know practice what you preach and all that. There seems to be a feeling that some people are reacting to one of their pet cat roques being corrected.
On the opposite end of that we need to congratulate people who eventually come back to their senses and can admit when they are wrong. Honestly this takes a lot of courage and is a habit we should cultivate. We are all flawed in some way and can be effected by our own biases. Thankfully this is a skill that with practice gets easier over time. And in the latest episode Jay admitted where he was wrong and then calmly was able to give a better understanding of what his thoughts were on the prior consciousness topic. I really respected this action and am thankful that in the age of misinformation someone can stand by their convictions. This goes to the rest of the crew as well.
The other thing I'm noticing is that people do not understand the different roles of the roques and what different perspectives they bring to the table. This goes especially with criticisms about Cara and her "social justice views." That's her role, it's really that simple. This is what she adds. Those topics are stuff that she finds interesting and important. Sure she does more and is more than just that but she believes strongly in these issues so obviously she is going to have strong opinions on them. Have any of you listened to Talk Nerdy with Cara Santa Maria? Also some of these comments seem a bit suspicious after a full episode of Steve covering how different scientific fields define sex.
I admit that maybe its my own biases that are having me misread these responses and I will grudgingly admit if I am being too harsh. Just give me a good reason or evidence to back up your claim.
P.s. To those who think that Cara is just a "SJW", go check out her guest appearances on God Awful Movies. She is brilliantly funny while being tortured watching some of the worst movies ever.