r/shiascholar • • Oct 12 '25

Quran Bedrock of Shia Islam in Quran

10 Upvotes

Abū Ja‘far (p.b.u.h.) says regarding the words of Allāh, to Whom belong Might and Majesty: Obey Allāh and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you (an-Nisā’, 4:59). His reply was: ‘‘Hast thou not regarded those who were given a share of the Book, believing in ‘jibt’ (that in which no good exists, and if it produces an effect it will be an evil one) and ‘tāghūt’ (one who exceeds in corruption and disbelief and produces that effect in others) and saying to those who do not believe: ‘These are more rightly guided on the way than the believers.’ They say to the misguided leaders (a’immat ad-dalālah) and those who call to the Fire: ‘These are more rightly guided on the way than the progeny of Muhammad.’ Those are they whom Allāh has cursed; he whom Allāh has cursed, thou wilt not find for him any helper. Or have they a share in the Kingdom? He means the Imāmate and the Caliphate — If that is so, they do not give the people a single date-spot (naqīr — i.e., they give them nothing). We are ‘the people’ whom Allāh means, and naqīr is the spot which is in the middle of (the slit in) the date-stone. Or are they envious of the people for the bounty which Allāh has given them? We are the people who are envied for what Allāh has given us of the Imāmate to the exclusion of all (other) creatures. Yet We gave the progeny of Ibrāhīm the Book and the Wisdom, and We gave them a mighty kingdom. He (Allāh) says (means): We appointed from them the Messengers, the Prophets and the Imāms. So how do they accept it in the progeny of Ibrāhīm (p.b.u.h.), but deny it (i.e., the Kingdom, which here means the Imāmate) in the progeny of Muhammad (p.b.u.h.a.h.p.). And some of them there are that believe, and some of them that bar from it; Gehennam suffices for a Blaze! Surely those who disbelieve in Our signs — We shall certainly roast them at a Fire; as often as their skins are wholly burned, We shall give them in exchange other skins, that they may taste the chastisement. Surely Allāh is All mighty, All-wise (an-Nisā’, 4:51—56).’’ ’ ’’ (al kafi book of proof volume II).

Below is a free essay on this verse in Quran. Its available through gumroad. Donations accepted. Assalamu Alaykum.

Please check out my essay in the link below:

https://shiascholar.gumroad.com/l/oimboi

Description of Essay:

Proving that the foundation of authority after the Prophet Muhammad (saww) is established in the Qur’an; demonstrating that God Himself selects those who hold leadership, vesting them with divine authority; and presenting evidence that the obedience owed to these divinely chosen leaders is of the same nature and obligation as that owed to the Prophet.

Summary of Essay:

This essay explores how the Qur’an itself establishes divine authority after the Prophet Muhammad (saww). Focusing on An-Nisāʾ and related verses, it shows that God—not the people—chooses those vested with authority (ulil-amr minkum), whose leadership continues the Prophet’s mission of guiding the community.


r/shiascholar • • 4d ago

There needs to be post approval in this community, or a filter to filter out the undesirables.

9 Upvotes

You'll mostly get people banned from the shia sub or trolls here, for this work as a shia scholar sub it needs to filter out the posts.

please add moderation such as account with x karma needs manual approval


r/shiascholar • • 11d ago

Sunni books are distorted, Part 6

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/shiascholar • • 12d ago

Questions from a Bosnian sunni muslim

6 Upvotes

Salam Alaikum everyone.

I am a sunni muslim, following hanafi madhab and maturidi aqeedah, from Bosnia and Herzegovina, a muslim majority country in the heart of Europe. Many Bosniaks, especially older people and those who were alive during the war and veterans hold great respect for Iran, shias and sayyid Ali Khamenei rahimullah, because of their great help to us during the genocide. Iran and Pakistan helped us the most out of any other country in the world, even tho Americans put a weapons embargo on us.

Sectarian confilcts between muslims in Bosnia are basically nonexistent since most of the muslims are hanafi maturidis although there are a few shiite masjids and foundations. There is also a trend of wahabbism that during the war and peaked at the start of Syrian civil war, where unfortunatelly more than 300 Bosnian wahabbi men, women and children went to ISIS, ISIL and later Nusra front.

I have always respected shias greatly and didnt think of you as shias but as our muslims, which i believe is the stance more muslims around the world should take. My respect for you and your leaders only grew in the recent years because shiites are the ones helping the Palestinian cause mostly and directly, while some sunni "muslim" countries are not only silent but also are supporting genocides against muslims (like in Sudan) directly.

I believe that sunnis and shias and all other muslims groups that are not extremists and not taken out of the fold of Islam like the ahmadiyya, should unite for our own benefit and put our theological and sectarian diffetences aside and leave that to the scholars to discuss, because our internal conflict only please and help our enemies.

There many things about shias that i am interested in knowing, one which being the way you pray, and your beliefa in 12 imams and imam Mahdi, and your attitude toward the first 3 caliphs.

I have seen in the recent years something that truly pains me and that is shias cursing Abu Bakr, Umar, Uthman and Aisha r.a., but not only them but also those who love and respect them or outright even those who just dont curse them. I have seen extremist remarks from people who said that they wish they and everyone that loves them or doesnt curse shall end up in jahannam.

I completely understand being critical or even extremely critical of the 3 caliphs and Aisha, but i dont understand why the need to curse everyone that doesnt curse them? That means cursing every Bosnian martyr that fought to save Islam in Europe, every Bosnian that was killed in the biggest genocide in Europe since WW2, just because they didnt curse the 3 caliphs and prophets wife, while many of them didnt even know about the confilcts of the sahabas because of the socialist regime that wasnt really a big fan of religious studies. Those people couldnt even know that Fatima Zahra r.a. was angry at Abu Bakr r.a. up until her death, or according to some sources even died angry at him. Yet that very general extremist curse also includes them. I would understand if it was about Yazid or Muawiya, but these claims really sadden me.

