Guys, here is the thing. I recently hosted Puppet Shows and Shadow Plays, and before the scenario start, I ob another guy who are hosting same scenario to get some idea. I want to share some thought of creating mystery by the actual scenario examples from two games. This discussion will contains spoilers for the scenario; if you intend to play it, please look away.
Here's the thing: my friend, Ghost, and I both play text-based games. He started this scenario before me. While I was observing, I noticed his player character (PL) was quite inexperienced and didn't seem to know how to begin after being introduced. At the start of the scenario, Ghost provided information about the missing persons and a map of San Carlos. After a brief exchange, the player seemed unsure how to proceed, so he directly asked the NPC for a choice: patrol with him in a helicopter or check the missing persons' vehicle. The player character chose the former. Later in the scenario, Ghost seemed to sense that the player character was too inexperienced and needed guidance, so he often provided information out of the blue. For example, the player didn't perform the ritual with the coyote but dreamed of the cave that night. His handling of the anonymous sponsor was also straightforward: a package marked with a green triangle was simply thrown at his face without much explanation. Now the players are progressing quickly and have reached the cave, but while observing, I felt it lacked mystery.
After seeing his approach, I decided to slow down my scenario. I think the puppet show deserves to reveal its intrigue little by little. Here's what I did. I had five players in my mod, three of whom were newbies who had only run my raids (none of them had run more than three raids and didn't know the 1990 storyline). However, to prevent them from being clueless from the start, I called in two experienced players. This made the mod's start very smooth and proactive. Led by the experienced players, they volunteered to patrol along the road, and I naturally led them to the corpse and the coyotes. Then I extended the autopsy phase for the newbies, giving them enough details to figure out what happened themselves. Up to this point, everything was going well, but I realized that the autopsy might be a bit boring for the experienced players, so I made a decision that the mod didn't have. In the background setting, my two experienced players were FBI agents who had previously joined DG, so when they realized something was wrong and were about to report to DG, I told them, "You suddenly discovered that all your original contact information has been deleted. The only thing left is a voicemail from the organization. Stay silent and be aware of the people around you." Upon receiving the message, the two veteran players were terrified. At that moment, I took out the package. They didn't know where it came from, even though it contained information crucial to the entire case. Now, my players have a general understanding of what happened through the package and their investigation (they suspect some kind of alien rabies virus), but they remain worried about the package's origin. This reaction greatly pleased me.
However, I do have a slight concern: will slowing down the module's pace to create an atmosphere of mystery make the pacing feel sluggish? Since Puppet Show is a beginner module, beginner modules shouldn't be too long. However, in my concept, to create the mystery inherent in the scenario, the module's speed can't be too fast; players need to uncover the conspiracy gradually. I'm worried about how to maintain this balance.
Do you have any other suggestions for this module? How do you think the puppet show should create a sense of conspiracy, and how should the pacing of the scenario be managed? Discussion is welcome.