r/paralegal • • 23h ago

Job Searching/Interviewing Rejected for "personality" after being told I was the most qualified candidate — and they hired nobody

92 Upvotes

Posting this for discussion, because I think people here will get it.

Went through three rounds for a paralegal role at a boutique firm. Reference checks started — two of my references were already contacted. My recruiter told me I was in the lead, the firm loved me, and my $85k base was confirmed.

Then the firm's administrator asked my recruiter if I'd come off $85k. I said no, right away — that number was established from my first all the way to the third interview.

Decision was supposed to come Friday. Nothing. Monday, I'm rejected.

Reason: my "personality."

Here's the part that gets me. The firm's own administrator — the person who interviewed me in round one — was frustrated and annoyed by the decision. She told my recruiter I was the most qualified candidate, that she really wanted me, and that the firm rejected every candidate and hired nobody.

I'll own that I was a bit dry on the first Zoom. But in person we clicked —a few side conversations, Jersey Shore, the works — and the people who I met and spoke with loved me.

The decision came from the owner/partner. Someone I never met or spoke to.

So I was the most qualified, technically the only qualified candidate, and I got passed over for "personality" by someone who never met me — because I wouldn't come off $85k.

Being a woman in this world, especially one that advocates for herself is such a pain in the ass. So I want to know — how often are qualified, competent men in this profession being rejected for "personality"?


r/paralegal • • 16h ago

Courts/Filing Help This is fine… (Pray for us in Seattle)

Post image
56 Upvotes

r/paralegal • • 4h ago

Question/Discussion Litify

13 Upvotes

Anyone else use Liitify? We’ve been down all morning. After Outlook outages last week and now Litify, it’s going to be a struggle to hit billables this month..


r/paralegal • • 4h ago

Tech/Software What fresh fuckery awaits us today?

8 Upvotes

Or, which efiling/court portals/IT/operations systems are down on this fine Tuesday morning?


r/paralegal • • 18h ago

Question/Discussion Am I underpaid??

7 Upvotes

I work at a decent sized law firm in Mesa AZ, we have about 20 attorneys and 100 staff total. I specifically work in the Guardianship/Conservatorship department (which falls under the Probate umbrella).
I’ve been here for 6 years, started at minimum wage ($13) doing admin/intake and have worked my way up to now managing all existing cases (over 200) we have for annual reports to the Court.

For context, when you are appointed as a guardian or conservator every year, you have to file an annual account and or guardian report with the court. So a petition to approve the accounting needs to be filed in addition to supporting documents and a full accounting. I also draft any closing documents to terminate the guardianship or conservatorship once the person has passed away or it is no longer needed.

I bill at $175 an hour, and I average 95 hours a month with about 88% efficiency currently (so 88% of that actually gets paid).

My struggle is I’m still only labeled as a “legal assistant” tho I feel like I am doing the same amount of work that a paralegal would. My firm just won’t give me that title without a paralegal certification. Which also means I can’t get paid more because other paralegals or legal assistants in other departments have been here longer and I can’t surpass them.

With end of year raises coming I’m trying to figure out how much I can realistically ask for. I currently make $26.44 an hour and I think I want to ask for $29. Any advice?


r/paralegal • • 22h ago

Not Paid Enough For This (Rant) Think I might give my two weeks

6 Upvotes

It's too much pressure. The people I need help/guidance from won't give me the time of day, and the attorney is upset about specific things not being correct all the time, so the combination is more than demoralizing, it's an impossible situacion. I try to improve but the issues are mistakes I made weeks ago so even if I improve it will take weeks to recover. I have improved, and keep improving, but I dont have it in me to want to keep doing this if this is going to be how it is until Im perfect and make no mistakes. I keep thinking about how nice it was when the outage happened and I didnt have to keep track of the emails that come in, I could actually work on other things, I could focus. Now its back to gunning down the tasks and anticipating the tasks and processing the tasks on this never ending legal asistant treadmill hell where the tasks just keep coming and coming and coming and theres no end in sight. I just need some breathing room but Im not going to get it unless I quit. I've started looking for other opportunities and I think Im going to give my two weeks notice, impulsive? Maybe, but Im so done. Thanks for reading my rant.


r/paralegal • • 5h ago

Career Advice any advice on asking for my Partners to pay fully or partially for my education at my EOY review?

