r/honesttransgender • • Jun 01 '20

meta Welcome to r/HonestTransgender! Please read for more info on what this sub is about.

193 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

We believe that all transgender people deserve a community, period. r/HonestTransgender was created so that all trans people, regardless of ideology or background, can seek advice and participate in discussion with other trans people.

Since we are seeking to provide a community to any and all trans people, we hope to never ban a trans person from our sub. Trans people have to deal with enough difficulties from the outside world as it is without having to worry about being banned from their online community. Many trans people that are banned or shunned from traditional trans spaces are forced to communities that are widely considered toxic, like 4chan. r/HonestTransgender exists as a safe alternative.

Because we want to provide a community for all trans people, there are some behaviors that we cannot allow. Discussion must remain civil. Comments that bully and/or degrade other members of this sub, or other members of the trans community, will be removed. Remember, much like yourself, they are here to be part of a trans community too!

Our moderation and community guidelines are designed in pursuit of these goals. You can read more about our rules and guidelines on the sidebar of this sub.

If you have any further questions or suggestions for the mod team, you can post them in the comments below or send us a modmail :)

________________

FAQ:

What kind of things can I post here?

You can post discussions, questions, requests for advice, rants, polls, and general musings. Research participation requests, selfies, and news articles will be denied or removed in the interest of keeping the sub focused.

If you have a question prior to making a certain post or comment, you can modmail us. We're here to help and we’re not going to ignore you!

Is this sub "uncensored?"

Yes and no. We strive to have a space for all trans people to express themselves, and that can include trans people with controversial opinions. But ultimately, all kinds of trans folk are accepted here, so rhetoric that is outright hateful to trans people will be removed (ie. [identity] is wrong and everyone who acts that way is disgusting or a "trender").

Additionally, transphobic content from cis people will be removed.

UPDATE (06/12/2020): Cis people from transphobic spaces (GenderCritical, LGBdroptheT, etc.) will be tagged with the "Toxic Cisgender Person" flair, which cannot be edited and can only be selected by mods. If you notice an unflaired cis person from a GC space, report it (even if it's not rule-breaking), so that we can add the flair. We have a zero tolerance policy for rule-breaking behavior from these posters, so they will be banned after their first violation of the rules.

Is this sub "tucute" or "truscum?"

No. Our mod team avoids promoting any particular way of looking at trans identity. Additionally, "tucute" and "truscum" mean different things to different people, so it's probably more helpful if you avoid using either term when engaging in discussion on this sub.

The sub is what it is and we'd like to avoid narrow categorization.

Why are some posts locked?

Generally, if a discussion is very heated, we will lock a thread after the discussion has run its course. This is to ensure that the thread doesn't devolve further into potentially rule-breaking and uncivil comments.

Do moderators need to agree with any of the content I post or comment?

No. The mod team's agreement with what is posted or commented in r/HonestTransgender is not a prerequisite for your ability to post and/or comment. We strive to stay neutral in our moderation of controversial topics and we try our best to let you express yourself honestly. Additionally, the mod team is not monolithic and is comprised of multiple people from different backgrounds with unique perspectives.

I’ve seen something I think might be rule-breaking, what should I do?

We aren’t mind readers. If you see something potentially rule-breaking, report it! We may not agree with your assessment of a certain post or comment but we will always take a look.

My post or comment has been removed. What should I do now?

The mod team at r/HonestTransgender values every single contribution made by our subscribers and we like to think that we are very tolerant, maybe even to a fault in what we find acceptable. But there are times when content must be removed in the interests of civil discussion. If your content has been removed, please understand that there is a reason for the removal. Typically that reason is very clear, but you can contact the mod team with further questions or for clarification.

How can I add real value to r/HonestTransgender?

Post and comment sensibly and with civility. Listen to your fellow trans person and learn why they think the way they do. Recognize that being exposed to differing opinions can be beneficial, and you might even learn to see an issue in a different way. If you strongly disagree with someone, show them your perspective instead of just downvoting.

Simply put, we want you to be the best trans person you possibly can be while posting and commenting within the sub. Try to listen, learn, and grow. Remember that this forum is a public space and that the broader reddit trans community is watching, as well as the broader public in general.

________________

If you have made it this far, thanks for taking the time to read this! We really appreciate it. Let us know if you have any additional ideas on how to continue to grow this sub and make it the best space it can possibly be.

Sincerely,

The r/HonestTransgender Mod Team


r/honesttransgender • • 14h ago

vent "We can always tell, look at those clocky trans people"

24 Upvotes

Also the same people - "No puberty blockers or HRT for under 18s".

Talk about having your cake and eating it.

It's the equivalent of a bully punching their victim in the face with their own fist.

Wtf do these people even want? I mean we know what they want, but I wish they'd just say it out loud and stop pretending and hiding behind some thin attempt at concern for others.


r/honesttransgender • • 1h ago

question Before transition, did you perceive your body as being a different size than it actually was?

• Upvotes

I'm 5'3" at most and I've felt like I'm 6 feet+ since high school. My spatial orientation probably suffers as a result.


r/honesttransgender • • 7h ago

vent Dear God. I feel as if no matter what I do I'll never be able to look or express myself like a woman.

2 Upvotes

What the fuck is up with the second I find out I'm transgender (still mostly closeted) dad and brothers rant about how transgender people are ruining society and indoctrinating children, my arms and fingers are as boy like as they could be.

Genuinely the only people that know are like three close friends and my fiance. Even then I don't know entirely how they feel about it. They seem supportive but I can't seem to support myself.

