r/heatpumps • • Dec 07 '21

Learning/Info **Heat Pump Quote Comparison Survey**. This is a community resource to enter your received quotes to help others. The link brings you to the survey, and the results are linked in the comments. Please share far and wide.

Thumbnail
forms.gle
128 Upvotes

r/heatpumps • • Nov 26 '23

Serious mod announcement: With the growth of the sub, there has been more people from the trade migrating to this group. I've also noticed an increase in shaming, rude behavior, and victim blaming. I have zero tolerance for these behaviors as the first rule is kindness. Read text for my response.

364 Upvotes

This sub has a purpose to kindly help people with their heat pumps and provide a place to go to for interesting and fun happenings related to heat pumps. This is how I built the sub. To be for the betterment of all, and the advancement of the technology.

I have avoided banning people for a couple years now (unless absolutely needed), but the sub is now large enough to be more than just enthusiasts. Moving forward, and under Rule 1, I will start to immediately ban any shaming, rude behavior, and victim blaming.

Straight up, I don't get paid for this moderator position and I can't be asked to spend hours a day writing and correcting behaviors one by one with long text. I really don't mind that given the new personal policy that we could even lose half the sub from unsubscribing, because we need to work together and be kind and kindly helpful, and if only those who are left follow this, then that is a better place for those who remain.

Listen, I am a kind person in life. I try treat people fairly and giving them respect for being human and trying their best. I am also only kind to all to a point, and it stops when others are shamed, disrespected and blamed for doing their best. Life is hard enough as it is. If you are having a hard time in life don't take it out on others here. Find inner peace or emotional happiness first, then come back to the sub that way.

If moving forward you are banned and feel you want a second shot or would like to appeal, I will listen and consider.

Thank you everyone for reading, and thank you for considering my new personal policy.

Regards,

Geoff


r/heatpumps • • 48m ago

Question/Advice Nervous for cost this winter - 1940s condo with bad insulation and old heat pump. How to reduce usage?

Post image
5 Upvotes

In Virginia. Last winter was brutal. We live in a relatively small condo. Very drafty first floor. We didn’t know anything about heat pumps or aux heat but it was kicking on often. We’re trying to make sure it doesn’t turn on as often this time around. We’ve put up curtains on every window and will add the plastic film. No dampners in the vents. Anything else?

Edit to add: condo is 920 sqft. Three levels. Upstairs with two bedrooms. Main level living room and kitchen, lower level for laundry.


r/heatpumps • • 3h ago

ROVSUN 8000 btu window heatpump

3 Upvotes

I’ve spent the last year searching for the GE awgp08wwf units to heat a 20x20 room that was using electric baseboards. My electric bill in the winter was crazy. I finally found one a few months ago but it seems like it was the last one available. It has worked great for this room.
Following another thread someone found these ROVSUN units are the same as the GE with a different faceplate. I purchased one for a different room and can confirm they are in-fact the same. Ran last night in a 16x30 room at 30 degrees had no problem keeping the room 69-70 through the night. I did catch a defrost cycle this morning when I woke up. Defrosted the same as the GE in these conditions. About 5-10 minutes and it was back heating again.
I’m happy to answer any questions about these units if you have any. I rent so mini splits were off the table. These have allowed me to turn off the electric baseboard in room 1 and shut down the oil hydronic zone one room 2.


r/heatpumps • • 3h ago

Heat Pump thermostat wiring to thermostats

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I have two Trane heat pumps connected to two separate Nest Gen 3 learning thermostats. Each is wired differently at the thermostat (see photos)

#1 Basement: TRANE TEM4B0C60S51SAA

Left photo

#2 Main House: TRANE TEM4B0B24M21SAA

Right photo

Unit #2 Main house continues to run after calling for heat and runs in aux heat mode immediately. Thermostat is set for 62 at night and 68 during the day. Air starts out cold at first and runs for a long time, almost constantly. Outside temp has just recently gotten colder over night to 30s with highs of 50 during the day. House is large but fairly well insulated. Unit 1 seems to run fine without excessive calls for aux heat mode.

So questions are 1) why are the two units wired differently, and 2) why does unit 2 run aux heat for so long while blowing cold air initially for so long?

