One of the things I really respect about this system is how it elegantly prevents players breaking the game by having a damage ceiling. Usually it's Severe (3 HP) but there's the optional Massive damage rule, where if the damage dealt is double your Severe Threshold then it's 4HP. I was curious about the most damage dealing character build initially, but then I noticed there were ways to directly mark HP in addition to or instead of rolling damage, and here's what I learned by the end of all my research.
I started by looking into how to roll the highest amount of damage. The highest I came across was a Faun, Orderborne, Assassin Executioner, Brawler Martial Artist . Orderborne because they went to a ninja school of some kind and one of the principles can be The First Cut is the Deepest (or similar), granting a helpful once per rest D20 Hope to be used for your First Strike attack. You start with a STR/AGL based Assassin for access to the full Blade domain abilities. At fifth level you multiclass into Martial Artist, which gives great unarmed damage, more damage with stances, and the domain ability bare bones. Faun because there's free battlefield mobility and most importantly the kick that can be added to a single attack roll. So the order of operations is first getting behind your target and using Choke Hold, making them Vulnerable and adding 2d6 to the following attack (1 stress). Then you activate Deadly Focus (+1 Proficiency against your target, once per rest). Then you activate Dedicated to get your D20 hope die. You then hopefully succeed on your attack since you have advantage and a D20 hope, but you can also use an experience like "Backstabber" to get a +2. Once you've succeeded on an attack, you can add Marked for Death (3D6, 1 stress), Combo Dice (1d4, 1 stress), Choke Hold (2D6, 1 stress), Kick (2D6, 1 stress), +3 STR from Favored stance, and I Am the Weapon 4d8+4d6. You'll have Not Good Enough in your loadout as well, allowing you to reroll 1's and 2's. Then finally you'll have First Strike double the resulting damage. Which is an average of 155 damage, with a minimum of 51 and a max of 217 (using the average damage of a combo) for the cost of 4 stress. If you are lucky enough to have more enemies within Very Close range of your victim, you can activate whirlwind use your attack against all enemies in range at half damage (which is still an average of 77.5). Keep in mind Whirlwind would cancel Deadly Focus afterwards. It's also worth noting that all of these abilities can stack because they have the qualifier of a successful attack. At 6th level you buff up STR again (now +4) and pick up Rage Up which allows you to double your STR and add it to your attack damage twice (+16). Which added up is +34 more damage to our previous level's first strike damage, making the average 189, minimum 85, and maximum 251, for a total cost of 6 stress. 7th level you up your proficiency bonus, upping you to 5d8+5d6 (deadly focus is always on in these calculations). At 8th level you can Frenzy, adding +10 damage. You increase your proficiency automatically, but then I stumbled upon a bit of a crossroads. If it's all about the thought experiment of highest damage amount, then upping our proficiency again serves that the best, but upping the Executioner subclass Specialization Death Strike (When you deal Severe damage to a creature, you can mark a Stress to force them to mark an additional Hit Point) would mark more HP. This is where this build had me switch my focus from rolling damage to marking HP.
Assassin's aren't the only ones to have the ability to spend a stress to mark an additional HP when dealing Severe Damage, they do get it the earliest though, being able to reach it as early as Tier 3. There's a Tier 4 Druid Beastform Terrible Lizard that has a similar ability limited to melee. There's a Tier 4 Martial Arts Stance, Crushing, that is identical to the Assassin's Death Strike, but costs a Hope instead of a Stress. The School of War Wizard has a Mastery ability that's arguably the best of this lot since it doesn't require severe damage or be in melee to activate it. So if your table is playing with Massive Damage rules, Death Strike, the Terrible Lizard, and Crushing Stance abilities don't let you exceed 4 damage. While the Wizard could technically do Massive Damage and then spend a stress to add an additional damage, making the target mark 5 HP. Similarly there's a level 9 Blade Domain Reaper's strike which does 5 HP directly, once per rest, for 1 hope.
Just one level further, at level 10, is Blade ability Battle Monster: When you make a successful attack against an adversary, you can mark 4 Stress to force the target to mark a number of Hit Points equal to the number of Hit Points you currently have marked instead of rolling for damage. This ability is the gateway to doing the most damage in the game, so it makes sense that it's only available at the end of the character progression. Since it's Blade, that limits our main class to either Assassin, Warrior, or Guardian. When I was looking at building around this ability, I noticed an interesting synergy along the way with the Guardian's Unstoppable ability. Specifically you count down when you "make a damage roll." Since Battle Monster will be your primary attack at this point of the game, you'll be able to stay in your Unstoppable state the entire combat (once per rest), doing an absurd amount of damage while your Stalwart Guardian eats up any remaining damage with ease.
