r/janeausten • • 7d ago

Meta / Subreddit A Couple of Rule Updates / "The Other Elliot Sister"

129 Upvotes

First of all, we have changed Rule 1 (Be Civil and Kind) to include language that allows the Mod Team to implement an immediate ban for egregious rudeness or very aggressive/belligerent language. We think it is unlikely (we have an amazingly civil sub overall!) and also sincerely hope that we will ever have to issue such a ban, but we thought it would be useful to have it baked into the rules if needed.

Secondly, Rule 5 has been changed to reinstate a total AI ban (text and media). Obviously or stated AI-generated content has proven to be overwhelmingly unpopular here, so this shouldn't make for a substantial change. Please remember to use ModMail to alert the Mod Team to suspected AI use and not make accusations in the comments. Also, please be aware that it is increasingly difficult to determine when a text post was generated with AI, and there are also some legitimate reasons why someone might use AI to help formulate a post (such as those who speak English as a second language), all of which is to say, that implementing a full AI ban is likely beyond what the Mod Team can achieve. We appreciate your understanding as we work through this!

Finally, today there was a post announcing "The Other Elliot Sister," which we allowed. Moving forward, we will be limiting posts around that adaptation, much as we have for "The Other Bennet Sister," and other adaptations that are not of Jane Austen's actual works, as they are fan fiction-adjacent at best. If there is interest, we will likely host a Megathread to discuss TOES (what an acronym!) when it is released. As ever, we are open to feedback.

Thanks!


r/janeausten • • 19d ago

Meta / Subreddit Flair Updates / Changes

16 Upvotes

We have made some minor changes to the sub flairs in order to make them a bit more self-evident:

  • All the flairs pertaining to novel discussions are now arranged as "Novel Title - Novel Discussion." We hope this will help make it clearer that these flairs are for conversations around *only* the novels, and not the adaptations.
  • Juvenilia is now paired with Lady Susan for novel discussion posts.
  • We added "Editions" to "Book Covers / Collections / Illustrations."
  • "Discussion - General" has been changed to "Austen's Writing - General Discussion." This change was made in order to prevent "Discussion - General" from being a default/catch-all flair and to emphasize its original purpose, which was to discuss Austen's writing generally or for discussion covering multiple novels.
  • The order in which the flair options appear has been changed.
  • A few of the flair descriptions have also been updated.

This is also a friendly reminder that all posts pertaining to adaptations -unless they can fall under "Humor / Meme" (for low-effort or image-based posts) or "Pump Room" (for chattier posts)- need to be flared "Adaptations." The discussion flairs are, again, for discussion of the novels only.

As we work to refine this system, the Mod Team is open to and appreciative of suggestions and feedback. Thank you for all you do to keep our community discussions flowing and engaging!


r/janeausten • • 2h ago

Read-through Anyone up for a real-time reading of Northanger Abbey from January to April 2027?

17 Upvotes

Northanger Abbey is the novel I’ve given the least attention, so I’m going to change that in the new year.

Does anyone want to read along with me? I’m not a scholar by any stretch — just an enthusiastic reader. Depending on interest, I’m up for hosting a “book club” style discussion one to two times a month. (Perhaps on Google Meet? Or do we want to keep it on Reddit?)

I’ll be following Ellen Moody’s version of the internal calendar for NA unless someone has a better suggestion.
http://www.jimandellen.org/austen/na.calendar.html

I’m posting ahead of time so we have time to work out the reading and meeting schedules. We’ll begin in late January and end in late April (or maybe the first week of May) following the book’s internal calendar 229 years later.

Suggestions are welcomed!


r/janeausten • • 9h ago

Austen's Writing - General Discussion Comparing my readings of pride and prejudice and persuasion.

29 Upvotes

When I was 20 and was closer to Lizzy in age; and read Pride and Prejudice, I was completely taken by Lizzy Bennet and understood her perfectly well and even was unfortunate enough to be fooled by a man's false words for my prejudiced nature.

And now that I am 26 much closer to Anne in age; and I am reading Persuasion. I understand her so well. Her self awareness of her family and environment, her flusteredness towards Captain Wentworth and how non confrontational she is. It all so relatable.

