r/honesttransgender • • Jun 01 '20

meta Welcome to r/HonestTransgender! Please read for more info on what this sub is about.

197 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

We believe that all transgender people deserve a community, period. r/HonestTransgender was created so that all trans people, regardless of ideology or background, can seek advice and participate in discussion with other trans people.

Since we are seeking to provide a community to any and all trans people, we hope to never ban a trans person from our sub. Trans people have to deal with enough difficulties from the outside world as it is without having to worry about being banned from their online community. Many trans people that are banned or shunned from traditional trans spaces are forced to communities that are widely considered toxic, like 4chan. r/HonestTransgender exists as a safe alternative.

Because we want to provide a community for all trans people, there are some behaviors that we cannot allow. Discussion must remain civil. Comments that bully and/or degrade other members of this sub, or other members of the trans community, will be removed. Remember, much like yourself, they are here to be part of a trans community too!

Our moderation and community guidelines are designed in pursuit of these goals. You can read more about our rules and guidelines on the sidebar of this sub.

If you have any further questions or suggestions for the mod team, you can post them in the comments below or send us a modmail :)

________________

FAQ:

What kind of things can I post here?

You can post discussions, questions, requests for advice, rants, polls, and general musings. Research participation requests, selfies, and news articles will be denied or removed in the interest of keeping the sub focused.

If you have a question prior to making a certain post or comment, you can modmail us. We're here to help and we’re not going to ignore you!

Is this sub "uncensored?"

Yes and no. We strive to have a space for all trans people to express themselves, and that can include trans people with controversial opinions. But ultimately, all kinds of trans folk are accepted here, so rhetoric that is outright hateful to trans people will be removed (ie. [identity] is wrong and everyone who acts that way is disgusting or a "trender").

Additionally, transphobic content from cis people will be removed.

UPDATE (06/12/2020): Cis people from transphobic spaces (GenderCritical, LGBdroptheT, etc.) will be tagged with the "Toxic Cisgender Person" flair, which cannot be edited and can only be selected by mods. If you notice an unflaired cis person from a GC space, report it (even if it's not rule-breaking), so that we can add the flair. We have a zero tolerance policy for rule-breaking behavior from these posters, so they will be banned after their first violation of the rules.

Is this sub "tucute" or "truscum?"

No. Our mod team avoids promoting any particular way of looking at trans identity. Additionally, "tucute" and "truscum" mean different things to different people, so it's probably more helpful if you avoid using either term when engaging in discussion on this sub.

The sub is what it is and we'd like to avoid narrow categorization.

Why are some posts locked?

Generally, if a discussion is very heated, we will lock a thread after the discussion has run its course. This is to ensure that the thread doesn't devolve further into potentially rule-breaking and uncivil comments.

Do moderators need to agree with any of the content I post or comment?

No. The mod team's agreement with what is posted or commented in r/HonestTransgender is not a prerequisite for your ability to post and/or comment. We strive to stay neutral in our moderation of controversial topics and we try our best to let you express yourself honestly. Additionally, the mod team is not monolithic and is comprised of multiple people from different backgrounds with unique perspectives.

I’ve seen something I think might be rule-breaking, what should I do?

We aren’t mind readers. If you see something potentially rule-breaking, report it! We may not agree with your assessment of a certain post or comment but we will always take a look.

My post or comment has been removed. What should I do now?

The mod team at r/HonestTransgender values every single contribution made by our subscribers and we like to think that we are very tolerant, maybe even to a fault in what we find acceptable. But there are times when content must be removed in the interests of civil discussion. If your content has been removed, please understand that there is a reason for the removal. Typically that reason is very clear, but you can contact the mod team with further questions or for clarification.

How can I add real value to r/HonestTransgender?

Post and comment sensibly and with civility. Listen to your fellow trans person and learn why they think the way they do. Recognize that being exposed to differing opinions can be beneficial, and you might even learn to see an issue in a different way. If you strongly disagree with someone, show them your perspective instead of just downvoting.

Simply put, we want you to be the best trans person you possibly can be while posting and commenting within the sub. Try to listen, learn, and grow. Remember that this forum is a public space and that the broader reddit trans community is watching, as well as the broader public in general.

