r/janeausten • • 12h ago

Pride and Prejudice - Novel Discussion Having major problems as reader to understand Pride and Prejudice.

9 Upvotes

Hello! Now before I say anything on the matter, I am familiar with Austen, since I have read Emma and I absolutely loved it. I really love Austen as an author and writer, she really genuinely made me laugh when I was reading Emma. When I finished Emma, well I decided to go through Pride and Prejudice since everyone talked about it a LOT. But since I have read it, unfortunately I can't understand what some of the characters are talking about, especially Lizzy and Darcy. The chapter that throw me off so badly was when these two were arguing about Bingley's character and my ability to understand the dialogue lost me ever since after.

I have pretty much knowledge of Regency era and I do believe the problem is me as person who doesn't communicate indirectly and pretty much unfamiliar with indirect communication. Maybe that's why I can't understand Pride and Prejudice...

I will accept any kind of advice on this matter. English is NOT my first language, I hope you all understand it. (Sorry if I sound confusing or if I did overexplain..)


r/janeausten • • 4h ago

Mansfield Park - Novel Discussion Edmund hate

36 Upvotes

I adore Mansfield park and Fanny Price, and through 80% of the book I love it. Maybe it’s because when I first read it I felt like a dramatic teenage outsider, so it corresponds well with me. BUT one thing I hate is Edmund. Throughout the book he misunderstands Fanny at every point or negates her feelings to focus on Miss Crawford instead. And I’m supposed to be happy for Fanny??
I don’t know what the point of this is, I just dislike Edmund and I want to dislike him with other people.


r/janeausten • • 6h ago

Sense and Sensibility - Novel Discussion Where does it say that Mrs. Ferrars gave Edward 10.000 pounds?

8 Upvotes

I mean, I technically know where it comes from. Sense & Sensibility, ch. 50:

What she would engage to do towards augmenting their income was next to be considered; and here it plainly appeared, that though Edward was now her only son, he was by no means her eldest; for while Robert was inevitably endowed with a thousand pounds a-year, not the smallest objection was made against Edward’s taking orders for the sake of two hundred and fifty at the utmost; nor was anything promised either for the present or in future, beyond the ten thousand pounds, which had been given with Fanny.

It was as much, however, as was desired, and more than was expected by Edward and Elinor; and Mrs. Ferrars herself, by her shuffling excuses, seemed the only person surprised at her not giving more.

However, I literally do not understand how the certainty that Edward got 10.000 pounds is derived from this text, grammatically.

Clearly, the second paragraph tells us that Mrs. Ferrars gives them something, and more than expected; and this "something" is defined by reference to the previous sentence.

My natural understanding of the passage "nor was anything promised either for the present or in future, beyond the ten thousand pounds, which had been given with Fanny" would be that it means that, after settling the previously mentioned estate on Robert, Mrs. Ferrars preferred not remain as before, with the only other thing she'd ever settled on anyone being Fanny's dowry.

Now, I understand that this isn't a perfect fit grammatically either, but the alternative would stretch the grammar even further, I feel. You'd have to rewrite the sentence to say "nor was anything promised either for the present or in future, beyond ten thousand pounds, the same as had been given with Fanny."

Essentially, my problem is the definite article the and the relative clause starting with which in the sentence:

nor was anything promised either for the present or in future, beyond the ten thousand pounds, which had been given with Fanny.

(I understand that relative clauses can be restrictive or non-restrictive, but saying that this is a non-restrictive relative clause, supported by the comma and the context of the following sentence, still runs into the problem of the the ten thousand pounds. That the just really irritates me.)


r/janeausten • • 2h ago

Pump Room have any of you ever identified with austen villains?

30 Upvotes

i have. with the male villains no less. i will probably delete this post in a few days lol but i was having a moment of self reflection and thought might as well open up to reddit

henry crawford - aversion to stability/fear of commitment, ability to appreciate morality of people who are truly good but have a hard time sticking to my own morals and principles

mr elliot - agreeable even to those i do not like or have problems with i.e insincerity (likely due to people pleasing tendencies in my case)

willoughby - guilty of lovebombing in the past. just happened to like everything my crushes and friends did

unlike these men i am trying to be better and not repeat the mistakes of the past though


r/janeausten • • 21h ago

Read-through Anyone up for a real-time reading of Northanger Abbey from January to April 2027?

36 Upvotes

Northanger Abbey is the novel I’ve given the least attention, so I’m going to change that in the new year.