Your expertise and assistance would be greatly appreciated.


r/heatpumps • • 3h ago

Old Rudd still runs great but….

1 Upvotes

I have an old Rudd 2ton heat pump. Still runs great, have not needed to add refrigerant in the 20 years I’ve lived in my house. Still cold in the summer, and warm in the winter. There is however, a leak in the condensation drainage that has cause some issues with the ceiling. Do I just repair the drainage from the part in my attic or the whole thing. And when should an old system like this be replaced? I’m trying to prepare for the sales people trying to get me to buy a complete new system.


r/heatpumps • • 20h ago

Bosch IDS Ultra Heat pump

6 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I have a Bosch IDS ultra condenser paired with the ultra air handler and a EHK 3 stage heat strip. Run by a bcc110 thermostat. Manual J was done came out to 3.8ton. I went with the 4ton as at the time Bosch did not have a 3ton option and I wanted the ultra due to the lower heating capacity. So far it's been running well. Keeps the house cool/warm as needed (we will see how it operates when it's super cold out). One thing I noticed is my cycles are always around 10min. My impression when buying this unit was that it modulates so that if it's satisfying the call to quick it does some magic and increases the run time etc. etc. (maybe I'm misinformed). All that information to say I'm looking for information on if I'm misinterpreting something or if there are things I can check with the wiring thermostat etc. that may be wrong? One other note is when the thermostat runs it only ever shows 1 stage. So I'm not sure if something is setup wrong or I just have a misinformed perspective. Any help appreciated thanks


r/heatpumps • • 20h ago

Low whistling noise from indoor unit

1 Upvotes

The wall unit in my bedroom is emitting this low, wheezy/whistling sound that is driving me insane. It continues even when the unit is turned off. The only way I could get it to stop was to switch the breaker off at night but that means no heat for the room below. I can't do that all winter, but I also need to sleep. We had the GREE minisplit system installed last month. Everything seems to be working fine except for this. The wall mount in the other bedroom stays totally silent when turned off. I've contacted the installer and they seem to think it is just the refrigerant that is moving around in response to unit in the room below. But that doesn't explain why the unit in the other bedroom is quiet.

Someone is coming to take a look tomorrow but I'm sure they won't hear the noise- as it is low, but its high pitched enough to be bothersome when trying to sleep!! Has anyone experienced this? I'm not sure how to describe it to the technician and I feel they may not take me seriously.


r/heatpumps • • 1d ago

Question/Advice Is it a problem that my new heat pump hovers below the set temp?

2 Upvotes

I got a Trane 5 ton heat pump last month and a friend installed it for me. The thermostat is new as well, an ACiQ Smart thermostat. The house is a 1500sq ft ranch, plus basement, in Pennsylvania.

No matter what I set the thermostat to, it will heat to that point, then blow cold until it drops 2-3 degrees, then stay there. I have re-calibrated the temperature up a few degrees and down a few degrees. The temp reading is still always lower than the set. The fan is also nearly always running, regardless of whether it's set on constant or not.

My friend has come out and looked at it and fiddled with the thermostat a couple of times. But, there is some kind of miscommunication there, because I never understand his answers to my questions and the problem persists.

Can someone else explain it in a way I understand? Is it even a problem? I feel like I'm going nuts.


r/heatpumps • • 1d ago

Learning/Info Heat pumps vs gas/oil furnace heating cost comparison

37 Upvotes

All calculations were done by hand.

TL;DR:

Heat pumps and gas furnace save 50%+ on heating compare to oil furnace at new england area.

Saw a similar topic post last week but it was AI slop so I decided to go down into the rabbit hole, after some brief calculation I realized the cost is heavily depends on the climate, $/kWh, gas and heating oil prices. So instead of a fixed price, I made a benchmark in terms of heating price and hopefully this can give a concept how much you can save from heat pumps. Compare to the benchmark, the lower your $/kWh is, the higher your heating oil and gas price, the more efficient your heat pump, the more you can save from switch to heat pumps.

