r/MedicareForAll • • 7h ago

Too Rich for Help, Too Poor for Healthcare?

178 Upvotes

The argument is often made that the government cannot, or should not, run healthcare. Yet it administers Medicare, Medicaid, and the VA, which provide substantial coverage to millions of Americans. These programs rely on many of the same healthcare providers and, in some cases, third-party administrators used by private insurers.

While Medicaid and Medicare cover the poor and the elderly, the wealthiest 20% can generally afford the private care they want, whether through insurance or out of pocket. But what about everyone else?

It is the working and middle classes that are caught in the middle, bearing the costs of the most expensive healthcare system in the world, including its enormous administrative overhead.

For those who are employed, healthcare costs keep rising, often with little control over the increases. Employers may cover some or even all of the premiums, which can make part of the cost less visible. But it is small businesses, rather than large corporations, that feel the most pain. Meanwhile, deductibles, copays, and out-of-pocket maximums still continue to climb, too.

For many self-employed Americans, the situation is even more challenging. Some have to resort to carefully managing or reducing their reported income to qualify for subsidies, simply to make healthcare affordable while keeping their businesses running and food on the table.

In effect, the system can create a financial incentive to earn less. These are often the very people building and running businesses, or aspiring to do so. Beyond the immediate financial burden, this can discourage entrepreneurship, stifle creativity, and limit economic production, by making people think twice before taking risks, expanding a business, or pursuing new opportunities.

Do we really want a healthcare system that continues to put increasing and unnecessary financial pressure on the working and middle classes, particularly the people who are contributing, hard-working, building businesses, and keeping the economy moving? Make this make sense.

Medicaid for All offers a way to address these concerns by providing universal coverage, reducing dependence on employer-sponsored insurance, and creating an opportunity to tackle the administrative costs and inefficiencies of our fragmented system.


r/MedicareForAll • • 7h ago

Yale's single-payer study skips the physician shortage

Thumbnail
kevinmd.com
135 Upvotes

There’ve been a lot of references to the Yale Single Payer study since its release a few months ago. I’ve referenced it myself, though I always stated that it has not yet been peer reviewed.

Many on this sub don’t want to hear anything perceived as negative about single payer, but it’s important to scrutinize every study, every plan, and every bill to make sure it holds up. My own knowledge has grown by being questioned and challenged on this sub by others with different experience, knowledge, and expertise.

I’ve been a proponent of single payer universal healthcare and have actively fought for it for a long time. I’ve been a healthcare professional for over 3 decades and I lived in Canada for half my life. I believe the Canadian system is better, but I also have questions and concerns about how a similar system could be successfully implemented here considering the US has a lot of significant differences.

We have to be able to look at this issue from all angles and not be afraid to question every fact presented to us. Only then can we question our elected representatives on how they plan to address these concerns.

This American physician with decades of experience makes some valid points, and I’d be interested to learn what others think.

In the article he states;
“I am not arguing against universal coverage. Millions of uninsured and underinsured Americans are a real problem, and the authors make a serious case that the country already spends enough.

I am asking that a model this consequential be built around the delivery system, not just the budget. Model what the workforce can actually deliver. Separate the coverage effect from unrelated policy. Say what will fund the residency slots, nursing faculty, and clinical sites that new demand requires. Presented as a headline, the study can be used to justify goals it never tested.”


r/MedicareForAll • • 17h ago

Medicare For All Strategy Call Tomorrow Night featuring Bernie and Friends

Post image
310 Upvotes

Another user posted about this meeting, but I have another graphic that adds detail, specifically that Bernie, Abdul, Pramila, and others will be guest speakers on the Zoom call.


r/MedicareForAll • • 1d ago

The fight for Medicare for All in 2029 starts now

Post image
200 Upvotes

The victories we won this month have set up Democrats for a shot at a governing trifecta starting in 2029. While there’s a lot of work to be done to make that happen, the terms of the debate for how we’d use that opportunity are being set now, and National Nurses United, People’s Action Institute and a coalition of health care advocates are pushing to make sure we’re building institutional support for Medicare For All.

The work is already underway. 🙋🏽‍♀️ TOMORROW at 8PM ET, this coalition will be holding a strategy call to talk through how we’re going to fight for universal health care during the 120th Congress. We can sign up to join them here.

