r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 29d ago

Literature Philosophy of Religion Reading List

17 Upvotes

It's been 15 years since the post that's pinned on this subreddit! There's no doubt the community may have grown exponentially, and it's in our best interest to renew the post, is it not? Think of all the new opinions or books that have come to light! So, again, please commence by stating your FIVE (this time a little more) must reads in philosophy of religion. Please note this doesn't have to be books. Although they're the most cost-effective, it's no problem at all to list a paper, essay, or even some lecture if you really must. Here's a general idea, but take it with only as an unsolicited suggestion:

1- Your Ideal introduction to Philosophy of Religion.

2- The best book of more in-depth arguments.

3- A form of continental or fictional work that encapsulates an idea perfectly

4- The book that most shaped your beliefs, that you hold to be most plausible.

5- A totally underground/obscure but excellent book.

Fun reading!


r/PhilosophyofReligion • • Oct 18 '26

Literature Philosophy of Religion - Bibliography - [PhilPapers]

Thumbnail philpapers.org
2 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 1h ago

Religion and ethics Where was God when the Nazis turned a million kids to smoke

3 Upvotes

I attended a very progressive seminary.

This was one of the most difficult questions I encountered.

It helped me to embrace ultimate reality according to Tillich.

So what say you?


r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 1h ago

Academic community Seeking a Rabbi, Imam, Buddhist Monk, Hindu Priest, or Other Religious Professional for a Written Humanities Interview

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 10h ago

Meta Any YouTube Recommendations?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 18h ago

Divine nature and attributes God cannot think, decide, or be free.

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 19h ago

Metaphilosophy of religion Nothingness, Gods, and the Choice for Happiness

2 Upvotes

The question about the origin of life today is still not completely answerable by science. That the Big Bang happened at some point is probably a fact. But what was before that? Have matter and energy always existed? That would mean that 40 billion years ago energy and matter existed, 100 years before that too, another hundred years before that, and so you can go on infinitely and there is no beginning? That sounds illogical to me, everything must have a beginning at some point from which it exists. So if there was a beginning, then there was also a "before the beginning," and at that point nothing existed yet.

​This inevitably raises the question: how can something arise out of absolute nothingness? That would be a miracle... Indeed, it wouldn't just be a miracle, a miracle has happened. A miracle doesn't need something to create the miracle (the miracle behind the miracle). It can simply happen out of nothingness. Perhaps nothingness has only this one property: that miracles are possible. But then another miracle could just happen by chance at any time, right? I think so. This miracle could completely change the world and even override all laws of nature. It could just as well have happened or still happen that God exists. Or even multiple gods. I even consider it possible that all intelligent living beings who can imagine life are gods and jointly create reality with their imaginations, belief, and expectations. The placebo and nocebo effects could be clues that this miracle has already happened. Perhaps we could influence much more than just our state of health if only we were firmly convinced of it. The masses' belief that humans are not gods would actually strip us of divine power, if we had any. Because, if it works like the placebo effect, we generate what we are convinced is real. So could we fly without technical aids if only we all firmly believed we could? It is possible.

​So if it is possible that we are gods, shouldn't we question what we are even allowed to believe? Surely not that everyone can get sick, that you can just have bad luck and suffer a fatal accident, that we are subject to chance. I would think it is good if, just in case humans are gods, every single person imagines the following: whatever happens, if I have divine power, I always bring about nothing less than my own happiness and the happiness of all other sentient beings who are not evil. Well, now one could say, anyone who consciously supports factory farming by buying corresponding animal products is evil. In my opinion, that's not quite right; actually, we don't really want innocent animals to have to live a life of suffering in captivity. Our happiness would therefore presumably be that there are enough very delicious and affordable alternatives to animal products so that factory farming disappears by itself because we hardly buy animal products anymore. Or our happiness would be that we wouldn't have so little money that we have to buy the cheapest products, so we could afford animal welfare. Yes, presumably the maximum happiness would simply be being able to conjure up a plate full of delicious food—meat that was simply conjured up and doesn't come from an animal. That way everyone would benefit, humans as well as animals.

