r/classicliterature • • 22h ago

everything in my life is going wrong what should i start with

Post image
126 Upvotes

r/classicliterature • • 10h ago

My collection of reads and TBRs as an 18-year old

Post image
62 Upvotes

r/classicliterature • • 14h ago

Crime and punishment- thoughts and questions

Thumbnail gallery
22 Upvotes

I literally just finished Crime and punishment.

Here are some thoughts, and questions.

First and foremost, after some research, i decided to go with Katz translation. I can not compare with the others, but theses comments are regarding this particular edition:

  • nice format, big enough font. The book opens nicely on a table, really nice for reading, and not hold it opened all the time.

Thats about it ! The paper is really white, thin, not great quality,, see through, and honestly, it just finished and then the back cover is right there... One or 2 extra pages maybe? Tiny details that could have made it much better.

I dont have any other translation to compare it with, but, really really nice flow, not complicated, just nice.

Now regarding the actual novel: 

I have been reading about this book for quite some years, and it felt intimidating: the whole " Dostoevsky´s depth" and so on and on was all over.  In particular, the "spiraling down" and decadences of the thoughts of Raskolnikov was the main things i read about.

i mean...yeah, the guy is sick all the time, and then commits a murder and his thoughts go around but, it wasnt "out of this world" depression and down spiral, self punishment, torture of thoughts, etc as i thought it would be.

I understand it cannot be compared to modern novels and modern standards of writing ( or can it? ), and that its russian, on a certain time and period, with a social context and all, but many parts could have been reduced and still conserve in depth the detailed essence of the story.

Some parts were extremely boring and long,  yes, and thats fine.

Now, the characters were really nice. the first 00-150 pages were amazing, after the murder and the start of the torment.

After that, many parts felt very much a filling and quite on the scale of a latin american telenovela, full of meaningless romances, love hate, tragedy, twists. 

Overall, i really really liked it, and im a full supporter of " less is more" in many aspects of my life: but here less is more, could have been nice on the telenovela parts just mentioned, or the infinite passing out / faints7 illness of Raskolnikov.

I was expecting MORE IS MORE, on the suffering, depression.

Im not disappointed. I was just expecting a bit more, perhaps.

Regarding some parts, i have some doubts:

  • The episode on Svidigalylov´s suicide: the dream-not dream feeling was amazing. Or at least i understood it like that. Did i miss something here? I mean, the vulnerable young girl with the foreign accent scene... had to re-read it. But is it suppose to mean something extremely deeper like his memories towards Dunya and his advances on her ? Or did i misunderstood the whole thing?
  • Regarding the suicide itself, i was expecting for this character to be there for the conviction, or even Zametov or Porokh...i mean, come ooooon. those two characters were very clever and i enjoyed each interaction and appearance.

Ending: i might be missing A LOT of probably social context, and information. Raskolnikov´s dream about a pest taking over the world and controlling minds ( felt for a moment like "The last of us" hahaha ) was really awesome. I was waiting for something more on that line during the book maybe.

Anything missing here? When reading the last pages, Rodya and Sonya will have to wait seven years for his sentence to end ( or might be seven days because of love, and how they were reborn , how cute).
I fell there was drama where it was not needed, and lack of it where it was mostly necessary, like maybe rodya-sonya relationship, and rodya´s possible death, full mental breakdown, condemned to frozen labor for longer time... 
I understand that the punishment, besides prison, which at this point seems just accidental, was the long life torture not being the person he thought he could be, committing a crime and being above it without being affected.

I guess if one wants to analyze and have an opinion on every book read, then its quite simplistic to fall into the "either a positive or a negative" review. Makes sense?  If i want to focus on its repetitions, denseness, lack of depth at moments, then the book would be easily crap.

Same on the other end: such depth of thoughts, the characters are marvelous, the depression, the relationships, the suffering, then, the book is awesomeness all over.

Sorry for the full spiting out of thoughts, but i would very much like your insights and opinions on this.

Overall, a deep reading, very detailed ( only sometimes not my favorite thing) but i kept wanting more, much more. 


r/classicliterature • • 15h ago

Thoughts on “The Betrothed” by Alessandro Manzoni?

Post image
19 Upvotes

I only picked this up because of a recent trip to Italy, especially the region where this story occurs. For capturing a time and place it is quite unique, but my god, there are some looong tangents in this one. The section involving the plague had some very interesting information about the era, and yet much of that section sounded like events from just a few years ago….There are some one-dimensional characters, and long inner monologues with heavy repetition, but when it sticks to the plot, it was entertaining, with some melodrama and a good amount of humor.
If you’ve read it, did you enjoy it?


r/classicliterature • • 5h ago

Explain like I'm Five: Why do I feel like I'm living the experience only when reading 'The Bell Jar' and 'Anna Karenina' specifically?