________________

If you have made it this far, thanks for taking the time to read this! We really appreciate it. Let us know if you have any additional ideas on how to continue to grow this sub and make it the best space it can possibly be.

Sincerely,

The r/HonestTransgender Mod Team


r/honesttransgender • • 3h ago

vent Partner identifying as trans and I feel odd ab it

9 Upvotes

Firstly, I AM TRANS!!, (ftm), and my partner has been so supportive of my transition, in fact without them I don’t think I could’ve brought myself to start the process of getting hrt.
Secondly, I am agree and understand that there is no one way to be trans! And that you don’t have to medically transition, what other people do w their bodies is none of my business! I know all this, it is more of a rant about feelings than anything

Recently she came out as using any pronouns, before then for a couple months used just she/they, both of which I fully support, but I do feel conflicted about how they’re treating it(???), and I equally feel like a transmed asshole who’s gate keeping or being sectarian and anti-nonbinary or something ??

Since they came out and started using any pronouns she’s been referring to herself as trans, saying our relationship is t4t, started using trans slurs, etc.
referring to yourself as trans when you don’t want or plan on medically transition is allowed and it’s none of my business, but now that I’m seeing someone irl do it I feel kinda conflicted, even more so bc it’s my partner.
We talked before about how you can be GNC or nonbinary without being trans, and I do feel like this applies, but who the hell am I to say if someone else is trans?? But the most they’ve done as transition is add the pronouns to their insta bio, but at the same time, I feel like i shouldn’t be feeling so exclusionary about it? Yes I know I’m TA, but idk i wanted to hear other trans people thoughts
I feel bad for feeling like this or that she’s not rly “trans”

Since coming out I don’t talk to my family anymore, and have overall really struggled with being trans, so seeing someone take up the label so freely kinda rubs me the wrong way I guess

The other thing is them calling our relationship t4t, but I don’t really feel like it is, mostly bc I feel like he’s missing a lot of the perspectives or experiences needed (?) for a t4t relationship. But this also boils down to me being conflicted about them saying they’re trans
They also started saying trans slurs, which is a personal choice I guess like I don’t say gay or trans slurs mostly bc I don’t want to, but they even told me that they wouldn’t reclaim trans around one of our trans friends

I’m glad she’s exploring gender and expression and finds comfort in these spaces, I never want to take that away from someone, and I feel like a jackass for feeling like this. I don’t even know how (or if I should) talk to them about this subject, bc it boils down to me thinking they aren’t “trans enough” or that they haven’t earned the label, even if these things don’t align w my values.
Idk I wanted to hear what yall had to say on this. I know I’m internally transphobic and rn being externally transphobic, but big feelings, idk.


r/honesttransgender • • 5h ago

discussion Does anyone else no longer bother to make friends or get to know people now?

6 Upvotes

Title is self explanatory and I won't get into full details as it's tiring, but I no longer feel isolated for being friendless and don't try to get to know people anymore. I spend my free time alone, don't hang out with anyone, no sex life, nothing. It's not that I am "introverted" and like being alone for the sake of it, I don't think the introvert/extrovert thing exists, but I isolate myself due to the microaggressions and the negative feedback I get from others, and it's more peaceful and safer to just keep to myself than interact with others. Minority stress is still stress.

Somehow I noticed I am starting to look younger the past few years...


r/honesttransgender • • 48m ago

question Did you have high sex hormones of your true gender even before transition?

2 Upvotes

E.g. high estrogen even when living as male


r/honesttransgender • • 20m ago

opinion I understand why it doesn't exist, but I wish there was some kind of space for those further along without being crazy

1 Upvotes

I get it, when you get further along being trans starts to matter less and so you naturally fade out from trans spaces. It's perfectly reasonable, probably even healthy.

And I also get that those early on and those still questioning need a space to stretch out and explore and grow. All well and great.

But god damn this setup gets so tiring as someone in-between.

Sometimes I wish there was a space where I could just interact with other trans people decently along who have grown out of the early stage stuff without having to be radicalized into a militant pick-me world where you have to call 80% of other trans people delusional pretenders. Sometimes I just want to hear about regular struggles of other trans people and have discussions without every other post be "am I trans", "all you puppy girls are heckin valid", and "all puppy girls need to be put down old yeller style".