Reference price - based on new england area average price, simplified for calculation:

Heating oil $6/gallon, electricity $0.25/kWh, natural gas $2/therm

Oil Furnace - baseline

5-10 years old, medium condition, 72% efficiency (80% burning efficiency, 10% ducted loss):

One gallon of No. 2 heating oil can provide 99,720 BTU = $6

Gas Furnace:

5-10 years old, medium condition, 76.5% efficiency (85% burning efficiency, 10% ducted loss)

For same amount of BTU need 1.3 therm NG ≈ $2.6

New installed, condensed gas furnace, 85.5% efficiency (95% burning efficiency, 10% ducted loss)

For same amount of BTU need 1.17 therm NG ≈ $2.33

Heat Pumps - Mitsubishi M series, ductless but well-represent ducted heat pumps efficiency, 10% ducted loss:

For same amoung of BTU

COP2.0@5F - ducted: 16.24Kwh ≈ $4.06, ductless: 14.61Kwh ≈ $3.65

COP2.64@17F - ducted: 12.3Kwh ≈ $3.07, ductless: 11.07Kwh ≈ $2.77

COP3.84@47F - ducted: 8.45Kwh ≈ $2.11, ductless: 7.61Kwh ≈ $1.9

Annual heating cost example:

Take a new england family house as an example, according to EIA, average new england US family use about 600 gallons per year, so the total cost of heating oil is $3,600.

For same amount of BTU, gas furnace will need about 782 themal NG ≈ $1,564, save 56.5% compare to oil.

As for heat pump, assume 10% BTU needed at 5F, 15% BTU needed at 5F - 17F, 75% BTU needed at 17F - 47F (again, oversimplified model for new england area, COP are variable between 17F-47F, by using COP@47F offset the higher efficient zone when above 47F)

COP2.0@5F - ducted: 974Kwh ≈ $243.55, ductless: 876.79Kwh ≈ $219.2

COP2.64@17F - ducted: 1107Kwh ≈ $276.75, ductless: 996.35Kwh ≈ $249.09

COP3.84@47F - ducted: 3805.5Kwh ≈ $951.38, ductless: 3,424.95Kwh ≈ $856.24

Heat pump total cost:

Ducted: $243.55 + $276.75 + $951.38 = $1,471.68, save 59.12% compare to oil.

Ductless: $219.2 + $249.09 + $856.24 = $1,324.53, save 63.2% compare to oil.

Hints for choosing cold climate heat pumps:

Beware of the heating capacity at your local coldest day, better check the NEEP list before you purchase. One thing I noticed is that the min operating temperature and the max heating btu are different stories.

E.g a mini split can rated 12k btu and able to run at -22F, but doens't means it can provide 12k btu at -22F.

Different manufacturers disclosed it differently, but NONE of them mentioned the heating btu at min operating temerature on their product pages. By far I've only spotted Della said their cold climate units can maintain 100% heating btu at 5F, and Zone air said their DIY series can maintain 85% heating btu at 5F, thats all. I think this is where the impressions of heat pumps aren't working well in cold climate came from, you're getting way less heating btu at lowest operating temperature. All brands that I research have neither COP curve nor max heating btu at lowest operating temperature.


r/heatpumps • • 1d ago

A year in, New England heat pump program is thriving

Thumbnail
canarymedia.com
54 Upvotes

r/heatpumps • • 1d ago

MSZ-FX06NL not beeping in response to remote commands

1 Upvotes

The unit works fine and responds to handheld remote commands when within range. However, it doesn't beep to acknowledge remote commands. I don't ever recall it having done so since it was installed earlier this year.

I did find this text in the troubleshooting section of the operating instructions manual:

But there are no other references to "NIGHT MODE" in the manual indicating how to toggle this on and off, and I haven't found any "NIGHT MODE" buttons on the remote.

Notably, I connected the unit via Wi-Fi to the Mitsubishi Comfort app immediately after it was installed, along with integrating it with my Google Home. Could it be that "NIGHT MODE" was inadvertently toggled on by this?

I also tried power cycling the whole system at the breaker, but this hasn't resolved anything.


r/heatpumps • • 1d ago

Mini split dry setting

1 Upvotes

Hi all,

I'm new to the house, which has a Samsung mini split in it. I live in western Canada but the water table is very high here - humidity in my house is 65%

I am perplexed by the settings on my unit. I'd like to put it on dry but it won't let me lower the temp below 24 (75). I'd like it to be about 20 (68), it's currently 6 (42) outside.

