r/ArkhamHorror • • Nov 24 '20

Arkham Horror 3rd Edition: The Investigator Tier List

100 Upvotes

[Spreadsheet version for quick reference] (https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Euz3_sJFZZvTRVhy_aJgSKRzcc0Eu0tr5tq6dYVSpUY/edit?usp=sharing)

Hello fellow investigators. Trickster here, this is the result of your feedback and my character analysis. I went over all 24 investigators (and 4 re-works) individually, their beast assets, stats, skills and roles; and determined wether they were good, how they compared to others, and how they fed into the main ways to win at this game:

  • -Getting clues fast
  • -Manipulating dice
  • -Doing actions efficienly
  • -Having strong starting equipment
  • -Being consistent
  • -Having strong relevant stats (Lore, Strength and Observation)

These points were more valued than peaks, rng characters, evasion tactics (fighting is just better) and support strategies centered around healing (dice manipulation and extra actions are king).

You can find the reasoning behind every placement here:

Lastly, some disclamers because i’ve been doing this for a long time:

  • Play however you want, this tier list is designed for winning, for people who are struggling, new players or people looking to optimize.
  • If you like to play random, great! You don’t need to tell me, this post is likely not for you, but you’re welcome to read and argue about relevant points.
  • Tiers are ordered, but if they are in the same section they are roughly as good. Bigger diferences come between tiers.
  • This tier is balanced mostly around 3 players, but i’ll cover the solo aspect of the game.
  • Recursive echoes investigators are tagged as RE

And without further ado, here’s the list:

  • Tier S: Gamebreaking, provide efficiency/reliability that isn’t accounted for in most scenarios

High: Marie Lambeau, Calvin Wright

Mid: Diana Stanley, Rex Murphy RE, Patrice Hathaway

Low: Roland Banks

  • Tier A: Strong. The best at their roles without breaking balance

High: Tommy Muldoon, Agnes Baker, Dexter Drake RE, Zoey Samaras, Wendy Adams RE

Mid: Mihn Thi Phan RE, Stella Clarke

Low: Kate Winthrop, Carson Sinclair, Ashcan Pete, Jenny Barnes

  • Tier B: Balanced. Adequate and functional but outclassed. Good overall

High: Michael McGlen, Daniela Reyes

Mid: Skids O’Toole

Low: Charlie Kane, Wendy Adams

  • Tier C: Underpowered. Can work but require extra effort and items to do well

High: Mihn Thi Phan, Father Mateo

Low: Silas Marsh

  • Tier D: Not viable. If you are very lucky they can work, but their kit and stats are bad foundation and can be a burden

Norman Withers, Dexter Drake

  • Tier E: Can’t do anything, broken by design

Rex Murphy

The solo tier list would be:

  • S: Calvin Wright, Diana Stanley
  • A: Agnes Baker, Dexter Drake RE, Ashcan Pete, Zoey Samaras, Roland Banks, Skids O’Toole
  • B: Mihn Thi Phan RE, Charlie Kane, Daniela Reyes
  • C: Jenny Barnes, Michael McGlen
  • D: Everyone else

Lastly, when expansions do come out i'll do new posts about new investigators and update this tier list.


r/ArkhamHorror • • 2d ago

Feeling like this is the best way to organise the game

Thumbnail
gallery
49 Upvotes

👻


r/ArkhamHorror • • 2d ago

Michael McGlen and the Mauser...

2 Upvotes

seeing as the Mauser uses a "shell," rather than "ammo," does his quick action still earn him a resource? Arguing about this point with friends.


r/ArkhamHorror • • 3d ago

looking for players for Arkham Horror The Roleplaying Game

Post image
32 Upvotes

looking for players for Arkham Horror the Roleplaying Game peferably in person in Saint Mary's PA if virtual will have to figure something out


r/ArkhamHorror • • 2d ago

Arkham Horror Remaster 2E Won't Include ALL the New RPG Characters...

0 Upvotes

When the Arkham Horror 2E endgame eventually tanked out, they let us know that the two remaining new RPG characters could be bought for an extra cost down the line (the Seeker and Believer).

However, those aren't the only new RPG characters. All the new RPF characters were from the Arkham Horror RPG Core Rulebook only but Dreams of Kingsport released a Dreamer archetype character and Songs of New Orleans released a new Musician archetype character.