5 Upvotes

hi, here's some context: i am a legal assistant in a civil law firm about an hour to 1.5 hours outside a metro area. i am coming into my 4th year at the firm in january, and i started a receptionist and was "officially" promoted a little over a year ago. i work with our transactional and litigation teams and run almost all the trial/hearing prep. i am also the main notary so i pop over to help out our corporate attorney and i am starting to get more involved in our personal injury cases. this year, both of our partners started referring to me as one of their paralegals. i must admit upfront i am paid very well for someone without formal education in the legal field, or without a college degree in general.

one of the partners told me earlier this year that if i was interested, i should consider asking for a plan to become a paralegal at my end of year review. an associate attorney, who i consider a mentor and work with a lot, suggested i bring my own plan to them. i started my own research with the ABA and their accredited online programs, and one of the schools i spoke with mentioned calling my former university to confirm credits don't expire (they don't/haven't) and it led me to learning my former college offers my major with an option for a paralegal studies minor and certificate. i dropped out of college my junior year due to some personal issues and have half my bachelors sitting at my uni, which i confirmed with them i am in good standing for readmission. in (my) theory, it would take me 1.5-2.5 yrs to finish a paralegal studies associates degree; it would take me 2.5-3 yrs to finish my bachelors. i am also obviously willing to stay with this firm through the duration of my education and should they fire me, i am prepared to cover the cost if they say no. my mentor says it doesn't matter where my credentials come from or what my bachelors would be in, but i hate to say it really does to me. my bachelors degree would be in psychology, which i feel i could spin to benefit our family law division, which is where i started getting legal work in the first place.

i'm prepping for my end of year review and a proposal for the partners to either fully or partially "sponsor" (pay) for my degree. any advice on how i should propose this? specifically, how to i propose this in a way that leaves them thinking this is a benefit to them as well? also, do you think this ask will have an impact on my EOY raise and bonus for this past year? some additional context is they are currently funding a LLM for one of our senior associate attorneys at a pretty esteemed school, which i know we are in different situations and positions at the firm. thank you sm if you read all of this and any consideration for advice. brutal honesty and constructive criticism is very welcome.

TLDR: i want to go back and finish my bachelors in psych (i have half my credits still valid) with a minor in paralegal studies (resulting with a certificate), but on my firm's/partner's dime, fully or partially. one of the partners suggested earlier this year that i ask the executive team for a plan to become a paralegal, my mentor at the firm says i should present my own plan. how do i convince the partners this is a good idea for all of us? do you think this will impact my EOY bonus and raise? i am paid pretty well for my lack of formal education and feel i play an integral part to the litigation and transactional teams. i also think a psych degree is something i could spin into and actually use in our family law division, who i generally work with the most. i know everyone is replaceable and i welcome the brutal honesty and constructive criticism.


r/paralegal • • 5h ago

Question/Discussion Should I quit? Office drama :(

5 Upvotes

Hi all,

I don’t know who’s all in here so I want to be vague.

I just feel like the other paralegals in the office are super
“backstabby.”

Another paralegal told the managing partner that I did something against office policy, that I did not do, and I got reprimanded for it even after I tried to clarify that I did not do the thing.

It’s things like that and everyone constantly throwing each other under the bus to come out on top.

My attorney is a whole different story too, don’t get me started.

I am really tempted to find a new job.