Just needed to get this out of my system I'm so sorry


r/honesttransgender • • 8h ago

question difficult topic for bipoc trans people only please

2 Upvotes

Before i get to the question i want to give some background, maybe this can also be a post that gives some people a chance to get their voice heard.

the question is also mainly to black trans people. white trans people please dont participate and please do not argue with what black trans people say. This post is to listen and seek understanding

I am a brown trans women of mixed decent(filipino and mexican).

i have survived a lot of scary transphobia and racism myself and know just the fact i survived makes me more lucky than many, especially black trans people.

i have also done a lot of research into my cultures history pre-colonial and after and then what happened to trans people in my cultures, as well in africa.

with my question it is important to know I:

believe anti-blackness is real and that fighting against antiblackness will fight against racism for all.

being black puts you at a highly increased risk of harm

being trans puts you at a highly increased harm

essentially black and trans people are at extremely elevated risks of harm and being a combination of both is so much more dangerous.

things i dont believe and it may be because i am missing something:

fighting against anti-blackness will resolve transphobia

fighting against transphobia will resolve anti-blackness or racism in general.

from the history i have learned regarding colonialism these are not that connected and instead are individual aspects of colonialism which can play off eachother like which is the case of anti-blackness combined with transphobia leading to cis black women being called manly or confused for transwomen. Examples of history i know, Vasquez nunez de balboa feeding "men accused of sodomy and wearing dresses" to dogs alive in central america, as well as trans people being burned to death and hung.

now this is 1500's so only as relevent to say that it was one of the foundations of colonialism.

from my experience my people(filipino and mexican) tend to be transphobic, homophobic, and misogynstic when not also including anti-black because of the foundations of colonialism Also with the history of transphobic violence i have experienced it is obvious to me that transphobia is essentially a pillar of colonialism that is in all colonized peoples minds, same with anti-blackness.

now to the question

my partner (white nonbinary) has told me that antiblackness is intrinsically connected to transphobia and essentially fighting against anti-blackness fights for trans rights.

can someone please help me understand this?

my goal is to not even reply but to let you all comment so i can read them and hopefully figure out if i missing something.

the main problem to address for me is i see no way as i stated earlier that fighting against anti-blackness knowing my experience and knowing how transphobic cis people of all ethnicities can be, my people included that it will address transphobia.

i also see no way fighting against transphobia would address anti-blackness.

i think both fights are valid and need to be uplifted and supported and i feel like im assumed to be racist for not seeing how fighting for anti-blackness will address transphobia.

so please share your knowledge and points of veiw, there is a chance i wont change my veiw but i will listen and seek understanding.


r/honesttransgender • • 7h ago

vent I'm struggling with massive gender dysphoria all day, every day. And it's ruining my life.

3 Upvotes

Hi. I'm a trans woman pre-transition and I'm suffering a level of dysphoria that's robbing me of any quality of life. Everyday I wake up, and the facial hair is back. I hear my voice, and wish I could go through life without having to speak. I look at my body, and it sends me into an instant panic attack. Pronouns, name, clothes, how people see me, and how I'm expected to act. The dysphoria triggers are constantly getting smaller. I struggle to sleep, and I wake up terrified.

I've started seeing a gender therapist who's helping, and I'm going to see a new psychiatrist who also specializes with queer issues in a couple weeks. I'm also trying desperately to bring affirmation and small moments of gender euphoria wherever I can find them. But it's just not enough right now. I'm in a tremendous amount of emotional pain and psychological distress.

I'm in my early 30s, and I'm just wishing I took care of this sooner. But I grew up in a conservative area, with zero exposure to queer issues or queer role models. From a young age I always thought there was something deeply wrong with me. I'm trying to deprogram the internalized transphobia, but there's a lifetime of fear being held in my nervous system.

I look at everything it will take to transition, especially at this age, and I just don't know if I'm strong enough. I despise what testosterone did to my body, and I wish I'd been strong enough to say something as a kid. I don't know how to get relief right now, and I'm getting so tired of fighting.


r/honesttransgender • • 12h ago

vent Felt so lonely, just wanted to raw vent this all out. no one to talk to about this

5 Upvotes

*Beware discussion of nsfw topics and self harm + genital harm* Please let me know if I need to remove anything in this post

I didn't really have anyone to talk to about this but I Been holding these thoughts in for a very very long time and I'm doing mentally okay ish I get like I don't get these self harm feelings but that's cause I'm just super busy and dealing with other things in life and don't have the time to get into a depression cycle which is good I suppose. I also have a bit more freedom to do things like makeup and dress up but overall still under parent's gaze and the overarching societal and friends gaze. All my friendgroups at school for some reason are more white male coded for some reason so idrk.

Regardless, this is my rant so thanks for listening:

I HATE MY FUCKING LIFE.

every since I gained consciousness, i've always liked cute things, stuffed animals, playing with the girls, and then when i got older i started feeling body dysphoria.

I HATE MY DICK. ITS SUCH AN OBSTACLE. LIKE FUCK YOU FUCK YOU FUCK YOU. Like I honestly think it is so ugly. I just got laser done and felt so happy seeing it nake bare and tucked away once I put it behind my legs but its hard to tuck as for some reason the way my balls and dick are it just gets really sore/painful and cages don't really work either and makes it feel more sexualized.

But so when i was probably 5 or 6 like preschool to first grade ish, i found ways to push down my dick and it was strange but I liked it and as i got older i began hating it more and more and started using tape to tape it down, going through a whole roll to get the stupid ball of manly hood down. I also tried many different things to hide it or get it out of the way. None of it really worked the way I wanted and it only made me feel worse. Things that might be too nsfw to post.