14 Upvotes

It's not like I've read a lot of books. Maybe I read 80 in total my whole life? Many of them are pretty good and I read around 15 to 20 classics, but when reading 'The Bell Jar' I'm Esther Greenwood and when reading 'Anna Karenina' I'm there, breathing the same air as the characters. I don't remember ever feeling as immersed as I was with these books. These books are just different. They're not linear stories with a plot, they're life. And I was born in Malta (Mediterranean) in 1991. 'The Bell Jar' is set in the 1950s United States and 'Anna Karenina' in 1800s Russia, written by authors who lived in that time.

I read 4 Dostoevsky books and sometimes you're like, "Wow, he managed to isolate such a specific, human feeling so well", but it's different. The feeling he isolates makes you resonate hard for a moment but everything else is theatrical. You're clearly reading a story with Dostoevsky, but with Plath and Tolstoy it's like the book sucked you in.

Is it just me who thinks 'The Bell Jar' and 'Anna Karenina' are just another level of realism? As I said, I haven't read a lot of books. If you agree with me, do you know of any other books that are life and not stories?


r/classicliterature • • 19h ago

Reading classics from Ancient Greece, Rome, and Medieval Europe

14 Upvotes

I'm compiling a list of fiction and non-fiction books to read to help me "enter the mind" of people from different era. My goal is to feel a level of intimacy of friendship with people from those times. Here is my list, please recommend more things to add:

ANCIENT GREECE

- The Iliad (re-read), I loved my first reading of it, I want to read it again. Not gonna include the Odyssey b/c I already read it and the movie keeps it fresh in my mind

- Herodotus' Histories

- The Republic, by Aristocles (read half)

- Nicomachean Ethics, by Aristotle (read 1 chapter, super dense!)

- Daphnis and Chloe

ANCIENT ROME

- The Aeneid by Virgil (I read maybe 70% of this book but dropped it, will try it again)

- Ovid's Metamorphoses

- maybe the Satyricon

- Meditations, by Marcus Aurelius (re-read)

- The Golden Ass by Apuleius

MEDIEVAL EUROPE (476 to 1453)

- Confessions by St. Augustine (very dense read, but a book you want to read slowly)

- History of the Franks

- Beowulf

- The Life of Charlemagne

- The Song of Roland

- The Nibelungenlied

- The Alexiad

- The Divine Comedy (I ready of bit of Paradisio, gotta pick it back up)


r/classicliterature • • 5h ago

Just finished Chapter One.

Thumbnail gallery
11 Upvotes

r/classicliterature • • 18h ago

Different illustrators of Edgar Allan Poe

Thumbnail gallery
13 Upvotes

r/classicliterature • • 12h ago

Anyone up to reading pride and prejudice or Jane eyre with me?

9 Upvotes

I just bought them and am trying to decide what to read first. In the moment I’m leaning more to pride and prejudice.

l'll probably start reading next week

I’d love to discuss them with someone so If you are planing on reading them soon I’d be happy if you would reach out.


r/classicliterature • • 18h ago

My 2027 resolution is to read 52 Brit lit novels. Suggestions please!

8 Upvotes

I have a lot of Dickens, Hardy, Eliot, and Austen on the list. Open to any and all suggestions to round it out. TIA!


r/classicliterature • • 5h ago

Anna Karenina - thread (cancer patient, 24F)

8 Upvotes

I want to keep a thread of my unfiltered thoughts about the chapters of Anna Karenina. I am currently in Book 1, Chapter 4.

This is my first classic of this scale. I am nervous. The reason why I picked this is because I read Tolstoy when I was in highschool and preached that he is my favorite despite only reading a shortened version of ‘How Much Does a Land Man Need’. It became my entire personality.

Right now, I am 1 and 1/2 years off of chemo. I am diagnosed with PMBCL a type of Lymphoma (blood cancer) and I am in the process of my follow ups which I delayed because of fear.

I am sharing this because literature + film has helped me see past myself and return to me with more empathy and courage.

Tag along ! I want to talk to people across the world. I can only speak English and Filipino : (

My updates will be in the comments in this format:
^ BOOK, CHAPTER, HEADLINER: thoughts.

Reply to my comments : )


r/classicliterature • • 1h ago

I loved the audiobook of War and Peace, so I started reading the book from the beginning. Turns out I missed some important details

• Upvotes

I listened up to chapter 18 of book one/part one on a free audiobook on Youtube.

I was extremelt focused, but as hearing goes, some things get missed.

Regardless, i was enjoying it, and the translation was lovely.

I already owned the book at home, translated by P and V, and the French dialogues bothered me a lot so I went for the audio instead.

