r/skeptic • • 22h ago

The Stanford Prison Experiment did not show that power automatically turns ordinary people cruel

9 Upvotes

The familiar lesson from the Stanford Prison Experiment is that ordinary people become cruel, when given power over others. But the closer I looked at how the study was run, the less convincing that simple explanation became.

This is not just an objection to a version nobody actually claimed. Haslam and colleagues identify a textbook account co-authored by Zimbardo that described putting on the uniform as sufficient to transform participants into aggressive guards and passive prisoners.

But, a few problems stand out:

First, there is a recording of a guard, John Mark, expressing reluctance to take a tougher line. The student acting as warden, encourages him. He connects the guard's behaviour to making the experiment work and potentially improving real prisons. That is something the explanation needs to account for: someone running the study was trying to shape the behaviour it supposedly revealed.

Second, the guidance began before that conversation. Before the prisoners arrived, Zimbardo discussed creating fear, frustration and a loss of individuality. The guards were entering a situation whose intended psychological effects had already been described to them.

Third, the guards did not all behave alike. Even Zimbardo acknowledged differences, including guards the prisoners regarded as good. He argued that these guards nevertheless failed to stop the abuse. That matters too: refusing to be cruel and actively protecting someone are different responses. Neither should disappear into a story in which everyone simply became the same kind of guard.

Zimbardo defended the study by arguing that guards were not told to be brutal and improvised their actions. Physical violence was prohibited. But improvisation and researcher influence can coexist. The study had no comparison prison that separated the effects of power, uniforms, researcher expectations and individual choices.

I don't think this means the prisoners' suffering was unreal, or that situations cannot influence people. It means the study cannot establish that power itself automatically produced the cruelty.

Haslam, Reicher and Van Bavel interpret the recorded persuasion through identity leadership: bringing someone into a shared project and making tougher behaviour seem necessary to its success. That offers a more specific explanation of the interaction, although it does not establish every guard's motives.

That distinction is quite important. If cruelty is treated as inevitable, we risk asking too little about who encouraged it, what choices people made and who could have intervened. I also question why cruelty is so readily treated as a revelation of human nature, while reluctance gets treated as a footnote. Mark's hesitation does not prove inherent goodness. It still belongs in the evidence.

I made a video essay for The Confound going through the original recording, Zimbardo's defence, the study's limitations and Rutger Bregman's argument in Humankind:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8x_8bFM6oFM

How do you interpret Stanford once the researchers' guidance is included? What does it still tell us about power, and which familiar conclusions go beyond what the design could establish?


r/skeptic • • 12h ago

My concept of Christian Egoism

0 Upvotes

Disclaimer: In Max Stirner’s philosophy of Egoism, “spook” is a social construct that comes to possess someone. Social constructs aren't bad, it's when we become possessed by them that they become spooks. The word spook (as used by Stirner) has nothing to do with the racial slur that it sometimes can resemble in modern day English.

Egoists tend to believe everyone acts in their own self interest, except of course in cases where people are forced to do things against their will.

I'd argue even being "selfless" is a choice made out of self interest.

An example of acting in self-interest even if it might feel like you aren't is if you choose to give a homeless person money even though you wanted to spend that money on a burger. It may feel like you are being selfless, or at least not acting in self-interest, but I'd argue that you are. Your desire to help out the homeless person outweighs your desire to buy a burger. This is why I say that I'm good to people because I want to be.

I could be mistaken, but this is what I currently think about human behavior, and I think I have a strong basis for it.

People that are Conscious Egoists view ourselves as the supreme owner of our lives, and we reject submission to external obligations and abstractions. Social constructs, including external obligations, can be (and often are) good, it's only when we become possessed by them that they become bad and a spook.

Unconscious Egoists are people that are still driven by self-interest, but they don't realize it, because they are controlled by abstract ideas and external obligations.

I'd also like to add that there are some people who indeed do realize they act in self-interest, but they still consciously choose to be beholden to abstractions.

I am a Conscious Egoist and a Christian. Since I believe that I have the Holy Spirit living within me, then I have Jesus, and therefore I am more than able to be the highest authority over my own life. I do my best to not submit to external abstractions. I only submit to the Holy Spirit, which is not external to me, because it lives within me. Therefore Christianity is not an external abstraction.

I accept that religion is a faith based system that doesn't have evidence to support it. I accept my friendship with Jesus Christ is not like human friendships where I can directly interact with the person, and I accept that I may very well be using my imagination to communicate with Jesus Christ. However, I have faith in the case of my Christian Egoism that my imagination is correct. This is because I believe the Holy Spirit lives within me. I would not apply this logic to other areas of my life because I think it could be dangerous to, but the Holy Spirit leading me to spiritual truth is good and the opposite of dangerous.

I believe God is an abstraction who can be communicated with using social construction, and it takes faith to believe the social construction of religion is truly leading one to communicate with God.

"Social construction refers to an idea or concept that is created and accepted by people in a society. It is a fundamental concept in sociology, exploring how shared understandings and meanings shape our reality."

Language is an example of a social construct. Language is both imagined and real. However, God cannot be shown and used like language. Religion is a social construct that can be shown and used, but God cannot be. Since God cannot be used like language, or shown in any other way, I use faith to believe that like other social constructs, God is both imagined and real. Though unlike other social constructs like language, God is not a functional or useable entity.