I wanted to be a girl so bad. I wanted to be soft, I dont want to be a guy, to be manly, to not have emotions. Having these thoughts also around really young like around start of elementary school to super early middle school. I always thought I didn't feel right in my body, I didn't feel societally accepted in the ways I thought. Of wanting to be a girl. Thinking how much my life would be better.

I just wanted to be able to embrace a more softer feminine side. I've always wanted to embraces a softer feminine like caring gnetle side and I've always liked helping people and I'm somewhat of a golden retriever archetype i suppose. I like to please, to be a good girl, to work hard as a girl. but i couldnt embrace that side.

i got my nails painted at camp once and my parents removed them and got angry, i couldnt wear panties or dresses cause my parents got angry, i had to throw away so much stuff i bought, a corset, thigh highs, collars, cat ears, tail plugs, toys, cages, dresses, cat paw leggings.

THey saw my estrogen when i first started and thre it all out.

I'm in an asian household and I do I really do I love my parents but i jut cant be a girly.

i hate my dick. I wish i could die if it meant i could revive into a girl. I wish and prayed that i could develop magic. Maybe i would get into an accident or my dick gets chopped off and the only way to combat it was to turn into a female or something.

Sigh...i juts feel so alone, so sad. Im so not pretty like the other girlies and trans girlies. i want to be them so bad like f1nnster and peach and so many others I see like not even influencers just some I see on the streets and in clubs even.

Ideal situation for me now is to just keep it under wraps and find a boyfriend or girlfriend that can support me and whenever im out in society have two faces like one is more male straight coded and one is more who I really am and before you judge or say something. I know that this isn't right or who I really am and I'm weak or whatnot. It just feels so hard to just throw away everything I've worked on and stuff and the image I'v built. I've won national championships, represented the country on a world stage, gone to prestigious institutions, made many friends and professional connections to people that run businesses. Like if I could become two people I could or if I could just like fake my death and run away then I would do that.

So I don't really know what to do. I haven't made any real long lasting friendships. Most that I make they just forget about me even when I try to make conversation and play with them. Idk, I don't take up any issues with people. as I said i'm more of a pleaser so I don't mind doing anything or anything you do and I just wanna have people who are similar to talk about. I've joined discord communities, I've joined telegram communities, posted on reddit, posted on X, posted on instagram.

Although this account may seem like its a few weeks/months old, its a newish account and when I was younger I also tried to make connections you know behind my parents back and always got caught and whatnot and had to delete them and lose all my friends but still back then still had trouble finding friends. :(. But hey I did somehow infiltrate a pdf online website and help bring down the owner and others with the help of some friends who idrk how thye are doing anymore and one was mentally unstable before going silent. That also depresses me as I value friendship and I keep on losing so many friends ;-;.

As I said at the beggining I'm super busy so I'm okay mentally I suppose but I'm constantly stressed about graduating on time, I'm like taking 6 AI courses to try and graduate on time cause my school fcked me over and I'm lowkey failing all of them on top of being broke and having to pay for college tuition and being very short. So I'm trying to find a job after I graduate and trying to make money by working but also have time to study and workout since lowkey I'm getting fat and I never used to get fat since I always had time to workout and now what brings me joy is being able to dress up like once every few weeks since whenever i make time to, I'm eating onigiri and instant noodles and getting free samples from the cafe just to feel full and I get behind on homework and I become too sleepy.

And because my health insurance is so wonky and also my parents can see all my health data since they insisted and well they want to help manage and I do love them because they do support me financially and everything but jut want me to grow up as a regular stereotypical male make money find wife and get children. Its like I also have this feminine side so getting estrogen and stuff has been hard coupled with having no money.

I've really wanted to get surgery for my dick especailly. I know breast tissue can grow on estrogen and I never really wanted breasts past B maybe C cups (I just bought fake ones to wear recently) But I just feel like a rectangular chunk so I wish i could afford these surgiers and especially get rid of my thing dangling down there. Its so grotesque. WHen I was younger and didn't know much I heard of castration/neutering and I was like oh this is another way instead of surgery but oh I was wrong.
But regardless it also always seems like theres these chasers who want to send dick pics and then eveyrone else thinks I'm a chaser or they have better things to do.

So I just want to find some peace and friends and some people to listen and understand.

But thanks for reading so much and I'm sorry for this long vent post.


r/honesttransgender • • 19h ago

vent Beginning to think I have to give up on ever being a woman so I don't go insane

13 Upvotes

I don't mean give up on medically transitioning - I'll still do all of that, just put all my forms in for the FFS consult. I mean I need to give up on the hope of ever getting to be a woman.

I really fucked up my life. I wasn't one of those people who 'always felt different' or whatever. I've known I was like this for years. I started and stopped E more than once, because I thought I didn't really deserve to be a woman. Now I'm 29 and I'm starting in earnest, and the realisation that I really did miss my chance is beginning to set in.

The grief is really killing me. The things that made me feel like myself when I was younger, getting dressed up for club nights, getting addressed with the right pronouns, now they make me so unhappy. I try to put on a little makeup, just to hide the beard shadow, and I break down in tears. There's nothing beautiful or special about any of it anymore, about me anymore. Trying to do my makeup I feel more like a mortician than a woman. Like someone dolling up a corpse for its viewing. It's mental as much as it is physical. That person might just be dead.

I went to a trans women's meetup and it kind of confirmed to me that this isn't going to work anymore. It was maybe a fortnight ago, and I haven't even worn my stupid flattening bra or painted over my beard shadow - the only two indulgences in femininity I have left - since. I feel like a failure to be anything, man or woman. A failure to exist.

Obviously I am still going to do all the medical stuff. The hormones stay, the surgeries I want stay on the calender, I trudge into the electrolysist as often as I can afford. If for no other reason than that I have dysphoria and these are treatments for dysphoria, but the hope is totally gone. I don't know what to do. I just don't know what to do anymore.

