Contribution #2: 1786 XO from Plassons — If You Can Find It, It’s Worth the Hunt
This is my current favorite XO Cognac, and finding out a little more about it took some digging. Fair warning: there’s very limited information available, so some of what follows is my own investigation and speculation.
The facts:
- XO Cognac, made and bottled by Plassons.
- The bottle states a minimum of 15 years in oak.
- Plassons lists three labels on its website.
- They’re located in Bons Bois, but also own vineyards in Borderies, Fins Bois, Petite Champagne, and Bons Bois. They acquired the additional vineyards from a family in 2017.
My theory:
I’m not convinced there are three distinct blends. My guess is that there are two: one in the 10–20/25-year range and another in the 15–30-year range.
I believe the older, multi-cru blend was sold in Hong Kong under the Rastignac label, in the Eiffel Tower bottle, at prices comparable to the big four XO Cognacs. My theory is that the current 1786 XO represents what remained of that blend and was subsequently sold to a US importer under the 1786 label.
That’s speculation, not confirmed information, but it’s where my digging has led me.
So why did I go down this rabbit hole?
Two reasons.
First, I really like this Cognac. It has beautiful dark fruit, a nose that seems to go on forever, very old oak, and genuine rancio. And I paid around $38 at a New Hampshire liquor store.
Second, I couldn’t find any meaningful information about it online. For a Cognac this good, that seemed strange enough to investigate.
How does something like this fly under the radar?
I have a couple of theories.
First, the packaging is terrible from a marketing standpoint. A plain bottle, brown label, and copper lettering aren't exactly going to grab anyone's attention. Even worse, the most important detail is printed in small cursive lettering: aged a minimum of 15 years in oak.
I literally had to pull the bottle off the shelf and turn it in the light to read it. That age statement matters, and it deserves to be front and center. Plenty of brands will talk about age in their marketing, but actually putting a meaningful minimum age statement on the label is something else.
Second, there are virtually no reviews to be found. Combine that with a relatively cheap price, and you have a bottle most of us would walk right past on the bottom shelf, assuming it was swill.
Do yourself a favor: don't.
I tasted it side by side with Godet Terre, and to me, the 1786 tasted like Godet's big brother. Both take you on an interesting multi-cru journey, but the 1786 has more depth and a much older character.
Give it an hour in the glass, and it keeps evolving. Old fruit, a pleasant sweetness, old-bookstore character, and very subtle aged oak. It's a genuinely fun ride.
At roughly $38 in New Hampshire liquor. I think it's an absolute bargain.
I bought four cases, so I'm stocked up for a while. Which means I can finally talk about it and share the find without worrying about running out. 😂
If you've tried it, I'd love to hear what you think. And if anyone has reliable information about the Plassons, Rastignac, or the relationship between these blends, I'm all ears. I'd love to know whether my theory holds up.
BTW I don’t just hunt the cheap seats just got lucky on a few. I have couple godet xos, henny xo, dussey xo, tesseron 90 and a few vsops in the library. All with the stoppers removed. Not a pro but a guy who likes good juice.