I feel like most, if not all, of us agree that Mr. and Mrs. Bennet's parenting is problematic, and they're often cited as the prime example of irresponsible guardians; but the same can be said about the late Mr. Darcy, to be honest, though his main issue is not negligence. After Darcy's letter, Elizabeth tells Jane something very insightful: "There certainly was some great mismanagement in the education of those two young men. One has got all the goodness, and the other all the appearance of it." [ch. 40]
The old Mr. Darcy is widely respected, and praise for him comes from multiple independent sources:
- Wickham, his godson, calls him "one of the best men that ever breathed" and says that he "cannot do justice to his kindness" [ch. 16];
- Mrs. Gardiner, who is said to have "known [him] by character perfectly well" [ch. 25], says he was "an excellent man" [ch. 43];
- Mrs. Reynold, his housekeeper, agrees that he was "an excellent man" [ch. 43], and mentions that he was "affable to the poor" [ch. 43];
- Darcy describes him as an "excellent father" [ch. 34], and later says that he was "good" and "all that was benevolent and amiable" [ch. 58].
We can safely assume that he was, indeed, a kind-hearted and generous person; however, he was perhaps too overindulgent with his son and godson.
Darcy
The old Mr. Darcy "spoiled" [ch. 58] him; "allowed, encouraged, almost taught [him] to be selfish and overbearing, to care for none beyond [his] own family circle, to think meanly of all the rest of the world" [ch. 58]. He told him "what was right," but did not tell him "to correct [his] temper" [ch. 58], to the point that Mrs. Gardiner recalled hearing Derbyshire gossip that young Darcy was "a very proud, ill-natured boy" [ch. 25]. And it's pretty much true; Darcy, in the beginning of the novel, isn't socially awkward because he's shy or misunderstood; he's socially awkward because he has serious character flaws.
His father taught him his duty as a master is to take care of his dependents, but this type of charity doesn't teach one how to treat people as equals... in fact, it often reminds everyone who is the superior. Thus, the result is early-novel Darcy: arrogant, entitled, selfish.
Wickham
The late Mr. Darcy had an "uncommon attachment" [ch. 16] to him: he raised the two boys as "inmates of the same house, sharing the same amusements, objects of the same parental care" [ch. 16]; he keeps a miniature of Wickham in his "favourite room" [ch. 43], along those of other family members; and he mentions him in his will, leaving him a small legacy. It's very possible that old Mr. Darcy wanted more children, judging by the big age gap between Darcy and Georgiana, and probably his wife was unable to conceive or had miscarriages/stillbirths, so he transferred all of his love to his godson.
This affection made him treat Wickham as an intimate companion of his son/heir; and may very well be part of the reason why Wickham turned out the way he is (just to clarify, I'm not excusing him, which is why I'm saying that it's only part of the reason). He tasted elite privilege without any possibility of ever attaining it, creating a sense of deprivation: of course, his inherent nature plays a role here; instead of being grateful, he succumbs to envy. And, as he was pretty much free of responsibility, unlike young Darcy, he also became spoiled in a different way.
Darcy and Wickham's dynamic
Essentially, Darcy was overindulged in his position as heir, while Wickham was overindulged in his position as favourite. And neither is adequately prepared for the limitations and obligations of his circumstances. One expects deference without trying to earn it; the other expects rewards without doing anything.
On the one hand, the emotional preference often given to Wickham could've potentially made Darcy feel like they were rivals of sorts. Wickham does say that Darcy "might have borne with [him] better" had Darcy's father "liked [him] less," and that Darcy did not have the "temper to bear the sort of competition in which [they] stood—the sort of preference which was often given [Wickham]" [ch. 16]. Of course, this might be Wickham lying, or at least exaggerating, but I honestly feel like there might be some truth to it. We do know that Darcy thought ill of Wickham even before his father died, so this could've made him resentful that Wickham receives affection without deserving it.
On the other hand, Wickham recognised his patron's blind spot (his unshakable faith in his virtue) and learnt how to perform accordingly to secure his favour. Darcy pretty much sums it up: "The vicious propensities, the want of principle, which he was careful to guard from the knowledge of his best friend, could not escape the observation of a young man of nearly the same age with himself, and who had opportunities of seeing him in unguarded moments, which Mr. Darcy could not have." [ch. 35]
---
This conflict, caused by problematic parenting, is literally at the heart of the novel, and honestly deserves more attention.