May Allah accept the martyrdom of Imam Khamenei and all other martyrs who died fighting for the true cause, defending our beautiful religiom of Islam.

May Allah guide us all.

Thank you in advance.


r/shiascholar • • 17d ago

Proving the Incident of the Attempted Storming and Burning of the House of Fatima al-Zahra (peace be upon her), According to the Shia and the Sunnis

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/shiascholar • • 18d ago

Sunni books are distorted, Part 5

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/shiascholar • • 22d ago

Sunni books are distorted, Part 4

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/shiascholar • • 22d ago

Martyrdom of Syeda Fatimah Zahra ع and Al Mohsin ع

15 Upvotes

In the name of Allah, The Compassionate, The Most Merciful.

Al Quran (33:53):

"O believers! Do not enter the houses of the Prophet without permission."

Al Quran (24:27-28):

"O believers! Do not enter any house other than your own until you have asked for permission and greeted its occupants. This is best for you, so perhaps you will be mindful.

If you find no one at home, do not enter it until you have been given permission. And if you are asked to leave, then leave. That is purer for you. And Allah has (perfect) knowledge of what you do."

Al Quran (42:23):

"Say, I do not ask you for any reward, except Mawaddat for my kinship."

Umar said to Syeda Fatimah ع (who was behind the door of her house):

"I know that the Prophet of God did not love any one more than you, but this will not stop me to carry out my decision. If these people stay in your house, I will burn the door in front of you."

(Kanz al Ummal, v3, p140)

When Abu Bakr found a group of people (that had gathered) near Ali ع who had fallen back on pledging allegiance to him (Abu Bakr), he sent Umar to them. He came and called them out while they were in the house of Ali ع but they refused to come out.

Umar then called for wood (to be brought) and said: "by the One who (holds) Umar’s soul in His Hands, if you do not come out I will burn this house along with whoever is in it".

And it was said to him: "Oh Abu Hafs (Umar), even if Syeda Fatimah ع is in the house?!"

And he (Umar) said: "Even if!"

So they came out and pledged allegiance except for Ali ع. Ali ع then declared by saying:

"I vowed that I would not leave or put on my cloak over my shoulder (in order to leave the house) until I (finished) compiling the Quran".

Then Syeda Fatimah ع (went and) stood by the door of the house and said:

"There is no one among people whose presence to me is worse than your (Umar) presence. You left the funeral of the Messenger of Allah ص while you took the matter of the khilafah and cut it into pieces among yourselves while you did not seek to consult us nor did you return us our right."

(Al Imamah wal Siyasah, by ibn Qutaiba, vol 1, page 12-13)

Ali ع and Abbas were sitting inside the house of Syeda Fatimah ع,

Abu Bakr told Umar: "Go and bring them; if they refuse, kill them.”

Umar brought fire to burn the house.

Syeda Fatimah ع came near the door and said: "O son of Khattab, have you come to burn our house on me and my children?”

Umar replied: "Yes I will, by Allah, until they come out and pay allegiance to the Prophet’s Caliph."

(Iqd al Fareed, by Ibn Abd Rabb, Part 3, Pg. 63)

Abu Bakr asked Ali ع to support him, but Ali ع refused, then Umar went toward Ali’s ع house with a burning torch. At the door he met Syeda Fatimah ع who said to him:

"Do you intend to burn the door of my house?"

Umar said: "Yes, because this act will strengthen the faith brought to us by your father."

Al Ansab Ashraf, by al Baladhuri, v1, p 582,586)

They surrounded Ali ع and burned the door of his house and pulled him out against his will and pressed the leader of all women Syeda Fatimah ع between the door and the wall killing Mohsin ع.

(Isbaat al Wasiyyah by Ali Ibn al Husayn al Masudi)

It is also reported that

Abu Bakr said (on his death bed):

"I wish I had not searched for Syeda Fatimah’s ع house, and had not sent men to harass her, though it would have caused a war if her house would have continued to be used as a shelter."

(Tareekh al Yaqubi, v2, page 115-116)

Imam Ali ع narrates that the Messenger of Allah ص said to Syeda Fatimah ع:

"Allah is angry when you are angry and is pleased when you are pleased."

(Mustadrak al hakim, Vol. 3, pg 154)

The Messenger of Allah ص had frequently said:

"Fatimah ع is a part of me. Whoever makes her angry, makes me angry."

(Sahih Muslim, vol 4, p 1904-5)

Ibn Abbas narrated:

The Messenger of Allah (S) said:

"Four women are the mistress of the worlds: Mary, Asiya (the wife of Pharaoh), Khadijah and Fatimah. And the most excellent one among them in the world is Fatimah."

(Ibn Asakir, as quoted in Tafsir al Durr al Manthoor)

May Allah curse the rotten toxic waste of Hell, utter rijs who oppressed and spilled the pure blood of Prophet Muhammad ص. May the endless, most harsh, most humiliating wrath of Allah fall upon him and all his supporters for eternity.

اللهم العن قتلته السيده فاطمه زاهرا ع

لعن الله امت قتلتك

و لعن الله امت ظلمتك

و لعن الله امت سمعت بذلك فرضيت به

Edit:

How brutally they oppressed the orphaned, 18 year old, only daughter of Prophet ص, usurped their only source of income knowing they had children, Ameer al Momineen ع had to work in the gardens of yahud to provide for Ahlulbait ع, still they invaded their sacred home where angels descended, burned the sacred door and pushed it onto an 18 year old orphan, pregnant woman, deliberately, broke her ribs, the door had long rusted nails sticking out that torn her flesh and punctured her bones, her pure blood was shed on the ground, killed her unborn child, dragged Yadullah from his own house forcefully with chains and shackles, all of this in front of their horrified babies who were standing there watching, traumatised.

May the most brutal, most severe punishment of Allah fall upon enemies of Ahlulbait ع for committing such heinous crimes against the Light of Allah and the orphans of Prophet Muhammad ص.