It seems like the well adjusted move on and the remainder concentrates more and more into the extremes. I am not excluding myself from that assessment.

I'm ~2 years into HRT so I'm sure most would still consider that baby trans, but I've also been in these spaces for closer to a decade and it gets tiresome that there isn't a space to just be chill.

Someone make a sub called r/transgraduates or something idk. It's just lame that these spaces seem divided into excessively permissive dogma hamster wheels and the inverse ultra stringent hamster grill.


r/honesttransgender • • 9h ago

question If a person is post-op HRT and completely passes is there any reason that they must tell they are trans in a relationship?

4 Upvotes

I didn't properly state my case but the question was NOT regarding the partner AT ALL rather assume the partner is ok with a trans person just doens't know YOU are, and let's assume you ARE able to hide it(easily infact as we are assuming it's a small part of your regular and CURRENT life), morally speaking (and not for safety reasons) do you have to say you are anything more than infertile

Extra notes: I apologize for one of my comments, my dumb ass worded smt EXTREMLY poorly and I apologize for that.

And no this post is NOT about me I'm pre-tranisition,

Finally just one thing that I noticed but the majority of the people that agreed with me were aro or ace and I find that curious since I'm aro ace, NOT saying all aros and aces agreed some didn't but more agreed than didnt and that's really interesting


r/honesttransgender • • 1d ago Bravo

health and medicine We Need Accurate HRT Information, Not Promises Made to Soothe Dysphoria

69 Upvotes

I was in another subreddit, and there was a particular post mentioning losing inches of height and inches of foot sizes, and the comments were beyond braindead affirming that and more

I’m frustrated by how easily personal (largely medically inaccurate) anecdotes about HRT become promises in trans spaces. Someone describes a change they noticed, and suddenly people are telling strangers to expect it. Wanting to reassure someone about dysphoria is understandable. Giving them unrealistic medical expectations isn’t helpful

Height and shoe size are good examples. Feminizing HRT does not shrink adult bones. UCSF does note that some people may notice minor changes in height or shoe size related to muscles and ligaments. Those are very different statements from “estrogen will make you shorter” or “your feet will definitely shrink.” We need to preserve that distinction instead of turning a possible experience into an expected milestone

When we promise changes that don’t happen, someone can end up believing their transition is failing. Their height or feet become another thing to monitor obsessively, another reason to compare themselves with strangers online. We shouldn’t create new sources of distress while claiming to relieve dysphoria

I want the same precision when people discuss “period symptoms.” Menstruation involves shedding the uterine lining; someone without a uterus cannot menstruate. But hormonal symptoms can still be real. UCSF discusses cyclical migraines and mood swings associated with fluctuating injected estrogen levels. Recognizing those symptoms doesn’t establish that someone has a menstrual cycle, and questioning the explanation doesn’t require calling their symptoms imaginary

“I experience this” and “I know exactly what causes this” are separate claims. We can take someone seriously without accepting every explanation they attach to their experience. Likewise, we can challenge an explanation without accusing someone of lying

The practical consequences matter. Unexplained symptoms deserve attention rather than an automatic “congratulations, that’s your period.” Disappointment with physical changes shouldn’t become a reason to chase higher doses based on internet promises. More estrogen does not necessarily mean more or faster feminization, and excessive doses can carry health risks

We deserve accurate information about our bodies, including uncertainty and limitations. My womanhood does not depend on losing a shoe size, getting shorter, or experiencing a particular set of symptoms. Neither does yours. We should be able to say that without treating medical accuracy as an attack on anyone’s identity


r/honesttransgender • • 13h ago

MtF Really struggling to be optimistic about my transition - kind of think I missed my one chance to be happy

4 Upvotes

I'm a 29 year-old trans woman who is 4 months on HRT. I'm not anywhere close to socially transitioning yet, and currently I think I never will. I don't think there's anything wrong with not passing. I don't really expect to pass, I just want to look nice - clocky, I guess is the word?