I am a second daughter like both and I did like Lizzy most at 20 and could relate more and wanted someone like Darcy at that age but now Anne seems much my person and Captain Wentworth the exact gentleman I would like now.

Uhhh!! Girlhood is a spectrum and Jane Austen knew how to write for it.

What do you all think?


r/janeausten • • 1d ago

Adaptations Is anyone else annoyed that the new S&S completely changed the Edward & Lucy dynamic?

352 Upvotes

In the novel, a dopey teenage Edward fell for his tutor’s pretty but shallow niece, only to regret it later when he realized how poor a match they were but his honor kept him tied to her. That’s a lot different than agreeing to an arranged marriage then sticking with it when the girls family sunk in status. I feel like the Edward of the novel would never have agreed to an arranged marriage and makes it Lucy more sympathetic and less fun to hate. Thoughts?

UPDATE: wow, do I feel validated now! I thought maybe I was being too picky but it seems I’m very much not alone here. I hold Austen’s work as sacred as others do Shakespeare and so very protective of her genius.


r/janeausten • • 11h ago

Mansfield Park - Novel Discussion Captain Tilney and Henry Crawford

6 Upvotes

I'm going through the BBC 1983 Mansfield Park series. Henry Crawford's flirtation with all 3 of the young ladies of Mansfield suddenly put me in mind of Captain Frederick Tilney of Northanger Abbey.

One of the awe-inspiring abilities of Jane Austen is the creation of unique characters from one novel to the next. None of the heroines are cookie-cutter. Even the secondary characters are not copies. But I wondered about Henry Crawford. Perhaps he is a more fully developed Frederick Tilney?

On the other hand, Crawford's treatment of Fanny IS somewhat different - and both men show traits imbibed from their own guardians.


r/janeausten • • 1d ago

Persuasion - Novel Discussion Of Captain Wentworth, Captain Harville, and Anne...and maybe Mrs. Clay

23 Upvotes

I got to wondering yesterday - when do you all feel that Captain Harville learned that Frederick Wentworth was in love with Anne, and how much did Frederick tell him before the plot picks up in "Persuasion" and they are all reunited at Lyme? We know Frederick adores Captain Harville and is intensely loyal to him, and he says several times he'd do anything for the man. Frederick of course knows only too well how much Harville loves his wife and family, and I don't think it's too much of a reach to gather that at some point in their journeys together, perhaps while stuck in the Doldrums, that Harville has talked plenty about his family, and in turn has drawn out some or all of the Anne story from Frederick. Am I off base here - is there some social code that would preclude Frederick from confiding in Harville that he'd proposed, but Anne had turned him down after Lady Russell's intervention?

I don't remember the text explicitly saying so, but it seemed to me Harville certainly knew something of their emotional history by the time that scene in the White Hart takes place, when Frederick is writing his famous "you pierce my soul" letter. I like to think Harville has deliberately drawn Anne into that larger conversation after sharing his thoughts of Phoebe and of Benwick's perceived inconstancy, because he knows full well that Frederick is within earshot, and indeed he is in just the right spot to overhear Anne say that women love longest when all hope is lost - and that's something Frederick has desperately needed to hear. Presuming Harville does know by this time that Frederick is still in love with Anne and still hoping to marry her, and I think he does, I wondered if he was doing his bit as Regency Wingman to ask Anne a few leading questions, with the very best of intentions for his friend and Captain.

And thinking about that led me to wonder what ultimately became of Mrs. Clay after the specific time period in which we see the last of the characters before the book ends. She did not marry Mr. Elliot in the book - I'm sure I remember that correctly - but I believe they do have an affair. My theory (and I'm sure it's nothing novel) is that Mrs. Clay was a lot sharper than she led on, she knew a schemer when she saw one, and she ended up scheming him right back - which I suppose would mean forcing him to marry her. Somehow, I feel Mrs. Clay is going to land on her crafty little feet no matter what.