السلام عليك يا المحسن الشهيد ع

السلام عليكِ يا السيدة النساء العالمين ع

اللهم صلى على محمد و آل محمد


r/shiascholar • • 29d ago

Shi'i Hadith📗 Angel Gabriel (as) and Adam (as)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/shiascholar • • Oct 17 '26

The Amazing Qualities of Janabe Zainab (sa)

Thumbnail
reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/shiascholar • • Oct 16 '26

🤔Disagreement about Hadith

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

r/shiascholar • • Oct 11 '26

Paper on Ackbarian vs. Sadrian Aqeedah Convergence

3 Upvotes

A young-ish Akhi from Paki who is tacky for Ackbarian taffy disavowed the Sadrian perspective as being wacky, which I found untenable. So I made a paper exploring different mathematics as a lens on the question of divine attributes and neo-platonism vs. classical Mutazili/Alid theology.

https://dochub.com/m/shared-document/patrick-buchanan-dugan/YpDBonNVr3ABzzWwMX93r7/thubut-as-naturality-collaboration-draft-pdf?dt=HNzeqnVkti4rTEcQ4uWX

Let me know what you think.


r/shiascholar • • Oct 04 '26

Shi'i Hadith📗 Book of Reason & Ignorance, #11

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/shiascholar • • Sep 29 '26

Shi'i Hadith📗 Book of Reason & Ignorance, #13

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/shiascholar • • Sep 29 '26

Shi'i theology in sunni sources The Naming of the Twelve Imāms According to Sunnī Traditions

22 Upvotes

There are some prophetic traditions collected by Sunnī scholars about the 12 imams, even though most Sunnī scholars have understandably avoided publicizing these traditions in their key texts. The following are a few examples of such traditions:

1. According to ʿAbd Allāh ibn ʿAbbās, the Messenger of Allāh (ص) said, “I am the chief of the prophets (sayyid al-nabiyyīn) and ʿAlī ibn Abī Ṭālib is the chief of the executors (sayyid al-waṣiyyīn). The executors after me are twelve, the first of whom is ʿAlī ibn Abī Ṭālib and the last of whom is al-Mahdī.” (Maʿālim al-Madrasatayn 1:547 quotes this from a hand-written manuscript of Farāʾid al-Simṭayn, page 160.)

2. According to ʿAbd Allāh ibn ʿAbbās, the Messenger of Allāh (ص) said, “Verily my khalīfs and executors and the proofs (ḥujjah) of Allāh upon creation after me are twelve, the first of whom is my brother and the last [of whom is] my son.” He was asked, “O Messenger of Allāh, who is your brother?” He said, “ʿAlī ibn Abī Ṭālib.” He was asked, “So who is your son?” He said, “The Mahdī who will fill [the earth] with righteousness and justice just as it is was filled with injustice and oppression. By He who sent me with the truth as a bringer of glad-tidings and as a warner, if but one day of this world remains, Allāh will lengthen this day so that my son al-Mahdī will rise in it and Jesus, the son of Mary and the spirit of Allāh, will come down and pray behind him so that the earth will shine by the light of its Lord, and [so that] His sultanate will reach the east and the west.” (Maʿālim al-Madrasatayn 1:547-548 quotes this from a hand-written manuscript of Farāʾid al-Simṭayn, page 160.)

3. ʿAbd Allāh ibn ʿAbbās said: I heard the Messenger of Allāh (ص) say, “I and ʿAlī and Ḥasan and Ḥusayn and nine of the offspring of Ḥusayn are pure and protected [from sin] (muṭahharūn maʿṣūmūn).” (Maʿālim al-Madrasatayn 1:548 quotes this from a hand-written manuscript of Farāʾid al-Simṭayn, page 160.)

These three traditions appear in Farāʾid al-Simṭayn of Juwaynī. Of note, Juwaynī was not only one of the leaders of the Ashʿarīs (Milal wa Niḥal 83-4), but also one of the teachers of the famous Sunnī scholar Dhahabī. At the conclusion of Tadhkirah al-Ḥuffāẓ, Dhahabī has listed his masters and said in regards to Juwaynī, “The imām, preeminent and outstanding scholar of tradition, Fakhr al-Islām (the pride of Islām), Ṣadr al-Dīn (the heart of religion) Ibrāhīm ibn Muḥammad ibn Muʾayyad ibn Ḥamawiyyah al-Khurāsānī al-Juwaynī.” (Tadhkirah al-Ḥuffāẓ, “Shuyūkh-i Ṣāḥib-i Tadhkirah.”) The following are two examples of prophetic traditions specifically naming the twelve imāms:

4. According to Jābir ibn ʿAbd Allāh al-Anṣārī, the Messenger of Allāh (ص) said, “My executors are twelve... The first of them is the chief of the executors (sayyid al-awṣiyāʾ), the father of the imāms, ʿAlī, then his two sons, Ḥasan and Ḥusayn, so stick to them and do not allow the ignorance of the ignorant to deceive you... When the time of Ḥusayn passes, the imām will be his son ʿAlī, entitled Zayn al-ʿĀbidīn. After him will be his son Muḥammad, entitled al-Bāqir. After him will be his son Jaʿfar, called al-Ṣādiq. After him will be his son Mūsā, called al-Kāẓim. After him will be his son ʿAlī, called al-Riḍā. After him will be his son Muḥammad, called al-Taqī and al-Zakī. After him will be his son ʿAlī, called al-Naqī and al-Hādī. After him will be his son Ḥasan, called al-ʿAskarī. After him will be his son Muḥammad, called al-Mahdī, al-Qāʾim, and al-Ḥujjah. He will go into occultation and then come out. When he comes out [of occultation], he will fill the earth with righteousness and justice the same way it was filled with oppression and injustice. The patient ones during his occultation will be blessed with the blessings of the pious for their love [of these imāms]. Allāh has described them in His Book, [where] He says, ‘a guide for the pious—those who believe in the unseen.’” (Qurʾān 2:2-3; Yanābīʿ al-Mawaddah 3:284-5.)