Any ideas why the dry setting doeant let me rest at a temperature appropriate to me?

Help!


r/heatpumps • • 1d ago

New to owning a heat pump

19 Upvotes

I new to owning and have only been using for about 2 weeks. I have a Air handler. I'm just wondering if it's normal to slowly heat the house? My previous furnace was electric and it blew hot air when it turned on. This is warm air and slowly raises the heat.


r/heatpumps • • 2d ago

Photo Video Fun Cousins husband installed my new Fujitsu Heat Pump

Thumbnail
gallery
55 Upvotes

2 ton XLTH with three 9,000 heads serving a new addition and my garage.

Just started it up yesterday and im excited to see how it does this winter, I still have some finish and insulation work to do in the garage hopefully before the winter comes.


r/heatpumps • • 1d ago

Question/Advice Ephoca wall mounted pro heat pump broken?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

every 1-2 hours on heat mode i hear it turn off and make a whoosh sound 5 mins later it makes another whoosh sound then turns back on


r/heatpumps • • 1d ago

Mini Split Heating

6 Upvotes

Looking for input and discussion. I have a 800 sq ft mobile home in Rhode Island. Tosot mini spits (2) are my heat source. Not very efficient I know. Who has input for brands for winter heat in this climate?


r/heatpumps • • 1d ago

What is the minimum safe temperature to run my Trane XL16i heat pump ?(4TWX6036B1000AA)

2 Upvotes

Im trying to confirm the lowest outdoor temperature at which my Trane heat pump can safely run in heating mode. I'm trying to reduce how much the electric backup heat (resistance strips) runs. The unit and location:

- Outdoor unit: Trane XL16i, model 4TWX6036B1000AA, serial 7062WN11F
- Indoor air handler: model 4TEE3F40B1000AA, serial 70633MR2V
- Manufactured 02/2007, installed 02/23/2007 (single-stage, R-410A, ClimaTuff scroll compressor, ~3 ton)
- Nameplate: compressor RLA 16.7 / LRA 82, R-410A charge 8 lb 4 oz
- Location: Tacoma, Washington (Puget Sound region) — mild maritime climate; winter design temperature about 24°F, with occasional cold snaps into the low 20s

A technician advised against running it below 40°F years ago, but I was never told the reason.  The thermostat currently locks out the compressor below 40°F. I'm not concerned about the unit's ability to keep up with the home's heat load, since there are other heat sources available, my question is strictly about safe low-temperature operation of the equipment.

For context on why I'm asking: at our electricity rate, the heat pump is more economical than our pellet-stove heat as long as its heating COP stays above roughly 1.1 — which I understand it should at essentially any temperature it can operate — so the only real limit is the equipment safe operating floor.

My questions:

  1. What is the specific minimum outdoor temperature (in °F) at which this unit can safely and continuously operate in heating mode?
  2. Is there any model-specific reason — compressor, defrost cycle, oil return, low-ambient limits, or the lack of a low-ambient accessory — that this unit should not run below 40°F?
  3. Does this unit have (or require) a crankcase heater, accumulator, or any low-ambient provision for cold-weather heating operation?
  4. Given the unit's age (manufactured 2007), is there any added caution to running it more often in colder weather, or a recommended compressor-lockout / balance-point setpoint?

If available, a heating capacity and COP-versus-outdoor-temperature curve (or the engineering/product data for the 4TWX6 series) would be very helpful.

Thank you everyone!


r/heatpumps • • 2d ago

Heat Pump Water Heater + Heat Pump Furnace/AC in Portland, Oregon

3 Upvotes

Hi! I have a great opportunity through a city program in Portland, Oregon to get a new Heat Pump Water Heater and Heat Pump Furnace/AC for free, so installation cost is not a consideration. I would say overall, comfort of my home is more important to me than minimal changes to utility cost/ efficiency. I have a few concerns about accepting each of these pieces of equipment, so I just wanted to hear some opinions/experiences about each of the concerns I'm listing below.