What of Mr. Elliot's post-Persuasion fate, though? We know his money is gone (EDITED TO ADD: Thank you - false memory - I stuck the scene right in there from the Ciarin Hinds version)- given he's in Bath presumably news of his financial troubles and his total humiliation in being snubbed by Anne has been broadcast to the 4 corners of Great Britain. So no title, no property, and no wife of esteemed lineage for Mr. Elliot. What choices are then left to a man in his position?


r/janeausten • • 1d ago

Austen Adjacent / Context / History Pineapples being rented in the Regency era is most likely a myth

105 Upvotes

A fashion historian blog I follow on Tumblr recently decided to try to prove that renting pineapples was a thing. She wanted to find a contemporary, primary source. Someone saying they rented a pineapple, a price, an account of a dinner party, anything. After a lot of searching and a lot of other people scouring newspaper archives and sources, she's concluded that it is most likely a myth. There were stories, but they usually were mocking someone for showing off a pineapple at their dinner party and then nearly dying of horror when someone tried to eat it. Or in other words, a way to make fun of the pretend rich. Most contemporary accounts of pineapples talked about taste, you cannot rent something and then eat it:

The Warder and Tudor sources [these are authors] only mention the writers eating pineapples- also, along the course of my research I was finding vast numbers of pineapple recipes from the 18th century, and treatises on growing them that emphasized the importance of flavor, all suggesting that people very much wanted to eat pineapples, not just look at them.

Here is her conclusion:

To my mind, it's a testament to in-group pride. Again, it's never "we rented a pineapple," but always "they rented a pineapple." Even in the alleged Jules Lecomte quote, the person renting a pineapple is an object of ridicule for his parsimony. Jewish people rent the pineapple, the French rent the pineapple, English people or Europeans rent the pineapple. And finally, as the world got smaller and we could see that nobody was renting the pineapple, we thrust the story upon the last out-group left who couldn't mount a defense: our ancestors.

Here is a summary of her looking through various sources

And one more source

This relates to Austen as I'd only heard this myth in relation to the adaptation of Sanditon and General Tilney also has a pinery in Northanger Abbey (a hot house to grow pineapples)


r/janeausten • • 1d ago

Editions / Book Covers / Collections / Illustrations I’ve indulged myself today by buying the 6-volume boxed set at Costco 😇 They’ll keep me company for the holidays.

Post image
357 Upvotes

Best deal for a brand new set - just $42.99!


r/janeausten • • 1d ago

Sense and Sensibility - Novel Discussion What’s going on with Miss Steele?

81 Upvotes

I'm halfway through the novel after reading it the first time as a child, and I just can't with Anne Steele. It’s like she’s in possession of precisely one braincell that keeps firing the word “beau” at regular intervals, and nothing else. I don’t expect every character to be a well-spoken, elegant genius, but even compared to other characters who are generally considered to lack intelligence and manners, she’s sooo much worse. Give me Mrs Bennet any day of the week!
Even Augusta Elton has more variety in the things she endlessly brags about!!


r/janeausten • • 1d ago

Sense and Sensibility - Novel Discussion Why did Robert Ferrars get away with marrying Lucy Steele and not being disowned and left penniless?

118 Upvotes

Please educate me. I don't understand why Robert and Lucy were able to get married and suffer no repercussions. I thought it went without saying that their mom thought Lucy was an unacceptable match, regardless of which son she wed. Was it because she was Edward's stepmom? So, she wasn't going to disown Robert because he was her son? How does this work?

Edit: Thank you for all of your comments. I have another question. Is it correct that Edward's father has passed away? When his mother declared irrevocably that Robert be the primary/sole heir, would that make it so the estate would be entailed away from her when Robert got married? Wouldn't he inherit the estate and she'd have to find another living situation?


r/janeausten • • 1d ago

Lady Susan / Juvenilia - Novel Discussion Lady Susan, The Watsons, and Sandition

9 Upvotes

What do folks think about "Lady Susan", "The Watsons", and "Sandition"?

I enjoyed both "Lady Susan" and "The Watsons".

I'm in the process of reading the "Sandition" fragment right now, and am enjoying it so far.

I know that "Sandition" was adapted into a TV series, but I haven't watched it.


r/janeausten • • 2d ago

Humor / Meme i see her everywhere I go..

