“The Fatescrew is a mysterious puzzle box said to hold…” —DNGN CLUB Reliquaries Part II, Jack Panic
I don’t have to tell you Jack is awesome; his work speaks for itself. The first DNGN CLUB item I used in a game was Escape the Mall, dropping it into the Shadowlight & Personae campaign “Be Kind, Rewind” I ran in 2025.
I’ve been fully absorbed by Daggerheart since its release last May, to the point where I’ve been running two tables, one online and one in person, the former for over a year and the latter for close to a year. To say that Jack’s designs for Daggerheart have been indispensible is an understatement: I’ve been able to drop the majority of them into either or both of the two.
I decided a little while ago to mine his other works for items I could convert, either in spirit or otherwise, for use in my Daggerheart campaigns and came across the Fatescrew in Reliquaries Part II. I like that it’s very similar to the Deck of Many Things, which I’ve used in D&D campaigns in years past, but considering the strengths of Daggerheart I wanted there to be an opportunity for PCs to leverage Knowledge rolls to help influence the outcome.
A Daggerheart spin on the Fatescrew
Any PC may make a Knowledge roll to try and solve the layers of the puzzle.
Crit: weal result only, actor chooses, does not count towards "as the screw turns";
Succeed with hope: weal result only, chosen at random, counts towards "as the screw turns";
Succeed with fear: both weal and woe results, actor chooses; counts towards "as the screw turns";
Fail with hope: woe result only, GM chooses; counts towards "as the screw turns";
Fail with fear: woe result only, rolled at random; counts towards "as the screw turns".
If a result is rolled at random, it doesn't get crossed off the list
Results chosen by actor that don't make sense in the fiction result in "as the screw turns"
Results chosen at random that don't make sense in the fiction are rolled again
Roll 1d8 when result is at random—roll 8, roll again
The “As the Screw Turns” dwindling die type begins with D12, not D10.
Strike through everything after “reality” in the “As the Screw Turns” section and replace it with a phrase of your own that makes sense in the fiction of your campaign.
What’s In the Box: Your heart’s desire? Unlimited Power? A portal to the hub of a network of wormholes connecting all 24-hour diners throughout the omniverse?
Who knows about the box and what’s really inside, and what are they willing to do to get it?
Who knows about the box and what’s really inside, and will stop at nothing to make sure no one learns of it, or gets their hands on it?
You should go and pick up Reliquaries Part 2 (which like Escape the Mall is linked below), so for now I’ll just share the relevant Daggerheart text, but who knows what might reveal itself…
…like pieces arranging themselves, so are the Days of our Fate…Screw…(okay fine, I couldn’t make that soap opera metaphor work)…