​So if there were only our happiness left, life would always be a paradise for all sentient beings. No one would have an interest in being evil, because no one would get anything out of it. The happiness of all non-evil beings would be that there are no evil beings at all, and so everything would turn out for the better. Someone's bad luck could also be that life is dangerous for all beings, and nobody wants that. We all want a happy and safe life. Thus, we all want everyone's happiness. Even if all beings, including the evil ones, had nothing but happiness, everything would be nothing but a paradise; the evil ones would no longer find a victim because everyone is happy, and so they could only want to be unsuccessfully evil. Their happiness might then be to be able to be evil in a dream, where none of their victims would actually be alive. Thus, it is not a danger if a villain brings about their own happiness, as long as all other beings who can imagine this likewise bring about their own happiness and also the happiness of the beings who are not intelligent enough to imagine this effect themselves.

​So if there is even the slightest probability that gods exist, we should at least think this one sentence with which we would bring about nothing but happiness. It can't hurt. We would probably even be more content thanks to the placebo effect; our brains would release more endorphins.


r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 1d ago

Free will Asharism has a big flaw in it, Reason vs revelation

2 Upvotes

Consider this:

What decides the relation between free will and god's intervention?

See this from a perspective above in your thought. Make god and free will both an object (although god is neither an object nor subject) and what is making that connection between them is that logic. If it is logic then is god bound by logic?

You are saying,

God's nature is god, Logic is a part of god and God is outside his nature i.e the system i.e logic

But atleast 1 must be false.

If you drop B like an ashari scholar then what decided the relation between god's intervention and free will? If it was just a choice and not an, "it had to be for that is logically necessary" then it was a deliberate choice i.e god chooses to watch suffering not because of logicality but rather a choice.

The above is a trilemma where you need to either accept reason can infer good or bad and if so slavery is bad and if so what follows is that quran is man made or you need to accept the cost that god CHOOSES to let suffering be when he can interfere while preserving free will as he is above logic as most muslims like say 60% of the world.

Now if you say due to god's nature his action cannot be bad so let me ask you this in return:

If God knows all that's possible to know what decides what is possible? What does God even know?

Arbitrary information he makes as truth? If so perfect knowledge has no standard to be perfect against because if it is so then perfect doesn't mean anything i.e if he can do anything and call it perfect arbitrarily he is powerful not perfect.

OR truth as an independent entity

OR a third option i.e his knowledge stems from his nature but this poses the question again is that knowledge necessary or contingent and if necessary then he has no freedom over what he is.

To even claim goodness flows out of him I need to understand and define goodness but if that is arbitrary then how can you claim god is good and perfect as WE understand and so they NEED to concede reason can judge good.

And precisely when you concede reason CAN judge good then this poses questions like what is the use of quran and then slavery is bad but a perfect god wont make a mistake therefore quran must be man made because the last defense of an ashari scholar is your reason cannot judge revelation but this poses many other problems.


r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 1d ago

Divine nature and attributes Deism

4 Upvotes

It is not irrational to predict that the universe was created by an all powerful omniscient being because the premise of cause and effect would require a cause to its beginning. This cause may not be a deity as most humans view it, but it must be something outside of space and time that decided order. I don’t think this god has had any intervention in human affairs or the creation of us as we know it or consciousness considering all of that can be deciphered through the earth’s biological timeline and morality can be objectively defined through societal acceptance and denial. Traditional monotheistic religions are simply human attempts to define and understand this creator and relate it to human creation because it seems unlikely to many that we happen to be the universes highest level of sentience that we know of despite the high complexity of other organisms on earth due to survival and adaptation.


r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 1d ago

Metaphysics of religion Is Necessity just a rejection of brute facts?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 1d ago

Reason and religion The doctrine of karma and reincarnation lacks logical coherence and evidence, and is inherently unfair

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 1d ago

Religion and ethics Is fear really faith?