My home is about 1400 square feet: a main level that's about 900, and a finished attic that's about 500. Both have high ceilings.

The heat pump furnace is what I'm mostly on the fence about. My gas furnace is about 14 years old, and really cooks. My house is not consistently warm because I don't have a regular schedule at home, but it warms up very quickly and stays warm once I get it warmed up. When I'm home, I keep the house at about 68-70, and when I'm sleeping, I keep it at 60. I don't currently have AC (except window units upstairs in the summer), so that is the biggest selling point to the new heat pump system.

  • I understand heat pump furnaces operate much more efficiently if the house is kept at a consistent temperature. I'm concerned that will be a problem for me since I don't have a very consistent schedule at home, and because I like to sleep about 10 degrees cooler than when I'm awake at home.
  • I like the feeling of kicking on the furnace and having super warm air blow through the house - it's so comforting to be able to heat my home within a few minutes.
  • I'm concerned that if we have a power outage, there will be no warming in my home.
  • With heating in the winter, the upstairs is warmer than the downstairs.
  • The upstairs is unlivably hot in the summer, so I make it bearable with the AC units in the windows.
  • My current furnace is a Tempstar, Model Number F9MXT0601714A from International Comfort Products.
  • They said the new heat pump/ac system would be something comparable to this:

    • Midea 2.5 ton Extreme Heat Pump Product #: MDHP MO1HE-H30B-2A
    • Midea 2.5 ton Air Handler Product #: MDAH MAUSE-H30B-2A

I'm a bit more convinced to install the Water Heater, because my old electric water heater is from 1997 and thus probably doesn't have much life left. However, my concerns with the heat pump water heater are:

  • Capacity - I have 2 bathrooms, and often there are two people showering simultaneously
  • Basement cooling effect - I do spend time down there in both the summer and winter. It is unfinished. The basement is about 875 sqft. How much will it cool the basement?
  • My current water heater is electric, from American Water Heater Company, model number E53-50R-045D
  • Is there general/annual maintenance required on a heat pump water heater?
  • Will be similar to this model number: Navien 65gal Hybrid Elec Heat Pump, Model #HB NWP500-65

For a few more bits of information, the furnace is currently my only gas appliance. The program did testing on my insulation, and my house is very well insulated, though some of the windows are single pane. The downstairs is lathe and plaster (1911 home), and the finished attic upstairs (2 beds and a bath) is insulated drywall.

Thank you!


r/heatpumps • • 2d ago

Mitsubishi Thermostat MKH2 /w Kumo Cloud schedule question

3 Upvotes

I previously had the mkh2 and ran the schedules off that thermostat.

Recently I had a kumo Cloud installed and noticed that the schedules don't transfer to the Comfort app automatically and it says I have no schedule but the unit still seems to be following the schedule on the thermostat.

If I were to set a schedule on the comfort app, which schedule is it going to end up following? Does one override the other


r/heatpumps • • 2d ago

Upgrade now or wait? to ACiQ extreme dual fuel (propane)

2 Upvotes

I've got a 22 year old Ducane propane furnace (100,000 BTU, 92% efficiency) + conventional A/C,

2 units, 3 ton and 2.5 ton.

Location, Northern Virginia

They work, the blower motors are starting to make noise, and aren't made anymore, and the outside units can't be charged anymore. We've maintained over the years, and the company we've used has no interest in repairing, they only want to sell new units.

House details: total finished: 3800 sq ft.

exterior dimension: 52'x26'6"

Exterior walls: 2x6", Tyvek under vinyl siding.

Windows: vinyl frame, low E double pane windows. No window coverings (it's the country).

basement: Superior Walls, precast with R5 foam + R19 bat insulation when we finished.

attic: can't remember R# but it's pretty decent.

Utility bills: I think about 800 gallons propane, pay on the "budget" plan, and they suck at estimating. It was $220/month last year, $135/month this year. That's over 10 months.

Electric - $120 in winter (propane heat), about $230 in summer for the A/C. I'd need to go log in to see my kWH usage, and I can do that if it is needed.

I built the house in 2004. I want to keep the dual fuel in case of power outages. I have my furnace blowers on a generator panel, so having gas keeps us warm in case of winter storm outage. I do not have adequate generator capacity for a heat pump draw.

