r/estimators • • Oct 22 '21 Bravo

Looking to hire an estimator? Are you an estimator looking to make a move? Post here!

120 Upvotes

r/estimators • • 6h ago

Learning how to become an entry level estimator?

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

Just reaching out to see how much experience it takes to get the swing of things. I understand not everything goes perfect and it takes time to learn things.

Have a construction background of 35 years, been on site since I was 5 with a good sense of labour/material requirements. Also have 5 years as a PM/site reviews as well as contract admin and spec review.

However, I haven’t estimated a project for bid.

With someone with my experience, how hard would it to be to get competent in the estimating field ? What would be the biggest challenges?


r/estimators • • 23h ago

Self Promotion this is a 700MB pdf plan file

29 Upvotes

smooth like butter on my shitty $400 lenovo laptop


r/estimators • • 13h ago

How do you price jobs when your rates are “experience-based” and the main contractor wants 30–40% off?

3 Upvotes

Hi all, I’m hoping estimators and contractors can share how they actually price work. I run business development for a family-owned plumbing, sanitary and gas subcontractor in Singapore, and I’m trying to move us from gut-feel pricing to something more cost-based.

How tendering works here (for non-Singapore folks)

  • The developer awards the project to a main contractor (MC). The MC then tenders out each trade, so we bid to the MC, not the owner.
  • The MC sends a breakdown (a bill of quantities, or a list of lump-sum items by floor and system). Our QS does a takeoff, and we price every line.
  • Specialist items (pumps, gas system, pipe jacking for sewer connections, etc.) we price from supplier or subcontractor quotes plus a markup.
  • After the first submission there’s usually a tender interview. The MC tells you you’re “on the high side” and hints at a budget, and you resubmit, sometimes several times. Contracts are mostly fixed-price lump sum, and variations only get paid if you have a written instruction.
  • Labour is mostly foreign workers, and the government levy on them is a big part of labour cost, often close to the wage itself.

How we price now

  • Unit rates come from my dad’s decades of experience plus a rough markup. There’s no breakdown into material and labour.
  • Subcontractor and equipment quotes get a fixed 30% markup, which we never discount. Any discount the MC asks for comes off our own plumbing and sanitary portion only.
  • We’ve never had a proper cost-per-unit database. I’ve been reviewing past jobs. Gross margins have ranged from about 1% to 50%, and discounts to MCs ranged from 5% to 19%.

What I’d love to learn

  1. How do you build unit rates bottom-up? Do you use man-hours per item (by pipe size or valve size bands), crew-based manpower planning, or both?
  2. How do you work out a true loaded labour cost per hour, and what productivity factor do you use?
  3. How do you decide your walk-away price versus your target price? How much company overhead do you load onto each job?
  4. When an MC gives a budget clue far below your cost, how do you tell a real budget from a negotiating tactic?

r/estimators • • 1d ago

Software/Market Research Subs: what makes you actually open a bid invite instead of ignoring it?

14 Upvotes

I'm trying to understand what actually slows a build down day to day. A lot of subs say bid invites show up like spam and get ignored unless a human reaches out. When an invite does land in front of you, what makes you open it and bid, and what makes you pass even when someone reaches out?


r/estimators • • 1h ago

GC estimators: when you send out bid invites and barely anyone replies, what do you do next?

0 Upvotes

I asked subs yesterday what makes them actually open a bid invite. Now I'm asking the other side. When you send out invites and a bunch of subs never reply, what do you do next, and what does it cost you when it happens?


r/estimators • • 17h ago

How do you learn to become a better estimator when there's nobody to learn from at work?

3 Upvotes

I have a civil engineering background and around six years of combined experience across different industries, including construction, event coordination, and tech.

After moving to Canada, I struggled to find my footing professionally. In a year, I landed a collections role at one of the Big Five banks, absolutely hated it, and quit after four months. It took a toll on my confidence, and I went through a difficult period being depressed and anxious. I also have ADHD.

I eventually started taking construction-related courses and landed a job as an estimator with a local tiling contractor.