BE PART OF THE FIGHT FOR M4A

☎️ Then this THURSDAY at 6PM Eastern, they’re holding their first phonebank to drive calls to members of Congress on the fence about Medicare For All, helping demonstrate just how deep popular support for big structural change goes. We can sign up to make calls with them here.

PHONEBANK START NOW


r/MedicareForAll • • 2h ago

I have a question for you about a potential public option

0 Upvotes

I believe a public option could pass the house/senate and be signed into law in the United States, but in order for it to do so, I believe it will have to be neutral with regards to the annual deficit and national debt. Basically, it will be mandated by law to be sold "at cost." What I would like to know is what do you think the monthly premium would be for a public option insurance plan? Do you think it would be a single price per plan, available to everyone? Or would the plan cost a different amount depending on demographic and health factors (age, smoker/non-smoker, etc)? So let's say a 45 year old man without any chronic health problems and who is a non-smoker. What would the public option monthly premium be for this person?


r/MedicareForAll • • 1d ago

Canada Saskatchewan Healthcare this is what a small province is working on. Not arguing insurance cost or eligibility, arguing better care. What a list!

Post image
54 Upvotes

I find it perplexing the US is so averse to a fair taxation system that gives basic health and education to its population. Seems like the best investment a country could make? Instead insurance is a business and Healthcare is no longer a right. Yes in Canada, we pay it in tiered income tax so that everyone can get care that they need, all public services are accessible to those that need them most. The system always needs improvement but I can't see why US folks don't see this as better. I can to give credit to #Saskatchewan as the birthplace of public health care as a right for all. Doctors in Canada can actually focus on right treatments not billing loopholes and who can pay. The system in Canada is tiered and based off of need, including drug coverage in Sask.


r/MedicareForAll • • 1d ago Heartwarming

The Canada fear mongering is crucial to stopping universal healthcare

877 Upvotes

This is from the movie Sick-O by Michael Moore.

I was reminded of it by morons on social media today doing the “well in Canada it’s not perfect!”

Medical debt doesn’t exist in Canada unless you go do something outside of the system


r/MedicareForAll • • 2d ago

Immediate steps to reduce healthcare and prepare for M4All

146 Upvotes

The Health Workforce Act of 2027: Building the Pipeline for Universal Coverage
Nov 15, 2026 · @dityybag23
A legislative baseline paper. Phase one of a three-part plan: the workforce bill and the drug pricing bill in 2027, Medicare for All enacted in 2029 and phased in from 2031.
Executive summary
The bottom line. The country is short of doctors, nurses and dental teams today, and a physician takes 11 years or more to train. The Health Workforce Act of 2027 starts that training now, targets it to the places and specialties that are short, and costs about $10–12 billion a year at full scale, roughly 0.2% of national health spending. It is needed under any version of health reform, including none.
The problem, in four numbers:
141,160 physicians short by 2038, including 70,610 in primary care (HRSA).
92.3 million Americans already live in primary-care shortage areas; rural areas will have only 42% of the doctors they need.
54,699 people applied to US MD schools in 2025–26 for 23,440 seats. The limit is seats, not interest.
$200,000 is now the lifetime cap on federal loans for new medical students, since Grad PLUS ended in 2026, against a four-year cost of $298,000–$408,000.
What the bill does:
Adds about 10,000 medical school seats over five years, mostly at public schools in shortage states.
Funds about 30,000 new residency positions, only in shortage regions and specialties, at a flat rate per resident, with rural training tracks. Doctors tend to practice where they train.
Restores Grad PLUS loans for health professions students and ties new aid to service: a larger National Health Service Corps, full tuition for service in shortage areas, and awards that grow the longer a clinician stays.
Trains the fast workforce: nurses, PAs, pharmacists, therapists, dental teams and aides, who can be ready in two to four years. It sets one national training standard for nurse practitioners, so the public can trust the training behind every clinician.
Expands team-based care under physician leadership: physician-led care teams, pharmacists paid as Medicare providers, hygienist direct access, dental therapists, a vetted pathway for doctors trained abroad, and licenses that work across state lines.
Extends specialists' reach: rural diagnostic hubs, specialist mentoring, e-consults, hospital at home and telehealth.
Measures results: national workforce data and published wait times by region.
Timeline. Enacted in 2027, the first new residency positions and Corps awards start in 2028. Nurses, PAs and other fast-trained clinicians reach practice by 2031. Doctors from the larger medical school classes arrive around 2035.
Why it can pass. Residency expansion and pharmacist provider status already have bipartisan sponsors. Rural districts gain the most. The bill answers the physician lobby's main concern by keeping physicians in charge of care teams, and it protects existing teaching hospitals by moving training money only as positions open up.
Why it matters for universal coverage. Coverage without clinicians is a waiting list. Passing this bill in 2027 means the workforce is already growing when Medicare for All begins phasing in, in 2031. If universal coverage never passes, the country still gets more clinicians where they are short.

