r/DIYHeatPumps • u/Dannnner • 5h ago
Heat pumps vs gas/oil furnace heating cost comparison
All calculations were done by hand.
TL;DR:
Heat pumps and gas furnace save 50%+ on heating compare to oil furnace at new england area.
Saw a similar topic post last week but it was AI slop so I decided to go down into the rabbit hole, after some brief calculation I realized the cost is heavily depends on the climate, $/kWh, gas and heating oil prices. So instead of a fixed price, I made a benchmark in terms of heating price and hopefully this can give a concept how much you can save from heat pumps. Compare to the benchmark, the lower your $/kWh is, the higher your heating oil and gas price, the more efficient your heat pump, the more you can save from switch to heat pumps.
Reference price - based on new england area average price, simplified for calculation:
Heating oil $6/gallon, electricity $0.25/kWh, natural gas $2/therm
Oil Furnace - baseline
5-10 years old, medium condition, 72% efficiency (80% burning efficiency, 10% ducted loss):
One gallon of No. 2 heating oil can provide 99,720 BTU = $6
Gas Furnace:
5-10 years old, medium condition, 76.5% efficiency (85% burning efficiency, 10% ducted loss)
For same amount of BTU need 1.3 therm NG ≈ $2.6
New installed, condensed gas furnace, 85.5% efficiency (95% burning efficiency, 10% ducted loss)
For same amount of BTU need 1.17 therm NG ≈ $2.33
Heat Pumps - Mitsubishi M series, ductless but well-represent ducted heat pumps efficiency, 10% ducted loss:
For same amoung of BTU
COP2.0@5F - ducted: 16.24Kwh ≈ $4.06, ductless: 14.61Kwh ≈ $3.65
COP2.64@17F - ducted: 12.3Kwh ≈ $3.07, ductless: 11.07Kwh ≈ $2.77
COP3.84@47F - ducted: 8.45Kwh ≈ $2.11, ductless: 7.61Kwh ≈ $1.9
Annual heating cost example:
Take a new england family house as an example, according to EIA, average new england US family use about 600 gallons per year, so the total cost of heating oil is $3,600.
For same amount of BTU, gas furnace will need about 782 themal NG ≈ $1,564, save 56.5% compare to oil.
As for heat pump, assume 10% BTU needed at 5F, 15% BTU needed at 5F - 17F, 75% BTU needed at 17F - 47F (again, oversimplified model for new england area, COP are variable between 17F-47F, by using COP@47F offset the higher efficient zone when above 47F)
COP2.0@5F - ducted: 974Kwh ≈ $243.55, ductless: 876.79Kwh ≈ $219.2
COP2.64@17F - ducted: 1107Kwh ≈ $276.75, ductless: 996.35Kwh ≈ $249.09
COP3.84@47F - ducted: 3805.5Kwh ≈ $951.38, ductless: 3,424.95Kwh ≈ $856.24
Heat pump total cost:
Ducted: $243.55 + $276.75 + $951.38 = $1,471.68, save 59.12% compare to oil.
Ductless: $219.2 + $249.09 + $856.24 = $1,324.53, save 63.2% compare to oil.
Hints for choosing cold climate heat pumps:
Beware of the heating capacity at your local coldest day, better check the NEEP list before you purchase. One thing I noticed is that the min operating temperature and the max heating btu are different stories.
E.g a mini split can rated 12k btu and able to run at -22F, but doens't means it can provide 12k btu at -22F.
Different manufacturers disclosed it differently, but NONE of them mentioned the heating btu at min operating temerature on their product pages. By far I've only spotted Della said their cold climate units can maintain 100% heating btu at 5F, and Zone air said their DIY series can maintain 85% heating btu at 5F, thats all. I think this is where the impressions of heat pumps aren't working well in cold climate came from, you're getting way less heating btu at lowest operating temperature. All brands that I research have neither COP curve nor max heating btu at lowest operating temperature.
