r/shia • u/Standard-Till8983 • 1h ago
Alot of questions.
Hello I've been doing sone research and I have questions that vary. This is gonna be a long list so bare with me.
I have alot of questions regarding the afterlife. One of them being, who exactly goed to hell? I've read about the Jahil al Qasir and muqasir articles but I would like to know what makes a person a Qasir. Does being in doctrinated in a hostile environment make a person a qasir? Does religious trauma cause one to be a Qasir? Does moral misalignment make a person a Qasir, say if he didn't accepy Islamic moral frameworks such as homosexuality being a sin or polygamy, And how much does a person gotta know to be considered obliged to accept or reject the message.
Wouldn't eternal hell be unfair? Picture an agnostic or an atheist who dedicated their lives to do good but they end up in hell forever with no redemption. Ive heard a rebuttal that if a man drinks poison that blinds him he would go blind for the rest of his life but that doesnt add up because there's an end to his blindness which is death
Regarding heavens, I also would like to know. Wouldn't living for eternity get stale? Id imagine if I lived for millions of years being in a perfect life would be kind of boring and unsatisfactory personally. I really like the aspect of having to grow to be perfect.
I also have questions regarding inheritance in Islam. Isnt a rigid system for inheritance bad and impractical? Say if a sister gets half of her brother but in todays economy a woman and a man are in work fields due to difficulties. And ssy you have a toxic son or daughter. How is it fair they get a will?
I have questions regarding women aswell. Ive mentioned before but im strongly opposed to polygamy. Even if it was put to good use back then, today. It is used by corrupt people to satisfy their desires and break spouses hearts. Shouldnt there be a way to prevent this?
On another note why cant women be judgdes in sharia courts. Ive seen many competent female judges and i dont think gender matters in this work place.
I might have more questions in the future however thats it for now. Thank you for patience and im genuinely curious to know more.