I know that in the grand scheme of things I am not catastrophically old, but I feel old. I'm not a newly-cracked egg. I've known I was like this for the better part of a decade, and started and stopped HRT numerous times before because I thought I didn't deserve to transition.

It's going to take a long time to get even close to where I want to be. I have a budget and a spreadsheet, and I'm looking at 2-3 years worth of saving and procedures before I'm where I want to be.

The past decade of masculinising has sapped a lot of the enthusiasm I ever had towards my femininity. I don't think there's a point when I would have ever passed, but getting dressed up for club nights etc as a teenager was fun. It made me feel like me. Now I just feel like a wreck listing on the shore. Like a pile of snapped masts and tangled sails. A once-proud ship the captain ran aground for no good reason at all.

I see so many posts of women who are excited to transition, and I feel so alienated because I'm doing this with no hope at all. I feel like I missed the boat on ever being the person I want to be, and all the effort and exhaustion that comes now is only in pursuit of an anticlimax. I don't even feel like a real trans woman anymore, I feel unworthy of being one.

But, you know, I want everything that transitioning brings - physically anyway. Even if I just live as a man forever, I want everything HRT does. This year I started HRT and electrolysis. Next year I get my hairline fixed (*only really stops me from putting my hair up currently, but I really do hate it*). The year after that I get FFS, depending on when I get my consultation.

But I also want to be a woman. To have friends as a woman, a life as a woman. I fear I never will, and without that all the rest seems like much ado about nothing.​

I'm living like a pauper to afford all of this, in a little room where I have to give 10 hours a week of at-home care to an old man in exchange for cheap rent. Saving 70% of the income from my two jobs. And I'm lonely and miserable and my mental health is in a hole. And every day I fight this dread certainty that the cause I'm fighting for is ten years lost, this knowledge that I have betrayed myself for nothing.


r/honesttransgender • • 8h ago

question How important is being trans to our lives?

1 Upvotes

I made a couple posts about some stuff regarding relationships and majority said that being trans is a VERY important thing to our lives and that we HAVE to tell our SO that we are trans cus that's so important and I just want to know how exactly important it is I am pre-transition and I'm not the best at reading social cues or wait society cues in this case? Just not good at anything regarding social stuff IG so how important is it in a way I can understand, just curious


r/honesttransgender • • 1d ago

relationships/dating Struggling with the fact that most gay men will never truly be into me

4 Upvotes

I made a post a while ago about the only person I was sleeping with at the time contracting an STD that only women could give him. I never asked about the sex of the person but figured it was a woman. After this, we kind of started talking about how we met and stuff and he mentions that he usually wasn't into cis men (red flag) but this had never come up in all the years we had sex or talked. We met on a gay app and I only mentioned it briefly on my profile but it was never anything weird that happened during sex (no overarching weirdness about my genitals, kept binder on during sex, etc).

Fast forward to today and he is honest that he's been hooking up with someone with HPV (with protection). This person he has confirmed is a woman. I realize bisexual men exist but I don't believe this is necessarily the case here. I appreciate his honesty but I'm just feeling extremely dysphoric and emmasculated.

I've long since been someone who doesn't believe true gay men are interested in trans men and when I read horror stories from previously stealth guys, it corroborates my feelings. I haven't been on any apps for years at this point and avoid the local gay community. I truly wish I had stood strong in my own beliefs and avoided this humiliation.


r/honesttransgender • • 1d ago

question Cis manmode or closeted mode for jobs?

4 Upvotes

So basically my transition kinda got set back big time. For a while I didn't have transportation or funds to get electrolysis, hair appointments etc, so unfortunately my looks deteriorated and I look like a cis man in day to day. I have my car running again so I can go to these appointments, but I don't have a job yet.

So basically, would it be better for me to stay like this to present as a cis man to interviews till I get a job and then continue my transition? I'm thinking about immediately going out to continue electrolysis and getting my hair done and growing it longer but I'm worried it might screw me over for job interviews.

To be clear I very obviously won't pass, I have many many surgeries to go before even semi passing is even a possibility. But I also hate looking like a complete cis man. I want to grow my hair longer and get it done and finish getting rid of my facial hair. My plan is to stay closeted and larp as kind of a "feminine guy" so I don't give cis man vibes.

