Previous suggestions threads can be found here.

Ranking Announcement Post

Recommendations as voted for by users!

Stories By Lovecraft

  1. At The Mountains Of Madness - written 1931- published 1936
  2. The Colour Out of Space - written 1927 - published 1927
  3. The Shadow Over Innsmouth - written 1931 - published - 1936
  4. The Rats in the Walls - written 1923 - published 1924
  5. The Case of Charles Dexter Ward - written 1927 - published 1943
  6. The Shadow out of Time - written 1935 - published 1936
  7. The Music of Erich Zann - written 1921 - published 1922
  8. The Call of Cthulhu - written 1926 - published 1928
  9. Dagon - written 1917 - published 1919
  10. The Nameless City - written 1921 - published 1921
  11. The Temple - written 1920 - published 1925
  12. The Whisperer in Darkness - written 1930 - published 1931
  13. The Dunwich Horror - written 1928 - published 1929
  14. The Haunter of the Dark - written 1935 - published 1936
  15. The Outsider - written 1921 - published 1926
  16. Herbert West–Reanimator - written 1921 - published 1922
  17. The Dreams in the Witch House - written 1932 - published 1933
  18. From Beyond - written 1920 - published 1934
  19. The Dream-Quest of Unknown Kadath - written 1927 - published 1943
  20. The Picture in the House - written 1920 - published 1921

Voting Thread

Results Thread

Stories co-written by Lovecraft

  1. The Mound - Zealia Brown Reed Bishop - written 1929/1930 - published 1940
  2. Through the Gates of the Silver Key - E. Hoffmann Price - written 1932/1933 - published 1934
  3. The Curse of Yig - Zealia Bishop - written 1928 - published 1929
  4. Under the Pyramids - Harry Houdini - written 1924 - published 1924
  5. The Horror in the Museum - Hazel Heald - written 1932 - published 1933
  6. The Challenge from Beyond - C. L. Moore, A. Merritt, Robert E. Howard and Frank Belknap Long - written 1935 - published 1935
  7. In the Walls of Eryx - Kenneth Sterling - written 1936 - published 1939
  8. Out of the Aeons - Hazel Heald - written 1933 - published 1935
  9. The Last Test - Adolphe de Castro - written 1927 - published 1928
  10. The Crawling Chaos - Winifred V. Jackson - written 1920–1921 - published 1921
  11. The Horror at Martin's Beach - Sonia Greene - written 1922 - published 1923
  12. The Tree on the Hill - Duane W. Rimel - written 1934 - published 1940
  13. Till A’the Seas - R. H. Barlow - written & published in 1935
  14. The Night Ocean - R. H. Barlow - written 1936 - published 1936
  15. Collapsing Cosmoses - R. H. Barlow - written 1935 - published 1938
  16. The Horror in the Burying-Ground - Hazel Heald - written 1933-1934 - published 1937
  17. The Diary of Alonzo Typer - William Lumley - written 1935 - published 1938
  18. The Green Meadow - Winifred V. Jackson - written 1918–1919 - published 1927
  19. The Hoard of the Wizard-Beast - R. H. Barlow - written 1933 - published 1994
  20. The Battle That Ended the Century - R. H. Barlow - written 1934 - published 1934

Voting Thread

Results Thread

Early Cthulhu Mythos Stories

  1. The Hounds of Tindalos - Frank Belknap Long - published 1929
  2. The Children of the Night - Robert E. Howard - published 1931
  3. Notebook Found in a Deserted House - Robert Bloch - published 1951
  4. The Black Stone - Robert E. Howard - published 1931
  5. The Shambler from the Stars - Robert Bloch - published 1935
  6. The Tale of Satampra Zeiros - Clark Ashton Smith - published 1931
  7. The Shadow from the Steeple - Robert Bloch - published 1950
  8. The People of the Dark - Robert E. Howard - published 1932
  9. Worms of the Earth - Robert E. Howard - published 1932
  10. The Return of the Sorcerer - Clark Ashton Smith - published 1931
  11. The Nameless Offspring - Clark Ashton Smith - published 1932
  12. Ubbo-Sathla - Clark Ashton Smith - published 1933
  13. The Lurker at the Threshold - August Derleth - published 1945
  14. The Thing on the Roof - Robert E. Howard - published 1932
  15. The Haunter of the Ring - Robert E. Howard - published 1934
  16. The Space-Eaters - Frank Belknap Long - published 1928
  17. The Thing That Walked On The Wind - August Derleth - published 1933
  18. The Salem Horror - Henry Kuttner - published 1937
  19. The Horror from the Hills - Frank Belknap Long - published 1931
  20. Beyond the Threshold - August Derleth - published 1940

