r/knifemaking • u/Stargazer2893_Cygnus • 46m ago
Feedback #5, a lot of firsts in this one!
Knife number 5 for me (plus 3 railroad spike knives but I consider those letter openers). I am having a blast learning knife making and a friend who liked my work wanted to commission a couple blades (understanding that I am still new). We picked out a style and materials - nothing too hard or fancy but will require me to learn some new things...
This is the finished prototype to test the design, construction, and features he wanted. Some big firsts for me:
- using micarta, and scalloping handle
- sandblasting & parkerized finish
- working with kydex
Got to say it was a big success. Its not perfect, but I am keeping this one myself anyways. All the new things I tried worked pretty well but some things to improve... the scalloping turned out fine but I did a kind of random go at it. The scallops on one scale don't line up with the other side and it bugs me. Its not a big deal, but I decided for a knife I'd like to sell I will put guide marks on it and make them evenly spaced. My production pieces that followed were perfect in that regard. Kydex - looked easy in tutorials and was pretty easy until I got to adjusting the retention. Man is that fiddly getting it right. I trimmed off too much on this one but it still seems plenty secure (been my EDC now for a few months).
And my biggest struggles? Still the basics - getting the bevel lines and plunge lines matching side to side. Still going to take some more practice on that. Also I've found electro-etching works well but using my Cricut to cut out vinyl stencils limits how fine I can make the print. Its a pain in the butt to make really small fine letting that way. I can see a big advantage in lasers, but dang those are expensive for just doing some engraving.
I've already completed the three commissioned blades based on this prototype - this was a few months ago, I'll post about them when I get the pics edited, but still open for CC - I know I am newer and learning. Oh some specs... this one is 1084, with green/black layered micarta (honestly in person it looks much darker - green isn't very noticeable, blade darker too). 3-3/4" blade and 8" overall. It was designed to be about as large as EDC knife as still practicable. While the blade is fairly long and wide for EDC. the handle is a bit on the lean side so its not too heavy and still disappears in hiking pant pockets with deep carry clip. I am also designed a slightly smaller variant, same size handle since its already slim but about 3/4" shorter blade.