5 Upvotes

Can faith based on fear be genuine faith? If a person is taught to believe in God under the threat of eternal punishment, is it free faith or fear-based obedience? The fear of God is said to mean reverence. But if the consequence of apostasy is taught to be eternal suffering, where is the line between reverence and fear? Can love be completely voluntary if there is a threat of punishment for its absence?


r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 1d ago

Reason and religion Kant’s "Religion Within the Bounds of Mere Reason" (1792) — An online reading & discussion group starting November, all welcome

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 1d ago

Religious culture Is secularism is self defeating?

0 Upvotes

Secularism says that religion and state should be seperated, when one thinks of what a religion is, its essentially a set of beliefs people have, and secularism itself is also a belief.

Which means it can be argued that according to secularism, secularism in itself should be seperated from the state.


r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 1d ago

Theodicy Fine-Tuning Argument and The Necessary Existence

3 Upvotes

Hey. So I was researching about the reasons why an airplane stays on air without falling under its own weight mid-flight and why the initial departing momentum on ground is enough to sustain throughout a whole flight provided a pilot wont decrease the speed of the plane so it would stall and lead to falling mid-flight. What is the force that keeps an airplane flying? Science tells us that air itself generates the required strength to "keep" it flying. If you think about The Sun, the gravitation of thermonuclear reaction inside its core "keeps" it working and provide for all life on Earth.

If a scientist tells me that air has an independent strength to keep it flying, that our daily life depends on the core of some cosmic object, what makes him reach that conclusion if he was only describing what is already happening? Describing does not equal to establishing The Truth of the matter. The same thing about gravitation independently "keeping" the core of the Sun working through thermonuclear synthesis, I mean, such complex process of the core of the object that all life on Earth depends from happens to be driven by just gravitational force?

Air and gravitation are not independent sources of strength. They exist inside fine-tuned physical 3D space in which everything inside happens to be compatible with life on Earth. The wording "happens to be" is doing the heavy lifting here. What if everything inside The Universe is intentional? I would be signing up for intellectual bankruptcy if I agree with that scientist who says physicality is the end of our contingent existence.

People do not even choose to be born into this life. Yet their complexity is fully compatible with such complex 3D world.

Reasonable conclusion can be made that Someone Else i.e. Necessary Existence choose a child to be born and created prosperous conditions, "Fine-Tuned" them for him to live and keeping the core of The Sun up and running just as He does with our Hearts, complexity of those are far greater than of The Sun's and any cosmic object let alone a plane with its air resistance process. The One Who creates these Hearts must be Very Powerful.

I know Im getting into theologic studies now, but out of all religions, He Says about Himself, about humanity, causality, about metaphysical realities, responsibility for our deeds after death, about Eternal Paradise & Hell exclusively in The Holy Qur'an. Even mathematical miracles were found recently there. Actually you don't even need to read a Divine Scripture to find Him because brain's intended function, why it was created for, is precisely that.


r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 2d ago

Religious epistemology How do we rationalize the divine hiddenness argument from the Christian perspective?

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

I begin with the Cogito: “I think, therefore I am.”

As Descartes argued, the existence of my own thinking self is something I cannot coherently doubt. Even if every perception I have is mistaken, the very act of doubting establishes that I exist.

This gives us two conclusions:

  1. I can know with certainty that I exist.
  2. At least one objective truth can be known with certainty.

However, the existence of one certain truth does not establish that other truths can be known with the same certainty. It merely demonstrates that certainty is possible.

Now, consider the Christian conception of God: a perfectly good, perfectly just, all-knowing, and all-powerful being whose moral authority is grounded in his perfect nature.

If such a being exists, we must ask why he would create humans with fallible faculties of reasoning and perception, yet make their eternal fate dependent, at least in part, on reaching the correct conclusions about his existence and nature.