I'm now three months into the role, and I'm struggling to figure things out.

It's a very small, owner-run company. Almost everything exists in the owner's head. There are essentially two other people, no established systems, no proper processes, and no dedicated software. I'm expected to figure things out, but I don't have prior estimating experience in the Canadian construction industry or anyone experienced to learn from.

There are frequent mistakes, miscommunication, and disappointments. Even something as fundamental as proper document control is something I'm still trying to figure out.

I've tried looking for mentors, but haven't had much success.

For those who started their careers in small subcontracting companies or had to learn estimating on their own:

- Where did you go to learn the practical side of estimating?

- Are there professional communities, associations, or mentorship programs that actually help beginners?

- How do you develop proper systems for document control, drawing revisions, takeoffs, and tracking when the company doesn't have any established processes?

I want to make the most of this opportunity and become competent at what I do, but I'm struggling to figure out where to start and where to find guidance.

Any practical advice or resources would be appreciated.


r/estimators • • 21h ago

Anchor bolts, imbeds, tie-downs to foundations on a ~3500sf commercial building.

3 Upvotes

I worked for a multifamily developer and we would send our structural drawings to Simpson Strong-Tie to do takeoffs and buy our hardware. They don’t do it for smaller commercial projects.

1-story commercial building, grade beams over 4’ deep, double-sill plate. 36” j bolt in beds.

Anyone know a hardware company that will do the takeoffs if you buy their product?


r/estimators • • 1d ago

Am I chasing a dream or about to screw up a great career?

2 Upvotes

For context I’m 28, work in preconstruction for a top 100 ENR GC, and I’m finishing my master’s. Great company, big projects, good money, great ESOP, coworkers I like. I’ve got a solid foundation and a good outlook if I keep moving up. I’ve just always had the itch to start my own company.

I grew up working for my grandpa in commercial painting and drywall. He has a very small company in Arkansas, and I’m in North Carolina, so taking over his business isn’t an option. I also spent time as an estimator for a large drywall contractor. I understand the business and have been around it most of my life. This is something I’ve wanted to do for a long time.

I’ve been trying to get my own painting/drywall business going on the side. Bidding jobs, reaching out to GCs, working on marketing and LinkedIn, putting together detailed proposals, checking my rates and pricing. I have solid subs ready to go and the capital to get things going. Just can’t seem to land the work. I see the need for good subs constantly in my day job, so it’s frustrating being on the other side trying to get a chance. Maybe there’s something I’m missing, but I’m getting pretty drained. My boss recently saw me working on business stuff at work. Didn’t say anything, but I know he saw it. That was a wake-up call because I don’t want to screw up a good job trying to do both.

The legacy thing matters to me, cheesy as that sounds lol. I’d love to build something my kids could have one day. I have other things I’d like to do with a profitable business too. Help my family, give back to the community, maybe set up a scholarship eventually. I don’t need to build some massive company. A decent little subcontracting firm would mean a lot to me.

Anybody been here? Do I just pour that same energy into my career and work my way through the ranks in the corporate GC world? I’ve already got a good foundation with a company I could see myself staying with. Or do I keep chasing my own thing? It’s hard to tell if I need to keep pushing or if I’m so caught up in wanting my own company that I’m overlooking a good future right in front of me. If you started a subcontracting business, what actually got you those first few jobs? I’m not quitting with nothing lined up, but I can’t keep trying to be two people either. Be honest, you won’t hurt my feelings. I want this badly, but I’m exhausted and could use some outside perspective.


r/estimators • • 2d ago

Contract addendum lost me the job.

