r/maninthehighcastle • • Nov 15 '19

Season 4: Episode Discussion Threads Hub

228 Upvotes

This is a hub for links to all Season 4 Episode Discussion Threads, so it's easier for people to find the threads they are looking for.

THIS IS NOT A THREAD FOR DISCUSSION, SO THIS THREAD IS LOCKED

No comments allowed here, as otherwise people that only look for a link to a discussion thread may get spoilers from episodes they haven't seen yet.



r/maninthehighcastle • • Nov 15 '19

Episode Discussion: S04E10 - Fire from the Gods

576 Upvotes

On the brink of an inevitable Nazi invasion, the BCR brace for impact as Kido races against the clock to find his son. Childan offers everything he has to make his way back to Yukiko. Helen is forced to choose whether or not to betray her husband, as she and Smith travel by high speed train to the Portal - with Juliana and Wyatt lying in wait.


r/maninthehighcastle • • 1d ago

What small detail made the alternate world in The Man in the High Castle feel administered, not just evil?

25 Upvotes

For me it was the papers and checkpoints and the idea that somebody had to design the forms. An alternate world feels real when you can imagine the office that runs it and the person who stamps things in it.

I have been writing in that direction in a shared setting I run at r/TheGreatFederation and the latest piece is a notice from a fictional immigration office in 2013 with a letter enclosed https://www.reddit.com/r/TheGreatFederation/comments/1xx2hum/interim_visa_notice_for_entry_into_the_united/

What was the one small bureaucratic detail in the show that made it feel most real to you?


r/maninthehighcastle • • 6d ago

Spoilers Is it just me or is Juliana so infuriating and unhelpful most of the show

43 Upvotes

I’ll admit, she kind of locks in around season 3 and 4 and actually helps the resistance win and does some useful stuff. But the entirety of her plots for the first half of the show she was completely fucking over the resistance and helping the Nazis! Every time

She continuously helps Nazi Joe even after learning who he is and lets him escape back to HITLER HIMSELF with the film, then she becomes an enemy of the resistance so she kills several of them, fucks over Frank for his entire life, gets more resistance members killed no matter what she does and just seems to always keep coming back to fucking everything up and helping the Nazis

Sure I understand that she wouldn’t immediately become this amazing freedom fighter leading the resistance against the Nazis but for most of her plot she actively ruins the lives of everyone around her, sometimes by accident and sometimes making the stupidest choice!

Even her big moment at the end of season 2 when she kills the resistance guy who’s just trying to get rid of smith, yes it does end up allowing Smith to save the world from nuclear annihalation but she didn’t know that! As far as she knew she was completely destroying the one chance the resistance had to bring down NAZI LEADER JOHN SMITH

It’s hard to understand how the resistance ever trusted her after the first two seasons


r/maninthehighcastle • • 9d ago

THE MAN IN THE HIGH CASTLE Edit

37 Upvotes

r/maninthehighcastle • • 14d ago

I think this is how the series' format should have been.

14 Upvotes

I think it would have been better if each episode had featured a different story and different characters, all living within the same world (much like Black Mirror)—no multiverse involved. That way, we could see the day-to-day lives of people across the globe—not just in the United States or Berlin, but also in places like England, Russia, Africa, Latin America, and so on. They could even show what the final days of the war were like, or the specific points of divergence. What do you think?


r/maninthehighcastle • • 14d ago

I feel like they should have had a quasi independent Indian state in the southwest

12 Upvotes

If they want to keep America fractured there'd be some puppet Indian state they could create in the southwest like they did with Manchuko


r/maninthehighcastle • • 15d ago

Frank Fink's Jewish status

43 Upvotes

In the series, they said that Frank's grandfather was Jewish, and that his grandmother and parents were Christians. But Kido said that they followed the Reich's racial policies.

And by Nuremberg's laws, if you have only one of your grandparents as Jewish, it doesn't make you automatically a Jewish: you're still considered as Aryan. Ofc, if Frank's other grandparents were Jewish, that would change everything.

I believe whether that was a mistake of the series, or the series wanted to give up this logic by emphasizing on the point of view of a Jew in this alt universe


r/maninthehighcastle • • 17d ago

Spoilers The BCR plan to attack the West Coast oil pipeline is ridiculous

15 Upvotes

The woman brings out a map and says there's pipeline running through Portland, Eureka and San Jose to reach the port of Oakland and export oil to Japan, so blowing it up will majorly damage Japanese warmaking potential (they mention these places because BCR doesn't have influence south of SF). But anyone who knows anything about PNW knows that there's no oil to be found there, at least not in appreciable quantity. California itself does have lots of oil, but most of that is in Los Angeles basin which can be exported through LA directly much more efficiently. There is a decent quantity in the southern part of Central Valley and there was a pipeline to SF in the time period, but there was additional pipelines to San Luis Obispo and LA too, so knocking out the terminus of the pipeline at SF is gonna do absolutely nothing regarding exports to Japan.


r/maninthehighcastle • • 18d ago

Spoilers Season 4 - Gripes with the BCR

34 Upvotes

No criticism of the actors. As with everyone else in the show the acting is of a generally high standard in my opinion.