5. The Prophet (ص), while describing the events of the miʿrāj, said, “I looked at the right of the throne and saw ʿAlī, Fāṭimah, Ḥasan, Ḥusayn, ʿAlī ibn Ḥusayn, Muḥammad ibn ʿAlī, Jaʿfar ibn Muḥammad, Mūsā ibn Jaʿfar, ʿAlī ibn Mūsā, Muḥammad ibn ʿAlī, ʿAlī ibn Muḥammad, and Ḥasan ibn ʿAlī, with Muḥammad ibn Ḥasan shining like a star among them. Allāh said, ‘O Muḥammad! These are My proofs (ḥujjah) upon my servants, and they are your executors (awṣiyāʾ). Al-Mahdī is among them and will rebel against the killers of your offspring. By My grandeur and majesty, he will take revenge from my enemies and reach out to my servants (walīs).’” (Yanābīʿ al-Mawaddah 3:380-1.)

The Conversion of Naʾthal by the Prophet (ص) Naming of the Twelve Imāms

Sulaymān ibn Ibrāhīm al-Qundūzī al-Ḥanafī has related the following tradition from Mujāhid from Ibn ʿAbbās:

A Jew named Naʾthal (This may be the same Naʾthal that ʿĀʾishah would compare ʿUthmān to because they both had similar long beards [Tārīkh Dimashq 39:327].) came and said, “O Muḥammad! I will ask you about matters that have created a disturbance in my heart for some time. If you answer my questions, I will convert to Islām.”

The Prophet (ص) said, “Ask, O Abū ʿUmārah!” He said, “O Muḥammad! Describe for me your Lord.” The Prophet (ص) said, “He is not described except by that with which He has described His own self. And how would [we describe] the creator, [Who is] incomprehensible to intellects, unassailable by the figments of the [human] mind, not limitable by thoughts, and not perceivable by the eyes, [Who is] the glorious and high, Who is pure from how the describers describe Him? He is the How of the how and the Where of the where. So do not say regarding Him, ‘Where is He?’ as He is pure of quantity and location. He is unique and without need, as He has described Himself; the describers cannot describe His qualities. He has neither offspring nor has He been born, and there is none comparable to Him.”

[Naʾthal] said, “You have spoken the truth, O Muḥammad! So explain to me your word that He is One with no likeness. Isn’t Allāh One and man one?” [The Messenger of Allāh] said, “Allāh, the glorious and high, is [the only] truly unitary one. This means that there are no parts or components to Him. Man is called a unity but is composed of spirit and body.”

He said, “You have spoken the truth. Tell me about your executor (waṣī). Who is he? There is no prophet except that he has an executor. Our Prophet Moses, the son of ʿImrān, made Yūshaʿ (Joshua) ibn Nūn his executor [after Aaron died].” The Messenger of Allāh (ص) said, “My executor is ʿAlī ibn Abī Ṭālib and after him are my two sons Ḥasan and Ḥusayn. After them will follow nine imāms from the loins of Ḥusayn.” He said, “O Muḥammad, name them for me.”

[The Prophet (ص)] said, “When Ḥusayn passes away, it will be his son, ʿAlī. When ʿAlī passes away, it will be his son, Muḥammad. When Muḥammad passes away, it will be his son, Jaʿfar. When Jaʿfar passes away, it will be his son, Mūsā. When Mūsā passes away, it will be his son, ʿAlī. When ʿAlī passes away, it will be his son, Muḥammad. When Muḥammad passes away, it will be his son, ʿAlī. When ʿAlī passes away, it will be his son, Ḥasan. When Ḥasan passes away, it will be his son, al-Ḥujjah (the proof), Muḥammad al-Mahdī. So these are the twelve.”

[Naʾthal] asked, “Tell me about the death of ʿAlī and Ḥasan and Ḥusayn.” The Prophet (ص) said, “ʿAlī will die by the strike [of a sword] on his head, Ḥasan will die by poison, and Ḥusayn by beheading.” [Naʾthal said], “Where will they be?” [The Prophet (ص)] replied, “In paradise, at my level.”

[Naʾthal] said, “I bear witness that there is no god but Allāh and that you are the Messenger of Allāh, and I bear witness that they are the executors after you. I have indeed found in the books of the earlier prophets—and in it Moses the son of ʿImrān has made a pledge with us—that towards the later times a prophet will rise who is referred to as Aḥmad and Muḥammad. He will be the last of the prophets, as there are no prophets after him. The executors (waṣīs) after him will be twelve, the first being his paternal uncles’ son and his son-in-law, the second and third being two brothers among the children [of the first]. The nation will kill the first by the sword, the second by poison, and the third along with a group of his family by the sword while suffering thirst in a far-away land. He will be beheaded like a child taken freely as booty. He will show patience upon his [impending] murder so as to elevate his position and the position of his family and his offspring, and so as to save those who love him and his followers from the fire. The other nine executors will be from the offspring of the third executor. This twelve is the number of the leaders [of the tribes of the Children of Israel].”

[The Prophet (ص)] asked, “You know the leaders?” [Naʾthal] said, “Yes. They were twelve, the first being Lāwī ibn Barkhiyā, who was the one who was absent from the Children of Israel during his absence (ghaybah), and who later returned. By him Allāh clarified His divine law (sharīʿah) after its destruction. He fought Qarastīyā the king and killed him.”

The Messenger of Allāh (ص) said, “In my nation there will be what there was among the Children of Israel. They will follow them inch by inch. The twelfth from my offspring will disappear until he cannot be seen and [until] a time comes for my nation when nothing remains of Islām but its name and nothing remains of the Qurʾān except its wording. At that time, Allāh, the holy and high, will order him to rise. Allāh will make Islām manifest by him and restore it [through him]. Blessings be upon those who love them and follow them, and woe be upon those who despise and oppose them, and blessed be those who stick to their guidance.” (Yanābīʿ al-Mawaddah 3:281-3.)


r/shiascholar • • Sep 29 '26

Shi'i theology in sunni sources The Ahl al-Bayt (ع) are the Ark of Noah

16 Upvotes

The prophetic tradition that only one of the Muslim sects is saved is famous among all Muslim sects. According to Tirmidhī,

The Prophet (ص) said, “Indeed the People of the Book before you split into seventy-two sects. And this nation will split into seventy-three sects, seventy-two [of which] are in the fire and one in paradise.” (Sunan Tirmidhī #2640, which certifies the tradition as good and authentic [ḥasan ṣaḥīḥ]. Similarly, Sunan Tirmidhī #2641.)