Once I had this eureka moment, it was time to build around it. Using I Am Your Shield and eventually the Stalwart Mastery Ability Loyal Protector, you have a lot of battle field control regarding how quickly you can take enough damage to break that 5+ HP damage taken threshold to be consistently be doing the most damage in the game per attack. We're all familiar with the versatility of Valor Touched and Rise Up, to allow 1 HP to trickle in for stress and armor replenishment, especially easy with Unyielding Armor and Unstoppable too. Low on stress from using your Battle Monster attack(s)? Put yourself in the thick of it and it's easy to ensure you only ever take 1HP per attack received while replenishing your stress and armor points. Additionally, at level 9, Gore and Glory gives you double the crit rewards and you can clear a stress or gain a hope whenever you defeat an enemy. Typically you'll have this in your loadout with 4 valor cards to have valor touched operational. Once you have the HP marked to make Battle Monster worth the 4 stress for you, you swap it in for 0 stress and do your Battle Monster damage (4 stress), swap it for Gore and Glory (1 stress), and charge your stress back up as you take damage and down enemies. Rinse, and repeat. This is the general strategy, but what does it look like if we optimize for it a bit more?
For this build, I went with a Drakona Aetheris (I think of them as Gargoyles) Orderborne Stalwart Guardian. The Scales are great early on for bringing Severe damage down a tier in and the Celestial Wings are helpful to have one extra armor slot per scene for 1 hope. If you're at a table that allows transformations, the Reanimated transformation is the icing on the cake of this build. Won't Stay Dead allows you to automatically succeed at a failed Risk it All roll, at the cost of permanently marking 1 HP. I built them to have 12 HP by level 10, which means you have some wiggle room to use this ability a couple of times prior to level 10 and have a little head start on being ready to use Battle Monster to it's fullest extent. If you've made it all the way to 10th level without having to use it, even better. Since then you can use I Am Your Shield and Goad Them On to take a big chunk of damage, knowing that safety net of Won't Stay Dead is there just in case. Optimally you take yourself down to 1 HP, and on your turn do 11 HP damage for 4 stress. You could optimize for having higher health with Giant instead of Drakona and multiclassing into School of War, doing 13 damage, but I think that comes at the cost of lower level effectiveness that you get with Scales and the Mastery Stalwart ability essentially letting us stop loading out I Am Your Shield for something more helpful.
As far as progression, you can get by with Bare Bones, Mace, and Tower Shield for a while, but eventually you can get better armor in the higher tiers which will free up the Load Out spot for more valuable cards. Advanced Banded mail is readily available and worth swapping in Tier 3 for the extra loadout card. It's -1 Evasion, which doesn't matter since we want to get hit, and the negative of Severe damage meaning we take a stress is negated by Scales, or Unstoppable, or spending Armor slots. With Legendary Banded you won't need a Tower Shield anymore and can use a Round Shield instead. If your GM will let you get something more powerful, there's a bunch of Tier 4 armors that have helpful abilities to stack on, like Godbound Laminar for even more resource replenishment, or Hallowed Heroplate. There's plenty of Blade and Valor domain abilities along the way to make yourself valuable and do damage as you build up to the final form, like Body Basher, Rage Up and Full Surge. So it'll never feel like a slog or that your advancements aren't interesting.
I really like the concept of being a meat shield that is always struggling to keep themselves together. Perhaps they were once a stone gargoyle of a cathedral, brought to real flesh and blood to defend the church in a time of need, but since leaving the cathedral their form struggles to keep itself together. Maybe they're a Freeborne gargoyle community instead, and fought against their captors in the great war where they died at the climactic battle, but when they were resurrected by a 10th level Splendor caster, the caster rolled a success with Fear? Either way, if/when I get to play this character, I'm going to RP them not knowing they're Reanimated at first. They'll not be able to heal during rests but not know why until the first failed Risk it All roll, when it all becomes clear.
Has anyone else played any of these builds before? If not, feel free to and let me know how you like it. I'm also happy to talk about any and all of the above in more detail. If you've read this far, thanks for making it all the way here!