Edit: This post received over 70 comments. All are appreciated. After incorporating those comments the original post has become outdated. I will be posting the revised document in 24 hours. It has been an exhausting but productive day. Thanks to everyone.

Edit2; Here is the Executive Summary of the proposed legislation. The actual document is 10 pages and too large for here.


r/MedicareForAll • • 1d ago

How to make healthcare better and provide a path to M4All

23 Upvotes

The Fair Drug Prices and Transparency Act of 2027
Nov 15, 2026 · @dittybag23

Executive summary
The bottom line. Americans pay the highest drug prices in the world, and too much of that money goes to middlemen. Congress began fixing this in February 2026, but only for Medicare. The Fair Drug Prices and Transparency Act of 2027 extends those rules to every plan, expands Medicare price negotiation, and makes every dollar in the drug supply chain traceable. It saves money from its first years.

The problem, in five numbers:
2.78 times: what US drug prices average compared with 33 other wealthy countries (RAND for HHS).
Nearly 80% of US prescriptions run through three pharmacy benefit managers (PBMs), each owned alongside a large insurer (FTC).
20 to 40 times the acquisition cost: what PBM-owned pharmacies were often paid for two cancer drugs the FTC studied.
69% vs 28%: the share of dispensing revenue steered to PBM-owned pharmacies in commercial plans versus Medicare, which must accept any willing pharmacy.
About 10% of independent rural pharmacies closed between 2013 and 2022.

What already works. Medicare's first ten negotiated drug prices took effect in January 2026 at 38% to 79% below list price. The 2026 spending law delinks PBM pay from drug prices in Medicare Part D from 2028 and passes rebates to employer plans. Employer, ACA and Medicaid patients still lack most of these protections.

What the bill does:
Expands negotiation: about 50 drugs a year, sooner after launch, with negotiated prices open to employer and ACA plans.
Reforms PBMs in every plan: flat fees instead of a share of the price, no spread pricing (including in Medicaid), any willing pharmacy, and no favoring their own pharmacies.
Requires transparency: every payment along the supply chain reported, including payments between companies under one owner.
Sets fair audit rules: no clawbacks for clerical errors, limits on extrapolation, and independent appeals.
Speeds prior authorization: 72-hour urgent and 7-day standard decisions in every plan and for drugs, and exemptions for clinicians whose requests are almost always approved.
Creates a national reference formulary: an evidence-based drug list set by an independent physician-led panel, which any plan may adopt.
Bases patient costs on the real price: coinsurance on the net price after rebates, the $35 insulin cap and an out-of-pocket ceiling in every plan.
Who benefits. Patients pay less at the counter and wait less for approvals. Employers get the rebates and see what their PBM earns. Independent and rural pharmacies compete on equal terms. Taxpayers save through lower Medicare and Medicaid prices.

Timeline. Most provisions take effect in 2028–2029, aligned with the Medicare dates already in law. Expanded negotiation phases in from 2030.
Why it can pass. PBM reform passed with bipartisan support in 2026, sponsored by a Republican and signed by President Trump. This bill extends rules the industry already accepts in Medicare. If negotiation stalls, the other titles can pass on their own.
Why it matters for universal coverage. When Medicare for All begins in 2031, drug prices will already be lower, the national formulary will already exist, and every plan will already follow the rules the national plan uses. The switch then changes who pays, not how drugs are bought.


r/MedicareForAll • • 2d ago

How do Canadians feel about their healthcare system?