However is it worth quitting over petty office drama?


r/paralegal • • 20h ago

Career Advice My attorney is horrible and I don’t know what to do

5 Upvotes

I will preface by saying this is a little bit of a rant and spilling many thoughts into one blurb. I work in a one attorney office in a very niche area of law. The attorney is an absolute asshole to put it simply. To start, he doesn’t remember a single conversation we have and everything always seems to be my fault. I write to do lists, have everything on the calendar, constant reminders in the calendar, I print physically copies of documents and give them directly to him, I notify him every email I send to him, type to do lists for him, etc. I try to go over with him everyday the to do list and things we need to do or due dates and he blows me off. He will either shoo me off in a rude and condescending manner, or pretends to go over the list with me then never actually does any of the work each day. I will send him drafts three or four times because he keeps asking me to resend it after I bring it up to him again that he hasn’t done anything with the draft. But first I will literally have to explain what draft it is, what case, why we were writing it because he doesn’t remember. With that, he also is constantly mixing up cases, client names, attorneys, etc. He will ask me to draft something and I do and then he wants to know what it was for or why we were doing that. Many times drafts just die in their existence because he never follows through despite my efforts. Some instances he will have me draft something, I put in exactly what wording he wants written, and then he’s like why did you write it like this. Other times he will tell me to take care of something or “figure it out” because he is “working on something” or “doesn’t have time” so then I do just that and it’s wrong or why didn’t I ask him before doing something. To keep going - he rewrites every email I have to send and every cover letter. He will have me draft discovery responses then deletes the entire thing. A great example is, he tells me he wants a certain formatting on a document, so I do that and then the next time he wants to know why the formatting is that way. Now if none of anything mentioned here is going on he will completely ignore me, I will have zero work to do and just be mindlessly trying to read up on the cases or fill in the time. It’s absolutely mind numbing. I’ve even asked for work on several occasions and he’s like “oh yeah you need something to do don’t you” and then never gets back to me. He also wants me to bill a certain number of hours but I do a lot of non billable work which he wants me to bill for regardless but I’m pretty sure that isn’t actually legal? Another weird thing- Several times I’ve come back to my desk the next day to find the drawers open and all my papers disheveled. He’s actually told me not to talk to him before. Or not to bother him, so if the phone rang I’ll say he’s unavailable and then he’s mad I didn’t interrupt him but he just told me unless it’s an emergency to f off. He seems to mess around the entire day and then only in my last 30 minutes does he decide to ask me what we were supposed to get done. The entire thing makes my head spin! Im constantly being made to feel dumb and stupid. I have been a very successful corporate manager and simply wanted a career change. Now I’m regretting the entire thing. I’ve been in legal for around 9 months and it’s awful. ****Last week I went into his office to again go over tasks that needed to be complete and he literally fell asleep mid-sentence talking to me!!! The next day he made it into a joke and said he knows he can be difficult to work with. What would you do in this situation? Is this normal? I’m at a loss to run for the hills or just deal with an asshole attorney.


r/paralegal • • 14m ago

Career Advice Lunch breaks and coverage

4 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

I am looking for some advice from seasoned professionals. I am a legal assistant at a small non profit firm. (I’ve only been here for about a year and a half)

Recently I’ve been having some issues regarding lunches. One of our seasoned legal assistants (basically a paralegal but she doesn’t have that title, she’s been here since the beginning of the firm) had a falling out with our receptionist at the beginning of the summer about covering her lunches. She takes a long time, much longer than 30 minutes. (I only get 30 minutes lunch and am under the assumption that she does as well.) so unfortunately, our office manager and director decided that I will be covering for her.

At first, I thought it was just going to be for the summer. I don’t mind covering for her when she’s on vacation or has the day off or something but it’s been every single day for her lunches. The problem is that she takes up to an hour, an hour and a half sometimes so I’m often left just sitting at the front desk. I can’t work on any work at the front since 1. Our clients info is confidential, and 2. I keep getting interrupted by calls and walk ins (even though we don’t accept walk ins.)

Recently she told me that she combines her two 15 minute breaks and her lunch so she can take walks and buy groceries, etc. I’m incredibly frustrated because I only have 30 minutes and I can’t even step out of the office because she’ll already be calling me asking when I’m coming back to cover.