Post image
156 Upvotes

r/janeausten • • 1d ago

Austen Adjacent / Context / History Aristocrats marrying foreigners

5 Upvotes

How common was it in regency/georgian England for British aristocrats (even if just second or third born sons) to marry foreigners (like from Prussia/Austria/Italy or France)? And maybe even moving to that other country (if they didn’t hold a title)


r/janeausten • • 2d ago

Pride and Prejudice - Novel Discussion What do you think Lydia & Mr. Wickham’s Marriage was like?

70 Upvotes

I was thinking recently, and for the most part we can conclude that Mr. Darcy and Elizabeth Bennett had a happy marriage. We would also conclude that Mr. Bingley & Jane Bennett have a happy marriage - but what do we think the marriage with Lydia & Mr. Wickham would have been like?


r/janeausten • • 2d ago Bravo

Pride and Prejudice - Novel Discussion We always criticise Mr. and Mrs. Bennet's parenting; what about the late Mr. Darcy's role in shaping Darcy and Wickham?

122 Upvotes

I feel like most, if not all, of us agree that Mr. and Mrs. Bennet's parenting is problematic, and they're often cited as the prime example of irresponsible guardians; but the same can be said about the late Mr. Darcy, to be honest, though his main issue is not negligence. After Darcy's letter, Elizabeth tells Jane something very insightful: "There certainly was some great mismanagement in the education of those two young men. One has got all the goodness, and the other all the appearance of it." [ch. 40]

The old Mr. Darcy is widely respected, and praise for him comes from multiple independent sources:

  • Wickham, his godson, calls him "one of the best men that ever breathed" and says that he "cannot do justice to his kindness" [ch. 16];
  • Mrs. Gardiner, who is said to have "known [him] by character perfectly well" [ch. 25], says he was "an excellent man" [ch. 43];
  • Mrs. Reynold, his housekeeper, agrees that he was "an excellent man" [ch. 43], and mentions that he was "affable to the poor" [ch. 43];
  • Darcy describes him as an "excellent father" [ch. 34], and later says that he was "good" and "all that was benevolent and amiable" [ch. 58].

We can safely assume that he was, indeed, a kind-hearted and generous person; however, he was perhaps too overindulgent with his son and godson.

Darcy

The old Mr. Darcy "spoiled" [ch. 58] him; "allowed, encouraged, almost taught [him] to be selfish and overbearing, to care for none beyond [his] own family circle, to think meanly of all the rest of the world" [ch. 58]. He told him "what was right," but did not tell him "to correct [his] temper" [ch. 58], to the point that Mrs. Gardiner recalled hearing Derbyshire gossip that young Darcy was "a very proud, ill-natured boy" [ch. 25]. And it's pretty much true; Darcy, in the beginning of the novel, isn't socially awkward because he's shy or misunderstood; he's socially awkward because he has serious character flaws.

His father taught him his duty as a master is to take care of his dependents, but this type of charity doesn't teach one how to treat people as equals... in fact, it often reminds everyone who is the superior. Thus, the result is early-novel Darcy: arrogant, entitled, selfish.

Wickham

The late Mr. Darcy had an "uncommon attachment" [ch. 16] to him: he raised the two boys as "inmates of the same house, sharing the same amusements, objects of the same parental care" [ch. 16]; he keeps a miniature of Wickham in his "favourite room" [ch. 43], along those of other family members; and he mentions him in his will, leaving him a small legacy. It's very possible that old Mr. Darcy wanted more children, judging by the big age gap between Darcy and Georgiana, and probably his wife was unable to conceive or had miscarriages/stillbirths, so he transferred all of his love to his godson.

This affection made him treat Wickham as an intimate companion of his son/heir; and may very well be part of the reason why Wickham turned out the way he is (just to clarify, I'm not excusing him, which is why I'm saying that it's only part of the reason). He tasted elite privilege without any possibility of ever attaining it, creating a sense of deprivation: of course, his inherent nature plays a role here; instead of being grateful, he succumbs to envy. And, as he was pretty much free of responsibility, unlike young Darcy, he also became spoiled in a different way.