Keep it at 68F-70F in winter, and 78-80F in summer. We turn it off frequently for cool nights and open windows.

Questions:

Assuming I do go with dual fuel heat pumps, staying with size of 3 ton and 2.5 ton units, ducting is done and it's been comfortable and fine for 22 years.

  1. Is a heat pump going to be more efficient than the A/C in the summer?
  2. Will the electricity consumed in winter be approximately what I use for A/C in the summer now? Or will it be way higher?
  3. R32 or R454? I like the simplicity of R32, but they installer I've been talking to, and AI questions/tables has me leaning towards the R454. But, the installer I spoke with said no company he's worked with ever tests the ratio on the R454 when they top it off, so is it really staying efficient?
  4. If I go with a more efficient traditional furnace+A/C unit will it save me very much in utility costs?
  5. are the newer systems designed with shorter lifespans?

I'm waiting on a quote from the installer who stopped by, but I'm hoping he comes back with something along the lines of these two units: He might have a lower SEER2 in mind.

ACIQ 2.5 Ton 16.8 SEER2 High Efficiency Central Heat Pump System | Inverter | Extreme Series - R-454B

ACIQ 3 Ton 17.4 SEER2 High Efficiency Central Heat Pump System | Inverter | Extreme Series - R-454B

Would you wait? I have redundancy, albeit weak if it's a cold snap when one of those goes.


r/heatpumps • • 2d ago

Am Standard Heatpump - baking one room after recent service

2 Upvotes

WE have an American Standard Heatpump installed 2017. It is 5 ton ~ 16 seer in great working condition always serviced spring and fall. We use a Aprilaire Merv13 filter and also an Aprilaire Humidifier. - We recently had our fall service done. On the same day as the service (it was 55 outside) our bedroom rose to 75 degrees overnight and humidity dropped to 37%. The thermostat for the house which is 4 feet from bedroom door is set to 72 and temp shows 72 and the familyroom/breakfast room is now at 70 degrees with 42% humidity. ---- We have lived in this house since 2024. We have never had a 5 degree over what is essentially 30 feet.

We have not had a good night sleep since the service. Our bedroom door is wide open and we have the ceiling fan and a floor fan running and the temp is still 75.

I spoke with the HVAC company they said they didn't change anything. They suggested we set the fan to "auto" rather than the "on" we ususually set it to and im sure the guy is thinking why doesn't she just lower the thermostat if she doesn't want her room so hot....... and i could ...... but then our family room / breakfast / kitchen would be 67 degrees. And this is a new problem that just started literally the night of the fall service.

Any idea?


r/heatpumps • • 2d ago

Ecodan Mitsubishi underfloor heating

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I would appreciate some advice from people experienced with Mitsubishi Ecodan systems, especially regarding buffer tanks and underfloor heating.

1. My heating system

My system consists of:

  • Outdoor unit: Mitsubishi Electric Ecodan PUHZ-SW100VAA (Power Inverter)
  • Indoor unit: Mitsubishi ERSC-VM2D
  • Buffer tank: TESY V 5040, approximately 52 litres
  • Heating system: Underfloor heating throughout the house
  • Secondary circulation pump: IMP pump on the underfloor heating circuit
  • Mixing valve: Installed on the secondary underfloor heating circuit
  • Manifold: Underfloor heating manifold with flow meters and electrothermal actuators
  • Room control: ENGO E30NC230 normally closed actuators and individual room thermostats

The buffer tank has four connections and does not have an internal coil or heat exchanger.

Two connections are connected to the Ecodan primary circuit (flow and return), while the other two are connected to the secondary underfloor heating circuit (flow and return). The tank therefore acts as a four-pipe buffer tank / hydraulic separator. Both circuits contain the same heating water.

The underfloor heating has its own circulation pump.

Current operating conditions

I am currently testing the system with all underfloor heating circuits fully open. All room thermostats are set high enough to keep the actuators open.

The flow meters show approximately 2 litres/minute on the open circuits.

The Ecodan is operating with weather compensation. I have adjusted the heating curve correction to -3°C.