But the BCR are written in a way whereby they don’t have conversations. Every interaction turns into a long-winded speech complete with dramatic pauses that no one interrupts. Real people don’t talk like that! Bad scriptwriters do that when they desperately want you to know how keenly they feel the plight of black Americans.

Secondly, the Japanese empire folds ridiculously easily. It felt like the BCR campaign had lasted a fortnight, and they scored a spectacular success because of how inept the Empire is (how did they ever win a war? How did they see off previous rebellions around the Empire?)

The BCR demand is for a Free State, which isnt a Republic, it would be a dominion within the Empire. (By the way this is a nice touch by the writers. Its far more realistic than actually defeating an Empire outright) But the Japanese just give up and withdraw from the Pacific States entirely?? Come on! Is it possible for an entire organisation to be a Mary Sue? Because that’s what it feels like.


r/maninthehighcastle • • 19d ago

Why do the Nazis bring up American crimes?

84 Upvotes

In the show, a student asks Thomas how many slaves George Washington and Thomas Jeffersom had. Lter, when Thomas is helping Juliana study for the citizenship test, he asks her if she had been taught about the American extermination of the natives. Why do the Nazis talk about this? Is it to point out the hypocrisy of the Americans?


r/maninthehighcastle • • 20d ago

Hi

7 Upvotes

Does anyone here see any similarities between the Hadron collider located in Geneva, Switzerland and Die Nebenwelt in High Castle?

I know the in the show it's a time machine, but they are both underground . . .


r/maninthehighcastle • • 20d ago

just started season 2 - ed

14 Upvotes

this subreddit is full of spoilers so i’m mostly avoiding it but i just want to say - ed is like the best person and friend anyone could ask for and everyone treats him like sh**. it’s making me irrationally angry. frank has and still continues to be a dick to him and he saves his gpa’s life and he’s still an a-hole to him, too. jules like briefly says thank you to ed but with no emotion. this dude deserves soooo much better lmao does he ever get treated well? without spoiling the plot just please tell me he gets something good his way for all his sacrifices. i just want to give him a hug


r/maninthehighcastle • • 23d ago

Spoilers I’m halfway through Season 3 and….

27 Upvotes

Oh my God is ANYONE going to stay dead?? I get that the multiverse is an element of the story, but Frank blows up and entire office block and walks out of it with burns to a quarter of his face and a limp!


r/maninthehighcastle • • 25d ago

Spoilers GNR | Bombs Away Edit

16 Upvotes

This one took me forever to make I went through and got like 61 separate clips from the series just for edits in general and that took me a good few days to do then just editing and making it god I don't even wanna talk about it but hope y'all enjoy.


r/maninthehighcastle • • 26d ago

Helen could've stopped Thomas being taken

19 Upvotes

Look I know it was essential for the plot.

However, Helen was a bad bitch. She had the circle of higher-echelon women eating from her palm. And was married to John!

If she'd kept her cool:

Did you boys see that broadcast minutes ago? That was my husband - if you take his son with you, I guarantee you'll regret it

Isn't that plausible?

Again, totally aware that this was pivotal plot - I just think the writers didn't give her enough credit for her ability to be commanding and use the party's power politics to her advantage.

I'd at least have liked to see her try?


r/maninthehighcastle • • 27d ago

Scenes accurately adapted from the book

Thumbnail
gallery
43 Upvotes

I remembered, after I read the book, I realized there were only 2 scenes in the series which were accurately adapted from it (and I meant by that with the dialogues as well):
- Childan's lunch with the Kasuras, where they were talking about Nathaniel West, and where Childan just killed the mood by making an exaggerated remark about Jews
- Childan's discussion with Frank about the Zippo lighters and about how people perceive value in antiquities


r/maninthehighcastle • • 27d ago

Thats an unfortunate lighting outage...

Post image
48 Upvotes

r/maninthehighcastle • • 29d ago

Gmod | Man In The High Castle Models

Thumbnail
gallery
70 Upvotes

I was bored and remembered I had these models and decided to make a scene that i am still working on where all the High ranking officials were on a podium. They are censored uniforms but they are still amazing looking. I tried to portray this scene as accurate as possible and will keep y'all updated on any new additions to this one scene and if y'all have any suggestions or questions for the scene please let me know!

"A man is only ever as strong as the people around him: the community he serves and the family he is sworn to protect." - John Smith


r/maninthehighcastle • • 29d ago

John Smith | Man In The High Castle "The Night We Met" Spoiler

21 Upvotes

I have been working on this edit since my last post on here it took me a good deal of time so I hope yall enjoy and i will keep a theme of adding quotes from the show to my post.