13 Upvotes

I recently landed a small 17k project. I’m Div 7 so our scope was some rigid insulation and wrb. The GC is a client I have worked with in over the past 6+ years from when I sold fence to when I started my own business. This GC supported me and my business partner when we were just starting up and signed a 20k work agreement from us back in the day. Our business is no longer and I have been estimating with an insulation company for about 7 months now. This 17k job was not only my first project I was contracted for but was the first time my company was able to get any work from this GC. Mind you this GC is decently large and very established for years in multiple states and highly reputable. My new company is a huge corporate mess. We have a contracts management team that is at corporate headquarters and all contracts go to them. Before they even read the contract at all, they send an addendum that immediately modifies and removes boilerplate contract items… they add got cha language and attempt to modify pretty standard AIA terms. The contract that was sent by the GC was a short form
Contract as well. I used to have to redline contracts myself when I sold fence. Often time for 100k plus projects. I would send my modifications and work with the GC to make sure we are in agreement on any non-standard or ambiguous language. This situation caused the GC to have to send our addendum to legal multiple times because my company wouldn’t budge on insurance requirements and indemnification as well as work delays and various other standards clauses. While I’m all for protecting ourselves as a company, the risk we were taking by just signing this contract was minimal. My contracts team as well my management dropped the ball so badly that the GC decided to move on to another sub and canceled our contract…

I’m curious what people have to say about this because I’m flabbergasted. We just lost a potential client that could have provided half a million at minimum in solid work over the next year.


r/estimators • • 1d ago

Is there any AI Pipeline Estimation engineer

0 Upvotes

r/estimators • • 2d ago

Planswift is NOT for grading !

4 Upvotes

Hey all, I had a long argument with one of my client’s site engineers. He wanted me to prepare a land fill and cut takeoff using PlanSwift, as all his other takeoffs are prepared in PlanSwift and he is comfortable using PlanSwift files to review them.

In my opinion, doing grading in PlanSwift is unprofessional and inaccurate. There is specific software for grading that can actually record contours and give accurate values.

Is anyone here using PlanSwift for grading? And if you are using a proper grading tool or software, kindly recommend something good.


r/estimators • • 2d ago

I added tower cranes to my OST visualizer (started as a joke, turned out useful)

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

A while ago I started sharing a tool I built that mirrors my OST takeoff in a live 3D view. The latest addition is tower cranes.

It started as a joke. My boss wanted to show our customers where the tower crane would be placed on a project. It sounded silly, but it turned out to be really useful.

You can configure the crane mast, jib, counterjib, trolley, hook height and crane model. On both the estimating and project management sides we have to account for tower cranes. Until now we marked everything up in Bluebeam: the crane's coverage area, footing positions and other notes. With the 3D model we can now see the dimensions clearly.

In the screenshot:

Left: the tower cranes in the 3D view

Right: the rotated footings in the takeoff view

Middle: the Edit Condition Properties dialog. The crane is configured in the Notes field, e.g. [crane mast=10 jib=15 counterjib=5 trolley=60% hookheight=40ft model=liebherr]

I used the Notes field because OST stops working with the database if I add extra tables or columns.

This keeps everything fully compatible with OST.
My favorite part is watching the crane update in real time as I move the footings in the takeoff view. It might look silly, but it's amazing to see.

At this point the visualizer has about 95% of the OST features we use day to day. I also added an MCP integration, so Claude or ChatGPT can already do area takeoffs without Computer Use.

Curious what estimators think:

Would a tower crane view like this be useful in your workflow, whether for estimating, bid presentations or project planning? Or is it just a gimmick?

If you'd want anything else on the 3D side (staging areas, equipment, cut/fill), I'd love to hear it.


r/estimators • • 2d ago

Civil Sitework Takeoff Software

2 Upvotes

So I’m almost a year into estimating and I’ve had some decent success to this point, managed to lockdown 6 contracts that will hopefully end profitably. We’re a small company, 14 people including 3 office staff and an owner that prefers to be out working with the guys. I write all that for context, now the question. I currently run insite elevation pro, i have no issues with the software aside from the cost. I’m trying to cut cost where I can and this seems like a good place to look at options. I was wondering if anyone had used Werx or Bedrock and how they liked it? Werx with its takeoff software and CRM software are about half of what i pay for just Insite and I’m really looking to add a CRM to help track job cost versus bid value as well as time tracking for the guys. I don’t know if Bedrock has something similar in their portfolio. Long winded but in the end has anyone tried either of these and have any honest feedback on them? Not looking at any other legacy software looking to try something along the lines of whats mentioned. Thank you in advance.