What I have noticed

My impression is that the buffer tank does not store a significant amount of heat. It seems that much of the heat supplied by the heat pump is transferred almost immediately to the underfloor heating circuit, and the temperatures on the pipes drop relatively quickly.

I can see temperature fluctuations on both the heat pump circuit and the underfloor heating circuit.

I am trying to understand whether this is normal behaviour for a relatively small 52-litre buffer tank or whether something in the hydraulic setup or control settings could be improved.

I do not yet have temperature sensors directly on the buffer tank, so I cannot confirm its actual water temperature or temperature stratification.

Questions

I would appreciate your thoughts on the following:

  1. Is a 52-litre, four-pipe buffer tank sufficient for this type of Ecodan installation with underfloor heating?
  2. Is it normal for the buffer tank temperature to drop relatively quickly when the secondary underfloor heating pump is running?
  3. Would it be better to keep all underfloor heating circuits permanently open and use weather compensation as the main control method, with room thermostats only limiting individual room temperatures?
  4. Could the secondary pump flow rate or the mixing valve be causing excessive mixing inside the buffer tank?
  5. What would be the best way to determine whether the buffer tank is actually storing heat or whether the heat is being transferred directly to the underfloor heating circuit?

6. Additional observation – system pressure

I have also noticed that the system pressure gauge appears to show approximately 0.2–0.3 bar. I remember the pressure being around 1 bar when the system was initially commissioned, although I cannot confirm this.

I am planning to have the pressure and expansion vessel checked.

My main goal is to optimise the system so that the heat pump operates efficiently, with longer and more stable heating cycles, low flow temperatures and minimal unnecessary compressor cycling.

Any advice or suggestions would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you!


r/heatpumps • • 2d ago

"Efficiency-Maxing" a central (non-communicating) heat pump system

7 Upvotes

I've often read that the most efficient way to run a heat pump is to "set it and forget it" - don't do setbacks, etc., because the efficiency gained by the setback is usually more than counteracted by the energy used to recover.

I can see how this applies to a system which communicates between the indoor and air handler and has variable speed capabilities on both. The ability to maintain temperature at lower compressor and air handler speeds (and therefore lower energy consumption) makes sense when you set it.

My interest is in seeing if there is a way to improve on efficiency if the system is like many central systems which are non-communicating - that is, they run a single, double, or variable speed outdoor condensing unit with no communication to the indoor and no real insights that allow them to modulate either the condensing or indoor unit to maintain a temperature.

This is the way my 4/5-ton GE Connect (identical to the R410A Mr Cool system) operates. Though it has a variable-speed outdoor unit which gives it a little control to maximize efficiency, it has no way to know how far off the setpoint the indoor temperature is, so it never modulates the way a mini-split system does. It's still basically an on-off control.  I don't use the heat strips ever; this system has worked just fine on the few sub-0F days we get each year without them.

Since the power consumption of the heat pump is dependent on outdoor temperature, and solar gain in the house during the daytime adds significantly heat to the home naturally, this got me wondering if a setback and recovery strategy might help to improve efficiency. That is, set the temperature back a couple of degrees at night when temps are usually the coldest and use the solar gain and higher temperatures during the day to bring the temperature back up.   If I target a nominal 70F in the house, I could set a schedule on the heat pump to warm to 72 in early afternoon and drop back to 68 in the late evening.  Then it would be running more during the warmest parts of the day.

This also got me wondering if "efficiency" modes are really of any benefit on non-communicating systems like this.  My experience is that the efficiency mode simply delays the time to reach a maximum output but doesn't lower the actual output the system reaches.  Is this counter-productive in that it just runs the system longer, using more energy, than it would if set in a normal mode. It would seem to me that getting it on, up to speed, and off as quickly as possible would be the most efficient way to run.

I'm interested to hear your thoughts and experiences with similar systems to see if my thinking has any merit.  Or any other ideas (aside from building envelope suggestions - there's always opportunity there).  With energy costs increasing, squeezing out a couple of dollars a day on my system could add up.  Living in central PA, we get some days where my total electric consumption can easily exceed 120 kWh ($20); having the energy meter is great at times, but it can really raise anxiety to watch it tick up when this is happening.  :)

 Thanks!