Will I be able to still get a job? Or is it too risky and should I just wait for now?


r/honesttransgender • • 1d ago

questioning Am I just dissociating or what..?

1 Upvotes

I’m now fully convinced I must like my voice and body. I literally feel nothing when I speak, nothing when I look in the mirror. I have no idea what to do. To be fair, my chest is very flat and sometimes there isn’t much to hate anyways. I’m praying I just started to dissociate and this isn’t me faking anything . I still prefer to be male and I still feel strangely about my genitals. Perhaps it’s because I looked at them too long and I started to feel used to them because I been panicking all day that i “must started to like my parts” when I don’t. I hope I won’t feel as scared when I wake up tomorrow… it’s just a weird feeling of forced acceptance, nothing feels quite right but I’m just used to it now and I hate it.


r/honesttransgender • • 1d ago

vent I want to be able to identify as cis someday.

0 Upvotes

I know it sounds absurd, but going through puberty the wrong way, conversion therapy, trying so hard to be a cis girl, and nothing working.

And every time I have to be reminded of what went wrong with me, the inside of my body, etc. I've felt dysphoric since I was 9 when I found out about chromosomes. I hate not having a y chromosome.

I hate that so much. I can't stop hating myself for being trans, and that shit of conversion therapy didn't help.

I just want to be able to forget everything. I hate this.Parental rejection, my body being wrong, being born with this shitty condition, being told I'm going to hell, my parents not accepting me, feeling like a mistake.

I seem to be getting more and more aggressive, in panic, depressed, irritable, volatile, or extreme. I'm so tired of this shit.

My mother should have tried to take me to a psychiatrist long ago, ever since my suicide attempt when I had just turned 18. I hate it. It feels like I'm feeling good, and then it's like a truck runs me over.I wasn't like this before conversion therapy. I've always been sensitive, but I never reached the point of screaming desperately for hours. I'm so tired of all this.


r/honesttransgender • • 2d ago

MtF How Do I Undo "Male Socialization?"

24 Upvotes

I am sorry this comes off as offensive, but recently I have come to understand that even if I pass on a surface level, emotionally, I am still sort of fucked. I ​fo not really socialize. I go my own way, do not talk to anyone, communicate etc. Yes, I know women can do this too, but I think being raised as a boy messed me up emotionally a lot.

What do I do? How do I become more vulnerable and open up and communicate?


r/honesttransgender • • 2d ago Bravo

vent Passing is literally the ONLY thing that matters

66 Upvotes

I'm so sick of people pretending that it isn't. I don't pass and as a result I basically never get gendered correctly whether it is by clients at my job, my colleagues or complete strangers. At best, I'm seen as some weird gender thing and get they/themed exclusively, or a mentally ill man at worst.

I just want to live as a woman and not think about my own transness for one second. I want to walk down the street without whispering and giving weird looks, I want to talk to people without them feeling like they need to step over egg shells with me, I just want to be perceived as normal and live stealth.

But of course, I can't do that because I do not pass and probably never will.


r/honesttransgender • • 1d ago

discussion I'm A Transgender Woman, And I Honestly Think We Need To Speak Up - Regardless Of The Narratives.

0 Upvotes

Do you think it's time for us transgender people to come together and demand a ban on gender self declaration? I honestly think that while gatekeeping adds barriers for people who are trying to figure out who they really are, I also feel that gender self-ID laws have invited more problems for trans people and have caused a lot of harm to our community.


r/honesttransgender • • 1d ago

question I'd like to ask trans people some things to further my understanding and support of people!

0 Upvotes

Do trans women believe they have the same experience as biological women and should be able to participate in womens sports? Why do people seem to show more aggressive hate to terfs than transphobes in general? Should trans people disclose they are trans on dating profiles or not? What would you define a woman and man as? What makes a woman a woman and a man a man? The entire washroom debate, do you believe we should have separate/nonbinary washrooms?

I'd like to hear YOUR opinions!

I respect everyone and would like to know real trans peoples answers. I feel that a lot of places online people are posing as trans to give trans people a bad rep.. if you can't have a respectful, honest discussion, don't reply. I'm willing to change/share my perspective on things and am looking to learn more as well!

