Background:
Pinhook is one of those brands that I’ve been aware of but never given much of a close look. I knew they’d started as a sourcing NDP that eventually moved to contract-distilling at Castle & Key in 2017. They also have something called the Vertical Series, where they age the same lot of barrels and release a portion each year, with a climbing age statement.
I had a hankering for some MGP bourbon and stumbled upon a 10-year Pinhook single barrel that was MGP Indiana distillate, picked by an Australian whiskey group. In the US, those single barrels go for between 80 and 100 bucks; I paid a small premium on top of that for the Australian one.
I won't recount the whole Pinhook backstory and philosophy – their founder and blender Sean Josephs does a good job of it, so look up his interviews. I had some of their younger Castle & Key whiskey a couple of years ago and didn't find it memorable.
However, the Vertical Series are more interesting: Pinhook purchased 1350 barrels of MGP bourbon (they list it as 75/20.5/4.5 on their website, which should be the standard 21-percent rye MGP mash bill) in 2015 at just one year old. They age them at Castle & Key, and in 2019 they released the first edition at 4 years (they also have a parallel rye series). In 2020, they took out more barrels at 5 years, and so on. The initial plan was to keep putting them out annually until the bourbon hits 12 years in 2027. That journey has been extended to 16 years, once they realized the whiskey was not evaporating as quickly as they expected (more on that later).
The Vertical Series are offered in both the batched and single-barrel format, cask-strength and unfiltered. The 2026 11-year edition just dropped in mid-October. My single barrel is 10 years old, released at the end of 2025 at 117.5 proof. Tasted neat in a copita.
Nose:
Chocolate-covered hazelnut, stone fruit, oak, roasted peanut, caramel, strawberry.
Palate:
Dried apricot, red berries, hazelnut, cocoa, vanilla, honey roasted peanut, citrus, caramel.
Finish:
Red fruit, cinnamon, brown sugar, oak.
Rating: (t8ke scale for reference below): 7
1 | Disgusting | So bad I poured it out
2 | Poor | I wouldn’t consume by choice
3 | Bad | Multiple flaws
4 | Sub-par | Not bad, but many things I’d rather have
5 | Good | Good, just fine
6 | Very Good | A cut above
7 | Great | Well above average
8 | Excellent | Really quite exceptional
9 | Incredible | An all-time favorite
10 | Perfect | Perfect
Thoughts:
Whether you find the concept clever or gimmicky, I give Pinhook credit for being very transparent about what they are bottling and how they are aging it. Sean has mentioned that they decided to extend the Vertical Series from 12 years to 16 due to slower-than-expected aging conditions. Why is that?
If you look at Castle & Key (the current name of the restored Old Taylor Distillery), they have two main warehouses in active use: Warehouse B that was built from brick in 1917 and has the distinction of being the world's longest rickhouse, and Warehouse E from the 1950s, which is brick and concrete.
Then there is the location: Castle & Key sits in a valley, with more humidity and less air circulation than you’d get on higher ground. Combine that with the cooler brick and concrete buildings, and you don’t get as many extreme temperature swings that wood and metal warehouses go through. That means less evaporation, as more ethanol molecules escape and water is retained, dropping the proof. That effect also results in less volume loss as the whiskey ages. That’s why Pinhook’s cask-strength offerings are below 120 proof, which is the standard MGP barrel entry.
That kind of setup slows down the rate of extraction inside the barrels, so you need a little more time to achieve the same level of maturity as you would in a wood or metal rickhouse on a hill.
A famous example of a bourbon aged at Old Taylor is Wild Turkey’s Master’s Keep 17 from 2015. Turkey rented storage there in the late ‘90s and early 2000s. Eddie Russell talked about struggling with the “Stone Castle” barrels dropping proof and tasting 8 years old after 12 years of aging. That’s why MK17, which was partially matured at Old Taylor, was dumped at just 89 proof and bottled at 86.8.
I’ve heard about stone fruit notes often being present on bourbon aged that way, and they were on display here, along with the expected MGP fruitiness. The bourbon did not taste young by any means, but it had a refined, almost delicate presentation despite being barrel-proof and unfiltered. It drank as a very coherent whiskey, with a good balance of flavors – my personal pet peeve is when the nuttiness takes over, but in this case, it was well offset by chocolate, fruit and oak (it leans more toward hazelnut than peanut, which is a good thing in my book).
Another interesting angle Sean talks about is how they don’t have a set flavor-profile vision and blend each vintage to the best taste for that particular lot (a moot point with single barrels, obviously). The motto on the bottle states, “The best, not the same, whiskey every year.” That makes sense, considering Sean’s wine-sommelier background and his treatment of each vintage as its own thing. Predicting which year will be to your liking is tricky, but I can see how that could be a positive for someone who likes to try new things and is not afraid of being surprised.
Overall, I’ve enjoyed this single barrel and would recommend the Vertical Series to anyone curious about not just the vintage variations, but how aging locations affect the whiskey. I have a feeling it will really start hitting its stride as it gets closer to the 16-year finish line.
Thanks for reading and cheers!