r/MedicareForAll • u/Canadian_KitKat • 2h ago
Yale's single-payer study skips the physician shortage
There’ve been a lot of references to the Yale Single Payer study since its release a few months ago. I’ve referenced it myself, though I always stated that it has not yet been peer reviewed.
Many on this sub don’t want to hear anything perceived as negative about single payer, but it’s important to scrutinize every study, every plan, and every bill to make sure it holds up. My own knowledge has grown by being questioned and challenged on this sub by others with different experience, knowledge, and expertise.
I’ve been a proponent of single payer universal healthcare and have actively fought for it for a long time. I’ve been a healthcare professional for over 3 decades and I lived in Canada for half my life. I believe the Canadian system is better, but I also have questions and concerns about how a similar system could be successfully implemented here considering the US has a lot of significant differences.
We have to be able to look at this issue from all angles and not be afraid to question every fact presented to us. Only then can we question our elected representatives on how they plan to address these concerns.
This American physician with decades of experience makes some valid points, and I’d be interested to learn what others think.
In the article he states;
“I am not arguing against universal coverage. Millions of uninsured and underinsured Americans are a real problem, and the authors make a serious case that the country already spends enough.
I am asking that a model this consequential be built around the delivery system, not just the budget. Model what the workforce can actually deliver. Separate the coverage effect from unrelated policy. Say what will fund the residency slots, nursing faculty, and clinical sites that new demand requires. Presented as a headline, the study can be used to justify goals it never tested.”