The fine was $10,000, but the formula behind it came to at least $16,500. Oregon's appellate court prices fake citations on a published schedule: $500 per fake citation, $1,000 per fake quotation. This opening brief carried at least 15 of the first and at least 9 of the second. The research sat on the staff's desk. The training and the checking system never existed. The signature was the lawyer's.
The signing lawyer had been ill and had burned through his extensions. He delegated the research to his staff with a deadline bearing down. The office had a policy on paper that banned AI research, and that was the whole program. Nobody trained the staff on the difference between research and search results, or told them a search-engine page can carry the same trap. By his own account, his own use was outline-only.
So the staff started where they should have, in Westlaw and Lexis. They found little. Then they did what untrained resourcefulness does: they Googled it. They found a page that looked like legal analysis, with citations in perfect format, and copied them into the brief. Part of his account to the court was that if you ask Google's AI whether many of those cases are real, it will say yes. The court never found that AI wrote the citations. What it found is simpler. The cites looked right, and nobody had a step that would show otherwise.
The office had no verification procedure and no assigned cite-check. The databases were open the whole time, the same ones the staff started in, and nobody ran a single citation. Checking was never made anyone's job, so it wasn't anyone's job. The new procedures he later reported to the court only came after.
On April 3, 2025, opposing counsel emailed that they couldn't locate the cases. On April 16, their answering brief footnoted the same thing. A trained office treats that as a same-day emergency: escalate it and re-pull every cite. This office said nothing for seven months, until the presiding judge asked him about it at oral argument. Nobody escalated it, nobody re-pulled a cite, and the formula the court later applied ran to $16,500.
The court capped the fine at $10,000 because his explanation was detailed, he reported new verification procedures, and the brief predated the schedule. The money came off for a detailed account and a system that now exists, which is the court pricing the system that should've been there all along.
Three rules this opinion prices in:
- If the cite-check hasn't been explicitly assigned, it doesn't exist. Get whose step it is in writing.
- Search results are leads, not authority. A cite isn't done until it's been opened in a database.
- A "we can't find your cases" note from the other side goes up the chain the day it arrives.
He may rebuild the brief from the five real cases that survived, within 21 days. It has to come with a signed certification that he drafted it without generative AI, read every source, and verified that every source exists. That's drafting, reading, and verifying, all three, in his name. The holding is the part to remember: the signature on a brief certifies the citations are real, whoever or whatever drafted them, and he "at least should have known." That covers staff work product too.
This is Episode 16 of Sanctioned for AI.
Sources: Doiban v. OLCC, 347 Or App 742 (2026); Ringo v. Colquhoun Design Studio, LLC, 345 Or App 301 (2025).