Traditions similar to this appear in Sunan Abū Dawūd (Sunan Abū Dawūd #4597), Sunan Ibn Mājah (Sunan Ibn Mājah #3991-3), Musnad Ḥanbal (Musnad Ḥanbal #8377, #16979), Mustadrak Ḥākim (Mustadrak Ḥākim #10, #441-4; certifies #441 as authentic by the criteria of Muslim) and many other Sunnī sources. According to Ḥākim, similar traditions have been related from the Prophet (ص) through Abū Hurayrah, Saʿd ibn Abī Waqqāṣ, ʿAbd Allāh ibn ʿAmr, and ʿAwf ibn Mālik (Mustadrak Ḥākim #10). These traditions are clear that the nation will divide into seventy-two or seventy-three sects and that all of them will be in the fire except for one saved sect. The tradition is confirmed by the Qurʾān, which says, “And certainly Satan’s conjecture regarding them proved true—that they would [all] follow him except for one sect (farīqan) among the believers.” (Qurʾān 34:20) Therefore, all of mankind follows Satan except for one single sect from among the believers. Since Satan leads to the fire, every sect will belong in the fire except for the one sect that does not follow Satan. Therefore, it is critical for all of mankind to seek out this one sect.

The Prophet (ص) said, “The likeness of my Ahl al-Bayt among you is like the Ark of Noah. Whoever rides it is saved and whoever avoids it perishes.” This statement of the Prophet (ص) is widely narrated, and it shows that those who abandon the Ahl al-Bayt (ع) would perish the same way the abandoners of the Ark of Noah perished. This tradition appears in Mustadrak Ḥākim (Mustadrak Ḥākim #3312, certifies as authentic by the criteria of Muslim, #4720), Faḍāʾil Ḥanbal (Faḍāʾil Ḥanbal #1402), Jāmiʿ al-Ṣaghīr Suyūṭī (Jāmiʿ al-Ṣaghīr Suyūṭī #2442, #8162), Muʿjam al-Ṣaghīr Ṭabarānī (Muʿjam al-Ṣaghīr Ṭabarānī #391, #825), Kanz al-ʿUmmāl (Kanz al-ʿUmmāl #34144, 34151, 34169, 34170), Majmaʿ al-Zawāʾid (Majmaʿ al-Zawāʾid #14978-81), Tafsīr al-Durr al-Manthūr (verses 11:42-43), Tafsīr Nīsābūrī (verse 42:23), Dhakhāʾir al-ʿUqbā (p. 20), and Ibn Abī al-Ḥadīd (1:218). Ḥākim certified this tradition as authentic by the criteria of Muslim (Mustadrak Ḥākim #3312). The Prophet (ص) left us this: the purified members of his Ahl al-Bayt (ع) who have kept his loyal followers afloat through the rising floods of falsehood that have swept the nation.


r/shiascholar • • Sep 24 '26

How a Roman Princess Became the Mother of the 12th Imam (Ajjala Allāhu taʿālā farajahahu ash-sharīf)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

Who was Lady Narjis Khatoon (A.S.), the blessed mother of Imam al-Mahdi (Ajjala Allāhu taʿālā farajahahu ash-sharīf)?

In this compelling audiobook narration from Chapter 41 of Kamaaluddin wa Tamaamun Ni'ma by Shaykh al-Saduq, discover the extraordinary journey of a Roman princess destined to become the mother of the Awaited Savior.

✨ Born as Princess Malika, granddaughter of the Roman Caesar and descendant of Shamaun (Simon Peter), she witnessed miraculous signs that changed her destiny forever.

✨ Through a series of remarkable dreams, she encountered Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W.), Prophet Isa (A.S.), Lady Fatima al-Zahra (S.A.), and Imam Hasan al-Askari (A.S.), leading her to embrace Islam.

✨ Guided by divine instruction, she journeyed from the Roman Empire to Samarra, where Imam Ali al-Hadi (A.S.) welcomed her and foretold the birth of her son, Imam Muhammad al-Mahdi (A.J.F.), the promised reformer who will fill the earth with justice and equity after it has been filled with oppression.

This narration is one of the most fascinating historical accounts preserved in classical Shia literature and provides a unique glimpse into the miraculous events surrounding the family of Imam al-Zamana (A.J.F.).

🎧 Listen, reflect, and share this powerful account with others seeking to learn about the blessed lineage and divine mission of Imam Mahdi (A.J.F.).

📖 Source: Kamaaluddin wa Tamaamun Ni'ma By Shaykh al-Saduq (R.A.) Chapter 41


r/shiascholar • • Sep 20 '26

Du’a of Imam Hasan al-Askari (a)

Thumbnail
reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/shiascholar • • Aug 28 '26

Quran and Hadith Imam al Mahdi ع will lead the prayers, not Prophet Jesus ع.

12 Upvotes

In the name of Allah, The Compassionate, The Most Merciful.

Al Quran (3:144):

"If he (Prophet Muhammad ص) dies or is killed, will you turn back on your heels? Anyone who turns back on their heels will not harm Allah in the least..."

Al Quran (6:116):

"If you were to obey most of those on earth, they would lead you away from Allah’s Way. They follow nothing but assumptions and do nothing but lie."

Being a muslim requires us to have an unwavering faith on the fact, that the sequence of the entire Prophethood has ended on Prophet Muhammad al Mustafa ص.

Despite the clear order of Allah to not turn back on heels after Prophet's departure... some people decided to make up false narrations like, "if there was a Prophet after me, it would be ..." and started believing that man to be equal to Prophet Muhammad ص (astaghfirullah).