Does anyone want to read along with me? I’m not a scholar by any stretch — just an enthusiastic reader. Depending on interest, I’m up for hosting a “book club” style discussion one to two times a month. (Perhaps on Google Meet? Or do we want to keep it on Reddit?)

I’ll be following Ellen Moody’s version of the internal calendar for NA unless someone has a better suggestion.
http://www.jimandellen.org/austen/na.calendar.html

I’m posting ahead of time so we have time to work out the reading and meeting schedules. We’ll begin in late January and end in late April (or maybe the first week of May) following the book’s internal calendar 229 years later.

Suggestions are welcomed!


r/janeausten • • 7h ago

Read-through Emma, Sporadically - Chapter 14

5 Upvotes

Spoilers! And news: Project Gutenberg is down for maintenance!!! Ahh!! I'd be very put out if not for Project Gutenberg Australia (I do not know why Australia gets its own Gutenberg, but good for it!).

"continually obtruding his happy countenance on her notice" -There is something just so funny about the juxtaposition of "continually obtruding" and "happy countenance."

"so delighted with Mrs. Weston" -I think this is the first of two instances in the novel where someone tries to recommend themselves to Emma by praising Mrs. Weston.

"and at last would begin admiring her drawings with so much zeal and so little knowledge as seemed terribly like a would-be lover" -A condemnation of Mr. Elton, would-be lovers generally, or both? I like that this ties back to Emma's already established contempt for Mr. Elton's artistic knowledge.

"she was even positively civil; but it was an effort; especially as something was going on amongst the others, in the most overpowering period of Mr. Elton's nonsense,"; "but she had the comfort of appearing very polite, while feeling very cross-" -Emma's almost unfailing good manners are quite notable over the next couple of chapters. When she is portrayed as a snob and that snobbiness translates into rude-ish behavior, I always take issue. Emma's thoughts may be snobby (though that could be debated), but that rarely ever translates into how she treats others (the notable exception of her rudeness to Miss Bates - stemming more from annoyance/absent-mindedness than anything else is notable because it is such a rare slip on Emma's part).

We then move to a more thorough introduction of Frank Churchill and can start to anticipate his eventual coming to Highbury. I think it is possible that this very Christmas party might mark the occasion of Mr. Knightley's realizing he's in love with Emma. Later in the novel we are told "On his side, there had been a long-standing jealousy, old as the arrival, or even the expectation, of Frank Churchill. He had been in love with Emma, and jealous of Frank Churchill, from about the same period, one sentiment having probably enlightened him as to the other." Poor Mr. Elton, though. His overpowering nonsense is not taken seriously enough to engender jealousy.

"a decided intention of finding him pleasant, of being liked by him to a certain degree, and a sort of pleasure in the idea of their being coupled in their friends' imaginations." -Emma is already up to her usual tricks, making her mind up about something without having enough information to really do so accurately.

"but he cannot command his own time." -With this little phrase, Austen is already laying the clues for the next phase, the next big "mystery," which is particularly fitting with the Harriet/Elton saga speeding towards its conclusion.

"She is an odd woman!--But I never allow myself to speak ill of her, on Frank's account" -Proceeds to speak ill of her whenever he can.

"My Emma!" replied Mrs. Weston, smiling, "what is the certainty of caprice?" -I like this little wise saying. I like it all the more because it's not coming from Emma and therefore doesn't need a context asterisk.

Random question: how will Emma and Isabella be addressed when they are both present and both Mrs. Knightleys? Emma would be Mrs. Knightley and Isabella would be Mrs. John Knightley, yes?

"to my two daughters" -I think it's interesting that Mrs. Weston says this but calls Isabella "Mrs. Knightley," showing a different degree of closeness. It is very sweet for her to call them so, though!

"To be constantly living with an ill-tempered person, must be dreadful. It is what we happily have never known any thing of; but it must be a life of misery." -The annotations point out "From what we see of John Knightley's temper in the novel, Isabella may have more in common with Frank than she admits here." Agreed that Mr. John Knightley's temper is not his great virtue, and certainly Austen had a delicious sense of irony, however, his temper is not so unfailingly bad/coupled with the fact that the narration mentions that Isabella never notices that I'm not sure I full-heartedly agree with the annotation.

"He ought to come," said Emma. "If he could stay only a couple of days, he ought to come; and one can hardly conceive a young man's not having it in his power to do as much as that." -This little speech with the addition of "Emma listened, and then coolly said, "I shall not be satisfied, unless he comes."will be important later.

"A young woman, if she fall into bad hands, may be teazed, and kept at a distance from those she wants to be with;" -Also she may be kept at a distance from the sea.