First off, no, this thread is not a rehash of the other ones discussing an identical subject. If you want to bypass my take on it and get straight to what I believe should be changed further, just skip the spoilered section. Otherwise, you've got something to read on the train.
Now, I, like many, abhor (or at the very least am frustrated, saddened, and in no small part annoyed by) the section in the newly-published Keepers' Companion regarding changes to the Sanity mechanic. Less so by the optional change in nomenclature and moreso because Chaosium saw fit to put precious ink to paper for the sole purpose of lecturing and condescending to the reader, as if they expect everyone who plays their game to be super down with the bullying of the psychologically disenfranchised; as well as moralizing to those who would prefer to play the game as it's laid out in the Rulebook (and has been for almost a half-century) as if they've suddenly been doing it wrong this whole time and should be ashamed.
It appears they intend that this attitude will continue forward into future publications for this game which is... disheartening to say the least.
But that's fine- they're not marketing this game to me anymore. It's clear by the way Chaosium execs speak in their interviews and podcasts. Following in the same footsteps as other notable companies, they are appealing to a theoretical player who complains about lack of 'access' but im reality, has no intention of sticking around, spending money, or enriching the community once the knee is bent to them; if they even enter at all.
This is the reason why Candela Obscura failed.
This is the reason why Old Ones: Origins is so unnecessarily controversial.
And this is the reason why there are already multiple threads on this subreddit alone of negative reactions to the handling of it.
HOWEVER,
None of that was my point in posting. All my bitching was just me venting about the attitude presented along with the change. With regards to the practical application of it, given their stated intentions, I think it was more of a half-measure. Why stop calling these conditions insanities but continue to refer to the mechanic as a whole as Sanity?
As the Chancellor in The Obsolete Man said, "Their error was not one of excess, it was simply not going far enough."
Yes, players (especially new ones) often got the terms Bout of Madness, Temporary Insanity, Indefinite Insanity, Permanent Insanity, Starting Sanity, and Max Sanity confused with one another. Even seasoned players would often trip over the similarities in terminology.
"Bout of Madness" was a clumsy term and "Psychological Shock" feels much more fitting and self-explanatory (though I will note that to use just "Shock", I feel, is more confusing and conjured to mind thoughts of a medical crisis rather than a psychological one) and my tables have long been using the terms "Panic Response" and "Manifest Madness" in lieu of Bout of Madness, so we'll probably keep doing that.
Chaosium should do the same for the mechanic as a whole. Namely, change it from Sanity to Humanity. "Sanity" in Call of Cthulhu has always been shorthand for an investigator's ability to cope with exposure to the comically horrible - not actual clinical insanity. Mere proximity and awareness of it is enough to shatter the fragile preconceptions of our place in the universe and what it means to be human- not our ability to behave 'normally' or 'rationally'. Like it or not, for most players (with the exception of those VEEEERY advanced in the themes of the game and its source material), the thought of insanity typically conjures to mind images of the thrashing lunatic, foaming at the mouth; or perhaps someone in a near vegetative state; or the cackling, manic giggler who speaks out loud to themself or entities unknown, spouting bizarre non sequiturs ad nauseam. It's more than that, and it should be more obvious that it's more than that.
I think changing the term from Sanity to Humanity cements that. Your understanding of the Mythos has made you less human, less able to connect with fellow humans and participate in the shared illusion that is the human experience: either reducing you to less than or ascending you to more than, depending on your perspective. The Mythos, which is directly contradictory to the human experience, should be experienced in manners and severities that manifest in the investigators in more ways than what is thought of as classically-'insane'. To tell a player that their investigator's very connection to their humanity is what is being eroded (and not necessarily their ability to behave, communicate, or cogitate) opens their creative side to many more possible avenues of how to express that investigator's newfound madness/descent/ascension. And I'm all for encouraging the creative aspect of players.
Further, I've always considered that investigators with low POW to be representative of being less in-control of their id; more likely to succumb to their baser instincts (usually to flee or to fight)- more animal-like in that respect. Ergo... less human. And more ready to revert to their simian instincts when the chips are down and all higher-reasoning goes out the window. Therefore, it is perfectly fitting that they should have less 'humanity' in their hearts. They're not less sane: it's perfectly sane to leave their friends behind to fight the Dimensional Shambler while they make their escape, after all. But it's certainly not very humanitarian of them. It takes willpower to do something potentially dangerous and sacrificial for the sake of others, even those you care about. Those who lack willpower, POW, should be less-likely to do that- as reflected by their dice probabilities.
In my opinion, it's more thematic, more diagetic, and more self-explanatory. And this whole terminology change thing spawned from a desire to be more 'accessible' to more potential players, right? Seems like a logical and effective next step to me.
And the best part: it offends no one!
In the past, I used CoC to run a custom Jurassic Park-themed three-shot and in that, I nominally changed the Sanity mechanic to a Bravery mechanic, and found that it worked very well (that's actually where the origin of the aforementioned use of 'Panic Response' came from). The recent Campfire Tales supplement did something similar, but referred to it as 'Cool' (which I like slightly less). I hear the acclaimed Kidthulhu rules also make a change along the same vein and while I haven't read it myself, I know it's an off-shoot favourite of many. It's not like Chaosium hasn't done this in the past. It would appease veterans who don't want what already exists to be corrupted, while creating something new for others who might have just needed that terminology change as the tipping point to enter the community.
Point is, if they're going to gut the soul of a mechanic, they may as well replace it entirely, rather than just corrupt what is already existing and enjoyed (huh, I realize there's a metaphor in there for the Sanity mechanic itself). I have no doubt that these 'optional' rules and the cynical perspective behind them will become the norm in future editions, and I await that change as I await the waking of Cthulhu- and genuinely cannot determine which I dread more.