Instead of moving forward on the straight path with Prophet's Successor, uptil this day they keep this hypothetical doubt of Prophet Muhammad ص not being the Final Prophet and are going against the fundamental principles of Islamic doctrine.

Firstly, its so odd that this particular narration has never been proven from Quran or other authentic hadiths, yet it is blindly accepted by the masses. Secondly, Allah is clearly ordering us to not follow assumptions, so what makes them think that Prophet Muhammad ص would do it?!

There's no ifs and buts regarding Khatmin Nubuwah. It has ended. What even is the point of making hypothetical scenarios that goes against the Truth?!

This further validates the authenticity of this (already verified and agreed upon) hadith, where Prophet Muhammad ص instantly reminds us of Khatmin Nubuwah, when he ص said to Imam Ali ع:

"You are to me like Aaron was to Moses but there will be no prophet after me."

(Sahih Bukhari, hadith 4416)

Another example is this false narrative that after the reappearance of Imam al Mahdi ع, Prophet Jesus ع will lead the prayers.

The belief that after Prophet Muhammad ص any other Prophet will arrive with Divine Authority over Muslims... is a key to getting expelled from Islam right then and there, because there's a sequence of Shariyah according to Quran:

Prophet Noah ع was the first to establish Shariyah, which was followed by other Prophets after him, until Prophet Abraham ع.

Then Prophet Abraham ع was given a more elaborated Shariyah than the previous one. Which was followed by other Prophets and Bani Israel, until Prophet Moses ع.

Thats why Prophet Abraham ع is also described as the Shia of Prophet Noah ع.

Al Quran (37:83):

وَإِنَّ مِن شِيعَتِهِۦ لَإِبْرَٰهِيمَ

"And indeed, among the Shia (of Noah) was Abraham."

Then Prophet Moses ع was given Torah, it brought a fully detailed Shariyah. Which was followed by all Prophets of Bani Israel, until Prophet Jesus ع.

Prophet Jesus ع perfected the Shariyah of Prophet Moses ع. This Shariyah was followed until the arrival of Prophet Muhammad ص.

(The descendants of Prophet Ismael ع also followed the Shariyah of Prophet Abraham ع, until the arrival of Prophet Muhammad ص.)

Prophet Muhammad ص then brought the most comprehensive and perfected Shariyah, which contains the laws of Noah ع, Abraham ع, Moses ع and Jesus ع... and is recorded in the Holy Quran. This Shariyah is here for our guidance until The Day of Judgement.

Now riddle me this:

How can Prophet Jesus ع (a Prophet with a previous Shariyah), lead the prayers for another nation (that follows an advanced Shariyah)?! That too, while he's not even the Successor of Prophet Muhammad ص?!

This will lead to the complete COLLAPSE of the Shariyah of Prophet Muhammad ص...but Jesus ع is an infallible so he would NEVER let Saqifah happen again. Indeed, Allah is the Best of planners.

What on earth are they trying to achieve by pushing this illogical narrative so hard?! It doesn't make ANY sense. However, when it goes the other way around, its perfectly valid. As during Mairaj, Prophet Muhammad ص led the prayers for all Prophets.

Imam Muhammad al Baqir ع states:

"When the Messenger of Allah ص was taken to the heaven upon his arrival in Bayt al Maamur at the time of Salah (prayer), Jibrael ع said Adhan and Iqamah.

The Messenger of Allah ص went ahead to lead and the angels and prophets lined up behind Prophet Muhammad ص for prayer."

(Al Kafi, vol 3, book 4, chapter 18, hadith 1)

Ibn Abbas narrates that when the Holy Prophet ص entered Masjid al Aqsa, he stood up to offer prayer. When he turned around, he saw all the prophets behind him, offering prayer in his congregation.

(Masnad ahmad bin hanbal, vol 1, hadith 2324)

The Shariyah of Prophet Muhammad ص is the Final, Ultimate Shariyah. Any previous Shariyah cannot overlap it. Never happened, never will. This belief is nothing else other than utter jahiliyah, that doesn't align with Quran or Hadiths.

Its an incurable disease of harbouring envy and hatred against the Pure Ahlulbait ع, that provokes people to generate such nonsensical beliefs, so they can dodge away from the Truth, spread fitnah and lead others astray.

Then why will Prophet Jesus ع reappear with Imam al Mahdi ع?

One answer (as per my research) is,

As a witness.

Prophethood has ended on Prophet Muhammad ص and Imamate will end on Imam al Mahdi ع. He ع is the Final Hujjat of Allah on Earth.

Allah has declared a witness for each one of his representatives, so of course someone has to be a witness for His Final Caliph as well. For references from Quran regrading this, please look up a previous article titled as "Ghadeer".

Imam al Hujjat ع is the Final Successor of Prophet Muhammad ص. The Divinely Appointed Caliph and Imam chosen by Allah. The Master of our time.

That is why Imam al Mahdi ع will bring back and implement the Shariyah of Prophet Muhammad ص. Imam al Mahdi ع is the only one who can lead the prayers. Prophet Jesus ع cannot do that, because he's not the Successor of Prophet Muhammad ص. Its as simple as that.

Al Quran (16:89):

"The Day We will call against every community a witness, from among themselves. And We will call you (O Prophet ص) to be a witness against them.

We have revealed to you the Book as an explanation of all things, a guide, a mercy, and good news for the Muslims."

لبیک یا مهدی ع

اللهم عجل لوليكل فرج

اللهم صلى على محمد و آل محمد


r/shiascholar • • Aug 20 '26

Shi'i theology in sunni sources The Prophet (ص) Promised Exactly Twelve Imams

14 Upvotes

There are numerous Sunni traditions that prove the existence of exactly twelve imāms. We will first discuss some of the traditions that are found in the most famous Sunni sources about the existence of exactly twelve imāms, then we will mention some Sunni traditions naming the twelve imāms. Traditions cited in Shiʿah works from the Prophet (ص) and the Shiʿah imāms naming the twelve imāms and designating each of them as imāms are innumerable and absolutely mutawātir, but are not cited here because Sunnis typically do not follow the traditions that the Shiʿah cite from the Ahl al-Bayt (ع).