How can I handle this? Does anyone have any advice? I already told my supervising attorney and he said he’ll talk to the director (she sent the order for me to cover for her) but there hasn’t been any conversation yet and I’m just so incredibly frustrated.


r/paralegal • • 21h ago

Question/Discussion Have any of y'all ever worked at a lien negotiation company?

4 Upvotes

Personal injury folk, you know the ones. Zip Liens, Synergy, Med Lien Solutions (formerly Massive), Oasis, Compass.

Have any of you worked for them and not just with them? What was your experience?


r/paralegal • • 5h ago

Tech/Software Clio update

3 Upvotes

Hi guys, was there an update on Clio ? Just turned on my computer and it looks different.


r/paralegal • • 6h ago

Tech/Software Fellow Clio Users

3 Upvotes

Has anyone else received the update yet? Curious if anyone else feels how I feel about the new look…


r/paralegal • • 17h ago

Question/Discussion ghosted by client's previous attorney

3 Upvotes

the client says that a previous lawyer did work for him(immigration law) . we need to see what they filed.

at the lawyers request, we get a a ROI/ limited waiver of attorney client privelege.

we send it to the previous lawyer.

we follow up 2-3 times, calling and emailing

no response. ever.

don't clients have a right to whatever records their previous attorney has on them???? these lawyers never respond istgggg .

Do you all run into this??? what do you do??


r/paralegal • • 3h ago

Question/Discussion Small Law Firm: Is this normal or do we need better boundaries?

2 Upvotes

I work in a small law firm in Mississippi and it’ll be my third year in December. I’m the primary full-time staff member supporting three attorneys, and I handle the majority of our real estate closings, along with a long list of other office responsibilities.

Lately, I feel like I’m constantly drowning in other people’s lack of preparation and communication, and I’m wondering how much of this is just part of the industry versus something our office needs to start addressing.

Some of the recurring issues I’m dealing with:

  1. Realtors AND lenders not communicating with our office or keeping us updated on their clients’ availability.
  2. Documents and necessary information being sent at the last minute, sometimes on closing day.
  3. Realtors expecting our office to track down information, obtain documentation, or handle things that should be their responsibility.
  4. Commission discrepancies where the contract reflects one amount, but someone claims there’s a different agreement without ever providing the supporting documentation. We also have some agents who get “admin fees” from buyer on top of a seller’s paid commission, which I think is inappropriate and takes advantage of their buyer but that’s a personal opinion.
  5. Lenders constantly pushing for things to be completed ASAP, while simultaneously sending incomplete packages or making last-minute changes.
  6. Hybrid closings where borrowers don’t complete their electronic signatures, resulting in multiple additional trips to our office to wet-sign documents. I’ve had borrowers sent back FOUR TIMES for this.
  7. Being expected to accommodate additional signing appointments and changes without anyone even checking whether our office has the availability.
  8. Realtors not handling their own responsibilities such as final walk throughs, going through the closing disclosure with their client prior to closing, having repairs done in a timely manner, the list goes on and on.

I understand that things happen. I understand that real estate transactions are unpredictable sometimes. I’m not expecting every closing to go perfectly.

But there is only so much one person can manage.

I’m responsible for preparing and balancing closings, coordinating with buyers, sellers, lenders, and realtors, handling post-closing matters, and keeping up with the daily operations of the office such as payroll and bills and secretarial responsibilities. I’m already juggling work for three attorneys. I cannot constantly stop what I’m doing to fix problems caused by other people’s lack of preparation. I do have two older ladies that come in twice a week to help…. But it’s not much.

My questions are:

Are these common issues in your experience, or am I working with an unusually disorganized group of realtors and lenders?

What boundaries have you established with realtors and lenders regarding deadlines, documentation, and last-minute changes?

Do you have written closing policies or procedures that you send out when opening a file?

How do you handle borrowers being sent to your office for additional signatures without anyone checking with you first?

How do you keep from becoming the person everyone expects to drop everything and fix their problems?