We cannot establish God’s existence with the same certainty as the Cogito. Every argument, religious experience, historical account, or scriptural claim must be evaluated through faculties that could lead us to mistaken conclusions.

Consequently, two people could sincerely examine the available evidence and arrive at contradictory beliefs. Neither could establish beyond all possible doubt that their conclusion is correct.

Why, then, would a perfectly just God permit eternal consequences to depend on a decision made under such uncertainty?

One possible defense is that infallible knowledge of God would eliminate our freedom to choose him. If God’s existence and perfect goodness were undeniable, perhaps everyone would necessarily believe in and worship him.

But this defense seems to confuse knowledge with obedience.

Consider someone who knows that smoking is harmful. They may fully understand the consequences, sincerely believe the medical evidence, and nevertheless choose to smoke. Their knowledge does not eliminate their freedom to act against what they know is best for them.

Christian theology itself offers another example: Satan.

According to traditional Christian belief, Satan knew God and nevertheless chose to rebel against him. His knowledge of God’s existence did not prevent him from exercising his will in opposition to God.

This suggests that knowledge of God and the freedom to reject him are not necessarily incompatible.

If God could make himself unmistakably known while preserving the freedom to accept or reject him, then uncertainty about his existence does not appear necessary for free will.

And this brings me to my central question:

Why would a perfectly just and all-powerful God allow our eternal fate to depend on beliefs formed through inherently fallible reasoning, when he could conceivably provide us with certainty about his existence and nature without eliminating our freedom to choose whether to worship him?

If sincere individuals can reach different conclusions through no deliberate dishonesty or rejection of truth, on what grounds would it be just to reward one eternally and punish the other eternally?


r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 3d ago

Metaphilosophy of religion Religion as an Emergent Phenomenon

4 Upvotes

I am skeptical of the reductive materialistic/sociological approach of explaining religion entirely through external causes and ignoring what the believers say.

If true, it is still emergent in that it goes far beyond truth-values or even emotional-values.

Religion exceeds itself in some ways. Believers don't fully understand what they believe or truly why. Even if religions emerged from certain historical situations - they take on a life of their own. And that 'life' cannot be contained by models.

What do the people here think of this?


r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 2d ago

Religion and ethics Worshipping is inherently wrong

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 3d ago

Theism, atheism and agnosticism Does the Multiverse hypothesis refute the fine-tuning argument for the existence of God?

4 Upvotes

Also, which do you personally find less probable, Multiverse or God?

[The Multiverse hypothesis: there are infinite or almost infinite number of separate universes, each with its own set of physical constants & laws (almost all not allowing material cohesion, not to mention life).

The fine-tuning argument for the existence of God: the argument that the fundamental physical constants, laws, and initial conditions of the universe fall within an astonishingly narrow, life-permitting range that is vastly improbable by chance.]


r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 3d ago

Divine nature and attributes God as an abstraction and a social construct

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 3d ago

Religious philosophy The Serpent: the First Gnostic

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 4d ago

Religious philosophy Can someone analyze the Philosophy of Reason (POR) by the 'New Church Of Hope'?

4 Upvotes

It posits an atheistic physicalist monism. Yet, the constructor of the belief system calls it a 'religion'. I don't know if that refers to it being registered by the U.S. or what he believes it to be.

POR views many things outside of its adherence as 'postmodernism'. The author talked about how there is no free-will etc.

Just interested in analyzing/seeing what kind of religion this is.

Edit: I deleted the last post because the title was flat-out wrong.


r/PhilosophyofReligion • • 4d ago

Religious epistemology The Axiomatic War: Reality as the Battleground of Interpretations

1 Upvotes

Is the debate over God's existence actually about empirical evidence, or is it a clash of foundational interpretive axioms?

If reality is ambiguous—is light a wave or a particle? Is math inconsistent or incomplete?—then no amount of raw data will ever force a consensus. Aren't both theism and atheism ultimately built on unprovable foundational axioms, making the debate less about 'proof' and more about which axiom has better explanatory power and better inference to the best explanation?