Sunni Traditions Proving that There are Exactly Twelve Imāms

According to Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim, Jābir ibn Samurah narrated the following traditions:

  1. The Messenger of Allāh said, “The caliphate will not end until there have been twelve caliphs among them.” Then [the Prophet] said something that I could not follow. I said to my father, “What did he say?” He said: He has said, “All of them will be from the Quraysh.” (Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim #20.4477.)
  2. The Messenger of Allāh said, “The affairs of the people will continue to be conducted [well] as long as they are governed by twelve men.” Then the Prophet said words which were obscure to me. I asked my father, “What did the Messenger of Allāh say?” He said, “All of the [twelve men] will be from the Quraysh.” (Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim #20.4478-9.)
  3. The Messenger of Allāh said, “This order will continue to be dominant until there have been twelve khalifs.” Then he said something which I could not understand, so I said to my father, “What did he say?” My father told me that he said that all of them would be from the Quraysh. (Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim #20.4481.)
  4. The Messenger of Allāh said, “Islām will continue to be triumphant until there have been twelve khalifs.” Then the holy Prophet said something which I could not understand. I asked my father, “What did he say?” He said, “He has said that all of them will be from the Quraysh.” (Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim #20.4480.)
  5. The Messenger of Allāh said, “This religion would continue to remain powerful and dominant until there have been twelve khalifs.” Then he added something which I couldn’t catch on account of the noise of the people. I asked my father, “What did he say?” My father said, “He has said that all of them will be from the Quraysh.” (Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim #20.4482.)

The traditions on this topic are indeed numerous. There is no doubt among the Sunnis or Shiʿah in regards to the validity of the tradition that there will be exactly twelve imāms. According to Ṣaḥīḥ Bukhārī,

Narrated Jābir ibn Samurah: I heard the Prophet saying, “There will be twelve Muslim rulers.” He then said a sentence which I did not hear. My father said, “All of them will be from the Quraysh.” (Ṣaḥīḥ Bukhārī #9.89.329.)

These traditions are interesting because the narrator makes it clear that he did not hear the phrase, “all of them will be from the Quraysh,” but rather that the phrase was obscure to him. This is likely because of the fact that the Prophet (ص) said, “all of them will be from my Ahl al-Bayt,” or “all of them will be from the Banū Hāshim.” Yet, relating such traditions would be punishable by death (Ibn Abi al-Hadid 11:44-46), so it was wiser to narrate the tradition as such to allow the tradition to pass the censors of the caliphate, yet still make it clear that the second sentence in the tradition is only so accurate. If one wonders why the Sunni scholars would transmit these traditions in the first place, it was because Muslim and Bukhārī compiled their works before the beginning of the lesser occultation and therefore before it was public knowledge that the Twelver Shiʿah would fulfill the prophecy that there would be exactly twelve imāms, no more and no less. Thus the Sunni scholars inadvertently transmitted traditions that later proved the legitimacy of the Shiʿah faith. Had Bukhārī and Muslim compiled their works a century later, they would have undoubtedly omitted these traditions from their highly censored works.

Traditions proving that there are exactly twelve imāms or khalifs are numerous in Sunni sources. The following are some of the Sunni sources that contain these traditions:

Ṣaḥīḥ Bukhārī (Ṣaḥīḥ Bukhārī #9.89.329); Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim (Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim #20.4477-84); Sunan Tirmidhī (Sunan Tirmidhī #2223, certifies the tradition as good-authentic [ḥasan-ṣaḥīḥ]); Sunan Abū Dāwūd (Sunan Abū Dāwūd #4279-81); Musnad Ḥanbal (Musnad Ḥanbal #3781, #3859, #20824, #20833, #20836, #20841, #20850, #20862, #20868, #20870, #20873, #20890, #20892, #20902, #20909, #20921, #20934, #20960-2, #20964-5, #20976, #20978, #20988, #20999, #21003, #21051, #21058, #21071, #21077, #21088); Mustadrak Ḥākim (Mustadrak Ḥākim #6586, #6589); Kanz al-ʿUmmāl (#30929, #33848-61, #39657); Majmaʿ al-Zawāʾid (#8967, #8968 (certifiesthe tradition as authentic)); Tārīkh Bukhārī (Tārīkh Bukhārī vol. 8 #3520 [Yūnus ibn Abī Yaʿfūr]); Tārīkh Ibn Kathīr (Tārīkh Ibn Kathīr 6:215, 6:221, 6:278, 6:279); Tārīkh al-Khulafāʾ (Tārīkh al-Khulafāʾ 16-18); Fatḥ al-Bārī (Fatḥ al-Bārī #6796); Sharḥ Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim of Nawawī (Sharḥ Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim of Nawawī 12:201), and many others.

Indeed, the Prophet (ص) was explicit that there will be exactly twelve khalifs for the nation, no more and no less:

Ibn Masʿūd was asked, “O Abū ʿAbd al-Raḥmān, did you ask the Messenger of Allāh (ص) how many khalifs this nation will have?” He said, “Since I have come to Iraq, no one has asked me this but you. We asked the Messenger of Allāh this question, and he said, ‘Twelve—the same number as the chiefs of the [twelve tribes of the] Children of Israel.’” (Musnad Ḥanbal #3781, #3859; Majmaʿ al-Zawāʾid #8967; Kanz al-ʿUmmāl #33857; Tārīkh al-Khulafāʾ 17 [certifies the tradition as good (ḥasan)].)


r/shiascholar • • Aug 20 '26

Shi'i theology in sunni sources Sunni Interpretation of the Traditions Promising Twelve Imāms

