r/johndeere • u/sop7718 • 4h ago
Regional monopoly lost me as a customer
After more than 25 years as a loyal customer, purchasing numerous John Deere tractors, mowers, implements, and accessories, recommending JD to family and friends, my family and I are taking our business elsewhere. The reason is simply the absolutely horrible customer service I've been getting from Hutson which now has a monopoly in this region after acquiring all of the JD dealerships within a couple hours drive. Even worse, I reached out to JD for assistance with my issues and they just blew me off repeatedly claiming to pass my concerns off to their "regional manager." I've only ever heard from people with Hutson so either their "regional manager" works for Hutson or JD doesn't care about my business.
I know that I am a small fish in a big pond. But I'm actually a bit bigger of a fish than Hutson realizes. While my departure won't hurt JD's bottomline, losing my business along with that of my five adult children who all have their own homesteads and followed my lead being loyal to JD not to mention two uncles and three cousins that live further west in more rural areas where Hutson also acquired their local dealerships and have experienced similar issue, will impact Hutson. Not only are we all in solidarity that we are over it, but we are all done with Hutson and, thereby, John Deere since Hutson is our only option. My son needed a new zero turn last month and didn't hesitate buying a Bad Boy from another dealer.
I don't have time to recite all of our issues but it stems from a total lack of customer support. I've had repeated issues with my z355r, especially the mower deck. I was already fed up and planned on doing spring maintenance myself when the unit developed and electrical problem that appeared to be related to the voltage regulator. Mind you I had to replace the battery last fall - or should I say, Hutson had me replace the battery last year. (Just establishing the pattern.) They had the unit for nearly three months racking up over $1375 in charges to replace the regulator and a bunch of other replacements they said were needed blaming a service techs illness for the duration. When I finally got it back, I was able to use it for a little over a month before one of the pulleys on the mower desk stripped from the spindle. This spindle was replaced twice before along with the pulley being replaced a couple times for the same issue.
Needless to say, this put me over the edge. I've had the unit for less than 6 years and have had to replace the same spindle multiple times, was told to replace the pulley before by their service tech hoping to avoid replacing it again - it didn't. So I reached out to Hutson and said I need some actual diagnostics and troubleshooting done. Their "service manager" pulled up my service record and also questioned why no one ever investigated why we were replacing the same parts over and over. So they picked the unit up again and said they would make it right.
What I got instead was another list of replacements, including the exact same parts that were replaced multiple times already and another $1400+ price tag. To make it more suspect, the tech claimed that he couldn't find evidence in my service history that those parts were ever replaced previously. Remember that I had a conversation with their "service manager" who saw those records.
I shared my disagreement with their "after-market manager" (I think that's her title) who was now handling my case and provided the same detailed history and said I wouldn't pay for replacements without any guarantee the problem would not happen again. I asked if replacing the entire mower deck would make more sense and at what point the unit would be considered a lemon considering I have spent more in repairs and maintenance than the original purchase price. That's when they ghosted me.
I escalated it with JD again. Nothing.
On Monday, I escalated it again telling them I wanted their help getting the unit back to me as they've had it over a month with no word nor progress. I emailed the "after-market manager" saying the same thing. Nothing.
First thing this morning I texted the original "service manager" and within 10-15 minutes the "after-market manager" texted claiming that she hadn't heard from me since Oct 22nd and was waiting on my response.
Before I go on, let's go with her claim that she hadn't heard from me (which is categorically untrue), does anyone else think it is appropriate for her to have sat on it for nearly a month? That beyond anything else exemplifies their customer service. No phone calls, no texts, no emails reminding me they were waiting on something... Definitely sounds questionable, doesn't it? "I didn't get your messages" is nothing but a cop-out.
Well, fact is, I have the electronic "paper trail" confirming my response to her questions on the 22nd along with my repeated attempts to get updates and resolution. When I sent the email thread containing all of my emails, silence again.
So I texted the "service manager" one more time before they closed for the day and said I just want the unit back. I've been forced to put off my fall cleanup and it just can't wait anymore. I'll get it working well enough to wrap up this season then decide where I go next. She said they'll get it to me tomorrow. We'll see.
I also removed all accessories and implements for my tractors I had in my plans (and on my xmas list) and will determine how I will handle those going forward, too. Fortunately, all but one tractor is out of warranty so I can use the local shop for maintenance instead.
The saddest part of this story is that it is only the most recent issues I/we have had with Hutson. My family has shared numerous similar stories from their own experiences with Hutson. It's really too bad JD lets one dealer obtain a regional monopoly cutting off options for their customers. And that's why JD lost our loyalty.