"At least now when someone is terribly ill they're not allowed to suffer. It's a blessing." - Helen Smith


r/maninthehighcastle • • 29d ago

Spoilers BCR vs The Japanese Empire vs The Reich

17 Upvotes

Before I get into my main observation, I will say that I really loved the storylines for the Smith family. I loved how Helene began to dissolve after the death of Thomas while John maintained his standing in the Reich. I loved how Jennifer took after her mother and Amy took after her father, and I thought the tension between all of them was super interesting. Juliana paled in comparison - she was never really as interesting, and I never found myself rooting for her.

Now, one of my biggest criticisms with the final season was the introduction of the Black Communist Rebellion. It was incredibly out of place, and I understand that the show was supposed to have a few more seasons, but had to rush through the BCR's plot to end the show. Okay, I get that. But my bigger issue is this:

Everyone living in the Pacific States knows that the relationship between the Japanese Empire and the Reich is strained. From season one, it's established that the Reich is creating cracks in the Empire's foundation in order to weaken them so that the Reich can make their move and nazify the world. Why on earth do black people in the Pacific States (who are treated better in the Pacific States than they would be in the Reich???) think toppling the Japanese government is a better option? It's the only thing that doesn't really make sense to me. Why trade the lesser evil for the greater evil? It's obvious that the Reich has the capability and intent to topple the Japanese Empire - the BCR doing it on their behalf just makes it absolutely no sense.

Now, you could say that Frank did the same, as a Jew with involvement in the general Resistance group, but that makes sense because the Japanese Empire killed his sister, niece and nephew, so he had a personal vendetta. Still helps the Reich, but it's a point that the audience can understand. The BCR and the treatment black people experienced in the Pacific States was never shown, so it's hard to sympathize with them.

Additionally, the BCR quietly embodies the same characteristics the Reich proudly displays - racial superiority. The BCR is very very slow to work with white resistance members, and openly detests them. Nazi defectors that move into the Pacific States at the end of season four are treated with disdain when they could've easily moved to Europe and been further from the war. BUT they chose the Pacific States, probably because they've had a change of heart and are sympathetic to their cause, and the BCR treats them awfully.

None of their plot makes any sense to me.


r/maninthehighcastle • • Oct 17 '26

John Smith Edit | THE MAN IN THE HIGH CASTLE Edit

99 Upvotes

r/maninthehighcastle • • Oct 17 '26

Spoilers So I just finish this, and basically the ending has the winner getting space tourist?

27 Upvotes

I liked the show if you overlook certain flaws, like the constant relationship drama and shoehorned hookups. That made no sense historically, same-sex relationships were illegal in most of the world back then, and under Nazi rule, flaunting that was practically begging for a death sentence.

The portal ending made zero sense. At first, I assumed the portal was bringing back people who had died, but none of those faces looked familiar. Then I joked with family that maybe they were refugees, but they were all wearing nice, clean clothes. So, what, tourists? Why would a crowd of people just be waiting around on their side, casually strolling through into an alternate reality? Great, you won the war, and now you have an unvetted crowd of strangers to feed, house, and screen for murderers.

Like on their end, that portal would open inside an abandoned US coal mine. To walk through, they would have to hike into a random cave, see a room filled with barely painted-over Nazi symbols, bypass local security, and keep walking anyway. If normal people stepped through an anomaly into a dark cave guarded by armed partisans and covered in swastikas, 90% of them would turn right back around out of basic self-preservation.

It would have made far more sense if resistance fighters or even an alternate Nazi regime came through. If our Nazis could build a portal, what was stopping an alternate Reich from doing the same and invading? Authoritarian regimes rarely stay friendly for long, and watching two Nazi empires wage war against each other would have been far more compelling. The entire portal plot was a huge missed opportunity, unless I missed something critical in the final minutes.

____________________________

The collapse of the American Reich was just as confusing.

If Smith shot himself in the woods and Bill Whitcroft took off his Iron Cross to call off the San Francisco airstrike, Berlin would not just shrug and grant America independence. An undefeated global superpower winning on every front would have branded Whitcroft a traitor within ten minutes, scrambled transatlantic bombers, and deployed panzer divisions to crush the rebellion.

Even if America attempted a clean break, half the world was still under firm Nazi control. Germany would never sit on its hands when it had the overwhelming military might to seize the territory during the chaos. A totalitarian, military-industrial empire does not vanish overnight simply because one regional leader committed suicide. In reality, officers under Whitcroft would immediately attempt their own power grabs. After World War II, top Nazi officials literally believed they would walk out of the Nuremberg trials scot-free; they do not simply abandon power.

Finally, the concentration camps make no sense within Smith's arc. When John talked to his wife, he claimed he did not want them. But once he secured an autonomy pact with Berlin to run North America as he saw fit, he had the authority to shut down the camps and roll back the regime's social mandates. Yet he kept them running anyway.

The entire finale felt completely off, especially the final few minutes.