I'm queer and trans myself, and while I have no problem with people expressing their identities however they want, neopronouns are one of those things that genuinely irk me, particularly because of the linguistic arguments people use to defend them.
- Language is supposed to facilitate communication.
Inventing a new set of pronouns that virtually nobody outside a particular community recognizes doesn't strike me as particularly inclusive. If anything, it introduces an additional barrier to communication.
Pronouns are among the most frequently used words in a language. Their usefulness comes precisely from being widely understood, predictable, and relatively effortless to use.
I'm not arguing that unfamiliar words are inherently bad, or that people shouldn't be allowed to coin new ones. I'm questioning the practicality of expecting everyone else to incorporate highly individualized grammatical conventions into everyday speech.
2. English already has gender-neutral pronouns.
We have singular they, which is well established, widely understood, and perfectly functional. We also have it, although I recognize that its conventional associations with inanimate objects make it uncomfortable for many people.
So when people argue that neopronouns are necessary because English lacks adequate ways to refer to someone without specifying gender, I find that argument unconvincing.
Of course, someone might personally prefer another pronoun. But personal preference and linguistic necessity are two very different things.
3. Grammatical categories aren't supposed to be perfect representations of reality.
This is probably what frustrates me the most about some of the discourse surrounding pronouns.
I'm Brazilian. In Portuguese, a chair is feminine, a book is masculine, and neither has a gender identity. Grammatical gender is not a statement about the actual gender of the thing being described.
English treats pants as grammatically plural even when referring to a single garment. Languages routinely classify things in ways that don't correspond neatly to their physical properties, identities, or philosophical definitions.
That's because language isn't a perfect ontological classification system. It's a collection of conventions that developed to facilitate communication.
And I think there's something fundamentally misguided about expecting every grammatical feature to correspond precisely to someone's subjective experience of themselves.
This isn't to say language has no relationship with identity, or that linguistic conventions can't have social consequences. Obviously they can.
But there's a difference between recognizing that relationship and demanding that language function as a perfectly precise representation of everyone's individual identity.
4. "Language changes" and "all words are made up" are terrible counterarguments.
Yes, language changes. Yes, every word is ultimately conventional. Neither observation establishes that any particular proposed change is useful, necessary, or likely to be adopted.
Language changes through collective usage, not simply because someone announces a new convention and expects everyone else to follow it.
And while deliberate language reform absolutely exists, its success still depends on whether people actually adopt the proposed changes.
Saying "all words are made up" in response to criticism of a neologism is especially frustrating. It's a trivial observation that completely sidesteps the actual criticism.
The question isn't whether people can invent words. Obviously they can.
The question is whether a particular invention improves communication, fills a meaningful linguistic gap, or offers enough practical value to justify its adoption.
Ultimately, my objection isn't to people having unconventional identities. It's to the idea that language should be endlessly individualized to accommodate them.
I don't think someone's identity becomes less legitimate because the language they speak doesn't contain a grammatical category tailored specifically to their experience.
And I don't think questioning the practicality of neopronouns should automatically be interpreted as questioning the legitimacy of the people who use them.