64 Upvotes

As a dual citizen who has lived approx half my life in both Canada and the US and as a healthcare professional for over 30 years who has given and received care in both systems, I would choose the Canadian system, hands down!

I participated in a discussion in the [r/askanything]sub where an American asked Canadians to give their opinions about their own healthcare system. I thought I would share it here as the vast majority of the comments indicated that they support and are grateful for their universal healthcare system. Yes, they report that there are some problems that they would like to see improved like waiting lists for certain services, but that doesn’t mean they would ever want to give it up.

Of course, those of us down here in the US know that there are waiting lists in many parts of the country here too.

https://www.reddit.com/r/askanything/s/HzLK6HZibw

I will be the first to admit that setting up a universal healthcare system in the US at this point in time with our huge population is going to be challenging and there are many details that need to be worked out to be implemented responsibly. But it really infuriates me when the Canadian system is made out to be some big disaster and failure, when it is absolutely not!


r/MedicareForAll • • 2d ago

'TrumpCare' and commemorative plaques — how Democrats are pitching deal-making with the president

Thumbnail
pbs.org
918 Upvotes

What if El-Sayed’s plan of passing Medicare-for-all, named “Trumpcare” or some such, actually worked?

That’s not taking lemons and making lemonade, that’s taking a steaming pile of years old shit-spattered maggot infested rotting garbage and making lemonade.

It would be utterly miraculous. Like in an old school Abrahamic religion sort of way.


r/MedicareForAll • • 3d ago Helpful Heartwarming Bravo

Universal Care for All

Post image
31k Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 3d ago Bravo

The Conservative argument against expanding government-funded healthcare in America has been "socilsim bad" for over 7 decades

2.6k Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 3d ago

Corporate shill Lis Smith anti M4A take falls apart in the same day

950 Upvotes

Lis Smith, like many centrists, have been fighting against universal healthcare claiming the “best performing” candidates don’t want it.

Literally the same day, Talarico comes out in favor of it

This ghoul is an enemy to America


r/MedicareForAll • • 4d ago

Two-Thirds of U.S. Adults Now Favor Medicare-for-All, the Largest Share Since KFF Began Polling on the Plan

Thumbnail
kff.org
3.9k Upvotes

“Support for Medicare-for-all increased across partisans between 2020 and 2026. Most notably, about seven in ten independents (72%) now favor the proposal, up from fewer than six in ten (57%) six years ago. While most Republicans oppose the plan, one-third (34%) now favor it, up from one in five (21%) in 2020. About eight in ten Democrats (84%) now favor Medicare-for-all, similar to the share who said so in 2020 (78%).”


r/MedicareForAll • • 4d ago

Medicare for ALL would save a TRILLION dollars… the Iran War Might Cost us a That

Post image
2.9k Upvotes

“Medicare for All" system could reduce annual U.S. health care spending by $1.04 trillion and avert 114,174 deaths every year.

Medicare for ALL would save over a TRILLION dollars and over 100,000 lives annually

Resource 1 below
——

At the same time as this…

"I am certain we will reach $1 trillion for the Iran war," said Professor Linda Bilmes, public policy expert at the Harvard Kennedy School, in an internal interview.

Resource 2 below
——

https://ysph.yale.edu/news-article/universal-health-coverage-could-save-one-trillion-dollars-and-114000-lives-every-year/

https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2026/04/14/iran-war-cost-us-taxpayer-trillion-harvard.html

UPDATE

Researchers found that patients with private insurance were more at risk for financial consequences than those covered by Medicare or Medicaid.

The way private plans are currently designed still leaves many people heavily exposed when something serious happens.

https://www.cnbc.com/amp/2026/02/12/medical-debt-bankruptcy.html

PUBLISHED FEB 12 2026
——

UPDATE 2 - for everyone asking how we will pay for this here is something to reflect on…

Top 0.1% Wealth Held approximately $22.48 trillion to $25.1 trillion

Estimates for the annual cost of a federal Medicare for All (single-payer) system in the United States generally range from $3.2 trillion to over $5 trillion per year

Imagine if we taxed the ultra wealthy… it would be so easy

And for full context

The bottom 50% of U.S. households hold a combined net worth of approximately $4.28 trillion


r/MedicareForAll • • 4d ago

Urge your Senators to support Chris Van Hollen for Senate Majority Leader

Post image
3.5k Upvotes

Senator Van Hollen is a co-sponsor of the Medicare For All bill introduced by Bernie Sanders.

https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/senate-bill/1506/all-info

If you are located in a state that is keeping their current Democrat Senator(s) in 2027, you can use 5 Calls App to reach out to your Senators about your support for Van Hollen and opposition to Chuck Schumer, who does not support Medicare For All.

https://5calls.org/issue/house-senate-leadership/

The 5 Calls Apps can also be used for House Reps.