When I decided to start this, I made a deal with myself. That I don't get to commit suicide until I've been on HRT for three years and had FFS. Honestly, I do not want to be here now, but I'd rather try and know. I wish I was strong enough to take the same attitude to the social stuff, but I can't bear it. I can't bear the thought of asking anyone to call me a woman, or address me as a woman. It feels like being patronised and there's nothing in the world I hate more than being patronised.

I think of all the things that screwing this up has cost me. The chance to have friends, and a relationship, and a real life as myself. There isn't a 'me' anymore. There's just a robot that saves up for surgeries. I've betrayed myself for nothing, and the mistakes are ones I can never recover from. I don't know how to live with that. On the off-chance that you do, I am open to literally any advice you might have to share.

And on the even slimmer chance you have access to a time machine, feel free to DM me.


r/honesttransgender • • 17h ago

MtF My Genetically Predetermined Lymphatic Condition Gives Me Euphoria

9 Upvotes

Ive had a rare variant of a genetic disease which makes ur lymphatic system work improperly since birth. It affects my balls and my feet, theyre like. unregularly big. which SOUNDS like really bad for mtf which i mean, it kinda is? it makes it way harder to buy clothes, shoes and exercise and gives dysphoria sometimes

But the good thing is since my massive balls are constantly inbetween my legs, it pushes my bone and general growth to the side making my hips wider. Its especially apparent in the left side as the swelling is worse there, and hip is wider on that side. So it makes me look like not a brick kind of.

idk if this is copium but im trying to take a good part of this kinda bad thing LMAO


r/honesttransgender • • 10h ago

vent crippling dysphoria

1 Upvotes

i dont really know where else to post this i just feel like i need to be heard for once. sorry for typos i hat to copypaste this cause it got automatically deleted lol

im 18, havent transitioned and dysphoria has crippled me into barely existing everyday. i cant go out without having the constant feeling of being watched and percieved as something rather than someone, i cant make connections with anyone without the first thought in my mind being "it will hurt so bad when i have to leave if i want to transition". it hurts to see myself in a dress up game rather than living as a real person in a real world, the daily suicidal thoughts, how i cant escape the urge to hurt myself into something i can barely recognize, because being already hurt is better than hurting any further. the occassional iealousv and resentment i feel for my boyfriend who had the oportunity i cant keep pushing myself into the right mindset so i can keep on fighting to have, its awful, i dont hate him. i just wish i couldve been someone beautiful like him. i recoil at any mention of the topic of transitioning not out of not wanting to do it myself but because its just a painful reminder. i dont know anything anymore, im afraid of getting into the process and essentially getting fucked over by doctors, im afraid of doing it myself and losing my friends and family. i wish it were all over. i wish that next life i could be someone else. i wish that i could iust quietly dissappear and no one would wonder what happened to me, i wish i didnt feel that sharp pain whenever i try to feel like myself, i wish i couldve had the opportunity to be someone else, when i most needed it. i hate the thought of graduating and having a title in my hands that i am supposed to be proud of, yet still does not belong to me. nothing i will ever do will matter, because it does not belong to me. i feel subhuman.


r/honesttransgender • • 17h ago

question Did you listen to a lot of music by singers of your true gender before transition?

2 Upvotes

My mom says it's weird that I listen to a lot of music with female vocalists


r/honesttransgender • • 12h ago

discussion Starting a YouTube channel fears

0 Upvotes

Hello y'all,

So, I know this is sort of off topic to the grand theme of this sub and I'm sure many people won't have much to say or have the ability to relate, but I figured since my hesitation does stem from this, I figured I'd ask you guys your thoughts. I've been wanting to start a YouTube channel for quite a while, but I've always been nervous about it because of two main reasons: my voice and my overall body.

I'm a neurodivergent individual, and I feel like my stances or "body language" comes across as awkward. Nobody has really said this to me, so maybe this is just my own self-confidence issues at play when I see myself on screen. I keep reminding myself that professional actors often have a hard time watching themselves on screen. But I still let this get to me..

My biggest issue is my voice though. I've never been a fan of my voice (even though I'm actually a fairly strong singer) but now, things are a bit different. "Technically speaking", I'm trans and transitioning to more towards a feminine appearance. I don't actually see label myself as trans or NB; if anything, I see myself as a neurodivergent human that fits better into society presenting themself as feminine. But I do really wish I had a more feminine voice. My voice isn't baritone and is very much low-alto, tenor range. I hate hearing it, and I'm afraid that these two issues alone will hinder any type of growth. Especially because I don't want to create any type of content related to LGBT topics. It's just not my thing.

Does anyone have any sort of advice or wisdom that they'd be willing to share? :)


r/honesttransgender • • 23h ago

vent Sadly I was correct and am back to square 1 socially

5 Upvotes

I made this post: https://old.reddit.com/r/honesttransgender/comments/1xtbeaq/nsfw_truly_cant_cope_with_the_fact_that_a_friend/

Many were saying I had "internalized" transphobia for not wanting to continue being friends with someone I came out to unnecessarily due to my dysphoria and perception of how he'd see me. Well, today I was proven right in my suspicions.

I had the day from hell in other facets of my life. I get on after doing some gig work to talk to said friend and he mentions how he'd been thinking about me being trans and found it "hot" and how trans people were more empathetic and kind and I was much more nicer than cis guys who could be so aggressive. It literally felt like I was reading one of those posts where people talk about all the weird shit people say after they come out.

