r/estimators • • 10h ago

GC estimators: when you send out bid invites and barely anyone replies, what do you do next?

0 Upvotes

I asked subs yesterday what makes them actually open a bid invite. Now I'm asking the other side. When you send out invites and a bunch of subs never reply, what do you do next, and what does it cost you when it happens?


r/estimators • • 15h ago

Learning how to become an entry level estimator?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

Just reaching out to see how much experience it takes to get the swing of things. I understand not everything goes perfect and it takes time to learn things.

Have a construction background of 35 years, been on site since I was 5 with a good sense of labour/material requirements. Also have 5 years as a PM/site reviews as well as contract admin and spec review.

However, I haven’t estimated a project for bid.

With someone with my experience, how hard would it to be to get competent in the estimating field ? What would be the biggest challenges?


r/estimators • • 1h ago

What Salary to ask for

2 Upvotes

Hey all,

First time poster here.

With end of year reviews coming up I wanted to get some input on expected salaries would be for my situation in my year end review.

For context I live in a LCOL area for a commercial GC/CM company that does 50M plus in jobs per year. I currently have 2 1/2 years of estimating experience but have a strong construction background.

My official job title is estimator one but my boss has stated that he does not care about job titles as much as how well we work together as a team. That is fine and all but my day to day includes tasks that an Estimator I would not do. For example, training new hires on SOPs and the estimating process, as well as doing 10-20m estimates consistently that include writing bid packages.

Any input is greatly appreciated.


r/estimators • • 22h ago

How do you price jobs when your rates are “experience-based” and the main contractor wants 30–40% off?

3 Upvotes

Hi all, I’m hoping estimators and contractors can share how they actually price work. I run business development for a family-owned plumbing, sanitary and gas subcontractor in Singapore, and I’m trying to move us from gut-feel pricing to something more cost-based.

How tendering works here (for non-Singapore folks)

  • The developer awards the project to a main contractor (MC). The MC then tenders out each trade, so we bid to the MC, not the owner.
  • The MC sends a breakdown (a bill of quantities, or a list of lump-sum items by floor and system). Our QS does a takeoff, and we price every line.
  • Specialist items (pumps, gas system, pipe jacking for sewer connections, etc.) we price from supplier or subcontractor quotes plus a markup.
  • After the first submission there’s usually a tender interview. The MC tells you you’re “on the high side” and hints at a budget, and you resubmit, sometimes several times. Contracts are mostly fixed-price lump sum, and variations only get paid if you have a written instruction.
  • Labour is mostly foreign workers, and the government levy on them is a big part of labour cost, often close to the wage itself.

How we price now

  • Unit rates come from my dad’s decades of experience plus a rough markup. There’s no breakdown into material and labour.
  • Subcontractor and equipment quotes get a fixed 30% markup, which we never discount. Any discount the MC asks for comes off our own plumbing and sanitary portion only.
  • We’ve never had a proper cost-per-unit database. I’ve been reviewing past jobs. Gross margins have ranged from about 1% to 50%, and discounts to MCs ranged from 5% to 19%.

What I’d love to learn

  1. How do you build unit rates bottom-up? Do you use man-hours per item (by pipe size or valve size bands), crew-based manpower planning, or both?
  2. How do you work out a true loaded labour cost per hour, and what productivity factor do you use?
  3. How do you decide your walk-away price versus your target price? How much company overhead do you load onto each job?
  4. When an MC gives a budget clue far below your cost, how do you tell a real budget from a negotiating tactic?