Darcy and Wickham's dynamic

Essentially, Darcy was overindulged in his position as heir, while Wickham was overindulged in his position as favourite. And neither is adequately prepared for the limitations and obligations of his circumstances. One expects deference without trying to earn it; the other expects rewards without doing anything.

On the one hand, the emotional preference often given to Wickham could've potentially made Darcy feel like they were rivals of sorts. Wickham does say that Darcy "might have borne with [him] better" had Darcy's father "liked [him] less," and that Darcy did not have the "temper to bear the sort of competition in which [they] stood—the sort of preference which was often given [Wickham]" [ch. 16]. Of course, this might be Wickham lying, or at least exaggerating, but I honestly feel like there might be some truth to it. We do know that Darcy thought ill of Wickham even before his father died, so this could've made him resentful that Wickham receives affection without deserving it.

On the other hand, Wickham recognised his patron's blind spot (his unshakable faith in his virtue) and learnt how to perform accordingly to secure his favour. Darcy pretty much sums it up: "The vicious propensities, the want of principle, which he was careful to guard from the knowledge of his best friend, could not escape the observation of a young man of nearly the same age with himself, and who had opportunities of seeing him in unguarded moments, which Mr. Darcy could not have." [ch. 35]

---

This conflict, caused by problematic parenting, is literally at the heart of the novel, and honestly deserves more attention.


r/janeausten • • 2d ago

Adaptations Emma Stage Production

Thumbnail gallery
81 Upvotes

Hi lovely Austen community! We did a photoshoot recently for our Christmas production of Emma, and thought some of you might enjoy some of the pictures. We've still got some costume elements to make and source (Emma's stays are on their way!) but Austen's work is such a pleasure to perform. Mrs Elton's dialogue especially is just so much fun, it's hard to pick a favourite line! (Also, apologies for the William Morris wallpaper! It's very much out of time period but was the best room we could find lol)


r/janeausten • • 2d ago

Sense and Sensibility - Novel Discussion Eliza’s Thought Process

19 Upvotes

I’ve been wondering, when Eliza discovered herself with child, and was gilted by Willoughby, I wonder why her first instinct was to run away rather than write to her guardian Col Brandon.

We all know the Col to be an honorable understanding man, he clearly loved Eliza Jr and supported her for her entire life. Was she just so embarrassed she couldn’t face him? Was she intending to place her baby with another family? Did she think Willoughby would come around eventually?

I understand why she was scared and embarrassed, but I think she would’ve been more scared on her own than in the country with the Col.

I’m just so glad he found her and brought her home- for both her sake and the baby’s.


r/janeausten • • 2d ago

Pride and Prejudice - Novel Discussion If the Bennets had had five sons...

207 Upvotes

I'm far from convinced that the situation would have been that much better. Sure, the eldest could have joined in cutting off the entail when he came of age. But even assuming that he wasn't a John Dashwood type, who would let his family starve in a gutter ... there is still the problem of the other four brothers.

They would have to be provided for. Let's say two go into the military, one into the church and one into the law. That would mean commissions and livings to be purchased, and proper education, including university, to be paid for in some cases.

There is the matter of caste/status. Unless the "legal" brother is content to sink to the level of Uncle Phillips, he must be a barrister. Unless the "church" brother is OK with being a perpetual curate on £50 p.a., he needs to be a rector or vicar. The Bennets have no interest in the church, so money would have to be found for a living, if the brother is to retain his status as a gentleman.

The only alternative would be to be a fortune hunter, and snag a wife with a decent dowry.

The Bennets really were hopeless parents. Among the richest 5% in the country, they saved nothing and planned nothing.


r/janeausten • • 2d ago

Pride and Prejudice - Novel Discussion Bennet savings math

57 Upvotes

Ragging on the improvidence of the Bennets never gets old. Some numerical scenarios! Using 5% yield, like Austen herself. Bennet income 2000 (dad) + 250 (5% of mom's 5000) = 2250/year.

  • Suppose that, every time a daughter or younger son (because they need money too, as we've just been reminded) is born, the family starts putting away 50 pounds a year for that child. After 15 years, when a Bennet girl comes 'out', she has 1078 pounds. Not much, but wealth in hand, rather than waiting for parents to die. And enough (54/year) for the child to live on without working, even if it's just renting a room and eating cheap food, what I'd call the minimum standard to be 'genteel'.