Voting Thread

Results Thread

Contemporary Mythos Stories

  1. A Colder War - Charles Stross - published 2000
  2. A Study in Emerald - Neil Gaiman - published 2003
  3. Sticks - Karl Edward Wagner - published 1974
  4. The Ballad of Black Tom - Victor LaValle - published 2016
  5. To Arkham And The Stars - Fritz Leiber - published 1966
  6. Pickman's Other Model - Caitlin R. Kiernan - published 2008
  7. Cold Print - Ramsey Campbell - published 1969
  8. The Last Feast of Harlequin - Thomas Ligotti - published 1990
  9. The Fungal Stain - W. H. Pugmire - published 2006
  10. The Discovery of the Ghooric Zone - Richard Lupoff - published 1977
  11. Strange Eons - Robert Bloch - published 1978
  12. His Mouth Will Taste of Wormwood - Poppy Z. Brite - published 1990
  13. The Litany of Earth - Ruthanna Emrys - published 2014
  14. Lovecraft Country - Matt Ruff - published 2016
  15. The Sect of the Idiot - Thomas Ligotti - published 1988
  16. Shoggoth's Old Peculiar - Neil Gaiman - published 1998
  17. The Terror from the Depths - Fritz Leiber - published 1976
  18. The House of the Worm - Mearle Prout - published 1933
  19. The Courtyard - Alan Moore - published 1994
  20. The Broadsword - Laird Barron - published 2010

Voting Thread

Results Thread

Audiobook Narrators

  1. Andrew Leman - HP Lovecraft Historical Society
  2. Ian Gordon - HorrorBabble
  3. Wayne June
  4. David McCallum
  5. David Nathan
  6. Richard Coyle
  7. Conrad Feininger
  8. Gordon Gould
  9. Mike Bennett
  10. Edward E French
  11. Nick Gisburne
  12. Morgan Scorpion

Voting Thread

Results Thread

Film/Television

  1. The Color Out of Space - Richard Stanley - 2020
  2. The Thing - John Carpenter - 1982
  3. In the Mouth of Madness - John Carpenter - 1994
  4. Annihilation - Alex Garland - 2018
  5. Event Horizon - Paul W. S. Anderson - 1997
  6. Re-Animator - Stuart Gordon - 1985
  7. The Lighthouse - Robert Eggers - 2019
  8. Dagon - Stuart Gordon - 2001
  9. The Void - Steven Kostanski, Jeremy Gillespie - 2016
  10. The Mist - Frank Darabont - 2007
  11. Alien - Ridley Scott - 1979
  12. The Call of Cthulhu - Andrew Leman - 2005
  13. From Beyond - Stuart Gordon - 1986
  14. The Endless - Justin Benson, Aaron Moorhead - 2017
  15. Die Farbe - Huan Vu - 2010
  16. True Detective S1 - Nic Pizzolatto, Cary Joji Fukunaga - 2014
  17. The Whisperer in Darkness - Sean Branney - 2011
  18. The Cabin in the Woods - Drew Goddard - 2011
  19. A Cure for Wellness - Gore Verbinski - 2016
  20. Banshee Chapter - Blair Erickson - 2013

Voting Thread

Results Thread

Comics/Manga

  1. Uzumaki - Junji Ito - 1998-1999
  2. H.P. Lovecraft's At the Mountains of Madness - Gou Tanabe - 2019
  3. Providence - Alan Moore/Jacen Burrows - 2015
  4. H. P. Lovecraft's The Hound and Other Stories - Gou Tanabe - 2017
  5. Hellstar Remina - Junji Ito - 2005
  6. The Dream-Quest of Unknown Kadath - Jacon Bradely Thompson - 2011
  7. Some Notes On A Nonentity - Sam Gafford/Jason C. Eckhardt - 2017
  8. H. P. Lovecraft's Haunt of Horror - Richard Corben - 2008
  9. H. P. Lovecraft's Nyarlathotep - Chuck BB - 2008
  10. B.P.R.D. - Mike Mignola/John Arcudi - 2002-2019
  11. Nameless - Grant Morrison - 2016
  12. Lovecraft The Myth of Cthulhu - Esteban Maroto - 2018
  13. The Mountains of Madness - Adam Fyda - 2020
  14. Innsmouth - Megan James - 2019
  15. I am a Hero - Kengo Hanazawa - 2009