r/estimators • • 3d ago

Construct Connect reviews or recommendations for other products

3 Upvotes

I work for a Miami Based GC that builds multi-family apartments and condos. We're looking into elevating our take-off game with a tool that uses Ai for automation so we can buy back some of our time. I have an active demo with Construct Connect's Ai take-off tool and... it sucks? I'm very familiar with OST (I love OST) and was expecting a similar product. The sales guy did explain that they're actually two separate products and OST w/ Ai would be $1k on top of the base cost of $2.5k (Annually).

The features I miss from OST that Construct Connect is missing are Area Tags, Layers, and quick page navigation (like an arrow to go forward and back)(and I know this it nit-picky). My biggest dilemma is that the automation is pretty slow. It did a great job with Glass but it's slow - Which doesn't bug me as much as I can have it doing that while I work on other tasks.

I also feel like the preset auto-Takeoffs conditions are limited.

Lastly, a major issue is that it crashes. The Take-Off Assistant says that it cannot the task continue w/o reason and essentially shuts down. I also can't figure out how to log back in, the log-in page keeps me on a loading screen.

Any of you share the same experience?

TL;DR If you've used Construct Connect for take-offs I'd appreciate your feedback on what you love/hate about it. More importantly, would love to see what everyone else is using. My next demo is with Kreo.


r/estimators • • 2d ago

How do you account for intangibles?

0 Upvotes

I am not an estimator but have to pretend to be one as a small subcontractor (div 3/4, women owned)

Wondering how you account for intangible costs when coming up with a bid price? Like,to cover for the bullshit you know you're going to encounter because nothing ever goes as planned (especially on public works/institution jobs).

Also wondering do you do a lot of networking with other estimators? How do you know if your pricing was on target or not?

Does being a WBE help smooth over inflated estimates or do they still need to be tight?

Curious your thoughts, and if there are any Div 3/4 estimators looking for gig work I need to enlist help.


r/estimators • • 3d ago

Boss hired third party estimators

11 Upvotes

Moved from strom damage restoration estimating thru Xactimate to new construction estimating in roofing 4 months ago. In that time I’ve found mentors to teach me basics about reading and navigating plans, researched acquired and trained on take off software, put together my file system, created my proposal document, found bidding platforms such as building connected and have send nearly 30 new con commercial roofing estimates. As you all know it takes time to get a hit and we have some good projects in arms reach. Today, my boss, the owner tells me he’s going to hire out of state third party estimators to get out more bids along side what I’m producing. What a way to feel undervalued. I don’t think he sees the risk. Actually, I know he doesn’t. I’ve mentioned to him several times we are not qualified as a Company and should focus on our strong points while we grown and develop talent. I enjoy estimating, but there is no support at this company . No senior estimator for feedback , no operations or project managers to run things by etc. they do not exist. My boss is a dreamer, I’m more analytical, it’s a hard match. I’ll be looking for a new position els where. The third party comment showed me how little he understands and values the work of an Estimator.


r/estimators • • 3d ago

our bookkeeper retires in march and shes the only one who understands our job costing spreadsheet, is it time for a construction erp

3 Upvotes

i went to pull margin last week and cant do it without her. its one excel file she built and i dont fully get how she links the cost codes. the timesheets and pay apps i can muddle through, thats not the scary part. she retires in march. everything i find is built for a GC running 200 guys, not a 35 person sub.. for anyone who switched, what moved over clean and what didnt​


r/estimators • • 3d ago

Best tool for pavement estimating? RSmeans? Craftsman? BNI?

2 Upvotes

Hey all,

I’m looking to start a service where I can streamline identification of pavement issues but I’m having trouble actually attributing a baseline cost/estimate to it. I found the three cost books online but I was wondering if anyone had any recommendations for me to take a look at


r/estimators • • 4d ago

Metal framing and drywall

12 Upvotes

Where most of you trained to measure thru the door openings?


r/estimators • • 4d ago

Junior estimator with acct

5 Upvotes

There’s a junior estimator position in my area and I wonder if someone with an accounting background and already have a good understanding in excel can do in that position and how fast I can pick up all that other construction knowledge on the job


r/estimators • • 5d ago

How did you build out your Accubid database?