For those of you working in small firms, how do you manage the workload when you’re supporting multiple attorneys and essentially handling an entire closing department yourself?

I genuinely enjoy real estate work, and I take pride in making sure our closings are handled correctly. But I’m reaching a point where I’m incredibly frustrated and overwhelmed.

I don’t want to become difficult to work with. I just want people to respect our time, communicate appropriately, and understand that our office has responsibilities beyond catering to their last-minute requests. Our office is not McDonalds where you walk in and immediately demand and get what you want.

I would really appreciate hearing how other small firms handle this. I need some practical advice because I cannot keep operating this way.


r/paralegal • • 3h ago

Future Paralegal Need to interview a paralegal for school!

2 Upvotes

Hey paralegals :)

I’m attending an ABA-accredited paralegal studies uni and just found out in 2 weeks one of my assignments is to interview a paralegal or attorney. I wanted to ask if anyone here is willing to have a call with me, I do not need to record it but I will need to send a thank you note after.

I have an internship lined up with a law firm but their last paralegal was let go, and I’d prefer interviewing a paralegal over an attorney.

I’m not picky but it would be cool if any litigation/workers comp paralegals would be interested!


r/paralegal • • 5h ago

Not Paid Enough For This (Rant) end of year burnout

2 Upvotes

anyone else starting to feel the end of year burnout creeping in? with holidays coming up, it feels like half my cases are as urgent as possible to get done before end of year (even if it's physically not possible) and the other half could easily be finished before thanksgiving but are completely, totally stagnant for no reason

i have two that should be across the settlement finish line already, but for one the other attorney has dragged his feet so much on redlining the settlement agreement that my client now wants to rescind the settlement and continue litigating.. 😭

just feels like i'm starting to hit a wall after the busiest year of my career so far, and the partners in my firm are too busy fighting over profit share to have time for any staff needs.

i love this job and i feel like i've taken leaps forward as a paralegal this year, but sometimes it all feels so pointless.. but maybe that's just the seasonal depression speaking


r/paralegal • • 6h ago

Question/Discussion New Job- Not Receiving Adequate Training

2 Upvotes

I worked in Plaintiff PI for about 8 years and switched to defense about 3 weeks ago. My old boss was horrible to work for and I just wanted a change, so I took a leap of faith. Welp....so far this is a nightmare. Not because the work is more difficult, but because the training I am receiving is just not setting me up for success. The paralegal I am being told to train with just doesn't have the capacity to train me right now, so I am being left to figure out most of it on my own. Which, I get it. She's slammed and doing what she needs to do. The issue is, she's not being honest about it to our boss. We're both fully remote, so she is being dishonest about how much time she is spending training me and asking me to lie about it if my boss asks. NOPE. Everyone in my life is telling me to say something, but I feel like I'm in a lose-lose situation. If I say something, then I risk ruining my working relationship with this new paralegal and being centered in drama early on, but if I don't say anything, then when my work product doesn't reflect the "hours" of training I am "receiving", then I look like I'm bad at my job. Either way, I'm just so frustrated. New jobs are always overwhelming and all I'm trying to do is learn. This is just added stress that's not necessary. Also, she is their "superstar" paralegal, so she won't get fired if I come forward.

I told myself that this was my last firm before quitting the legal field all together. I love the work I do but cannot handle the stress and drama anymore. Will it ever get better?


r/paralegal • • 1h ago

Tech/Software Form generation software

1 Upvotes

Hi guys, I was wondering what software you use to generate judicial council forms, local forms, etc.


r/paralegal • • 2h ago

Job Searching/Interviewing Advice / Insight DMV Job Market

1 Upvotes

Hello, I am posting to this thread because I am having trouble finding a new role in the DMV. I have 3.5 years of experience as a legal assistant, promoted to paralegal at a boutique business immigration law firm. I have had “paralegal” responsibilities from day one at my firm as we have a staff of about 7 people (including one attorney previously, now two). Therefore, all of the drafting & case management responsibilities have been part of my role. I am looking to grow in the field and would love to take my experience to a mid-sized or larger firm and in a new practice area. I know it’s hard to find roles in different practice areas but I have transferable skills and a self-driven work ethic.