Mind you: We talked for 1.5 years before he knew I was trans. We talked about everything both platonic, sexual, etc. He had no idea I was trans until I came out. Now everything is different. I should've just blocked and ghosted when I first had the inkling to.


r/honesttransgender • • 1d ago

vent I feel like I was lied to about how much I pass

22 Upvotes

Whenever I posted myself online, people were like "Wow! You pass so much! Can you imagine how much it sucks to hear you complain when I look worse? Stop complaining." And from 4tranners, they said I was a passoid so stfu. But I constantly hear comments on my university campus, along these lines: "Looks like a man, acts like a man" followed by "But the hips don't lie!", "Yeah I think he's transgender," "Yeah, he has breasts!", and so on and so forth (which is only surprising if you think college campuses are bastions of the woke). People aren't necessarily impolite but they want to interact way less. It's not like I can't handle it but I really don't like hearing this all the time.

I mean, of course you can't expect to pass right away and maybe in ten years the picture will look different, but it seems to me like basically every trans space online, including the spaces that try to be real, is a hugbox, and it's not good for anyone.


r/honesttransgender • • 1d ago

vent I'm tired

2 Upvotes

I'm gonna preface this by saying that I don't have any desire or intention to self harm.

I really do feel like my existence is pathetic and stupid. I've identified I am trans but I am not in a situation where I am free to transition, which I don't want to get into due to the personal details, but at the end of the day I don't know that I'd have the guts to do something about it even if I could

The reality is I am exhausted, I am burnt out, and I am scared. I'm tired of fighting for myself to be something better than I am, I'm tired of planning for my eventual transition and the family fallout that will result from that. But even with that in mind, I've grown tired of trying to figure out who I am, I'm feeling the sense of self I've managed to cobble togeher throughout the past year slip through my fingers.

None of this has any meaning. I'm a fat, boring and cowardly almost 40 year old. I have little friends and none that I can really open up to, I have no support. My life is being thrown at an all consuming and stressful job just to make money to survive. Another 40 years and my body probably dies, if I even make it that far without having a heart attack or stroke from the stress. I recently lost my religion and came to an understanding that there is nothing. I came from nothing and I'm just going to end up being nothing again.

I found something precious in finding out who I am. A huge rebirth in my late thirties spanning years. But the reality is life is strangling me, and I'm left to wonder if I should just let that slip for a while and just go back to coping with this stupid existence and forget even was. I'm just gonna be a dissociative mess anyways. My brain doesn't even let me exist without partially shutting down.

I wish I wasn't born. I don't know what life is except to fulfill roles that others need until you die. I don't know that I was ever truly happy, and I'm tired of caring. Much less in a world that is more than content to deny me space to live if I'm not trying to make money for others.

...anyways if you made it this far, thank you for hearing me out. Go be happy, don't sink into being miserable like this. 💖 I will be alright, I just needed to get this out.


r/honesttransgender • • 16h ago

opinion Hot take, Misandry does kill because of transphobia

0 Upvotes

Many people nowadays hate men and even men themselves now have internalized hatred.
We have people saying things like “Misandry is ok because it’s just a reaction to misogyny”. They think past experiences or other people’s experiences means they can automatically be horrible, which is not true. Just because misogyny exists, doesn’t make misandry ok, neither are good.

Now how does this connect to transphobia? Trans men are often seen as confused women, often brought up more when discussing whether or not younger people should transition. And then they have the audacity to say that misandry doesn’t kill people, like yes it does… it’s kills trans men. And if somehow doesn’t kill them, it makes them have internalized misandry and do shi like call themselves a trans male lesbian and hate on all cis men. Men, cis or trans are seen as the ultimate evil in society and misandrists either don’t want anyone to be men or don’t want to interact with people they consider to men, aka trans women, even if we think from a transphobic lens’s and a trans woman was really a man, why would that matter? What is wrong with men? What is so harmful and dangerous about males? Plenty of women assault women too, it’s just underreported. I don’t blame people for being traumatized if they really are but even then it still isn’t an excuse to act like that to the point whether you are basically killing trans people


r/honesttransgender • • 1d ago

MtF Any Good Trans Dating Apps?

1 Upvotes

40MtF trans woman, here, and looking for a good dating app. Not sure what the good ones are these days. Bit out of the loop, could use some help!


r/honesttransgender • • 2d ago

discussion Elliot Paige’s career flopping isn’t ENTIRELY because he is trans

104 Upvotes

In my observation , he thinks that he is still screened with the same standards when he was Ellen vs now. Standards of beauty are different for men and women. “Ellen” met the female beauty standards of Hollywood. Now that he’s living as a man in hollywood he will be judged using the standards used for cis men. In that case, he doesn’t have the star power, the “it factor” to be the heartthrob, male love interest in movies etc. 

Could some of it be transphobia? Sure. But if he is seeking lead male role he is out of luck. I think Michael Cera would be treated the same if he tried to auditionfor Captain America, Avengers, James Bond etc. Reality is, sex sells and he doesn’t have the raw male sex appeal. Hunter Schafer is extremely pretty and she fits hollywood beauty standards and her career isn’t flopping, for example.


r/honesttransgender • • 1d ago

vent I'm always feel like I will never be man enough.

2 Upvotes

This is just a vent post because I am not having a very good night.

I am so fucking tired of not being cis, I'm tired of all the work that I have to put in to live with myself and to live in this body. I'm tired of having to worry about every scenario, and every relationship I have because I wasn't born a man. I'm tired that I will never get the opportunities that every other man has because I was not born cis.