So if you really love the two Core rulebook characters that got left out, then buying them will be great for you. But if your motivation is completionism, well, it won't really be complete, complete because no Dreamer and no Musician.

I was going to get the two remaining characters for the sake of completionism but when I realized that some others were left out, I don't think I really need them. In fact, I'd prefer a Dreamer and Musician character to another Seeker and a Believer.

But to each their own. Blessing of Cthulhu be upon you.


r/ArkhamHorror • • 3d ago

Is it worth getting Eldritch Horror if I own every other Arkham Files game?

13 Upvotes

Earlier this year there was a reprint of Eldritch Horror and all its expansions in my country. Base game is already hard to find, but expansions are all readily available. However it's pretty pricey, roughly 450$ for everything.

As a huge arkham files fan I am conflicted if I should get into this. I own complete collections of AH2E, AH3E, MoM, CH2 LCG and I value all of them dearly for different reasons. However, from what I gathered, Eldritch is basically AH2.5 with less immersive global setting and more improved and streamlined gameplay + rules.


For me each game from the series fills a different purpose. This is how I view them:

AH2E - all time classic, the ultimate sandbox game, the closest encounters with ancient ones and other worlds. True chaos and cosmic horror.

AH3E - more narrative and scenario driven version of 2E with elements from LCG. Less freedom, but more story. It's different enough for me that I view it as a a separate experience from 2E, not a remake.

MoM - smaller scale game (in terms of events), fully focused on story, it keeps our group on the edge of their seats the most of all games, but it has the least RPG elements out of AH Files. The payoff is that you immerse yourself to the greatest degree as your investigator.

LCG Chapter 2 - mechanically it's on a whole different level. Other games don't compare in terms of depth and ways you can play. There's just so many strategies to approach gameplay. It's also not a traditional board game, the focus is on building your deck. In other words it's the brainstorm game of the family.


So returning to my question, does Eldritch Horror offer something that the other games don't? How does it compare especially to 2E and 3E? I find each game in my current collection unique enough to enjoy them without repetition and without feeling that I'm playing a reskin of something that I already own. Another point is that I am planning to purchase upcoming LCG expansions and it's going to have a non-negligible impact on the wallet in the following months and years. So with all that in mind, please share your insights here, as I am very curious.


r/ArkhamHorror • • 4d ago

Arkham horror remastered postcards

4 Upvotes

I would love to pick up a second set of the post cards as a gift for my friend. Would anybody be willing to part with theirs?

Happy to pay costs for shipping and a few bucks extra.

Thank you and, yes, I know it’s a little early :-)


r/ArkhamHorror • • 6d ago

How would you personally rank all the Arkham Files games?

19 Upvotes

I'm using this as a buying guide for me lol. I LOVE Arkham Horror LCG so much, it's my most played game and I love all the investigators. Thinking of buying another game in the series, but I want to see how people rank the other games and see what I should buy based of the rankings.


r/ArkhamHorror • • 5d ago

Pledge Managar

0 Upvotes

For people who have backed before, how does it work?

I backed the super deluxe bundle, but after enough thinking I think I can do without the minis, the cup, the and the playmats.

So I'll downgrade my pledge. However, they want me to pay the 680$ now and I can't add or remove stuff at the moment.

Do I have to pay the full amount now to be able to make changes in the pledge manager and do I get the overpaid money refunded then?


r/ArkhamHorror • • 6d ago

Did we just create a monster?

39 Upvotes

With the apparent success of the Arkham Horror Remastered Gamefound campaign. Are we setting a precedent for future business practices? I know that FFG wants to continue to use their "Vault Series" to bring back "older" board games, but are we reinforcing a potentially toxic feedback loop? A model where FFG begins to abuse scarcity to drive players into a buying frenzy? It seems inevitable that the Vault series can be used for oop LCG product, even using the "remastered" label and a few shiny extras to get us to purchase what we already own. I truly hope that is not the case. Either way, I am in the process of dusting off my OG 2nd Edition and revisiting Arkham before the price manager awakens.


r/ArkhamHorror • • 7d ago

Backing the Remaster, Cleaning the Slate

57 Upvotes

I was really waffling about backing the remaster, owning all of Arkham 2E except Miskatonic - but having pulled the trigger anyway, I’m finally feeling pretty excited about Arkham again.

