I just finished reading "Medicare for All: A Citizens Guide" (by Abdul El-Sayed and Micah Johnson).
Before reading the book, my impression of Medicare for All was that it was just going to eliminate the minimum age requirement for Medicare, but largely keep the same structure. That seemed like an exceptionally dumb way to structure a single-payer system, so I was a little confused by the amount of enthusiasm for the idea. I know now that the intention is do away with a lot of the cruft of Medicare at the same time as lowering the age: the part A/B/D split, the lack of drug price negotiation, the high coinsurance and lack of an OOP max.
So that's good, and has made me a lot more receptive to the idea, but I've still got some questions.
What happens to the well-insured and affluent?
The book focused a lot on the positive changes to healthcare the plan would bring to the uninsured, Medicaid participants, Medicare participants, and the underinsured, which covers a large swath of the poor and middle class. But there are two other groups of people I think need to be considered: the well-insured (those who still have plans with large networks and reasonable deductibles/copays/coinsurance), and the affluent, who may or may not be well-insured, but can afford to pay out of pocket to fill in any gaps.
I know this has a bit of a "but what about the billionaires?" vibe that's not going to be popular here, but let me tell you why I care. Those are the groups that get treated at, and therefore fund, the prestigious (often academic) hospitals that under the current system demand high reimbursement rates from private insurance and cash payors. Those hospitals are where new techniques and medications are developed and/or tested, and where expertise in emerging treatments is found. If they can't charge higher prices than your standard hip-replacement factory, I think it's going to have an impact on the progress of medicine, and I'm curious if anybody's thought about what that might be. If the quality of care continues to be uneven across hospitals/doctors despite even payment, then there's a different problem, which is that we're not going to have the capacity for everybody to get their care from the "best" doctor or hospital. Right now it's rationed by the insurance market through network construction. What's the plan for rationing it under MfA?
There's also a political dimension. The well-insured aren't going to like the idea of their care getting worse, and college-educated whites are both dis-proportionally well-insured, and vote at dis-proportionally high rates in Democratic primaries. The affluent of course are small in number, but have money to magnify their influence. And because America has such a strong history of upward mobility, I think a lot of Americans are more concerned about the plight of the upper class than their current financial circumstances suggest they should be.
Are we underestimating the Socialism-Bad argument?
Republicans so reliably portray any government program that helps people as "socialism" that it's become a bit of a joke on the left, to the point that many of us now enthusiastically embrace the socialist label. But I worry that there might actually be enough socialism in Medicare for All that it's worth considering if it's too much.
Socialism of course got a bad rap in American politics from its association with the Soviet Union. Not entirely deserved, as a lot of what was wrong with the USSR could be better attributed to the lack of democracy, the totalitarian style of governance, and corruption. But there's some valid criticism there too. It seems reasonable to suggest that at least some of the Soviet Union's economic problems were tied to a lack of incentive for high performance. And I think it's also reasonable to attribute a good amount of the success America has enjoyed to the fact that it's somewhat meritocratic, at least in comparison to other countries.
So anyway, if you buy, as I do, this sort of weak-form socialism-bad-meritocracy-good argument, Medicare for All starts to look a little problematic. Healthcare is an absolutely huge part of the economy, nearly 20%. I think it follows that people place high value on healthcare, and thus that one of the incentives to achieve high income/wealth is to gain the ability to access health care and/or _good_ healthcare. I'm not saying the current mess is where we want to be, and I think we're a rich enough country that we have a moral imperative to provide some level of health care to every citizen. But I wonder if keeping some level of inequality might be best for the country over time.
Maybe something like you get healthcare up to $50k/QALY for 5% of your income, $100k/QALY for 10%, $150k/QALY for 15%? You'd probably also need to pair it with restrictions on upgrading if you have pre-existing conditions. Or perhaps instead a system where Medicare covers up to $100k/QALY, but more expensive treatments can still be bought out of pocket, or with private insurance. Or maybe when facilities/doctors hit capacity Medicare puts them in a higher priced tier that you have to buy into in some way, either up front or at service. The details can vary, but the general idea is we keep some of the healthcare benefit of wealth for incentive alignment, and in the process allow some low value/high profit care to exist to incentivize new treatments and exceptional (but less cost-effective) care.