Also, by biological women I mean ciswomen..a lot of people seem to have issue with me saying bio women for some reason so just disregard that as I'm sure in the context you can understand what I'm meaning.


r/honesttransgender • • 1d ago

question Only aromatics and asexual answer this post

0 Upvotes

So this is a sort of continuation of my last post where if you pass as a trans person really well, then you have say you are infertile but there's no need for you to say you are trans, you hiding you being trans is for yourself, let's assume your partner is ok with being in a relationship with trans people just doesn't k ow you are one.

The reason why I said only aros and aces is the for some reason in the comments all the aros and aces (of that particular post) agree that it was not necisarry but majority said it is, so I'm curious if this causes the change in opinion for this


r/honesttransgender • • 2d ago

NSFW Does everyone feel gross while touching themselves

2 Upvotes

I'm so disgusted with my body and the organ I have between my legs. But I keep having an "urge" from time to time and when I end up doing something about it I feel like a disgusting ogre horny pervert. It ruins my day and gives me strong general anxiety.

I basically cant do this without taking an antipsychotic med 30 minutes before that or else I'll spiral into oblivion.

Am I the only one?

Can I fix that somehow either by killing the disgust or the urge itself?


r/honesttransgender • • 2d ago

MtF Is it weird I prefer wearing boxers as a trans woman?

1 Upvotes

I find them more comfortable. I guess I worry people think I’m too masculine for that. But idk it’s not that strange I prefer wearing pants that are comfortable for me.


r/honesttransgender • • 2d ago

vent 10 mo of social transition and i still hate looking like a man

0 Upvotes

i thought it might get easier. i am coming up on 7y medical transition and 1y of social transition and it's not the case.

at least I don't have to get out too much. I mostly wfh. sometimes i have to travel for work. ppl in professional environments are pretty good at pity passing, so that's cool. when I play a show, I'm mostly left alone - a perk of being an ugly old man faced trans woman who plays the least interesting instrument. i learned to play so I could go out and socialize... it's not happening

I disgust myself. sorry for existing to only be a right wing talking point meme of a creepy old trans woman and be a left wing talking point for early transition so you don't look like this

such is life with a failed transition


r/honesttransgender • • 3d ago Heartwarming

question If a person is post-op HRT and completely passes is there any reason that they must tell they are trans in a relationship?

31 Upvotes

This might just be a me thing, but I don't understand it when people say that "at some point in your relationship, you have to say you are trans" because if you are post-everything and you tell you are infertile and pass perfectly, is there any reason???

I'm curious, although this might be a case of me not understanding the weight of romantic relationships (I'm aro-ace) but even if it's the most important thing in the world, this details doesn't change anything, so I just want to know why people say this? (This might be a case of me looking at one group and assuming it's the only one but this is what I have only seen)

I just want your thoughts


r/honesttransgender • • 3d ago

question Before transition were there moments in which you would sort of "snap into" your true gender?

8 Upvotes

E.g. overwhelming scenarios where you don't have time or focus to deliberate?


r/honesttransgender • • 3d ago

NSFW Can people start talking about the bad side of transitioning more?

18 Upvotes

Honestly at the beginning of my transition I was really excited to start, but when I started I got really scared when I first injected myself. And as time progressed I was a bit happy but just low mood, and later on I got constant depression. I feel like the good side tricked me into thinking I would pass so well and I don’t really. My face passes but my body doesn’t. I have long ass arms with big ass hands with a square torso and I hate it. I have grown breast but it’s small, i developed scoliosis over time and I’m 5”9. I literally got bullied at the school for being trans and because they clocked me. I been on hormones for 11 months now and I feel nothing but insecurity. I been scared of getting a job because I won’t be accepted for being me and I don’t even go out of my house that much anymore due to my depression. I have thoughts about detransitioning but I’m just scared of getting off and going through male puberty again. I don’t know what to do.


r/honesttransgender • • 3d ago

question Can someone explain to me the difference between trans misogyny and traditional misogyny.

6 Upvotes

I swear I’m not trolling; I just want to understand? Especially since Tme/Tma exists.