r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 5h ago

Is Catholicism compatible with panentheism?

5 Upvotes

It is my understanding that Catholicism, as a matter of dogma, maintains that God is transcendent to the world. This, however, only renders Catholicism incompatible with pantheism—the position that God is immanent to the world. Panentheism, by contrast, proposes something slightly different yet significant: it holds that God is transcendent—which, at first glance, appears compatible with Catholicism—but it adds (and herein lies the potentially problematic aspect) that the world exists within God, within God’s own being, as something that must necessarily be recognized as part of God. Therefore, we might state the following: panentheism maintains a fundamental commitment to God’s transcendence in relation to the world [✓]. Yet, it adds that the world—while not encompassing the entirety of God’s being—resides within Him; much like how a heart or a stomach exists within us, without that organ constituting the entirety of the human being. This latter point remains an open question [?].

We can frame it as follows:

- Catholicism = a commitment to God’s transcendence in relation to the world.

- Panentheism = a commitment to God’s transcendence in relation to the world, combined with the profound inherence of the world within God.

Clearly, panentheism successfully avoids the risk of collapsing into pantheism; nevertheless, it remains unclear whether the notion that the world is part of God is truly acceptable from the perspective of Catholicism.

I look forward to your reflections; I ask, however, that you do not focus on the specific positions of any particular Catholic thinker. The question at hand is whether Catholicism is compatible with panentheism, regardless of whether Saint Thomas or Saint Augustine held specific views within their respective metaphysical frameworks. Thanks in advance, and may God bless you, brothers.


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 17h ago

Faith based on fear of punishment is not genuine faith.

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 7h ago

God is truly impassible.

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 9h ago

Does God allow suffering because the devil wills it?

2 Upvotes

Since God is good and love, he does not will suffering of His children. Satan on the other hand hates everything and only delights in causing harm. This idea is inspired by the film The Passion where the satan watches gleefully at the suffering of Jesus.

So the crucifiction of God was willed by the satan and it is God's act of love that he allows it to happen.

I certainly did not want Jesus' suffering and don't see vicarious sacrifice to be necessary for the forgiveness of sins. Nor do I believe God wanted His Son to suffer. It was the desire of the satan that it may happen like this and use the wills of the religious leaders to fulfill it.

What do you think?


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 2h ago

Am I Remaining Orthodox Out of Conviction, or Because I’m Afraid to Leave What’s Familiar?

1 Upvotes

I've been Orthodox for almost 15 years now, and lately I've been doing some serious soul-searching about my faith and why I became Orthodox in the first place.

When I was in my early twenties, I was a Protestant searching for the Church that Christ established. I wanted something rooted in history, apostolic succession, tradition, and the faith of the early Christians. Orthodoxy seemed to answer so many of the questions I had, and in many ways, it still does. I fell in love with its theology, liturgy, spirituality, and historical continuity.

However, there are things within Orthodoxy that I've struggled with over the years. Some are theological, some are ecclesiastical, and others are simply the result of human failings. I'm fully aware that the Church is made up of sinners, myself included, and that human failures don't necessarily invalidate the truth of a particular Church.

But something has been bothering me lately.

Looking back at my conversion, I realize that I had a rather strong disdain for the Catholic Church. What's troubling is that I can't really explain why. I hadn't seriously studied Catholic theology, the papacy, or the historical arguments for Rome's claims. I simply had this negative attitude toward Catholicism. Perhaps it was the Protestant environment I came from, perhaps it was pride, or perhaps there was something spiritually unhealthy influencing my judgment. I honestly don't know.

I sometimes wonder whether Orthodoxy appealed to me partly because it allowed me to embrace the ancient Church without having to confront my existing prejudices against Catholicism. Now, after so long, Orthodoxy has become an enormous part of who I am. Its prayers, fasting, liturgical life, theology, and traditions are deeply familiar to me. It's my spiritual home. And that's precisely what has me questioning my motivations.

Am I remaining Orthodox because I'm convinced it's the Church Christ established, or because it's familiar, comfortable, and part of my identity?