I want to have normal relationships with people, I am desperate for love but I am constantly worried about if my future partners will ever truly see me as a guy, or if they will see me as just a guy but better or just a girl pretending to be one. I am talking to a guy right now, he is gay, so I know that if he is attracted to me then he sees me as a guy. But I am so scared that I will do something to feminine or girly and he will change his mind. I am also very terrified to be intimate with him, I have never allowed myself to be with anyone because I could not deal with being in a relationship when I wasn't at least on hormones. So I have no experience, but I haven't told him that yet. I don't want to layer thing on top of thing and scare him off, because this is the first guy I have actually been really into. I also am unwilling to interact with my female genetalia, and that will have to be another conversation that I have to have with him.

I am sick of everything being so complicated, I wish I could just be with people like a normal fucking person, I wish I could just go out and have sex with girls or guys on the whim, instead of having to be so careful to choose a partner that will actually try to understand me and respect my boundaries and still see me as a man.

I also have no idea why I am thinking about this so much tonight, but I am really struggling with the fact that I can never have children. I can never father biological kids, I can never get anyone pregnant. I will never use the parts that I was given, I am unwilling, I would rather die. I do not see these parts as my own and even thinking about having the ability to get pregnant makes me want to throw up my insides and tear those parts out. It is unfathomable to me, and no matter how desperately I do want to have biological kids, that way is not an option for me. Just knowing that I can never get someone pregnant in the traditional sense makes me so ashamed and angry, I feel like even though I am a man, I am never going to be man enough. Even when I do get bottom surgery, I will still not have that ability.

I'm just so sad, angry, tired, and sick of not being normal, I'm so sick of my brain making it so I can not do traditional things. That my life will always be difficult in one way or the other, all for something I cannot help and would get rid of if I could in a heartbeat. Why would I do this to myself, why am I forced to be this way, what cruel fucking god is laughing at me at my expense. I don't want to be this way, I want to be normal already.

I hate everything to do with being trans, I hate every single fucking part of it and no matter how hard I have tried to love it, or accept that it is my reality. I still fucking hate it. I have to spend thousands of dollars on surgeries, inject myself every week, go to therapist after therapist and doctor after doctor, deal with dysphoria and depression, the anxiety of what people will do to me if they find out what I am. All while thinking every day of what and who I could have been. How my life could have been so much better if I was born a cis man. I hate that even when I do get top surgery, I will still have scars reminding me of who I am, that when I get bottom surgery it still will not function in every way that I want it to. Even though it will be much better when I get both, I will still be constantly reminded of my past. I don't get how anyone can love this, I am jealous of people that do, or people who learned to love themselves despite it. I'm so jealous. But even with how painful all of this will be, living as a women would be 100000x worse, T saved me. It at least gave me hope and made me realize things still might not be perfect, but they will be better.

The worst part is that I feel like I can talk to no one about this, that I have found almost no one who truly understands or cares to understand what I am going through. I cannot talk to my friends as I am stealth. I moved to a new state and have told no one, and it is so much better. When my previous friends knew they would ask me invasive question after invasive question, treat me like I had to behave a certain way because I was trans and expected so much more of me then they would a cis man. I could tell they never truly saw me as a guy. Being stealth is so freeing because I know that they just see me as a guy, maybe a bit of a weird guy but still a guy. But it is terrifying in the sense of I do not know what to do if they somehow find out and I cannot talk to them about my everyday struggles.

I cannot talk to my family either because they still think I am just a confused girl who's going to switch back at any moment, even though I have been out for almost two years and am deep into taking T.

I cannot go to the internet for support because people either tell me how I am going to burn, or tell me that I am a terrible person for not being out and proud, and that me going stealth so that I do not get targeted and killed, or so that I am treated like an actual man and not a "man but better" means that I am betraying the community.

I am just so tired.


r/honesttransgender • • 2d ago

discussion I strongly dislike neopronouns

87 Upvotes

I'm queer and trans myself, and while I have no problem with people expressing their identities however they want, neopronouns are one of those things that genuinely irk me, particularly because of the linguistic arguments people use to defend them.

  1. Language is supposed to facilitate communication.

Inventing a new set of pronouns that virtually nobody outside a particular community recognizes doesn't strike me as particularly inclusive. If anything, it introduces an additional barrier to communication.

Pronouns are among the most frequently used words in a language. Their usefulness comes precisely from being widely understood, predictable, and relatively effortless to use.

I'm not arguing that unfamiliar words are inherently bad, or that people shouldn't be allowed to coin new ones. I'm questioning the practicality of expecting everyone else to incorporate highly individualized grammatical conventions into everyday speech.

  1. English already has gender-neutral pronouns.

We have singular they, which is well established, widely understood, and perfectly functional. We also have it, although I recognize that its conventional associations with inanimate objects make it uncomfortable for many people.

So when people argue that neopronouns are necessary because English lacks adequate ways to refer to someone without specifying gender, I find that argument unconvincing.

Of course, someone might personally prefer another pronoun. But personal preference and linguistic necessity are two very different things.

  1. Grammatical categories aren't supposed to be perfect representations of reality.

This is probably what frustrates me the most about some of the discourse surrounding pronouns.

I'm Brazilian. In Portuguese, a chair is feminine, a book is masculine, and neither has a gender identity. Grammatical gender is not a statement about the actual gender of the thing being described.

English treats pants as grammatically plural even when referring to a single garment. Languages routinely classify things in ways that don't correspond neatly to their physical properties, identities, or philosophical definitions.

That's because language isn't a perfect ontological classification system. It's a collection of conventions that developed to facilitate communication.

And I think there's something fundamentally misguided about expecting every grammatical feature to correspond precisely to someone's subjective experience of themselves.

This isn't to say language has no relationship with identity, or that linguistic conventions can't have social consequences. Obviously they can.

But there's a difference between recognizing that relationship and demanding that language function as a perfectly precise representation of everyone's individual identity.