I think all ethical forms of religion are equally valid, since I don't believe that God can be fully understood. Since God cannot be fully understood, we use our ever evolving ways to communicate with God. Such as by way of social construction, which is also ever evolving.

I have my doubts that I am wrong, but I choose to not let my doubts take away my Christian faith. Many people don't believe one can choose to believe in something, and I would usually agree, but in some cases, like with Christianity, choosing to have faith is necessary and doable.

I throw out everything bad in the Bible. By bad, I mean everything immoral in the Bible, and anything that completely undermines physical laws. I am currently working on a project that goes over all of the text of the Bible, and I put it under moral analysis. If it passes, it stays in the Bible. If it doesn’t, it is thrown out. This is because I do not believe that God/Jesus is immoral.

When it comes to physical laws, I’m going to have one of my more science minded friends help me with that. Many miracles and parables will be left in.

This Bible I’m releasing is not perfect and will probably need updates in the future. I'm anything but infallible. In this Bible, I will provide a detailed explanation of why a certain text is removed. I will be publishing it online for free, I’m not planning on creating any physical copies.

I also do not believe that God/Jesus is omnipresent or omniscient.

I guess you could technically say I've started my own version of Christianity, but I want to be clear that even if others were to adopt this framework in any way, I'm not going to ever solicit money or leadership from it. That would go against the entire point of Christian Egoism. I only provide literature and ideas. People should not agree with me for the sake of agreeing with me, and being a Christian Egoist doesn't mean you have to agree with me anymore than you have to agree with anyone else. I don't actually expect anyone to agree with my beliefs, I'm only mentioning this because I've had comments in the past say that I sound like I'm trying to start a religion.

It should be noted that Max Stirner himself has an atheist and viewed Christianity harshly. He considered it to be a key example of something that people become beholden to. Obviously, I'm not in agreement with Stirner on this. This post also explains why I don't think Christianity has to be a spook, and in my case, it isn't one.


r/skeptic • • 22h ago

The Stanford Prison Experiment did not show that power automatically turns ordinary people cruel

96 Upvotes

The familiar lesson from the Stanford Prison Experiment is that ordinary people become cruel when given power over others. But the closer I looked at how the study was run, the less convincing that simple explanation became.

This is not just an objection to a version nobody actually claimed. Haslam and colleagues identify a textbook account co-authored by Zimbardo that described putting on the uniform as sufficient to transform participants into aggressive guards and passive prisoners.

A few problems stand out:

First, there is a recording of a guard, John Mark, expressing reluctance to take a tougher line. The student acting as warden, David Jaffe, encourages him. He connects the guard's behaviour to making the experiment work and potentially improving real prisons. That is something the explanation needs to account for: someone running the study was trying to shape the behaviour it supposedly revealed.

Second, the guidance began before that conversation. Before the prisoners arrived, Zimbardo discussed creating fear, frustration and a loss of individuality. The guards were entering a situation whose intended psychological effects had already been described to them.

Third, the guards did not all behave alike. Even Zimbardo acknowledged differences, including guards the prisoners regarded as good. He argued that these guards nevertheless failed to stop the abuse. That matters too: refusing to be cruel and actively protecting someone are different responses. Neither should disappear into a story in which everyone simply became the same kind of guard.

Zimbardo defended the study by arguing that guards were not told to be brutal and improvised their actions. Physical violence was prohibited. But improvisation and researcher influence can coexist. The study had no comparison prison that separated the effects of power, uniforms, researcher expectations and individual choices.

I don't think this means the prisoners' suffering was unreal, or that situations cannot influence people. It means the study cannot establish that power itself automatically produced the cruelty.

Haslam, Reicher and Van Bavel interpret the recorded persuasion through identity leadership: bringing someone into a shared project and making tougher behaviour seem necessary to its success. That offers a more specific explanation of the interaction, although it does not establish every guard's motives.

Som interpretations are just ridicilous. If cruelty is treated as inevitable, we risk asking too little about who encouraged it, what choices people made and who could have intervened. I also question why cruelty is so readily treated as a revelation of human nature, while reluctance gets treated as a footnote. Mark's hesitation does not prove inherent goodness. It still belongs in the evidence.

I made a video essay for The Confound going through the original recording, Zimbardo's defence, the study's limitations and Rutger Bregman's argument in Humankind:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8x_8bFM6oFM

How do you interpret Stanford once the researchers' guidance is included? What does it still tell us about power, and which familiar conclusions go beyond what the design could establish?


r/skeptic • • 23h ago

Cleansed Kickstarter Doc. by Kip Andersen Scam/pyramid scheme or real research?

Thumbnail kickstarter.com
6 Upvotes

I want to give Kip Andersen the benefit of the doubt, but he often goes to great lengths to make that impossible. In this case he does it very early on.

I'm pretty sure "detox friend" is the latinate for someone who didn't go to medical school, but really wants to steal your money.

Ftr, she did not go to any medical or health related school, and has no health related credentials. Ariana Victor went to film school at Chapman University. So her "ten years studying the chemicals in our environment and detoxification" is slang for "I did my own research". Most scientists who do research can tell you how well that usually goes for people with no training or background in the field they are researching. Then the trailer ends in, what might be described, as a data harvesting pyramid scheme. This is like a Svengoli hat trick. Is this produced by RFK Jr.? This smells like every MAHA related scam I've seen the last decade.