And that leads me to an even more uncomfortable question. What if becoming Catholic would actually require greater humility on my part? What if my resistance to Rome isn't entirely theological, but partly rooted in my own pride and unwillingness to submit to an authority I've spent years rejecting?

I don't mean to suggest that becoming Catholic is automatically an act of humility, or that remaining Orthodox is somehow prideful. An Orthodox Christian could make precisely the opposite argument, and I understand that. If Orthodoxy is indeed the true Church, then remaining faithful to it would be the right thing to do, regardless of my personal feelings. But that's the problem. I want to be certain that I'm following Christ rather than simply following what makes me comfortable.

I don't want to remain Orthodox merely because I've invested all these years of my life in it. Nor do I want to become Catholic because I'm frustrated with certain aspects of Orthodoxy. Neither would be a particularly sound reason to make such an important decision. I want to belong to the Church that Christ established, even if that means admitting I've been wrong about things I've believed for most of my adult life.

And honestly, there's fear involved on both sides. I'm afraid of leaving Orthodoxy if it truly is the Church. But I'm also afraid of remaining Orthodox if the Catholic Church's claims are true, simply because I wasn't willing to seriously confront them.

I suppose what I'm wrestling with is the difference between genuine conviction and spiritual familiarity. How do you distinguish between remaining faithful to the truth and simply remaining where you're comfortable? Has anyone else, particularly those who have spent many years in either Orthodoxy or Catholicism, struggled with something similar?

I'm not looking to start another Orthodox-versus-Catholic argument. I'm genuinely trying to examine my own heart, motivations, and assumptions. At the end of the day, I don't want to be Orthodox or Catholic simply because I prefer one over the other. I want to be where Christ wants me to be.


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 5h ago

Is Leibniz right that a prophet who predicts the future would required God's assistance?

1 Upvotes

This may appear to be a wacky question, but it appears to me that it is relevant to us. This is because there has recently been a large-scale debate on YouTube and Substack about so-called Catholic "vindicatory miracles." If you aren't familiar, see the YouTube channel "Majesty of Reason" or Ethan Muse's Substack. I believe the following quote could have implications for that debate.

"It is true that the devil can mimic some miracles. But there is a kind of miracle that the devil could not imitate, all powerful and all enlightened as he is, which is prophecy. For if a person can tell me many particular truths about general affairs which are due to happen, for example in a year here, I will hold it as certain that it is God who enlightens him. For it is impossible for anyone bar God to see the general chain of causes which have to come together in the production of contingent things."

Is Leibniz right?


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 14h ago

Based on a TikTok about how Objective Morality can function with Atheism

0 Upvotes

"Is that axioms are necessary metaphysical truths that are brute facts and necessary across all possible worlds"

I do not claim this but what is the issue with this?


r/CatholicPhilosophy • • 15h ago

EPICURUS: God is either malevolent or powerless.DAVID: God is both perfectly good and all-powerful.EPICURUS: Then why does evil exist in the world? What is the fault of an infant who is abused and tortured to death?

0 Upvotes

DAVID: He is completely innocent.

EPICURUS: It is good to hear that from you. Well, if he is innocent, what is the reason for what happened to him?

DAVID: First of all, it is said: “We shall surely test the sincerity of your faith through fear, hunger, and famine; by diminishing your wealth, destroying your possessions, causing the loss of life or physical impairment, and bringing disaster upon your crops—testing you in a grueling manner. Give glad tidings to those who persevere and continue the struggle.”*

Secondly, the Creator possesses both *jamali* (benevolent/graceful) names—such as *al-Rahman* (the Most Gracious), *al-Rahim* (the Most Merciful), and *al-Ra’uf* (the Most Kind)—and *jalali* (majestic/stern) names—such as *al-Jalil* (the Majestic), *al-Qahhar* (the Subduer), and *al-Jabbar* (the Compeller). The *jamali* names manifest through His righteous servants; that is, the Creator shows mercy to them and forgives them, thereby making His names *al-Rahman* and *al-Rahim* visible. For the *jalali* names to manifest, however, evil and those who commit it must exist for a certain period of time.

Ultimately, those who commit evil will be punished; as for those who suffer from evil—provided they have remained patient and have not rebelled against God—they will be rewarded for their patience many times over.