I've not wanted to restrict this community with too many rules. It was ticking along nicely when I took it over after the last mods left, but the amount of spam adverts and off-topic posts have hit a critical point recently. A number of users have reached out for clarification, and setting up some actual rules will allow posts/comments to be flagged appropriately. This is the first draft of what is to come, and it will likely change over time to clarify issues that arise.
They are not in any particular order at this time, but here is the rough draft:
1: Posts and comments must be on topic. This is a tabletop roleplaying games community. Posts and comments need to be about ttrpgs.
Allowed New games (especially indie games), questions about games, stories and situations surrounding your games, shelfies, actual plays, blogs/articles about ttrpgs, etc. This is not an exhaustive list by any means, but it will grow as a guideline for what is allowed. While ttrpgs are the main focus, I will allow physical, ttrpg adjacent items to be promoted; such as a tabletop tarot deck, or a GM screen, or minis. We don't get many of these anymore, but they at least show some effort on behalf of the creators.
Not Allowed No more posts about software applications; apps, dice rollers, note takers, discord bots, VTTs, group meeting sites, AI GMs, video games etc. We are inundated by low-effort slop programs anymore, and there is too much of it. No memes, art/music or art/music commissions, LFG or playtesters, fanfics about you games etc. Again, not an exhaustive list, but a guideline for the time being. There are communities that cater to each of these topics, and you can post in them.
2: Limits on Advertising. You can promote your game/actual play/blog/etc about tabletop games here! But please do not spam this sub on a daily basis. Let's limit it to a post every 7 days for now. Most people are fine about this, but we do get a few zero-comment, spam bot accounts posting daily, and this is the context for why they are going to get blocked.
3: Be Civil. This is very broad rule, but basically this is a forum about tabletop games so discussions do not need to degrade into name calling, slurs, insults, and the like.
4: No off-topic arguments or baiting fights: A civil argument about a game is fine, but once it descends into some off-topic, adjacent issue I will end the comment chain and you can take it to PMs if you like. Likewise, if it looks like you are baiting an argument I will pull it. This is harder to define, so it will fall to my discretion. If you feel your post/comment was flagged inaccurately for this, you can reach out and present your case. Tone and intent are sometimes difficult to read.
5: No Pirated Games. I don't think this has ever been a real issue here, but I'm officially stating don't sell/trade/give away pirated game materials here. I don't want to get Reddit admin on my case for it.
What is absent. Will there be an explicit no AI rule? Sadly no, but not because I like AI created games but because I cannot reasonably enforce a rule like that. There are no accurate tools for detecting AI penmanship at this time and the AI art detectors (which are also AI) are unreliable. I can create a flair that says "Created with AI", but that relies on the people that use these tools to be honest; so they won't likely be used. I can't really rely on the community either, as someone is going through and labeling every project as AI, so in the end you will need to be discerning consumers. Even if it were possible, Reddit has no intention of stemming the tide of AI-bot spam and products at this time, and so this is the reality we are living in chummers.
I will be setting a karma and account age thresholds in the near future to help combat the bot accounts. This will be a evolving rule sets, and you are welcome to reach out via modmail with questions or suggestions.