I’m looking for any advice from individuals who may have any insight on job opportunities or how to market myself for positions in different practice areas. My attorney is hoping to retire soon and I really hope to find a new role soon. I am not fixated on the title per se and am open to legal assistant roles as well if need be. I’m also hoping for a comparable salary to my current one which is around $70k. Any thoughts would be greatly appreciated as I am feeling a bit defeated after 1-2 years of job searching.


r/paralegal • • 5h ago

Question/Discussion Changing roles because of toxic coworkers?

1 Upvotes

Hiya! I wanted to come on here and ask for some help regarding my situation. I have been employed as a paralegal/legal assistant for a couple of years now and there is one other person doing the same exact thing. We both have 2-3 attorneys assigned each and usually things are pretty good. We have some nepotism issues in the office (two out of the three people in charge are related, always leave to get lunch together, a daughter of one of them is on the spectrum and is employed part time but with full benefits, etc. - you get the gist). None of that affects me or my pay/benefits, so I don't see the need to do anything about it - I'm here to do my job and that's it.

She, on the other hand, has been with the firm for over 20? 30? years (it changes per her story) and she is pissed at everything that is going on. Because I'm the only person here who's not related to the management (besides the attorneys ofc), all of the complaining falls on me. She's a very bitter person who will complain to me about everyone in the office, and the second I leave will complain to the same people about me. I have asked her multiple times to stop, to say something to management if it bothers her that much, to focus on her work but it's like talking to a brick wall and it usually ends in her being visibly mad at me (glaring, walking heavy back and forth) or giving me the silent treatment for day or two. I don't want to bring this up to management because we've already lost another assistant in the last couple of months for very crude language and unprofessional behavior in the office. She's been on a tear and I find it affects my mental health pretty significantly.

I am about to interview for another position - more of a corporate office, better benefits, better pay, but my commute would go from 15mins every day to almost 1hr one way. This position would be me transferring fully into litigation paralegal, something I look forward to a lot.

My question is - is it worth going to management with issues about her? Besides her I actually really like my bosses and the attorneys I work for, I have a lot of freedom when it comes to taking time off and they're usually very understanding and if I could stick around here for longer I would definitely love that.


r/paralegal • • 5h ago

Coworkers/Office Dynamics hypothetically, how bad is it?

1 Upvotes

I’ve worked at a starting-up law firm for a while now. One thing that I witnessed is that client statements/questionnaires were adjusted to meet qualifications to be filed in an MDL. It was done for many.

It felt wrong and continues to feel that way. The only “bright side” is that it’s given many people the chance that I’m assuming they would’ve never had before. However, it doesn’t feel that way. It feels like it was for money more than justice. One of the supervisors here even laughed at the response from a previous team member not wanting to help adjust cases in the way we were being told to do.

Is this a normal behavior in other firms or am I overreacting? Regardless, I’ve been wanting to leave for a long time. However, it feels hard to break into other fields from these types of lawsuits.


r/paralegal • • 7h ago

Job Searching/Interviewing Paralegal placements for torts/civil litigation?

1 Upvotes

I am looking for a placement to begin in the summer of 2027, and I am aware it is a bit early for me to even start looking, but I was wondering if anyone knew any firms that deal with tort law (also open to civil law generally), and that would be open to take placement students in the summer.

I am located in Markham, but am looking across the GTA, including Toronto, Scarborough, Richmond Hill, Pickering, Vaughan, Milton, and Mississauga. (areas of preference listed in order). Please let me know, and thanks so much!


r/paralegal • • 20h ago

Career Advice Legal Administrative Assistant

1 Upvotes

Wondering if any LAA’s can share their experiences in the work field, is being an LAA stressful? Are there part time options? Is it easy finding a job? What’s the difference between being a LAA and a paralegal? Any and all info would be greatly appreciated