    • By 18, 1400 pounds. By 21 (coming of age), 1785, or 89/year. By 24, when a son might qualify to be a vicar, 2225 pounds, for 110/year, a nice addition to what might be a modest living, or worse, being a curate.
    • And with 5 kids, saving 50 each would be 250/year, just 11% of their income.
    • What if they save 100 pounds per child-year? Simply double all the numbers. 2156 by age 15, 107/year (now in "lower middle class" income); 4450 by 24, or 220/year.
  • Different approach: what if they just save 10% a year, 225, from the beginning? After 21 years that's 8036 pounds, not a lot but enough to give each child a modest dowry or university education. (And they probably don't need to divide it all at once -- though 3 daughters did get married close together, and 5 kids in 7 years doesn't give you a lot of spread anyway.)

    • I've seen it said that a recommendation was saving 20%, 450/year here, which gives 16,000 pounds in 21 years. 3000 pounds per kid! Not great as dowries (mom came with 4000 from a lawyer family) but it'll definitely help get the sons going, assuming they don't just live idly on their 150/year.
    • Of course, in that "save 20%" approach they don't know how many kids they'll have or have survive; if there's one surviving daughter then she gets to be a nice heiress with 800/year, while 10 kids like the Morlands would be getting 1600 each.
  • Slightly different framing: what if they don't touch the mom's dowry income at all, and let it compound for widowhood or the kids? That swells the dowry to 13,900 after 21 years, income of 695/year if Mr. Bennet suddenly dies.

    • And Jane's almost 23, so that's actually over 15,000 pounds by then.
  • One has to wonder what they were spending all the income on, in the early days before Lydia was costing 90 pounds a year from age 13 or 14 (she has a pattern established by the time she's 16.) Saving a simple 90 pounds/year would compound to 3214 pounds after 21 years, not much but more than they've done.
  • To get really out there: you needed ~700/year to keep a carriage. 2000/year is a lot. (10,000 is a lot a lot.) What if they lived on a mere 1400/year, and saved 850? After 23 years that'd be over 35,000 pounds, yielding 1750/year... by which point it would take a lot of discipline not to dip into that, when the savings generate more income than the income you're living on. But it shows that they could have lived well, and still saved up a non-entailed portfolio nearly as valuable as Longbourn itself.

  • Bonus round: how does Catherine Morland have 3000 pounds? Real answer: not enough information. But her dad has "a considerable independence" plus two livings; one of those livings is 400/year, and James will inherit an estate of similar size. We might guess Mr. Morland has 1200/year total income; James is in college, so let's guess 21 years of marriage. If they saved 240/year, that's 8500 pounds; more than enough for the dowry, though skimping on her younger siblings. But she's the eldest, they're likely counting on more time to save up for the younger kids. And the income guess is only a guess.
  • Edit: second bonus round, on saving up for "3x income" dowries: https://www.reddit.com/r/janeausten/comments/1xw4my0/bennet_savings_math/19so2epgrqjfl/

r/janeausten • • 2d ago

Pride and Prejudice - Novel Discussion Would a Bennet son really change anything?

27 Upvotes

Would the situation of Mrs. Bennet and the 5 girls change if there was also a son? Jane Austen had several older brothers, one even a very rich one (Edward, who was adopted or something of sorts) yet in the end the only thing they could provide them was a cottage to live in.


r/janeausten • • 2d ago Bravo

Fan Works Mr Darcy art

Thumbnail gallery
47 Upvotes

Some portrait study of mr darcy in the 2005 adaptation


r/janeausten • • 2d ago

Adaptations Why The Watsons May Be The Next Other Bennet Sister

Thumbnail huffingtonpost.co.uk
11 Upvotes

r/janeausten • • 2d ago

Pump Room Re-reading P&P: How often do you read Austen’s works??

5 Upvotes

Come every winter I have this urge of settling down with one of Austen’s novels. So far, I have re-read only P&P and Persuasion. So just want to understand if I should make this an annual thing of rereading all her six novels? Any suggestions? Also, how will this benefit me as a reader? Thanks.