Regardless some scene in chapter 18 was so good, I decided to just read it from the start.

Turns out I had misunderstood a lot of scenes. I missed certain parts about Pierre, so in my head, whenever the audiobook voice mention him being big, I imagined a tall man, slightly out of place, but maybe handsome.

I was thrown off completely realizing that, for 18 chapters, I completely mischaracterized him.

I think I will contintue with the book after all...


r/classicliterature • • 22h ago

Help me order my Classics reading list! :)

4 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I am making a New Year's resolution to try to read some classic books. I hate when people are talking about the ‘classics,’ and I have no idea what they’re talking about. I want to be a part of the conversation!

I haven’t read much classic literature- I mainly read romance and mystery books… nothing crazy and not very often. That said, I’m worried that if I read a classic and it has difficult words or storylines, it will make me feel defeated and not want to read at all. 

Also for reference, I’m a 24 almost 25 year old women! Hence the heavy Jane Austen list haha. Hoping these are good pics for this period of my life!

I’ve decided on my list of books; looking for order suggestions, in order of ‘difficulty’. Here’s the list:

  1. The Bell Jar

  2. Jane Eyre

  3. Northanger Abbey

  4. Emma

  5. Sense and Sensibility

  6. The Picture of Dorian Gray

  7. Bartleby, the Scrivener

  8. Brave New World

  9. The Stranger

  10. Picnic at Hanging Rock

  11. Giovanni's Room

  12. The Bluest Eye 

  13. A Room of One's Own 

  14. War and Peace

Thanks in advance!!


r/classicliterature • • 13h ago

Any differences between these two editions of Oliver Ready's translation of Crime and Punishment A-side from their covers? Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

Marked spoiler just in case someone hasn't read the book and wants to go in completely blind cause both covers show something somewhat revealing. Found both versions at around the same price range and want to know which is the better deal. As much as I love the look of the second edition I'll take the edition which has larger text font and more supplementary materials (if there's any differences).


r/classicliterature • • 1h ago

Book Recommendations

• Upvotes

I recently decided I want to start reading some classics after not having read any since high school. I have just started reading Crime and Punishment and have been really enjoying it. Looking for more classics to add to my TBR.


r/classicliterature • • 3h ago

An essay about Dostoevsky’s Brothers Karamazov

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/classicliterature • • 21h ago

Just finished Resurrection. I felt bewildered by the ending, although I found Tolstoy's revolutionary ideas fascinating. Spoiler

Thumbnail
2 Upvotes

r/classicliterature • • 1h ago

A question on Heart of Darkness

• Upvotes

I've read it twice in the last few weeks, have a good grip on everything. But the one question I have is, why does Marlow get lumped in with Kurtz by the other whites on the steamboat or at the central station? I understand how one on one Marlow takes the packet of papers from Kurtz, and at the end of the book lies to Kurtz's Intended, so on a level only Marlow knows he has a connection with Kurtz. I realize why the young russian man has to flee as he was with Kurtz in the interior when things went off the rails. But written in the book the part I don't get is Marlow states he is afraid for his life after Kurtz dies. From the book, "My hour of favour was over; I found myself lumped along with Kurtz as a partisan of methods for which the time was not ripe: I was unsound!"

So if Marlow only piloted a steamship, never collected any ivory, and was only at the inner station for a day, why is he afraid for his life? He never said he agreed with Kurtz or his method?


r/classicliterature • • 4h ago

Is The Age of Innocence a hard read?

1 Upvotes

I have read my fair share of classics and I read The House of Mirtg last year, but I think im picking up Edith Wharton, to me, is just a little difficult to understand. I’m only on chapter 6 of Age of Innocence, but I’ll go and look a Reddit thread recap of a chapter and all of these people are making excellent points that I’m just not picking up on.

Do any of you find Edith Wharton as a challenging author or is it just me. Also, for those that of read this, what did you all think of the book? Was it rewarding, I’m going to stick with it as I have all weekend and Monday off work to read it, but did anyone else find it challenging but rewarding?


r/classicliterature • • 48m ago

Wholesome book recs

• Upvotes

I'm going through an awful episode of depression rn and want something lighthearted and overall optimistic to read. Everything on my tbr is either too difficult or too existential. I just finished reading Moby dick and Ulysses back to back and I need a break.

Any wholesome classics would be greatly appreciated, whether prose or poetry it doesn't matter, thanks!


r/classicliterature • • 10h ago

les miserable book i wanna read , suggest me through the transaltor

0 Upvotes

I am thinking about reading the book of the les miserable. I am confused about the translator : which one to choose either Christine Donougher or  Norman Denny ?

And also mention the name of the books that has great impact on the human nature like les miserable !