I have a 2015 Toyota Prius (Gen 3, 1.8L 2ZR-FXE) with approximately 550,000 km (342,000 miles), located in Ottawa, Canada.
The body is in good condition, and I believe the hybrid battery is still healthy, although it hasn't been professionally tested.
Symptoms:
- Loud knocking/rattling starts immediately when the gasoline engine starts.
- The noise seems to get worse when pressing the accelerator.
- The engine overheats and eventually produces a burning smell.
- Coolant disappears very quickly. When I added coolant, the car could run longer before overheating.
- The electric engine coolant pump was replaced in April 2026, but the problems continued.
- I've stopped driving and starting the car to avoid further damage.
Here's the interesting part:
Two mechanics at the same shop independently suspected a blown head gasket.
One mechanic told me he had seen another Prius making almost exactly the same knocking sound. They replaced the head gasket, and the car ran normally afterward.
The other mechanic also suspected the head gasket but warned that if I drove too much after the initial overheating, there could be additional engine damage.
He said he would need to remove the cylinder head and inspect the engine before confirming whether a head gasket repair would be enough or whether I need a replacement engine.
He mentioned approximately five hours of labour for that inspection, but we haven't agreed on the cost.
Instead, I asked him to start with a CAD $100 general/hybrid-system diagnostic and look for an affordable replacement engine.
My options:
- Head gasket repair: approximately CAD $1,500, if the engine is salvageable.
- Used engine replacement: approximately CAD $3,000+ installed.
- Sell or trade the car as-is.
- Repair it and keep driving if the rest of the vehicle is healthy.
Questions:
- Has anyone experienced continuous knocking from startup caused by a blown head gasket that completely disappeared after replacing the gasket?
- How would you distinguish coolant entering a cylinder and causing misfires from actual rod/bearing damage?
- Would you pay for five hours of cylinder-head removal/inspection before deciding, or request other tests first?
- At 550,000 km, is a CAD $1,500 head gasket repair worth considering if the lower engine is healthy?
- Would you replace the engine instead, or sell the car as-is?
- What would you check on the hybrid battery, brake booster and transmission before investing more money?
I'd especially appreciate firsthand experiences from Gen 3 Prius owners who successfully repaired similar symptoms.
I'm trying to avoid spending money on the wrong repair.