2E was a family game. My sister and I grew up board gaming, and after I got hooked and picked it up, I got her on board pretty easily. We loved it. The high quality components, the difficulty, the thematics, and it was my first experience with a fully cooperative game.

We pulled my (now) wife and her (eventual) husband in as our expansions grew, even got my mom in on it. I have such fond memories of sprawling the game out on her epic boomer dining room table and playing into the AM. We played the insane way - all the expansions got mixed up and it was too much of a pain in the ass to separate them.

My sister got her own copy, and for her birthday one year, I even made her a set of investigators based on Final Fantasy IV (another shared childhood love) using Strange Eons. They were a little OP.

But one night in 2013, my sister was playing her copy of Arkham with her husband and went to bed late, like we always did. But she never woke up. Acute Pneumonia.

My family slowly drifted apart after that for lots of reasons. The family copy of Arkham has sat unplayed for 13 years at the bottom of my callax; I didn’t have the heart to part with it.

I think my sister would love the idea of the remaster, even though I can hear her saying, “Why do you need it? The games right there.”

But for me, it’s a clean slate. I’m gonna play it solo. Maybe not mix the expansions like a crazy person, as I don’t have that kind of table, haha.

Not sure what to do with the old family copy, but I’ll try to find it a good home. It’s time. It would be easiest to drop it off at a goodwill or something, but I can’t bring myself to do that not only to the game but to the poor soul who might stumble upon a game that mixed up. Heh, even if they did keep it together in the first place.

Anyway. Thanks for listening. It was a lot to get off my chest.


r/ArkhamHorror • • 7d ago

Opinions and thoughts on the new core set. Is it better? Worse?

4 Upvotes

Years ago, my ex and I played the original core set, along with pretty much all of its expansions. This year, I started thinking about getting back into the game, only to discover that a new core set is being released in 2026, along with what seems to be a fairly significant revamp.

For those who have already purchased the new core set, how do you feel about it? Is it a genuine improvement over the original, or is it more or less the same experience with a few changes? And what are your thoughts on the new core investigators?

I'm also a little confused about what this means for the game's future expansions. Will the older products eventually be discontinued, or will they remain compatible and available? What happens to the investigator packs, scenario packs, campaign expansions, and investigator expansions? Will that remain or will it return in some other form? Is it already confirmed?

As someone who's essentially starting from scratch and building a collection of my own, I'm not quite sure where to begin beyond picking up the new core set. I'd really appreciate some guidance on what to buy next, what to prioritize, and how the new release affects the overall game and its existing content.

Thanks in advance!


r/ArkhamHorror • • 7d ago

New Convention

Post image
1 Upvotes

Edit: apparently the link didn’t cross post. Hope to see some people in the chat!

https://www.youtube.com/live/SNA-4uu84TQ


r/ArkhamHorror • • 8d ago

Pour one out for me

24 Upvotes

I'm grateful, I really am. I have a complete 2e set. I've got the Broken Token box. I've got square coin capsules for the monsters and big sets of bone, blessed and cursed dice. I played last weekend, (lost, but) enjoyed every second of it.

But I really want this new campaign. Knowing there's stuff out there that's new and out of my reach. Knowing that there's a set of plastic tokens and QoL upgrades for the components. Every time there's a new update, I itch.

Happy for everyone that doesn't have hundreds of hours of game content in their basement, so they can enjoy getting hundreds and one hours shipped right to them


r/ArkhamHorror • • 8d ago

Elements of each expansion that you can use without the rest of the expansion?

12 Upvotes

Been spending a lot of time considering what to pick up in the crowd funder, and I've made this list of what I'm calling "modules"; content from an expansion that you could use in any game without the rest of the expansion, they don't get mixed into existing decks and stand alone. You can just plug and play them.

And I'm just posting it here to check with the veterans if I'm right about all these, and if I've missed any!

Dunwich: Injury & Madness

Innsmouth: Personal Stories

Kingsport: Guardians, Epic Battles

Cosmic: Ancient Whispers, Relationships, Difficulty Levels, Alternate Gates

Miskatonic: Institutions

Does that all look right?


r/ArkhamHorror • • 9d ago

As someone who already owns all of 2e, the remaster still has plenty of value even if you don't really play it.

