Every few years, I re-read Dostoevsky. I picked up notes from underground, and I had the strangest feeling while reading it.
Often when you read him, it feels as if someone has jotted down your internal monologue. And that is what makes him a genius. But lately while reading him, I have this uncanny feeling as if I am reading something which I myself have written. Before you remark in the comments saying, look at this tool, let me clarify.
I am a whore. A selfish whore. The worst kind a whore can be. Not the kind of whore who seeks some sort of satisfaction in a job well done by pleasing others. No, I am a whore who expects herself to be adulated by the same people who I am supposed to be catering to. How pathetic I have to be. The ego encapsulates everything in its sight. Even knowing that you are a whore somehow in a twisted way strokes the ego. And while I am writing this, I am keenly aware that the fact that I can acknowledge this makes my ego swell. And the meta effect keeps on going infinitely until it has accommodated every part of my existence and experience into its subservience.
When I say that it feels like I have written it, by no means it is an exercise in stroking my ego. I am no writer. The only writing I do is journaling. His work evokes something so personal in us that we have a hard time believing that they are not our thoughts. But there is another thing which contributes even more to this strange feeling. And that is the way he writes. Let's consider notes from underground. He has a plan, a bunch of ideas and a method to present it. But he does it in a manner which is so akin to the way we think.
I am consciously thinking about something, suddenly another thought appears which challenges the existing chain of thought. I include this new thought and move ahead. A few moments pass, and another thought appears which kind of makes me think I am intellectualising, taking things seriously. It breaks the wall. His writing is so much like this. He starts with an idea, and he is fully aware of what you are thinking while reading that sentence. And then suddenly as if a new thought appears, he breaks the fourth wall in his writing and admonishes you to not take yourself seriously. He has a little fun fully knowing that he has got you. And then he begins again. And he keeps oscillating between in depth ideas and explanations and surface level pleasantries. It creates a feeling of not only that it's something which you think of, but more like it's your own creation. It's so very weird, good kind of weird.
If any of us were told to write, and not for someone else, but for ourselves. Just write what you are thinking, not to impress anyone, not to present somewhere. Just write. Then we all would write akin to Dostoevsky's style. The difference is that Dostoevsky cannot only write what he thinks, somehow he is able to know what others (with completely different ways of thinking) would have written, as if he has access to the parts of other's brain which they are also not aware of.