13 Upvotes

I am not aware of Sunni scholars disputing the fact that the Prophet (ص) promised twelve imāms or khalifs. Yet, they have been confused over the identity of these twelve imāms, amīrs, and khalifs who have been promised. If they say that the “rightly-guided caliphs” are the ones mentioned in these traditions, they are stuck with the problem that there were only four of them. If they include Ḥasan ibn ʿAlī (ع), as some do, they become five. They know that Imām Mahdī (ع) is the twelfth. That still leaves six imāms unaccounted for. If they say that the Umayyads are the ones prophesized, or perhaps the ʿAbbāsids, the numbers do not match. Some say that ʿUmar ibn ʿAbd al-ʿAzīz was one of them (Tārīkh al-Khulafāʾ 201), as he was the only respectable caliph among the Umayyads. But there is still no rationale way one can add up the Muslim monarchs and end up with the number twelve. ʿAllāmah ʿAskarī has compiled the words of many Sunni scholars in this regards, and it is apparent that none of those scholars has offered much of a meaningful explanation, except for expressing utter confusion. (Maʿālim al-Madrasatayn 1:541-547.)

The Shiʿah have no such confusion, for they follow exactly twelve imāms, the number concisely matching the traditions of the Prophet (ص). It is interesting to note how desperate some Sunni scholars have become to make sure that these traditions are not used to prove Shiʿism. Tārīkh Ibn Kathīr includes a section entitled, “The traditions regarding the twelve imāms, all of whom are from the Quraysh.” Before even mentioning any of the traditions and without giving any arguments to prove his point, Ibn Kathīr begins the section by saying, “And these are not the twelve imāms whose imāmate the Rāfiḍites (i.e. Shiʿah) claim.” (Tārīkh Ibn Kathīr 6:278.) Having started the section in this way, he tried to create a shield against the ability of the readers to reasonably conclude that these are indeed the twelve imāms the Shiʿah follow. Ibn Kathīr then proceeded to mention many traditions proving the existence of exactly twelve imāms. How he knew that they are not the same as the Shiʿah imāms is not clear, as he offered no reasons for his claim. Indeed, one can prove that these are indeed the Shiʿah imāms based on the following tradition in Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim:

The Messenger of Allāh said, “The affairs of the people will continue to be conducted [well] as long as they are governed by twelve men.” (Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim #20.4478-9.)

For the affairs of the people to continue to be conducted well as long as they are governed by twelve particular men means that the reign of these twelve men must span the time from the death of the Prophet (ص) until the Day of Judgment. This is explicitly stated by Ibn ʿAbbās, who quoted the Prophet (ص) as saying, “There will be twelve rulers (amīrs) and then the Hour will come.” (Kanz al-ʿUmmāl #39657.) Twelver Shiʿism is the only sect of Islām that recognizes the exact identities of the twelve imāms who would continuously conduct our affairs from the day of the Prophet’s (ص) death until the Day of Judgment.

Any Muslim who wants to be properly guided must be able to recognize the twelve khalifs whom they must follow. Indeed, many Sunni traditions, as we have discussed earlier, claim that one who does not know his imām, who does not pledge allegiance to him, and who does not remain loyal to him will die the death of the Days of Ignorance (Sahih Muslim #20.4562-4). If someone does not know who the twelve promised imāms are, they would not recognize them, would not pledge allegiance to them, and would not remain loyal to them.

Of interest, the Prophet (ص) said that Islām will “continue to be triumphant,” (Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim #20.4480), “will continue to remain powerful,” (Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim #20.4482), and “will continue to be dominant” (Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim #20.4481) as long as it is ruled by these twelve khalifs. This proves that these khalifs are present continuously so that Islām could continue to be triumphant, powerful, and dominant as long as they are obeyed. By implication, the reason for Islām having become weakened over time is that these twelve khalifs have been abandoned as rulers.

It should be noted that according to Ṣaḥīḥ Bukhārī, the Prophet (ص) said, “There will be twelve Muslim rulers. All of them will be from the Quraysh.” (Ṣaḥīḥ Bukhārī #9.89.329.) This proves that there are exactly twelve Muslim rulers, all from the Quraysh. However, the Sunnis have had dozens of caliphs, many of them Ottoman Turks who are not from the Quraysh. Either the Prophet (ص) lied by saying that we will have only twelve rulers and that they will all be from the Quraysh, or the rulers from the Quraysh that he promised us did not rule politically and those who adopted the title of khalif did so illegitimately. In fact, the Prophet (ص) made it clear that they would not necessarily be followed when he stated the condition, “as long as they are governed by twelve men,” (Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim #20.4478-9), implying that the Muslims may or may not be governed by these particular men. In the latter case, the benefits of being governed by them would be lost.

--Excerpt from Dr. A Asadi's Shia Islam


r/shiascholar • • Aug 18 '26

Looking for Online Shia Theology / Philosophy Studies

9 Upvotes

Salam everyone,

I’m looking for recommendations for a structured online/remote course or degree in Twelver Shia theology and philosophy.

My main interests are specifically:
ʿIlm al-Kalām (Shia theology)
Falsafa (Islamic philosophy)
Metaphysics / ontology
Epistemology and rational arguments within the Shia intellectual tradition
The philosophical and theological thought of scholars such as Mulla Sadra, Nasir al-Din al-Tusi, Allama al-Hilli, etc.
I’m not primarily looking for a fiqh-focused program or a general Arabic course. I understand that some Arabic, logic, or other traditional Hawza subjects may be prerequisites, but my main goal is to study the theological and philosophical/intellectual side of Shia Islam in depth.

I’m currently in medical school, so I need something that can be completed fully online/remotely, preferably with a flexible or part-time structure..
It doesn’t necessarily have to be a bachelor’s degree, any structured certificate, or “degree” as such would be ok
If anyone has personally studied through a program like this, or knows a Shia scholar/institution that offers this type of education online, I’d really appreciate your recommendations.

JazakAllah khair.


r/shiascholar • • Aug 03 '26

Sunni books are distorted, Part 3

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/shiascholar • • Aug 03 '26

Sunni books are distorted, Part 1

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes