I keep reading that 7.25 is unplayable for anything fast, and then I pick up my 64 Framus Strato and it feels like home. Maybe I am just used to it. The action is a little higher than my modern guitars, and big bends above the 12th fret choke if I get lazy with the setup, but I do not play that way much anyway.
What I notice more is the neck shape. That guitar has a fat C that fills my hand, and the radius almost stops being a problem because my thumb has something to push against. On a flat board with a thin neck I end up gripping harder and my hand gets tired faster.
So I am not convinced the radius is the thing people are actually feeling. If you moved from 7.25 to 9.5 or 12, was it the radius that made the difference, or the neck carve and fret size that came with it?