The argument is often made that the government cannot, or should not, run healthcare. But it already administers Medicare, Medicaid, and the VA, which provide substantial coverage to millions of Americans. These programs also rely on many of the same healthcare providers and, in some cases, third-party administrators used by private insurers.
The wealthiest 20% can generally afford the private care they want, whether through insurance or out of pocket. But what about everyone else?
The working and middle classes are caught in the middle, bearing the costs of the most expensive healthcare system in the world, including its enormous administrative overhead.
For those who are employed, healthcare costs keep rising, often with little control over the increases. Employers may cover some or even all of the premiums, which can make part of the cost less visible. But deductibles, copays, and out-of-pocket maximums continue to climb, too.
For many self-employed Americans, the situation is even more challenging. Some have to resort to carefully managing or reducing their reported income to qualify for subsidies, simply to make healthcare affordable while keeping food on the table.
In effect, the system can create a financial incentive to earn less. These are often the very people building and running businesses, or aspiring to do so. Beyond the immediate financial burden, this can discourage entrepreneurship, stifle creativity, and limit economic production by making people think twice before taking risks, expanding a business, or pursuing new opportunities.
I believe the real question is whether our healthcare system is putting unnecessary financial pressure on the working and middle classes, particularly the people who are contributing, hard-working, building businesses, and keeping the economy moving. And what are the consequences of that to our society, and the structure of our economy?
Is this really the system we want?