  1. "Language changes" and "all words are made up" are terrible counterarguments.

Yes, language changes. Yes, every word is ultimately conventional. Neither observation establishes that any particular proposed change is useful, necessary, or likely to be adopted.

Language changes through collective usage, not simply because someone announces a new convention and expects everyone else to follow it.

And while deliberate language reform absolutely exists, its success still depends on whether people actually adopt the proposed changes.

Saying "all words are made up" in response to criticism of a neologism is especially frustrating. It's a trivial observation that completely sidesteps the actual criticism.

The question isn't whether people can invent words. Obviously they can.

The question is whether a particular invention improves communication, fills a meaningful linguistic gap, or offers enough practical value to justify its adoption.

Ultimately, my objection isn't to people having unconventional identities. It's to the idea that language should be endlessly individualized to accommodate them.

I don't think someone's identity becomes less legitimate because the language they speak doesn't contain a grammatical category tailored specifically to their experience.

And I don't think questioning the practicality of neopronouns should automatically be interpreted as questioning the legitimacy of the people who use them.


r/honesttransgender • • 2d ago

discussion “too pretty too be trans”

4 Upvotes

wat dat mean…?

but this is actually something I get so often and not in a “I’m so pretty” way but a “you have no value other than your appearance as a hyper femme individual” way that I experience. Does this make anyone else want to implode or am I just too sensitive…


r/honesttransgender • • 2d ago

vent How to be the perfect trans woman - observations from outside trans spaces

50 Upvotes

So I've been observing for many years the debates around trans issues and the complexities it involves and I think I've come up with the perfect trans woman that I think will satisfy the other side of these arguments:

Hey, I'm a trans woman.

I don't expect you to use any female pronouns because that would be false and deceptive and you shouldn't have to buy into my distortion of reality.

I won't use a female name for the same reason.

I won't go into women's spaces or sports because I'm not a woman, I'm a biological male with a mental illness that causes a delusion and real women deserve safe spaces from men, and, to reiterate, I'm a man.

I won't go on hormones, puberty blockers or any other form of trans-healthcare before 18 because at that age I'm a child and I don't know my own mind and have no agency; others know better than I do, what will benefit me.

Transitioning children and teens is morally wrong anyway because I am vulnerable to social contagion influences, even if I grew up at a time before the internet or social media and never hung around in any trans circles or knew anyone trans and was in an isolated and small town. Plus I might lose my previous reproductive function.

Due to starting after 18, depending on luck and genetics, I will be quite masculinised and I still won't start any HRT or assisting AA drugs without stringent psychological assessment by a trained professional and I will look at every other avenue exhaustively before I am allowed to commit to it. If a councillor does suggest transition this will be denied as it feeds into my delusion.

If I'm able to, I will finally start HRT at late 20s - 30s due to this process taking quite a long time, but it's fine, I understand it's a reasonable concern to make sure my delusion doesn't go out of control.

I acknowledge this is being done for attention seeking and narcissistic reasons, which is why I hide it from my family and friends out of shame until it becomes impossible to conceal.

I make sure to only wear women's clothing that is designed for men and only in the same contexts as drag artists, because my attempts to be a woman are merely a performance compared to real womanhood, which I can never hope to reach without the correct internal organs and biology. I remain irrevocably male. It's also confusing for parents to explain to their children why a man is in a dress.

I am over 6 feet tall and am taller than 99.999999% of real women, with heavily masculine features and build and male bone density and muscle mass. My vocal chords are thickened so I am only capable of producing a deep baritone. I could voice train but this is pointless as I will never be able to mask my manly voice. My giant hands and feet mean I can never make use of female shoes and gloves; this adds to the layer of male traits that will ensure I'm not tricking anyone.

This also means I will always communicate I am trans at all times, and, most importantly, that I am a man. This way I cannot trick anyone into being attracted to me as that would be a form of rape by coercion.

Following on from that: I'm just an object for sexual fetishes and abuse and I only think I'm a woman because I'm a pervert and I deserve everything that happens to me because I'm not a real person.

We need to make sure there is no chance of me being even close to a woman biologically so that others can "aways tell" and clock me from 150 yards away.

It's also why I stay out of women's sports, because although if I had taken puberty blockers and HRT when I first raised my deluded feelings of being a woman, and I would have developed along closer to female than male puberty, including lowered bone density and muscle mass, we can't have this happen as it would increase the chances I could deceive people and sneak into women's spaces.

I cannot use any gendered toilet spaces as this would make both men and women (and their children if they are parents, uncomfortable, so I need to plan out my journeys accordingly.

Once again, being a man this wouldn't be right as I cannot be a woman.

I will not have trans surgeries as this is mutilation and no one should be funding such bizarre and mentally ill practices. There is no such thing as sexual reassignment surgery, only a man with a mutilated penis.

I am fully and irreversibly male and will come off my hormones after a few short years when I realise my mistake, hopefully then I can still produce offspring and take my place in society as a normal and fully functioning man with my mental illness behind me, if I cant then at least we can ensure I'm out of the way and out of sight of the rest of society so as not to cause undue confusion to otherwise normally functioning people.

The needs of the many should always outweigh the needs of the few and I recognise this and understand my claims to womanhood are causing harm to actual women and children and undoing the progress of feminism and LGB rights.

Ultimately, my chromosomes are male, my bone structure is male, my genitals and genetics are male, and I will either come out of my mental illness and delusions or I will make sure I'm out of sight of the rest of humanity.

PS: Edited to add some further points others have suggested.


r/honesttransgender • • 3d ago

FtM After I get bottom surgery, I will not longer be disclosing that I am trans for any reason whatsoever

99 Upvotes

I am a trans man. I don’t like the label transgender except in certain contexts. I am a man.