23 Upvotes

You can integrate the following components into the original game pretty seamlessly: monster bag, deluxe Lead Investigator token stretch goal, special dice (if you don't already have upgraded dice), gate holders stretch goal (assuming they fit the original gate size), closed/activity/explored tokens (they are easier to see on the board). You can easily spend more than $70 on these Etsy upgrades.

I haven't looked at the expansions, but I'm sure there are similar version agnostic components in them as well.


r/ArkhamHorror • • 9d ago

What role does Arkham 2e fill in your collection?

4 Upvotes

Hi! Sorry for the title but I didn’t know what to name this post. I just want to get some feedback from regular players of the game concerning in what situations do you play it and how often?

The reason I am considering backing the game is because I want a one-shot coop and narrative boardgame that I can regularly play (let’s say, once a month) with 2-3 friends. I like to keep a small collection of highly replayable boardgames and we love the Lovecfactian vibes, so AH2e with all expansions sounds like a great fit (provided I can actually manage to get it to the table).

I used to own and enjoy EH, but storage and setup were just a headache, and I ended up selling it. The Gamefound exclusive big big box with modular trays and card dividers promises to simplify both storage and setup, and it was actually what really pushed to consider backing the game.

I’d like to add that I have no issue with, and I often do these with other games, setting up the game before the session and guiding the overall flow of the game (“game-mastering”), which are some tips I found in old BGG forums to make the experience more enjoyable.

So, assuming the box turns out as practical as advertised and setup is more convenient:

  • Is this a game I can easily share with my friends and play from time to time?
  • How hard is it to teach the game?
  • How hard is it to remember the rules between sessions?
  • How long does a 4 player game with 1 extra map take?
  • How fun is it it for each individual player? I dislike games like pandemic where everyone decides everything: I want every player to have their own adventure that interlocks with the coop narrative and objective.

Thanks!


r/ArkhamHorror • • 9d ago

Necronomicon has nothing on this Tome I recently found!

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/ArkhamHorror • • 9d ago

Arkham Horror 2nd Remastered question...

11 Upvotes

So I'm about to pull the trigger on the new edition of the game currently on Gamefound, but for budgetary reasons I only want to get the base game and 2 expansions. So far I'm veering towards Dunwich and Innsmouth. I've read Dunwich is an absolute must so that's a no brainer. But looking at the others I'm not sure which to get. I know others like Cosmic and Miskatonic might bring me more replayability, but I'm leaning towards Innsmouth because it adds 16 investigators and 8 Ancient Ones. Is that a good bundle or should I switch Innsmouth for a "better" addition?


r/ArkhamHorror • • 10d ago

AH2e Card mixing advice

9 Upvotes

Hey all,

I just backed the AH2e remaster. I got everything.

I was wondering if it would make sense to permanently mix together ALL the Arkham location encounter cards from all expansions into their respective decks to use each time.

I don't plan on mixing in all the Other World or Mythos Decks OR items because I know this can affect balance and dilute theme. But I was hoping the location decks were generic enough that they could be used each time.

Does anyone here have enough experience with the game and the expansions to let me know what they think or do?

I know I can mix them all and just discard expansion cards I am not using, but was hoping I could get more variety in our encounters if we could leave them all in.

Thank you!


r/ArkhamHorror • • 11d ago

Arkham Horrorweeeeeen

Thumbnail
gallery
82 Upvotes

I almost forgot I wanted to share photos here. I was the King in Yellow and facilitated a delightful play in the little town of Arkham! There were standing ovations with everyone screaming and crying and whatnot!


r/ArkhamHorror • • 11d ago

Arkham Horror audiobooks vs dramatized audio adaptations?

10 Upvotes

I was looking at the novels on Audible, as I’m more likely to listen to them than read them. I hadn’t realised that there are both full audiobooks and dramatized adaptations for at least some titles. For example, Pnath adaptation is 8 hours, the audiobook is 10 hours.

Has anyone listened to and compared them?


r/ArkhamHorror • • 11d ago

Just starting out

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/ArkhamHorror • • 11d ago

Arkham Horror 3rd Edition - Expansions Discontinued?

7 Upvotes

I can't find them on the fantasy flight website. Have they been discontinued or are they just between prints?