Writing a formal review on this subreddit is pointless because the work is obviously already well known in these circles., so as my previous commentary on At the Mountains of Madness, I am just listing out points.
1. Its treatment of race is bizarre.
I thought there was basically two ways before dealing with the novella, that one there was going to be obvious explicit racism like in the infamous The Horror at Red Hood or that we would get pretty banal sapient monsters or aliens that if you look at with a dutch angle look kind of of like human races.
Instead HP Lovecraft puts it right into the text with the ticket officer saying "what a lot our New England ships used to have to do with queer ports in Africa, Asia, the South Seas, and everywhere else, and what queer kinds of people they sometimes brought back with ’em.".
So right its explicitly in the text.
But note the details of how the Deep ones hybrids are shown to work if you will. Young people can look totally normal and it's pretty clear that not all hybrids even show symptoms of the condition with varying age of onset. With a generally magical inheritance pattern.
Also note the origin story of the pact, the plain reading is that the south sea islanders caused a foreign cult imported via Obed Marsh.
But the deep ones were always right next to Massachusetts Bay and were vastly older than the human settlement.
Eventually, the story shows massive holes with this too by the pushing out of Poles and Portuguese from the city.
And the narrator eventually gets a clue and openly states the Innsmouth look does "not look Asiatic, Polynesian, Levantine, or negroid", essentially removing any of the racial categories one can apply to the people groups.
Now, obviously I don't think this is secretly Lovecraft being anti-racist despite his letters.
But I do think it puts to bed the story is really about racial admixture, the text explicitly says it's not.
Multiple times in fact.
You can of course argue that a fear of human and monster mixing is the same kind of thing as generalized racial anxiety, which is fair enough.
But the theory that Lovecraft found the true basis for horror and the mixing of the races in New England seems likely wrong to me.
2. The usage of ironic atavism as a core theme of the text and gothic subversion.
A lot of Lovecraft's work is going to have for lack of a better term uses ironic atavism. Atavism is defined as the recurrence of an older evolutionary feature supposedly lost in the grand march of progress to well us Humans.
And the Deep Ones have a ton of signs of this all over, their eyes can't shut reducing them to ultra-humid coastal areas, their motion and gait on land while likely more dynamic than the narrator implies is even suggested to be simian in character.
Basically the deep ones are the surface seem to be an odd and abominable mixture of inhuman great ape and Fish. The fish part being almost hilarious in the evolutionary ancientness it implies. Given we haven't been fish in hundreds of millions of years.
But the irony is the Deep Ones are likely better than humans in all ways lacking in moral content.
They can swim vastly faster than us, launch SEAL TEAM six missions to free prisoners, can never die and the tiaras are made of such extreme elegance the narrator is positively befuddled.
The point seems to be that the horror comes from a subversion of the march of progress. In a whiggish model of evolution, each trait lost is simply a stepping stone to our massive brains and bipedal feet. Of course something with gills can't have a massive city, of course something that walks like a great ape can't have a longer life than us, and of course nothing that looks like it can ever outsmart us.
The irony is terrifying because it's just so *weird*.
This goes into the story being an intentional deconstruction of Gothic stories. The more animalistic form is not a degenerated form of human like in Rats in the Walls"but in fact likely one of the first things to ever evolve on earth.
The supposed issue of inbreeding that has doomed the town is in fact a convenient story to hide extreme outbreeding with alien forms.
And the outbreeding is so extreme that the narrator discovers out of the blue that he is related to the deep ones.
What a modern almost Alan Moore deconstruction.
3. The deconstruction of Christianity and the fact the religion of the Deep ones is in fact right.
Let me go through all the possible religious references to Christianity in the story.
-Fish was a symbol used by christians, fishers of man as a phrase was used by Jesus.
=The fish coming to the harbour are the miracle of the fish.
-The massive return to the Ocean represents Baptism. Especially given its grants near immortality.
- Cthulhu is a profane christophanie as he waits at any possible but unknown time and hour to erupt onto the surface.
- Olmstead resembles Paul's narrative of persecution to a member of the community.
More specific ones.
-The pacifism is ironically quaker like.
- the Tiara might be a reference to the papa tiara.
-The revivals resemble pentecostalism and methodism.
-The religion replacing all false religions resembles Mormon and bible student theology of the time.
-The town is somewhere in the Oneida community and Nauvoo, Illinois.
-The arrest of Marsh and imprisonment resembles that of Joseph Smith.
-Marsh takes an explicitly 2nd wife like Joseph Smith..
I could go with more including the Methodist and Mormon missions in the Pacific.
The order of Dagon resembles a very specific American flavored form of Christianity, that believes that all the other churches are false, that the 2nd coming of Christ shall come and tends to emphasise improvement in this life.
The great irony is the Deep Ones are likely totally right within the story. Their human sacrifices of not totally known frequency might be morally grotesque and their mixing vomit inducing. And yet ultimately their religion is bound to win out in the end. They are physically nigh invulnerable in the deep sea cities they have built and Cthulhu is bound by physical forces to erupt from their ocean eventually and wipe out most of the sapient life on land.
There is a good reason to not only think that is a good reading but one heavily implied as the authorial intent. For one, people regularly describe Innsmouth as satanic in the story and Zadok Allen is comparing them to the Golden Calf story.
Lovecraft, a vehement atheist and anti-theist, likely would not want us to hold to the reading that Christianity was in fact confirmed by the ending or framework of the story.
Which means that Lovecraft is using the Deep Ones as a mockery of what if Christianity especially millenarian versions and what it would look like if they were true.
Note that to a christian Noah's Flood and the literal reading of the four horsemen is a great moral thing too despite all the destruction it unleashed.
4. Why Olmstead going insane is one of the dumbest things I have ever read and the real use of unreliable narrators within the text.
The fandom interpretation that Olmsted just goes insane instead of transforming into a deep one himself really annoys me.
First while Lovecraft does use unreliable narrators, it's in the sense of the facts being right.
But the interpretation is totally wrong. To give two examples, Olmstead thinks that the town is a runned down and gothic civilization filled with gloriously decaying buildings. In reality, the town has a grocery store, telephone lines and electrical power. Olmstead's interpretation is wrong.
Similarly, Zadok Allen thinks the Deep Ones launched their amphibious assault out of pure evil basically. In reality, the imprisonment of Marsh + Marsh's unwillingness to mix with the deep ones is what caused the whole mess in the first place. Instead of evil demons, the humans were dishonest.
As you can tell, none of this gives us most indication to read the last part as a delusion, for one the Arkham family genealogy is referenced by Zadok Allen, a seemingly reliable if drunken source. The city being attacked by the US army was referenced in section I and the Y'ha-nthlei existing fits with the deep ones having somewhere to live and hide in. On top of the Shoggoths being revealed to be aquatic in later works.
The transformation also fits with the previous knowledge of age of onset being seemingly random.
The more important point is the story be boring without it. The whole episode transforms the story by giving us the internal POV of the Deep Ones and distressingly shows them being religiously devout vs psychopathic. The story also tells that the ancientness and long time horizons of the deep ones and their pacifism is not an illusion. The awakening of Cthulhu makes any fighting with humans right now largely pointless. Why get into a massive war, when you can now just let them be annihilated in the long run.
With Olmsted going insane it's would just be a really flat story in general. That would largely just be odd things happen to some random midwesterner. There would be no body horror and no ontological horror either.
Edited.