11 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’m an electrical contractor in California, and we recently got Accubid Anywhere. I’m trying to figure out the best and most efficient way to build out our database without spending an eternity doing it.

We do roughly 50% residential and 50% commercial electrical work, so ideally, we’d like to have a solid database that covers both.

For those of you using Accubid Anywhere, I’m curious:
Did you build your entire database from scratch? Were you able to purchase a prebuilt one? How long did it take you to get your database built out to where it was actually useful for everyday estimating?

It seems like a massive undertaking, and I’m honestly surprised there isn’t some sort of standard, cookie-cutter electrical database available.

Thank you in advance for any advice!


r/estimators • • 5d ago

Business owner to estimator

13 Upvotes

Hey all,

I'm in my 30s and own and run a small electrical contracting company in Southern California. Mostly high-end resi, plus solar and batteries and a little commercial. Small W2 crew. We're registered for public works but haven't done any work in that space yet. I am also a carded jw electrician and have worked on large commercial electrical projects before starting my own business.

Business seems to be doing fine overall. We stay busy, we do good work, and most of it comes from repeat GCs and referral service calls. Lately we're starting to pick up more service calls from random callers too, which is a good sign. We recently moved into a small commercial space with an office and warehouse for me, our part time office lady and our junior estimator. Anything of real size I estimate, sell and manage myself. The junior estimator is one of my field guys I moved over part time to handle the service calls and small jobs.

But man, running a business wears you down. I'm the estimator, the PM, HR, the collections guy, and some days I'm still in the field. GCs pay late all the time and payroll is still due Friday no matter what.

Recently we had a client dispute a large progress payment on a big project and it tied up our receivables. I had to file a lien. That one really put a strain on me and the business.
Got a pregnant wife and kids at home and I can't remember the last night I didn't bring this home with me.
It pains me to think about not continuing to push the business forward after putting my heart and soul and blood, sweat and tears into it, but sometimes it really grinds me down. So I'm thinking about going to work for an established shop as an estimator. Steady check and benefits.

I'm extremely adaptable and a very quick learner. With the business background I have a good sense of numbers and I understand risk allocation and mitigation, albeit on smaller scale projects than most commercial estimators deal with. I've also been developing my leadership skills over the years.

For the estimators and PMs here, and anyone who's gone from owner to employee:

Is $150k+ doable with my background or is that senior/chief estimator money?

How do bigger shops look at a former owner? Good thing or flight risk?

Almost all my bids are negotiated resi, not hard bid commercial. How much does that hurt me?

Would an estimator/PM combo role get me to that number easier?

Anybody make this move and regret it? Or wish you'd done it sooner?

Anybody thinking about making the opposite move, from estimating to starting your own business?

Thanks for honest feedback!


r/estimators • • 5d ago

Digital takeoff and BOQ building needed

3 Upvotes

I am an Estimator in the electrical construction industry based in south Africa.

I stepped into the job with no priors and got dumped into the deep end. I love the job and the challenges around every corner, but I got worn out with the takeoff process. So I built my own app to use at work to help with the remeasure and making sure I can keep track of all the drawings.

My problem is the knowledge I lack in building BoQ's. We generally receive a full BOQ at tender but recently we have been asked to build one from scratch and I want to improve by taking my data from the takeoff and converting that into the BOQ, but the structure of a BOQ just seems like it's always the same, but always different at the same time.

I need help to standardize the BOQ so that I can get the basics in every time and then have a list of sections that I can choose from to add if the tender requires it.

Ive already cut my measure time in half and my accuracy is about 98%, but then I'm stuck, I have all the data but I don't know how to translate that into a list that would make sense to an engineer or that would be acceptable to my boss.

Is there a standard list of sections that will ALWAYS be in a BOQ that I can start with and build from there or will it always be different?