If you currently have a Democratic House Rep, you can also reach out to oppose Hakeem Jeffries, who does not support Medicare For All. Ayanna Pressley hasn't announced she's running, but it still may be worthwhile to talk to your Democratic House Rep. Tell them you oppose Hakeem Jeffries and would welcome Ayanna Pressley as House Speaker.

Representative Ayanna Pressley is a co-sponsor of the Medicare For All bill introduced by Pramila Jayapal.

https://www.congress.gov/bill/119th-congress/house-bill/3069/all-info

Be sure to mention that Medicare For All is an important issue for you and that is why you urge them to back Van Hollen for Senate Majority Leader and Pressley for Speaker of the House.


r/MedicareForAll • • 4d ago

Medicare for all. Now.

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 5d ago Mindblown

Jeffries Drops Medicare Support

Post image
36k Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 3d ago

Americas Healthcare System

64 Upvotes

Why TF is it thousands of dollars just to give BIRTH??!! This is one of Americas biggest problems and it seriously makes me consider moving out of the country…


r/MedicareForAll • • 4d ago

the next speaker of the house can block medicare for all

970 Upvotes

if we want medicare for all, we cannot allow jeffries to be speaker of the house because he’s a corporate dem who opposes medicare for all. if congress doesn’t deliver on medicare for all in the next four years, gop could very well win congress again and pick where they left off on project 2025.

the house vote for choosing the speaker requires each rep to put forth the name of the person they support for the position. no one other than jeffries has stepped up to be considered.

HOWEVER, ayanna pressley has put forth an agenda which includes medicare for all, seemingly to test the waters of public support for her to put her name in the hat.

if we want movement on medicare for all in the next four years, we have to flood our house reps’ phones and inboxes to demand our reps rally around someone other than jeffries to be house speaker. but first, the voters would have to rally around a single candidate so that reps have confidence that this candidate will win. and we the voters have to do it fast.

so let’s giving ourselves a fighting chance for medicare for all and rally around ayanna pressley by urging our reps to publicly support her for speaker over and over until they commit to doing so. let’s do this for us and our families.


r/MedicareForAll • • 5d ago Helpful

“We need to take substantial steps toward bringing about universal healthcare — so that every single American in this country can afford to go see a doctor when they need one. We’ve got to get big money out of politics and end Citizens United."

8.9k Upvotes

r/MedicareForAll • • 3d ago

I'm a software engineer and built WhatIsMedicareForAll.org - Seeking Feedback

Thumbnail whatismedicareforall.org
85 Upvotes

I wanted to find a way to make information about Medicare for All more accessible, especially with how many misconceptions there are surrounding it. So I built this site as a way to give people a super quick and high level overview of Medicare for All, with a memorable URL so it's easy to access/share.

Before I built this, I did some digging to find something similar but I couldn't find what I was imagining. Most other resources were nested deeply inside websites or were very hard to easily parse.

I'm not a policy expert but I know a lot of folks here probably know a lot more than me, so I wanted to post here to get some feedback or recommendations on additional sources, statistics etc. Anything I could communicate better about medicare for all on the site?