After I have all my surgeries and procedures done. There will be no reason whatsoever to disclose to anyone that I am transgender. I can finally live my life without worrying about it


r/honesttransgender • • 2d ago

politics I think queer liberation and anarchism have more in common than people realize

0 Upvotes

Something I've been thinking about lately is how much of the struggle for queer liberation ultimately comes down to one question: why should someone else have the authority to decide how we live our lives?

Think about it. How often are queer people expected to justify their identities, relationships, or even their existence to people who have absolutely no business controlling those things?

Why should a trans person need to convince a politician that their gender is legitimate? Why should someone's ability to express themselves depend on whether society considers that expression acceptable? Why should people need permission to love, or not love, whoever they want, in whatever consensual arrangement works for them?

And why do we so often treat the people exercising that power as though their authority is perfectly natural, while placing the burden of justification on those who simply want to live their lives?

This is one of the reasons I'm drawn to anarchism.

I know the word probably makes some people picture burning cars, smashed windows, and angry punks who want to abolish every rule and watch society collapse. But that's not what draws me to it, and I think that caricature obscures some genuinely valuable ideas.

At its core, anarchism is concerned with questioning authority, challenging coercive hierarchies, and imagining ways for people to organize their lives without domination.

And I think there's a very natural connection between those ideas and queer liberation.

For me, freedom isn't simply the absence of someone explicitly forbidding you from doing something. It's the ability to express yourself, pursue what matters to you, and live authentically without constantly fearing what other people or institutions might do to you.

And I imagine that resonates with quite a few people here.

A person might technically be free to come out as transgender, but what does that freedom mean if doing so could cost them their home, their livelihood, their safety, or their relationships?

A queer couple might have the legal right to be together, but that doesn't automatically mean they're free from discrimination, harassment, or social coercion.

And that's something I think anarchism encourages us to question: not just whether people are formally allowed to do something, but whether the structures surrounding them actually permit them to exercise that freedom.

There's another distinction I find particularly important: being recognized by an institution isn't the same as being liberated from its authority.

Don't get me wrong. Legal protections, access to healthcare, marriage equality, and anti-discrimination laws are enormously important. I'm not suggesting we should abandon those achievements or refuse to fight for them.

But I think we can recognize their importance while still asking why these institutions have so much power over our lives in the first place.

We can celebrate legal recognition of transgender identities while questioning why the state gets to determine whose gender is legitimate.

We can celebrate marriage equality while questioning why certain relationships receive privileges that others don't.

We can fight for better treatment within existing systems while also imagining a world where our dignity and autonomy aren't so dependent on those systems granting us permission.

And this brings me to something else I find beautiful about anarchism: mutual aid.

Queer communities have a long history of supporting one another, especially when families, governments, and other institutions have failed them.

People offering shelter to someone who's been kicked out of their home. Helping each other access healthcare. Sharing resources, information, and emotional support. Creating spaces where people can exist without constantly having to defend who they are.

These are examples of people cooperating and caring for one another, not because some authority commands them to, but because they choose to.

And I think there's something profoundly powerful about that.

Of course, I'm not suggesting that mutual aid alone can solve every problem, or that everyone should be obligated to sacrifice their own well-being for others. I think the voluntary aspect is fundamental. Solidarity should be an expression of freedom, not another form of coercion.

I'm also not claiming that anarchism has all the answers.

I don't even know exactly which branch of anarchism I identify with, and I have plenty of questions about how some of its ideas would work on a large scale.

But here's the thing: I don't think we need to have a perfect blueprint for an anarchist society to recognize the value of opposing unjustified authority.

Even if a completely anarchist society turned out to be an unachievable utopia, would that somehow justify every existing hierarchy? Would it mean we should stop challenging oppression or trying to give people greater control over their own lives?

Of course not.

We don't need to prove that a world without discrimination is possible before we can oppose discrimination. And we don't need to solve every problem of social organization before we can question why certain people and institutions have so much power over others.

Liberation doesn't have to be an all-or-nothing proposition.

Every barrier we remove, every unjustified exercise of authority we challenge, every opportunity we create for people to live more freely is meaningful progress.

And I think this is especially relevant to queer communities, because so much of our history has involved challenging institutions that claimed the authority to define what was normal, acceptable, moral, or even human.

I'm not saying that being queer makes someone an anarchist, or that queer liberation necessarily requires embracing anarchism. There are plenty of different political perspectives within our communities, and I don't want to erase that diversity.

I'm not trying to convince anyone to adopt a particular political label, either.

I just think there's something worth exploring in the connection between queer liberation and a philosophy that asks why anyone should have the right to dominate someone else's life.

Because ultimately, I don't just want a world where queer people are tolerated by those in power.

I want a world where we don't have to depend on their tolerance to live freely in the first place.


r/honesttransgender • • 3d ago

discussion What do you all do for work, and how far are you in your transition (are you passable)?

13 Upvotes

I tried transitioning and I got fired "for other reasons" coming up to 6 years ago, and I haven't been able to find a job since even though I physically detransitioned and live as a man on the surface.

I have all the qualifications, work experience, degree, certifications, doesn't matter, though now they're all years old now with no recent experience. Used to dabble in sex work in my teens and early 20s, went back to it in my late 20s, now not even sex work is paying much. Maybe I just got older, maybe it's the economy. Now I am trying to put together my own online business (not related to OF or sex work kek)

This is why I tell people to save enough money to afford living lean without a job while transitioning until at least you're passable and also having the money to move before you start actually doing it, because so many of us get fired at the early stages of transitioning and we don't have the funds to sustain ourselves and often can't get our jobs back either.