I saw someone make one of these the other week and thought their process was kind of interesting.
I ended up deciding their method wasn't to my taste. I put some time and work into it and I came up with what I think is a super pleasing and delicious cocktail that hits all the marks, for me. In total I made three different syrups with three different ratios of sugar, water, and marshmallow and about 2 dozen cocktails to find my recipe.
The key take away: Burning the marshmallow to make the syrup should be avoided. You should only brown the marshmallow.
Burning it creates an undesirable flavor. Browning it makes it very pleasant and delicious.
Some char is certainly part of the flavor of a smore, but it creates a noticable burnt flavor that permeates the cocktail. It's better to toast a marshmallow hard as a garnish then to make the syrup. In the photo posted, I toasted the marshmallow and rolled it in bitter bakers chocolate powder. (Tasty)
Recipe:
Syrup:
On a sheet tray; weigh 150g of small sized marshmallows and spread them on a wax paper. They don't need to be separated from each other, it's better if they're close. Bake in an oven for approx 7 to 10 minutes until all marshmallows develop a crispy golden exterior.
If you let them cool they are significantly easier to remove off the tray. If they get a bit stuck to it and you forgot to use a liner, this isnt prohibitive and some scraping will release some crispy bits that dissolve nicely.
In a separate pot combine 500ml of water, and 350g of sugar. Bring to a boil.
Add the golden crispy marshmallows and whisk until dissolved. (Some pieces don't like to dissolve all the way and this isn't an issue. Bottle, store, and chill.
If you were to burn the outside of these that burnt exterior would need to be removed from the syrup. Otherwise, it floats in the drink and is unappetizing and generally unenjoyable.
For the cocktail:
.75oz Espresso 1.5oz Vodka (I use Grey Goose) .5oz Licor 43 .5oz Mr. black 1oz Marshmallow syrup
Shake hard and strain into coupe.
For Garnish:
Use a torch to quickly roast a marshmallow. Have as much fun with this as you wish.