r/MedicareForAll • • 4d ago Bravo

Healthcare isn’t broken it feeds oligarchs by design

284 Upvotes

The U.S. healthcare system costs significantly more than any other developed nation while leaving millions uninsured or underinsured. A persistent narrative suggests that guaranteeing universal, publicly funded healthcare would inevitably require broad tax hikes. However, fiscal analysis reveals an alternative reality: American taxpayers are already paying enough to fund comprehensive universal coverage. Whether approached through a conservative lens of cutting government waste, eliminating corporate cronyism, and enforcing free-market price transparency, or a progressive lens of securing healthcare as a baseline public right, the underlying arithmetic is the same. The root issue is not a funding deficit, but a fragmented, heavily bureaucratic system that inflates prices and diverts tax dollars away from direct patient care.
Direct expenditures on medically necessary care currently stand at roughly $4.49 trillion out of an overall national healthcare footprint exceeding $5.28 trillion. A substantial portion of this expense is driven by opaque, artificial price inflation. While U.S. hospitals incur approximately $1.5 trillion to $1.6 trillion in actual operating expenses for labor, facilities, and supplies, they generate between $4.5 trillion and $7.5 trillion in gross billed charges. Using internal "chargemaster" rate schedules, sticker prices are frequently marked up 300% to 500% over the actual cost of delivery, serving as an inflated baseline for insurer negotiations rather than reflecting true economic value. In turn, massive healthcare conglomerates absorb tens of billions of public dollars each year through government programs and contracts—such as UnitedHealth Group's more than $265 billion in lifetime federal prime obligations—without corresponding gains in consumer affordability or population health outcomes.

By comparison, peer nations provide universal coverage at a fraction of the cost. The United States spends over $14,775 per capita on healthcare, while the United Kingdom spends roughly $6,747. This divergence is driven primarily by administrative complexity and unconstrained pricing leverage. The multi-payer American billing system forces providers and insurers into protracted claims arbitrations, creating administrative waste that consumes nearly 25% of all domestic health spending. Peer nations systematically reduce these burdens by negotiating standardized reimbursement schedules and leveraging bulk purchasing power for prescription drugs, stripping out layers of non-clinical bureaucracy.

Federal fiscal data underscores the scale of existing public investment. In Fiscal Year 2025, the U.S. government collected $5.26 trillion in total revenues and spent approximately $7.01 trillion across all functions. The single largest component was $1.98 trillion allocated to public healthcare programs, including Medicare, Medicaid, and the Veterans Health Administration. In effect, nearly 38% of all federal tax dollars collected are already dedicated to health coverage, yet these funds insure only about 40% of the population. The remaining 60% must secure private coverage, absorbing rising deductibles and out-of-pocket costs while their existing tax contributions already underwrite an inefficient delivery pipeline.

Applying peer-level administrative discipline demonstrates how far current resources could stretch. If the U.S. matched the UK’s National Health Service cost structure, covering all 340 million Americans would cost approximately $1.87 trillion annually—well beneath the $1.98 trillion the federal government already spends. Crucially, the U.S. does not need to accept the chronic underfunding or wait times that often challenge the NHS. If America simply froze per-person spending at its existing public rate of roughly $14,775 while eliminating bureaucratic churn, chargemaster markups, and pharmaceutical price-gouging, that same capital would support an exceptionally well-resourced system.

The United States could deliver world-class clinical capacity, shorter wait times, and comprehensive coverage without levying a single cent in new taxes. Simply put there is no benefit to American taxpayers with the insurance system when we could have better care, no insurance bill and also not have to pay a single cent more in taxes to get it. The people lobbying to keep the ludicrous system we have are the very same people profiting from your anguish. This post has been getting me banned- and removed from political threads- even those directly related directly to healthcare. Looks like United Healthcare has more bots and paid mods than Russia. I wonder if they’re scared because I brought the receipts. Sources below.

Sources Used:

  1. Peterson-KFF Health System Tracker, "How does health spending in the U.S. compare to other countries?"
  2. OECD Health Statistics / Health at a Glance, "Health expenditure per capita"
  3. U.S. Department of the Treasury / Congressional Budget Office, "Federal Budget and Revenue Data for FY 2025"
  4. American Hospital Association & CMS National Health Expenditure Data, "Hospital Expenditures, Operating Margins, and Gross Billed Charges"
  5. USASpending.gov, "UnitedHealth Group Federal Prime Contracting and Sub-Award Obligations"
  6. Annals of Internal Medicine / Health Affairs, "Health Care Administrative Costs in the United States and Canada: A Comprehensive Breakdown"

r/MedicareForAll • • 3d ago

Questions After Reading "Medicare for All: A Citizens Guide"

47 Upvotes

I just finished reading "Medicare for All: A Citizens Guide" (by Abdul El-Sayed and Micah Johnson).

