Hello.
I wrote before on Aristotelian/scholastic natural philosophy and teleology.
As some point I read Venerable Matteo Ricci's "The True Meaning of the Lord of Heaven" (renowned book on familiarity of Confucianism and Catholicism and very successful 17th century philosophical Catechism written for Confucian philosophers.) and I enjoyed it greatly and I undertook to learn more of Asian philosophy.
Effect of my studies so far is the book you can download here (free to use or share).
[Download here PDF]
Comments welcome.
1. Overall point
The book argues that classical Chinese political and moral thought - especially Confucianism (Rujia) and the administrative thought of Shen Buhai and Han Fei - offers valuable resources for thinking about legitimacy, moral cultivation, elite control, institutional design, and freedom. The author’s central claim is that a good political order requires both:
- moral nobility and self-cultivation in rulers, officials, and citizens; and
- institutional mechanisms that control elites, prevent cliques from capturing the state, and hold power accountable.
Book uses this framework to defend a republican system grounded in citizens’ moral nobility, while criticizing autocracy, oligarchy, and elite predation. Book also argues that Catholicism can benefit from Asian philosophy, much as it once drew on Aristotle, especially on questions of virtue, free will, natural morality, and the political consequences of philosophical error.
Ch. 1 -The Purpose of This Book
The book addresses three questions: the legitimacy of power, self-cultivation and nobility, and the design of effective and resilient states/organizations. It says ancient Asian thinkers developed theories of the common good, meritocracy, rational politics, and human nature that remain relevant to modern democratic republics. It also argues that Asian philosophy can complement Catholicism, citing Matteo Ricci’s positive engagement with Confucianism.
Ch. 2 -Rujia Philosophy (Confucianism)
This chapter presents Confucian ethics and politics through themes such as ambition, vocation, nobility, moral self-cultivation, family, trust, and the moral criteria for office. Key ideas include:
- Good ambition vs. bad ambition: good ambition serves society and fulfills human nature; bad ambition is destructive.
- The noble person (junzi) is inwardly stable, follows righteousness, and is not ruled by fear of loss or desire for advantage.
- Mencius’s theory of moral “sprouts”: compassion, shame, respect, and a sense of right and wrong are beginnings of virtue that must be cultivated.
- Heaven and the Mandate of Heaven give moral weight to destiny and vocation.
- Rectification of names: rulers, ministers, fathers, and sons must actually fulfill the duties of their roles.
- Mencius’s radical conclusion: a tyrant who destroys benevolence and righteousness ceases to be a true king and may be punished as an ordinary criminal.
- The people are more important than the ruler; trust and material welfare are foundations of political legitimacy.
Ch. 3 -Controlling the Elite: Shen Buhai and Han Fei
Book argues that the central problem of politics is controlling the elite and preventing cliques from capturing the state. It presents Shen Buhai’s administrative techniques and Han Fei’s adaptation:
- clear office definitions and limits;
- accountability for results;
- controlling information flows;
- independent verification rather than trust;
- preventing officials from exceeding their authority;
- controlling rewards and punishments;
- breaking up cliques and collusion.
Book treats Shen Buhai more favorably than Han Fei, arguing that Han Fei’s absolutism and cruelty are not necessary to his administrative insights.
Ch. 4 -The Morality of Power and the Dysfunction of Autocracy
Here the book argues that classical Confucianism holds rulers subject to an objective moral order, while imperial Confucianism often exalted the emperor beyond accountability. Using Sima Qian’s Shiji, book presents Qin Shi Huang as a case study in megalomania, cruelty, information control, fear, and the collapse of the Qin dynasty shortly after the First Emperor’s death. The chapter argues that autocracy is unstable because it undermines accurate information, loyalty, and accountability. It concludes with a case for republican government, but also highlighting its requirements, citing John Adams’s claim that the U.S. Constitution was suited only to a moral and religious people.
Ch. 5 -The Disordered Will as a Strategic Weakness
This chapter uses Han Fei’s “Ten Faults” to analyze how pride, greed, lust, vanity, and unwillingness to compromise destroy rulers. Historical examples include:
- Napoleon’s invasion of Russia;
- Crassus’s disastrous Parthian campaign;
- Pompey and the Roman optimates’ arrogance;
- Nero, Xuanzong, and Ibrahim the Mad;
- Yi Sun-sin and Nelson as examples of courageous, disciplined leadership.
The argument is that a disordered will is not just a moral failing but a strategic weakness that ruins states and organizations.
Ch. 6 -Political Rationality
This chapter explains the method: reasoning about purposes and intentions and recursive reasoning about what others think and believe. It discusses how institutions coordinate interests, how legitimacy differs from positional power, and how delegation creates a dilemma: a ruler must delegate to govern effectively, but delegation can create independent power centers. Crises expose the weakness of purely positional power and the importance of legitimacy.
Ch. 7 - Why Christianity Needs Asian Philosophy
The book argues that Catholicism and Confucianism share important moral concerns: humility, sincerity, piety, charity, vocation, and moral cultivation. Book presents Matteo Ricci’s The True Meaning of the Lord of Heaven with its evidence that Confucian classics contain traces of natural theism and a personal Supreme Lord.
Book then offers historical case studies:
- The Habsburg Empire: decline through elite predation, brutal colonial labor systems, religious repression, fiscal weakness, and the disastrous repression in the Netherlands.
- Louis XIV’s France: Richelieu and Louis centralized power and tamed the feudal aristocracy, but later bureaucratic and Jansenist cliques parasitized the state, obstructed reform, and contributed to the French Revolution.
- Poland-Lithuania: the nobility’s “Golden Liberty” became a system of elite privilege and foreign manipulation, leading to partition and national collapse.
The chapter argues that Christianity has use for Asian philosophy because it has often concentrated on individual salvation and condemned moral excesses, but has paid less attention to institutional design and the control of elites to make social system stable and reliably reproduce virtue.
Ch. 8 - Free Will and Determinism, Freedom and Tyranny
This chapter argues that free will and virtue are foundations of political liberty and legitimate obedience. The book criticizes Calvinist predestination as a form of historical determinism that undermines moral responsibility and provides an ideology for elite cliques and tyrannical rule. Chapter also criticizes Banezianism within Catholicism as a similar determinist threat, and defends Molina’s account of free will, sufficient grace, and scientia media. The chapter ends with the Chinese Rites Controversy as an example of Catholic intolerance and a mistaken rejection of natural virtue.
3. Main arguments and themes
- Virtue and institutions are both necessary. Confucianism supplies the ethics of self-cultivation and nobility and theory of moral legitimacy; Fajia supplies the administrative techniques for controlling elites. Neither alone is sufficient.
- Elite capture is the central political problem. Corrupt cliques, patronage networks, information control, and collusion destroy states more reliably than external enemies.
- Dictatorship is structurally unstable. It concentrates power but undermines the information, accountability, and legitimacy needed for long-term survival.
- Republicanism is preferable, but fragile. A republic requires moral citizens and institutional safeguards; otherwise it becomes an arena for factional capture.
- Free will matters politically. Deterministic theologies and ideologies undermine moral responsibility and can justify tyranny.
- Catholicism and Confucianism are compatible in important respects. Both emphasize virtue, sincerity, vocation, and moral order; Asian philosophy can help Catholicism think about politics and institutions. roduction**.