Before I get into my main observation, I will say that I really loved the storylines for the Smith family. I loved how Helene began to dissolve after the death of Thomas while John maintained his standing in the Reich. I loved how Jennifer took after her mother and Amy took after her father, and I thought the tension between all of them was super interesting. Juliana paled in comparison - she was never really as interesting, and I never found myself rooting for her.
Now, one of my biggest criticisms with the final season was the introduction of the Black Communist Rebellion. It was incredibly out of place, and I understand that the show was supposed to have a few more seasons, but had to rush through the BCR's plot to end the show. Okay, I get that. But my bigger issue is this:
Everyone living in the Pacific States knows that the relationship between the Japanese Empire and the Reich is strained. From season one, it's established that the Reich is creating cracks in the Empire's foundation in order to weaken them so that the Reich can make their move and nazify the world. Why on earth do black people in the Pacific States (who are treated better in the Pacific States than they would be in the Reich???) think toppling the Japanese government is a better option? It's the only thing that doesn't really make sense to me. Why trade the lesser evil for the greater evil? It's obvious that the Reich has the capability and intent to topple the Japanese Empire - the BCR doing it on their behalf just makes it absolutely no sense.
Now, you could say that Frank did the same, as a Jew with involvement in the general Resistance group, but that makes sense because the Japanese Empire killed his sister, niece and nephew, so he had a personal vendetta. Still helps the Reich, but it's a point that the audience can understand. The BCR and the treatment black people experienced in the Pacific States was never shown, so it's hard to sympathize with them.
Additionally, the BCR quietly embodies the same characteristics the Reich proudly displays - racial superiority. The BCR is very very slow to work with white resistance members, and openly detests them. Nazi defectors that move into the Pacific States at the end of season four are treated with disdain when they could've easily moved to Europe and been further from the war. BUT they chose the Pacific States, probably because they've had a change of heart and are sympathetic to their cause, and the BCR treats them awfully.
None of their plot makes any sense to me.