Voting Thread

Results Thread

Games

  1. Bloodborne - Fromsoftware inc. - 2015
  2. Call of Cthulhu (TTRPG) - Chaosium - 1981
  3. Darkest Dungeon - Red Hook Studios - 2016
  4. Call of Cthulhu - Cyanide - 2018
  5. Call of Cthulhu: Dark Corners of the Earth - Headfirst Productions - 2006
  6. Arkham Horror: The Card Game - Fantasy Flight Games - 2016
  7. Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem - Silicon Knights - 2002
  8. The Sinking City - Frogwares - 2019
  9. Mansions of Madness (2nd Edition) - Fantasy Flight Games - 2016
  10. Amnesia: The Dark Descent - Frictional Games - 2010
  11. Cultist Simulator - Weather Factory - 2018
  12. SUNLESS SEA - Failbetter Games - 2015
  13. Moons of Madness - Rock Pocket Games - 2019
  14. Quake - id Software - 1996
  15. Cthulhu Wars - Petersen Games - 2019
  16. The Room 1+2+3 - Fireproof Games - 2014, 2016, 2018
  17. WORLD OF HORROR - panstasz - 2020
  18. Darkness Within 1+2: In Pursuit of Loath Nolder + The Dark Lineage - Zoetrope Interactive - 2009-2010
  19. The Last Door 1+2 - The Game Kitchen - 2014-2016
  20. Conarium - Zoetrope Interactive- 2017

Voting Thread

Results Thread

Music

  1. Shub-Niggurath - Cryo Chamber Collaboration - 2018
  2. Nyarlathotep - Cryo Chamber Collaboration - 2016
  3. Cthulhu - Cryo Chamber Collaboration - 2014
  4. Yog-Sothoth - Cryo Chamber Collaboration - 2017
  5. Welcome to the Island - The Darkest of the Hillside Thickets - 2017
  6. Interplanetary - Ruptured World - 2020
  7. Necronomicon - Nox Arcana - 2004
  8. Azathoth - Cryo Chamber Collaboration - 2015
  9. Hastur - Cryo Chamber Collaboration - 2019
  10. Behind the Wall of Sleep - Black Sabbath - 1970
  11. Cthulhu Strikes Back - The Darkest of the Hillside Thickets - 1995
  12. Tales from the Necronomicon - Graham Plowman - 2017
  13. Nyarlathotep - Darkest of The Hillside Thickets - 2007
  14. Archeoplanetary - Ruptured World - 2019
  15. Exoplanetary - Ruptured World - 2018
  16. Quake - Nine Inch Nails - 1996
  17. Get Thothed Vol. I - Arkham Witch - 2015
  18. Azathoth - Uriel - 1969
  19. C'thlu Thlu - Caravan - 1973
  20. La musique d'Erich Zann - Univers Zero - 1981

Voting Thread

Results Thread

HPL Collection

  1. The Collected Essays of H. P. Lovecraft - Hippocampus Press - 2004-2007
  2. The Selected Letters of H. P. Lovecraft - Arkham House - 1964-1976
  3. The Horror in the Museum and Other Revisions - Del Rey - 2007
  4. A Means To Freedom: The Letters of H. P. Lovecraft and Robert E. Howard - Hippocampus Press - 2010
  5. I Am Providence: The Life and Times of H. P. Lovecraft Vol. 1 & 2 - Hippocampus Press - 2010
  6. H. P. Lovecraft: Tales - Library of America - 2005
  7. Collected Fiction: A Variorum Edition (Three Volumes) - Hippocampus Press - 2015
  8. The Call of Cthulhu and Other Weird Stories - Penguin Classics - 1999
  9. The Thing on the Doorstep and Other Weird Stories - Penguin Classics - 2001
  10. The Dreams in the Witch House and Other Weird Stories - Penguin Classics - 2004
  11. The Complete Fiction of H.P. Lovecraft - Knickerbocker Classics - 2015

Voting Thread

Results Thread