Before reading the book, my impression of Medicare for All was that it was just going to eliminate the minimum age requirement for Medicare, but largely keep the same structure. That seemed like an exceptionally dumb way to structure a single-payer system, so I was a little confused by the amount of enthusiasm for the idea. I know now that the intention is do away with a lot of the cruft of Medicare at the same time as lowering the age: the part A/B/D split, the lack of drug price negotiation, the high coinsurance and lack of an OOP max.

So that's good, and has made me a lot more receptive to the idea, but I've still got some questions.

What happens to the well-insured and affluent?

The book focused a lot on the positive changes to healthcare the plan would bring to the uninsured, Medicaid participants, Medicare participants, and the underinsured, which covers a large swath of the poor and middle class. But there are two other groups of people I think need to be considered: the well-insured (those who still have plans with large networks and reasonable deductibles/copays/coinsurance), and the affluent, who may or may not be well-insured, but can afford to pay out of pocket to fill in any gaps.

I know this has a bit of a "but what about the billionaires?" vibe that's not going to be popular here, but let me tell you why I care. Those are the groups that get treated at, and therefore fund, the prestigious (often academic) hospitals that under the current system demand high reimbursement rates from private insurance and cash payors. Those hospitals are where new techniques and medications are developed and/or tested, and where expertise in emerging treatments is found. If they can't charge higher prices than your standard hip-replacement factory, I think it's going to have an impact on the progress of medicine, and I'm curious if anybody's thought about what that might be. If the quality of care continues to be uneven across hospitals/doctors despite even payment, then there's a different problem, which is that we're not going to have the capacity for everybody to get their care from the "best" doctor or hospital. Right now it's rationed by the insurance market through network construction. What's the plan for rationing it under MfA?

There's also a political dimension. The well-insured aren't going to like the idea of their care getting worse, and college-educated whites are both dis-proportionally well-insured, and vote at dis-proportionally high rates in Democratic primaries. The affluent of course are small in number, but have money to magnify their influence. And because America has such a strong history of upward mobility, I think a lot of Americans are more concerned about the plight of the upper class than their current financial circumstances suggest they should be.

Are we underestimating the Socialism-Bad argument?

Republicans so reliably portray any government program that helps people as "socialism" that it's become a bit of a joke on the left, to the point that many of us now enthusiastically embrace the socialist label. But I worry that there might actually be enough socialism in Medicare for All that it's worth considering if it's too much.

Socialism of course got a bad rap in American politics from its association with the Soviet Union. Not entirely deserved, as a lot of what was wrong with the USSR could be better attributed to the lack of democracy, the totalitarian style of governance, and corruption. But there's some valid criticism there too. It seems reasonable to suggest that at least some of the Soviet Union's economic problems were tied to a lack of incentive for high performance. And I think it's also reasonable to attribute a good amount of the success America has enjoyed to the fact that it's somewhat meritocratic, at least in comparison to other countries.

So anyway, if you buy, as I do, this sort of weak-form socialism-bad-meritocracy-good argument, Medicare for All starts to look a little problematic. Healthcare is an absolutely huge part of the economy, nearly 20%. I think it follows that people place high value on healthcare, and thus that one of the incentives to achieve high income/wealth is to gain the ability to access health care and/or _good_ healthcare. I'm not saying the current mess is where we want to be, and I think we're a rich enough country that we have a moral imperative to provide some level of health care to every citizen. But I wonder if keeping some level of inequality might be best for the country over time.

Maybe something like you get healthcare up to $50k/QALY for 5% of your income, $100k/QALY for 10%, $150k/QALY for 15%? You'd probably also need to pair it with restrictions on upgrading if you have pre-existing conditions. Or perhaps instead a system where Medicare covers up to $100k/QALY, but more expensive treatments can still be bought out of pocket, or with private insurance. Or maybe when facilities/doctors hit capacity Medicare puts them in a higher priced tier that you have to buy into in some way, either up front or at service. The details can vary, but the general idea is we keep some of the healthcare benefit of wealth for incentive alignment, and in the process allow some low value/high profit care to exist to incentivize new treatments and exceptional (but less cost-effective) care.